Knocking Talkback comments

PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 11/27/2007
 I think this was one of the best documetaries ever done. I have read some of the posts on here may of which seem to be from bitter people either given the boot or just bitter because they did not get what they wanted. Either way, this is a DVD that I found interesting and while I will never be a witness, I know from visiting Bethel and in depth discussion with numeroous witnesses that they do their best and answer to no one on this planet. Interesting is all the ex witnesses who decided to leave and now speaking out. Get on with your lives and stop hating it proves nothing!  4/18/07
 11/20/2007
 It's unbelievable that JWs still deny the Watchtower's membership in the U.N. for about 9 years when it can easily be determined by a quick search and viewable documents. Oh, I forgot, they can't think for themselves and do any research. It's funny to read the stupid back-tracking by the WT trying to extricate themselves from this. They claim they joined only to get a library card to do research in the U.N.'s library, yet a card was never needed for access and all the U.N. material is available from other sources including colleges that are WT's neighbors.  4/18/07
 4/18/07
 Robert
 California
 I am intrigued by the title and some of the comments made about the film and the culture of Jehovah's Witnesses (JW's). As Mr. Herrera commented about the director's assurtions, I have personally experienced that, yes, you will be shunned by any of the JW's if you go against the teachings of The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, Brooklyn, NY. Another person alluded to the term cult. Since the JW's believe that one will not survive "Armaggedon" unless one becomes a JW, that is a cult. That is why they go "Knocking" on doors everyday so they can proselytize the people they encounter. They believe they are following the mandate set forth by Christ @ Matthew 24:14 and Mathew 28:19-20.
 I no longer am one of JW's. I chose to no longer ally myself with a false prophet. None of their founding fathers predictions came true. They claimed they spoke for Jehovah. CT Russel and JF Rutherford, et al, are liars. Sincere, perhaps, but liars, nonetheless. I love the JW's I left behind and pray for them daily. The real Jehovah, Jesus Christ, who prophecied He would come and die for us in Isaiah and told Zechariah "they will look upon me whom they pierced" (Zech. 12:10), did indeed die for us and rose again three days later. That I will take to the bank for it was prophecied years before it happened and there was and is testimony it actually happened. There's more I'd like to share, however, I'm out of time. I look forward to seeing the movie.  4/18/07
 Sharon
 Chicago, IL
 I was very suprised to hear from the film that Jehovah's Witnesses were called "Christians" when in fact they are not. A Christian is one who follows and believes the teachings of the Bible, accepting the fact that Christ was God who came in the flesh as the scriptures clearly teach. Jehovah's Witnesses believe that they will attain eternal life by their good works.This is a religion based on good works not Christ and what he did at Calvary. According to the Bible in Ephesians 2:8-9 salvation is NOT by OUR works but by CHRIST'S Sacrifice when He gave His life that we might receive the FREE GIFT of eternal life. "For by grace are ye saved through faith and that not of yourselves it is the gift of God, not of works, lest any man should boast." people need to be aware that JW's do not believe in the same Bible nor the same Christ that fundamental Christians have believed in for 100's of years before Jehovah's Witnesses ever began. please see www.towerwatch.com I'm sure this won't get posted since 99.9% of the postings are positive. Don't get me wrong, I have personally talked to many JW's. They are very wonderful and sincere people. However they are still a cult and still sincerely wrong.  4/18/07
 FIRST OF ALL JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ARE NOT PART OF THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH. CHRISTIANITY IS BUILT ON THE HOLY TRINITY (THE FATHER, SON AND HOLY SPIRIT AS ONE )WHICH THEY DO NOT BELIEVE IN. I HAVE SOME FAMILY MEMBERS WHO ARE JW AND ARE NOT ALLOWED TO ATTEND OTHER RELIGIOUS CEREMONIES SUCH AS A ROMAN CATHOLIC WEDDING. MY QUESTION TO ALL JW'S IS WHAT ARE YOU AFRAID OF? I TRULY BELIEVE JEHOVAHS WITNESSES IS A CULT AND WAS STARTED OUT AS ONE MANS WAY OF MAKING MONEY. ISNT HE THE ONE WHO PREDICTED THE END OF THE WORLD ON SPECIFIC DATES THAT HAVE PASSED 3 TIMES.  4/18/07
 Colorado Springs, Colorado
 I believe that Jehovah is the one and only true God. I did grow up in a JW family. I have yet to see the documentary, but from my personal studies I believe that the early JWs fought with zeal and pleasure to do Jah's will. However, today, I believe the JWs do want those associated with them to conform and not to question bible passages or interpretations that are provided to us. As long as you conform, go to all the meetings, and go out in service once a week, pretend to be someone who you may not really be; then acceptance is granted. No matter what you do with or without other JWs seeing what you do, then you are accepted and they will stand behind you. However, as in my experience, if you question the bible or what god truly expects us to understand from his often symbolic writings given to us through man (in the Holy Bible); then the stares begin and you begin to hear the whispers and the rumors. So, you search for a new congregation where no one knows you and as long as your conform, go all the meetings, and go out in service at least once a week, you are accepted once more. But then when you feel that you have given them a chance to know the real you and you start to question, then the vicious cycle continues and you are off to find another congregation. I understand the teachings are given to us through the aid of the governing class, but we are still human and imperfect. If the early JWs did not question the wicked world around us or the bible teachings of other religions, would they be here today? I have two (2) wonderful children who I will teach through the use of the bible (on my own) to love Jah with their whole hearts, minds and souls. Their decision to actually go the meetings will be their own. I will not go only hear that I should try harder to attend all the meetings and that Jah will provide. Jah no longer gets involved with man's affairs and only when Armageddon begins will Jah's son step in. I understand that sacrifices must be made, but not to the detriment of my family; whether Jah says so or not. My motherhood takes precidence. Why must I question whether I will make it into the new order to see my loved ones? Why must I be told that my heart condition is not right, but that another's is, when I at least remain true to myself? I have suffered low self-esteem by not conforming and will not subject my daughter's to the same unless they make that choice for themselves. Even Job through his most trying of times, questioned Jah. He never cursed Jah, but he did question? If I will not make into the new order, how many of today's JW will?  4/18/07
 Maggie
 Miami, Fl
 Clearly, almost everyone talking about KNOCKING belongs to the JW sect.Yes, it is a sect and a dangerous one at that! They take from the society at large everything they want, but they speak about it badly, and they harbour a great contempt for everybody and everything outside of their so-called religion.Especially, they are very venomous when it comes to the Catholics. According to their teachings, all other religions are false. Their religion is the only true religion and they even use the term THE TRUTH to describe it.
 In October 2006, they organized a big Campaign (that's how they described it) going door to door in Poland, where I am located, distributing propaganda brochures in which they called all other religions FALSE RELIGIONS, and warned about the approaching Armagedon. Of course, only JWs will survive it at the end. The rest of the world comes from the Satan himself and will not be worthy of the eternal life. Only I am curious why do JWs use so freely everything the outside world produces? And,yes,I know their teachings and mentality first hand. My mother and sister converted to them some 25 years ago. Since then, my sister married a "nonbeliever" (Catholic), converted him to her sect, then he become an Elder of their group(prestigous function), then last year he became gravely ill. He needed heart surgery, rejected blood, died. Doctors at the local hospital call his death, a death by choice. Truly tragic!  4/18/07
 It's so annoying to get hounded by Jehoa's witnesses and in my area they don't take no lightly as if they work on commission. I have been with my husband for 23 yrs and I can tell you that my mother in law is a Jehova's Witness. My husband hated every minute growing up in that belief. When he became a teenager he became rebelious because of it. I hear the stories he tells our kids and it's heart wrenching to think of the humiliation he was put through when kids had birthdays and he could not attend, when it was Christmas and he saw kids with their gifts and he got nothing. We have 3 boys and my mother in law never attended their baptism nor birthdays and my kids have notice and have been hurt because of it. They have no affections or feelings towards her at all. She fought for my husband and I not to continue to date, by bad mouthing my then boyfriend to my family, but he and I over came the obstacles she laid and we are happily married, with 3 boys and a good life. There was a Jehova's witness family that turned their back on their daughter because she got pregnant out of wedlock and not only the family, but other members of the Jehova's witness Kingdom Hall. That is insane. This is no religion this is a cult created by a man who revised the Bible to his liking.  4/18/07
 It would be wonderful if this would air on all of our PBS stations. You can see by this video that Jehovah's Witnesses are mis-understood, or have even been slandered against. For instance, when the man asked if we believe that Jesus is God's son. A lot of people are led to believe that we don't believe in Jesus. However, we know that Jesus is his Father Jehovah's means of saving those who exercize faith in his ransom sacrifice.The most imporatant thing with showing who Jehovah's Witnesses really are is the sancification or (hallow) of Jehovah's name
 (Matt. 6:9)
 Jehovah answeres questions people have through the bible, such as:
 Does God have a personal name?
 Why did Jesus have to die?
 Why did Jesus perform miracles, such as healing and raising people from the dead?
 What happens to us when we die?
 Why are we here/what is our purpose?
 What is required of us to gain salvation?
 Does Jehovah God care for each of us individually?
 Why does God allow suffering?
 ETC...
 Jehovah's Witnesses are trained
 to show people from the bible (their own personal copy, if they prefer)where to find these answers.  4/18/07
 Jared
 Spring Hill, FL
 I realy liked it because I understood it being a jehova's witness my self.When I saw the movie I felt so inspired and proud to know these bible scriptures and why we apply them in our lives.thank you for making that movie i really enjoyed it.  4/18/07
 Stlouismo
 The problem is you dont tell the whole story to -- you make out like you are good, and thats what sucks people in, JW's have done so much damage in our family.  4/3/07
 Virginia
 I agree with a previous poster regarding "enjoying 98% of the film". I felt the same way. I thought that overall it was very acurate and unbiased, but I did feel that a couple statements should have been explained. For example, when the grandmother of the young man used the word "cult" to describe the witnesses. I can appreciate why they would interview both sides of the family, both witnesses and non, but I did think they should have explained that we are NOT a "cult". Also the statment that if someone doesn't comform to the teachings they are "expelled". It wasn't explained that every effort is taken to correct the views of the erring person, and that even if a person is "expelled", they can still attend congregation meetings. Someone who has been "expelled" is encouraged to change their bad actions and return to a way of life that honors God and conforms to BIBLE teachings.
 On the other hand,I really enjoyed the parts where they did the street witnessing and showed the reactions of the listeners. Also, it was nice that the producer showed how JW's have helped in legal and medical matters for everyone. The experiences were interesting and encouraging. I hope that viewers who are not Jehovah's Witnesses will not just take every single point at face value, but will ask questions and get an in-depth explaination from a Witness who may knock at their door.  4/3/07
 Ruben Herrera
 Eagle Pass, Texas

 The film was great! I'd like to see another documentry and I'd like to see it on what people believe and why? We JW's know why we don't Celebrate Holidays or pledge to any flag but I wonder if most people ever question why they do or why they believe what they believe. This would be truly fascinat
ing and to be made by a some one like you would be truly fascinating.  4/3/07
 Ruben Herrera
 Eagle Pass, Texas
 I felt your portrayal of Witnesses was very unbiased and educational to some degree, especially for those who are trying to understand our beliefs and misconceptions. I thought that the scene where a brother is street witnessing in the parking lot with the driver saying a bad word was uncalled for and it wouldnt of taken away from the essence of the documentary at all. I just thought that it would of been better to have omitted that part. Overall, it was a very interesting documentary. I found it very interesting to see the comments people had on us. Thank you for such a candid approach to our organization.  2/26/07
 california
 I would say I liked 98% of it, and totally agree with the other reviews -but I need to express what I feel were negatives. I will admit that although the overall film seemed unbiased, let's be honest, the director is not one of JW's so will use some of his own feelings, being raised by a Witness mom, but for his own reasons not accepting it. I have to mention that I totally disagree with the statement in the beginning of the film to the effect "If you disagree with their teachings, you are expelled." When has that happened? Is he talking about apostates? It was a total blanket statement, (which means "a vague and noncommittal statement asserting a premise without providing evidence") That makes us sound like mindless robots that are not allowed to think for ourselves. This is a MINOR thing in the film, only one sentence, but it bothered me because he did not elaborate on what he meant, or allow for a response to his statement. If I was in a religion in which they controlled my thinking, told me what to do, when and how to do it, and not allowed freedom of thought, personally I would say "see ya"!- as I was extremely independent and anti-authority before accepting the truth from the Scriptures. I also felt that using worldly catch phrases like saying we are "conservative" ;"fundamentalists" and "apolitical", (that has a negative connotation- more accurate is "politically neutral") is kind of stereotyping us inaccurately. I loved the special feature which showed us "street witnessing" on the Brooklyn Bridge and also on 42nd street- that was cool. And the part where Joel quite fondly talks about being raised by a single Witness mom and going door to door with her as a kid. (but Joel, how many times did people have their dogs attack you while out in service, come on now) I could see his appreciation and perhaps missing it just a little. Once you know Jehovah, it never leaves you. You can certainly see it in his face.  2/26/07
 Oklahoma City, OK
 I am one of Jehovah's witnesses, and I'm so glad to see something positive about God's organization. I spent my life searching for even basic truths and never found them in any other religion. Knocking shows what God's will really is. It is not simply leading a clean moral life, but it is taking part in spreading the good news of God's kingdom. That's what Noah did, and then the flood came. We are simply taking part in fulfilling Jehovah's purpose in the final days. When we are not knocking at doors, we are writing letters or having bible studies, informal witnessing or whatever it takes to do God's will. Thats the whole theme of the bible.  2/26/07
 I've viewed the video and enjoyed it quite well. It was definitely unbiased. As a witness, we know that there are ones with distroted views of us, but I still found it interesting to hear how off the mark their perceptions were. If you're not taught the truth, you will have mis-conceptions. Maybe this video can better inform them.
 3/27/07 Turpen, NJ My family and I are looking forward to this broadcast on WHYY (Philadelphia). We saw the screening at the Trenton Film Festival and found it to be accurate and fair.  3/27/07
 WKJ
 Taylor, Michigan
 I must say that I enjoyed the documentary very much! After reading the various comments, I thought I'd add my two cents ... The documentary was very accurate in its portrayal of the facts (Accurate not perfect). However, those of us who are JW's should understand that an outside organization will never "get it" completely correct. They cannot grasp the essence, the nuance of what is means to live in the world and yet be "no part of it."
 Though they may not be biased they don't understand the "pure language" of the truth! Those of us who speak it and live it, we understand! I'm very happy that an outside group took the time to do the research and put forth a sincere effort to accurately portray who Jehovah's Witnesses are. All of us have our trials, they may not be the trials portrayed in the documentary but we all have our trials!
 PBS and the Independent Lens have an excellent reputation for presenting interesting, informative, ground breaking material. I only hope that they will show it in their markets at a time when many are able to see it. (This piece deserves to be shown in prime time (8:00 - 10:00 or at least 7:00 - 11:00). Knocking was produced by an outside group (not Jehovah's Witnesses); maybe people will view this piece with an open mind. That is MY hope ... To the directors of Knocking: "Well done" :)  2/8/07
 Seth Mansbridge
 Portsmouth, Britain
 I live in Britain and ordered "knocking" via the internet.
 I was enthralled by the Thomas & Kempler families story. An excellent documentary that gave a telling and honest insight not only into the respective families but Jehovah's Witnesses as a whole.
 I have been a Jehovah's Witness for some 23 years and if half of what i heard people say about us was even half true i would not be one. However the "knocking" documentary was a fair portrayal of who Jehovah's Witnesses are and the lengths they have gone to secure religious and self determination freedoms which benefit society in general.
 A big thank you to Joel P.Engardio and Tom Shepard for doing neither a "hit job" nor a "puff piece" but an accurate piece. Also the extras on the DVD were superb thoroughly enjoyed them.
 I hope those who are not Jehovah's Witnesses who watch this documentary are left with an increased understanding of who Jehovah's Witnesses are. Because understanding leads to tolerance of people with a diffirent viewpoint and s uch a tolerance is good for society.  2/8/07
 Desiree Johnston
 Tempe, AZ
 I studied the Bible for 2 years with a Jehovah's Witness about a year ago. Although I ended my Bible study (temporarily) because of my divorce and some IRS problems, I plan to resume as soon as I get things straightened out. I viewed the documentary DVD "Knocking" at a friends house. I commend you for having the GUTS to bring out the facts. If there's ONE thing I've learned from my study, it's THIS! Contrary to popular opinion, Jehovah's Witnesses are normal people, with strong faith, trying to live up to all of God's requirements, to the BEST of their imperfect ability. In fact, NORMAL people let me down every day, most times on purpose! But the Witnesses have been nothing but kind, generous and HONEST with me. They truly put the Bible and preaching first, other peoples interests second, and themselves last. (Just like Christ did!) And everytime I asked what God says about things, they showed me, right in my own Bible. The only reason I can see why people ridicule them, call them a cult, and accuse them of teaching their own beliefs, traditions and customs, is out of their own guilt. They can plainly see, like I did, that what they preach is from God, directly out of his word, the Bible. When you learn exactly what God expects of you, (i.e. preaching door to door, like Christ did) a responsibility is suddenly laid upon you. Then, you have a decision to make, like I do, to either make changes in your life and try to follow what the scriptures say, or dismiss it as merely private doctrines of Jehovah's Witnesses, calling them extremists and fanatics. Unfortunately, the latter is usually the choice most people make.  2/6/07
 V. Amiel
 Houston, Texas 77054
 We are Jehovah's Witnesses and this e-mail is just to let you know how much our family and friends are looking forward to seeing your broadcast of the film about Jehovah's Witnesses, entitled "KNOCKING". We are very appreciative of you showing this documentary. We were just informed yesterday by friend living in New York and have visited their website and is about to order 2 DVD - we are informing as many friends as possible to view it on KUHT Channel 8 in Houston on Tuesday May 22, 2007 at 10:00 PM. By the way, we always watch Independent Lens - it is an excellent program. Thank you for dealing with topics affecting the everyday lives of people that we can relate to on a very human level.  2/6/07
 Robin Hamamy
 Toronto Ontario Canada
 I am either the only one with negative comments or the Public submission selection has been very controlled. I find it very hard to fathom that you have received little or no criticism of your documentary.
 I was raised as a Witness and spent some 40 years being reared in the teachings, traditions and customs of this group. During this time I have seen the religion from all sides and have seen the good you portray as well as the bad which you completely ignore in your coverage.
 Whatever your mandate was, I submit that a similar documentary about the Catholic church during the middle ages would be derelict in its task if it concentrated solely on any positive role Catholicism played in European culture, politics, architecture, and art without also showing the negatives as well. Cathedral construction while magnificent to behold cannot erase the blood shed and human suffering endured through the crusades and the many inquisitions.  1/31/07
 JK
 California
 I am very impressed with the portrayal of Jehovah's Witnesses in this film. In so many instances Jehovah's Witnesses are ridiculed, spoken harshly against and persecuted for their beliefs and their activity in the preaching work. Finally a bright light has been shined upon them, in an un-biased way, not putting them on a pedestal...but it's fair, honest and factual. Thank you so much for the film.  1/25/07
 Nicola
 I had a chance to watch the first 8 minute trailer of this documentary and I think that it is a good piece. I am one of Jehovah's witnesss and as of late most questions that I hear from people at the door is about blood. Especially when I have my toddler with me. Last week one lady asked me, why is it I would let her die then give her blood. Of course I explained it to her, but I think this third party view is going to help so many people to see this issue from the other side. Unfortunetly I will have to tape it because it airs here in Tampa on May 22, which is a Tuesday and that is a meeting night for most JW living in the US.  1/25/07
 Lynn Saracco
 Snellville, GA
 Finally a beautifully presented piece about Jehovah's Witnesses. Which one touches the heart more, dear Seth Thomas, with his life at stake, or the Kemler family? What wonderful examples of those that take the Bible seriously & the blessing that come from our Father! Thank you so much for airing fine, factual programming.  1/25/07
 clarissa otiz
 brawley, ca
 we just received the "knocking" dvd and viewed it. it is extremely well done! i have been in the truth since i was 8 years old. i have many reasons to take pride in my faith, and this programming is one of many reasons that confirms my pride. i have something many in the world don't have. thankyou so much for the portrayal of who we are as an organization. may Jehovah use you again to let others know of who he is and what he has in store for mankind.  1/25/07
 Mark Banegas
 San Pedro Ca.
 I am a teacher for the Los Angeles Unified School District. I appreciated your unbiased work on Jehovah's Witnesses. its interesting to see how much of an effect that they have had on preserving the rights of all Americans in a round about way. I have seen the full DVD and those that have seen it are also planning on purchasing one for them selves and family.  1/19/07
 R G
 Apache Junction, AZ
 I just saw the trailer for this documentary and am very excited to see it. As a person who was raised as a Jehovah's Witness, stopped being one, and returned 10 years later, I know both sides of the mirror. This world is filled to the brim with horror stories and misconceptions about us and our beliefs. I am very pleased that someone, besides us, decided to take a non-biased look at who we are and what we believe. We are normal human beings with a strong faith living up to God's requirements to the best of our imperfect ability. Being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is LIVING the Golden Rule, a path not easily followed.
 To anyone who has ever heard anything good bad or otherwise and has never talked to one of us - please, please, take a look, you will be surprised.
 1/16/07
 Brittany Gulley
 Farmerville, Louisiana
 I am a young Jehovah's Witness and I have been associated with them all my life. I think it's great that they have a documentary about our faith, showing the truth about us, what we believe and who we stand for. I look forward to seeing it, and sharing it with others.  1/16/07
 Lulu
 Although I had some mixed feelings about the documentary, I was delighted it hear that the World Wide headquarters of Jehovah's Witnesses in Brooklyn, NY gave the approval for the production of such a film. It is truly interesting how Jehovah uses so many avenues and individuals to educate others. Now the world has been given a witness through the commonalities of the media and entertainment by people that aren't even one of Jehovah's Witnesses!  12/21/06
 Tim MacMillan
 Vancouver Canada
 Hi I married an athiest from Ukraine. Talk about not only a clash of cultures, but there was language and belief systems that were poles apart. My wife had never met a JW in Ukraine but heard terrible reports of them. She researched for 2 years on what was the truth, even going to an Orthodox priest for advice. In the end not only have we overcome the language and cultural barriers but now my wife goes out "knocking" with her 12 years old son to try to teach others the bible. It is an incredible turn around from a young woman who thought it all "ridiculous garbage" to teaching the bible to strangers. It is difficult for her as she is a shy person by nature but she demonstrates a courage that over 6 million other JW"s show on a daily basis. Iryna misses New Year and some othe other holidays but the trade off has been a happy family life and a hope for the future living in a paradise world without race or language barriers. Besides we have lots of fun at other times like "tubing" down Mt. Cypress last week. A s a family we enjoyed seeing a friend's "knocking" CD and now we will order our own copy. Well done to all those that participated in the documentary. Special thanks to Joel and Tom who collaborated to produce a riveting drama that unfolded to create an inspiring story. We are about to go to The Ukraine to live for the next year. If you would like to do a documentary of a father and 12 years old son travelling from Kiev to Yalta on the black sea then let me know. ukraine is an amazing place to make documentaries. There are so many stories there. The other idea I had was a documentary in Papua New Guinea searching to the Aleandra butterfly, the largest in the world. They are almost 1 foot in diameter and were rare when I was living there 25 years ago. The Awake journal did an article about the a few years ago. Thanks again to you all for your excellent presentation.  12/19/06
 Portland Or
 I thought this Documentary was portrayed in a non-biased way that was deeply moving and exciting to watch. It's hard as one of Jehovah's Wittiness to show or tell the whole world who we are and what our objective is without being ridiculed, called some sort of name, interrupted and or accused of or trying to brainwash someone just by talking to them. Having an interested outsider present this from his own viewpoint is a great way to show the whole world why we are willing to take time out from our own busy everyday living, to spend so many hours talking from door to door. I mean we have a personal life too just like anyone else. Instead of going to the beach for a day or sleeping in through the mornings we will spend it going door to door and if time permits then we engage in wholesome recreation like enjoying the beach and so forth. I think because of this people think we are crazy, that we would volunteer for this, give up our time for someone else, we don't even get paid or reimbursed for our gas or our time spent we are not peddlers of God's word. I'm sure some who volunteer at a soup kitchen would understand what I mean. Our work is just as important if not more.  12/19/06 Sara Coatesville, PA This documentary is really good for all to see. There are many misconceptions about what we as Witnesses believe. And this video clears many of those misconceptions. The DVD is available for purchase at the video's website: www.knocking.org Definitely a well-worth video to purchase.  12/19/06
 As one of Jehovah's Witnesses I am very pleased with your work and proud of my brothers and sisters featured in the film. It shows them to be neither "saints" nor pariahs, but as an earlier poster said, ordinary people living their faith to the best of their ability. That's all God requires of us and there is no group on earth with more genuine happiness and positive outlook on mankind's future.
 If you (readers) haven't yet, you should really take a few minutes next time they call and ask some really pointed questions - but be willing to hear the answers. Then check everything against your own Bible and ask God to grant you understanding - you may be pleasantly surprised.  11/15/06
 Broomfield, CO
 Where did you guys get to see this? Here it isnt playing on the TV until May, 2007. I would love to see this before then.. can you tell me where?  11/2/06
 It is easy to see who have axes to grind and who don't by the bitter words in the comments but I married into a family that has members who are Witnesses and who are not about 30 years ago. Other than the holiday's that they don't celebrate, all of them get along and care for one another. Some of them were witnesses at some point but left or stopped going to their church, and there is no superior hypocracy or secret cult-like vendeta that pulses beneath the surface of our visits. The documentary showed that some people are upset about the distance that is sometimes difficult for the rest of us. But it also showed that they are just normal people who have the same problems we have and are just doing the best they can to serve God according to their beliefs. I enjoyed the show very much. Thank you for the insight.  10/30/06
 Paul
 Eugene, OR
 I saw a showing of this film and found it very balaced about what the Jehovah's Witnesses bible teachings are and followed real examples of real witnesses as normal people and the issues they face in life just like everyone else.  10/16/06
 CM
 US
 I just finished viewing the documentary and absolutely loved it. I don't know what all these negative remarks are about. A documentary is founded on finding facts and backing them up. Joel found the facts and legitamately published them. What's the big deal? Leave the Witnesses alone.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_a.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 11/27/2007
 I think this was one of the best documetaries ever done. I have read some of the posts on here may of which seem to be from bitter people either given the boot or just bitter because they did not get what they wanted. Either way, this is a DVD that I found interesting and while I will never be a witness, I know from visiting Bethel and in depth discussion with numeroous witnesses that they do their best and answer to no one on this planet. Interesting is all the ex witnesses who decided to leave and now speaking out. Get on with your lives and stop hating it proves nothing!  4/18/07
 11/20/2007
 It's unbelievable that JWs still deny the Watchtower's membership in the U.N. for about 9 years when it can easily be determined by a quick search and viewable documents. Oh, I forgot, they can't think for themselves and do any research. It's funny to read the stupid back-tracking by the WT trying to extricate themselves from this. They claim they joined only to get a library card to do research in the U.N.'s library, yet a card was never needed for access and all the U.N. material is available from other sources including colleges that are WT's neighbors.  4/18/07
 4/18/07
 Robert
 California
 I am intrigued by the title and some of the comments made about the film and the culture of Jehovah's Witnesses (JW's). As Mr. Herrera commented about the director's assurtions, I have personally experienced that, yes, you will be shunned by any of the JW's if you go against the teachings of The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, Brooklyn, NY. Another person alluded to the term cult. Since the JW's believe that one will not survive "Armaggedon" unless one becomes a JW, that is a cult. That is why they go "Knocking" on doors everyday so they can proselytize the people they encounter. They believe they are following the mandate set forth by Christ @ Matthew 24:14 and Mathew 28:19-20.
 I no longer am one of JW's. I chose to no longer ally myself with a false prophet. None of their founding fathers predictions came true. They claimed they spoke for Jehovah. CT Russel and JF Rutherford, et al, are liars. Sincere, perhaps, but liars, nonetheless. I love the JW's I left behind and pray for them daily. The real Jehovah, Jesus Christ, who prophecied He would come and die for us in Isaiah and told Zechariah "they will look upon me whom they pierced" (Zech. 12:10), did indeed die for us and rose again three days later. That I will take to the bank for it was prophecied years before it happened and there was and is testimony it actually happened. There's more I'd like to share, however, I'm out of time. I look forward to seeing the movie.  4/18/07
 Sharon
 Chicago, IL
 I was very suprised to hear from the film that Jehovah's Witnesses were called "Christians" when in fact they are not. A Christian is one who follows and believes the teachings of the Bible, accepting the fact that Christ was God who came in the flesh as the scriptures clearly teach. Jehovah's Witnesses believe that they will attain eternal life by their good works.This is a religion based on good works not Christ and what he did at Calvary. According to the Bible in Ephesians 2:8-9 salvation is NOT by OUR works but by CHRIST'S Sacrifice when He gave His life that we might receive the FREE GIFT of eternal life. "For by grace are ye saved through faith and that not of yourselves it is the gift of God, not of works, lest any man should boast." people need to be aware that JW's do not believe in the same Bible nor the same Christ that fundamental Christians have believed in for 100's of years before Jehovah's Witnesses ever began. please see www.towerwatch.com I'm sure this won't get posted since 99.9% of the postings are positive. Don't get me wrong, I have personally talked to many JW's. They are very wonderful and sincere people. However they are still a cult and still sincerely wrong.  4/18/07
 FIRST OF ALL JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ARE NOT PART OF THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH. CHRISTIANITY IS BUILT ON THE HOLY TRINITY (THE FATHER, SON AND HOLY SPIRIT AS ONE )WHICH THEY DO NOT BELIEVE IN. I HAVE SOME FAMILY MEMBERS WHO ARE JW AND ARE NOT ALLOWED TO ATTEND OTHER RELIGIOUS CEREMONIES SUCH AS A ROMAN CATHOLIC WEDDING. MY QUESTION TO ALL JW'S IS WHAT ARE YOU AFRAID OF? I TRULY BELIEVE JEHOVAHS WITNESSES IS A CULT AND WAS STARTED OUT AS ONE MANS WAY OF MAKING MONEY. ISNT HE THE ONE WHO PREDICTED THE END OF THE WORLD ON SPECIFIC DATES THAT HAVE PASSED 3 TIMES.  4/18/07
 Colorado Springs, Colorado
 I believe that Jehovah is the one and only true God. I did grow up in a JW family. I have yet to see the documentary, but from my personal studies I believe that the early JWs fought with zeal and pleasure to do Jah's will. However, today, I believe the JWs do want those associated with them to conform and not to question bible passages or interpretations that are provided to us. As long as you conform, go to all the meetings, and go out in service once a week, pretend to be someone who you may not really be; then acceptance is granted. No matter what you do with or without other JWs seeing what you do, then you are accepted and they will stand behind you. However, as in my experience, if you question the bible or what god truly expects us to understand from his often symbolic writings given to us through man (in the Holy Bible); then the stares begin and you begin to hear the whispers and the rumors. So, you search for a new congregation where no one knows you and as long as your conform, go all the meetings, and go out in service at least once a week, you are accepted once more. But then when you feel that you have given them a chance to know the real you and you start to question, then the vicious cycle continues and you are off to find another congregation. I understand the teachings are given to us through the aid of the governing class, but we are still human and imperfect. If the early JWs did not question the wicked world around us or the bible teachings of other religions, would they be here today? I have two (2) wonderful children who I will teach through the use of the bible (on my own) to love Jah with their whole hearts, minds and souls. Their decision to actually go the meetings will be their own. I will not go only hear that I should try harder to attend all the meetings and that Jah will provide. Jah no longer gets involved with man's affairs and only when Armageddon begins will Jah's son step in. I understand that sacrifices must be made, but not to the detriment of my family; whether Jah says so or not. My motherhood takes precidence. Why must I question whether I will make it into the new order to see my loved ones? Why must I be told that my heart condition is not right, but that another's is, when I at least remain true to myself? I have suffered low self-esteem by not conforming and will not subject my daughter's to the same unless they make that choice for themselves. Even Job through his most trying of times, questioned Jah. He never cursed Jah, but he did question? If I will not make into the new order, how many of today's JW will?  4/18/07
 Maggie
 Miami, Fl
 Clearly, almost everyone talking about KNOCKING belongs to the JW sect.Yes, it is a sect and a dangerous one at that! They take from the society at large everything they want, but they speak about it badly, and they harbour a great contempt for everybody and everything outside of their so-called religion.Especially, they are very venomous when it comes to the Catholics. According to their teachings, all other religions are false. Their religion is the only true religion and they even use the term THE TRUTH to describe it.
 In October 2006, they organized a big Campaign (that's how they described it) going door to door in Poland, where I am located, distributing propaganda brochures in which they called all other religions FALSE RELIGIONS, and warned about the approaching Armagedon. Of course, only JWs will survive it at the end. The rest of the world comes from the Satan himself and will not be worthy of the eternal life. Only I am curious why do JWs use so freely everything the outside world produces? And,yes,I know their teachings and mentality first hand. My mother and sister converted to them some 25 years ago. Since then, my sister married a "nonbeliever" (Catholic), converted him to her sect, then he become an Elder of their group(prestigous function), then last year he became gravely ill. He needed heart surgery, rejected blood, died. Doctors at the local hospital call his death, a death by choice. Truly tragic!  4/18/07
 It's so annoying to get hounded by Jehoa's witnesses and in my area they don't take no lightly as if they work on commission. I have been with my husband for 23 yrs and I can tell you that my mother in law is a Jehova's Witness. My husband hated every minute growing up in that belief. When he became a teenager he became rebelious because of it. I hear the stories he tells our kids and it's heart wrenching to think of the humiliation he was put through when kids had birthdays and he could not attend, when it was Christmas and he saw kids with their gifts and he got nothing. We have 3 boys and my mother in law never attended their baptism nor birthdays and my kids have notice and have been hurt because of it. They have no affections or feelings towards her at all. She fought for my husband and I not to continue to date, by bad mouthing my then boyfriend to my family, but he and I over came the obstacles she laid and we are happily married, with 3 boys and a good life. There was a Jehova's witness family that turned their back on their daughter because she got pregnant out of wedlock and not only the family, but other members of the Jehova's witness Kingdom Hall. That is insane. This is no religion this is a cult created by a man who revised the Bible to his liking.  4/18/07
 It would be wonderful if this would air on all of our PBS stations. You can see by this video that Jehovah's Witnesses are mis-understood, or have even been slandered against. For instance, when the man asked if we believe that Jesus is God's son. A lot of people are led to believe that we don't believe in Jesus. However, we know that Jesus is his Father Jehovah's means of saving those who exercize faith in his ransom sacrifice.The most imporatant thing with showing who Jehovah's Witnesses really are is the sancification or (hallow) of Jehovah's name
 (Matt. 6:9)
 Jehovah answeres questions people have through the bible, such as:
 Does God have a personal name?
 Why did Jesus have to die?
 Why did Jesus perform miracles, such as healing and raising people from the dead?
 What happens to us when we die?
 Why are we here/what is our purpose?
 What is required of us to gain salvation?
 Does Jehovah God care for each of us individually?
 Why does God allow suffering?
 ETC...
 Jehovah's Witnesses are trained
 to show people from the bible (their own personal copy, if they prefer)where to find these answers.  4/18/07
 Jared
 Spring Hill, FL
 I realy liked it because I understood it being a jehova's witness my self.When I saw the movie I felt so inspired and proud to know these bible scriptures and why we apply them in our lives.thank you for making that movie i really enjoyed it.  4/18/07
 Stlouismo
 The problem is you dont tell the whole story to -- you make out like you are good, and thats what sucks people in, JW's have done so much damage in our family.  4/3/07
 Virginia
 I agree with a previous poster regarding "enjoying 98% of the film". I felt the same way. I thought that overall it was very acurate and unbiased, but I did feel that a couple statements should have been explained. For example, when the grandmother of the young man used the word "cult" to describe the witnesses. I can appreciate why they would interview both sides of the family, both witnesses and non, but I did think they should have explained that we are NOT a "cult". Also the statment that if someone doesn't comform to the teachings they are "expelled". It wasn't explained that every effort is taken to correct the views of the erring person, and that even if a person is "expelled", they can still attend congregation meetings. Someone who has been "expelled" is encouraged to change their bad actions and return to a way of life that honors God and conforms to BIBLE teachings.
 On the other hand,I really enjoyed the parts where they did the street witnessing and showed the reactions of the listeners. Also, it was nice that the producer showed how JW's have helped in legal and medical matters for everyone. The experiences were interesting and encouraging. I hope that viewers who are not Jehovah's Witnesses will not just take every single point at face value, but will ask questions and get an in-depth explaination from a Witness who may knock at their door.  4/3/07
 Ruben Herrera
 Eagle Pass, Texas

 The film was great! I'd like to see another documentry and I'd like to see it on what people believe and why? We JW's know why we don't Celebrate Holidays or pledge to any flag but I wonder if most people ever question why they do or why they believe what they believe. This would be truly fascinat
ing and to be made by a some one like you would be truly fascinating.  4/3/07
 Ruben Herrera
 Eagle Pass, Texas
 I felt your portrayal of Witnesses was very unbiased and educational to some degree, especially for those who are trying to understand our beliefs and misconceptions. I thought that the scene where a brother is street witnessing in the parking lot with the driver saying a bad word was uncalled for and it wouldnt of taken away from the essence of the documentary at all. I just thought that it would of been better to have omitted that part. Overall, it was a very interesting documentary. I found it very interesting to see the comments people had on us. Thank you for such a candid approach to our organization.  2/26/07
 california
 I would say I liked 98% of it, and totally agree with the other reviews -but I need to express what I feel were negatives. I will admit that although the overall film seemed unbiased, let's be honest, the director is not one of JW's so will use some of his own feelings, being raised by a Witness mom, but for his own reasons not accepting it. I have to mention that I totally disagree with the statement in the beginning of the film to the effect "If you disagree with their teachings, you are expelled." When has that happened? Is he talking about apostates? It was a total blanket statement, (which means "a vague and noncommittal statement asserting a premise without providing evidence") That makes us sound like mindless robots that are not allowed to think for ourselves. This is a MINOR thing in the film, only one sentence, but it bothered me because he did not elaborate on what he meant, or allow for a response to his statement. If I was in a religion in which they controlled my thinking, told me what to do, when and how to do it, and not allowed freedom of thought, personally I would say "see ya"!- as I was extremely independent and anti-authority before accepting the truth from the Scriptures. I also felt that using worldly catch phrases like saying we are "conservative" ;"fundamentalists" and "apolitical", (that has a negative connotation- more accurate is "politically neutral") is kind of stereotyping us inaccurately. I loved the special feature which showed us "street witnessing" on the Brooklyn Bridge and also on 42nd street- that was cool. And the part where Joel quite fondly talks about being raised by a single Witness mom and going door to door with her as a kid. (but Joel, how many times did people have their dogs attack you while out in service, come on now) I could see his appreciation and perhaps missing it just a little. Once you know Jehovah, it never leaves you. You can certainly see it in his face.  2/26/07
 Oklahoma City, OK
 I am one of Jehovah's witnesses, and I'm so glad to see something positive about God's organization. I spent my life searching for even basic truths and never found them in any other religion. Knocking shows what God's will really is. It is not simply leading a clean moral life, but it is taking part in spreading the good news of God's kingdom. That's what Noah did, and then the flood came. We are simply taking part in fulfilling Jehovah's purpose in the final days. When we are not knocking at doors, we are writing letters or having bible studies, informal witnessing or whatever it takes to do God's will. Thats the whole theme of the bible.  2/26/07
 I've viewed the video and enjoyed it quite well. It was definitely unbiased. As a witness, we know that there are ones with distroted views of us, but I still found it interesting to hear how off the mark their perceptions were. If you're not taught the truth, you will have mis-conceptions. Maybe this video can better inform them.
 3/27/07 Turpen, NJ My family and I are looking forward to this broadcast on WHYY (Philadelphia). We saw the screening at the Trenton Film Festival and found it to be accurate and fair.  3/27/07
 WKJ
 Taylor, Michigan
 I must say that I enjoyed the documentary very much! After reading the various comments, I thought I'd add my two cents ... The documentary was very accurate in its portrayal of the facts (Accurate not perfect). However, those of us who are JW's should understand that an outside organization will never "get it" completely correct. They cannot grasp the essence, the nuance of what is means to live in the world and yet be "no part of it."
 Though they may not be biased they don't understand the "pure language" of the truth! Those of us who speak it and live it, we understand! I'm very happy that an outside group took the time to do the research and put forth a sincere effort to accurately portray who Jehovah's Witnesses are. All of us have our trials, they may not be the trials portrayed in the documentary but we all have our trials!
 PBS and the Independent Lens have an excellent reputation for presenting interesting, informative, ground breaking material. I only hope that they will show it in their markets at a time when many are able to see it. (This piece deserves to be shown in prime time (8:00 - 10:00 or at least 7:00 - 11:00). Knocking was produced by an outside group (not Jehovah's Witnesses); maybe people will view this piece with an open mind. That is MY hope ... To the directors of Knocking: "Well done" :)  2/8/07
 Seth Mansbridge
 Portsmouth, Britain
 I live in Britain and ordered "knocking" via the internet.
 I was enthralled by the Thomas & Kempler families story. An excellent documentary that gave a telling and honest insight not only into the respective families but Jehovah's Witnesses as a whole.
 I have been a Jehovah's Witness for some 23 years and if half of what i heard people say about us was even half true i would not be one. However the "knocking" documentary was a fair portrayal of who Jehovah's Witnesses are and the lengths they have gone to secure religious and self determination freedoms which benefit society in general.
 A big thank you to Joel P.Engardio and Tom Shepard for doing neither a "hit job" nor a "puff piece" but an accurate piece. Also the extras on the DVD were superb thoroughly enjoyed them.
 I hope those who are not Jehovah's Witnesses who watch this documentary are left with an increased understanding of who Jehovah's Witnesses are. Because understanding leads to tolerance of people with a diffirent viewpoint and s uch a tolerance is good for society.  2/8/07
 Desiree Johnston
 Tempe, AZ
 I studied the Bible for 2 years with a Jehovah's Witness about a year ago. Although I ended my Bible study (temporarily) because of my divorce and some IRS problems, I plan to resume as soon as I get things straightened out. I viewed the documentary DVD "Knocking" at a friends house. I commend you for having the GUTS to bring out the facts. If there's ONE thing I've learned from my study, it's THIS! Contrary to popular opinion, Jehovah's Witnesses are normal people, with strong faith, trying to live up to all of God's requirements, to the BEST of their imperfect ability. In fact, NORMAL people let me down every day, most times on purpose! But the Witnesses have been nothing but kind, generous and HONEST with me. They truly put the Bible and preaching first, other peoples interests second, and themselves last. (Just like Christ did!) And everytime I asked what God says about things, they showed me, right in my own Bible. The only reason I can see why people ridicule them, call them a cult, and accuse them of teaching their own beliefs, traditions and customs, is out of their own guilt. They can plainly see, like I did, that what they preach is from God, directly out of his word, the Bible. When you learn exactly what God expects of you, (i.e. preaching door to door, like Christ did) a responsibility is suddenly laid upon you. Then, you have a decision to make, like I do, to either make changes in your life and try to follow what the scriptures say, or dismiss it as merely private doctrines of Jehovah's Witnesses, calling them extremists and fanatics. Unfortunately, the latter is usually the choice most people make.  2/6/07
 V. Amiel
 Houston, Texas 77054
 We are Jehovah's Witnesses and this e-mail is just to let you know how much our family and friends are looking forward to seeing your broadcast of the film about Jehovah's Witnesses, entitled "KNOCKING". We are very appreciative of you showing this documentary. We were just informed yesterday by friend living in New York and have visited their website and is about to order 2 DVD - we are informing as many friends as possible to view it on KUHT Channel 8 in Houston on Tuesday May 22, 2007 at 10:00 PM. By the way, we always watch Independent Lens - it is an excellent program. Thank you for dealing with topics affecting the everyday lives of people that we can relate to on a very human level.  2/6/07
 Robin Hamamy
 Toronto Ontario Canada
 I am either the only one with negative comments or the Public submission selection has been very controlled. I find it very hard to fathom that you have received little or no criticism of your documentary.
 I was raised as a Witness and spent some 40 years being reared in the teachings, traditions and customs of this group. During this time I have seen the religion from all sides and have seen the good you portray as well as the bad which you completely ignore in your coverage.
 Whatever your mandate was, I submit that a similar documentary about the Catholic church during the middle ages would be derelict in its task if it concentrated solely on any positive role Catholicism played in European culture, politics, architecture, and art without also showing the negatives as well. Cathedral construction while magnificent to behold cannot erase the blood shed and human suffering endured through the crusades and the many inquisitions.  1/31/07
 JK
 California
 I am very impressed with the portrayal of Jehovah's Witnesses in this film. In so many instances Jehovah's Witnesses are ridiculed, spoken harshly against and persecuted for their beliefs and their activity in the preaching work. Finally a bright light has been shined upon them, in an un-biased way, not putting them on a pedestal...but it's fair, honest and factual. Thank you so much for the film.  1/25/07
 Nicola
 I had a chance to watch the first 8 minute trailer of this documentary and I think that it is a good piece. I am one of Jehovah's witnesss and as of late most questions that I hear from people at the door is about blood. Especially when I have my toddler with me. Last week one lady asked me, why is it I would let her die then give her blood. Of course I explained it to her, but I think this third party view is going to help so many people to see this issue from the other side. Unfortunetly I will have to tape it because it airs here in Tampa on May 22, which is a Tuesday and that is a meeting night for most JW living in the US.  1/25/07
 Lynn Saracco
 Snellville, GA
 Finally a beautifully presented piece about Jehovah's Witnesses. Which one touches the heart more, dear Seth Thomas, with his life at stake, or the Kemler family? What wonderful examples of those that take the Bible seriously & the blessing that come from our Father! Thank you so much for airing fine, factual programming.  1/25/07
 clarissa otiz
 brawley, ca
 we just received the "knocking" dvd and viewed it. it is extremely well done! i have been in the truth since i was 8 years old. i have many reasons to take pride in my faith, and this programming is one of many reasons that confirms my pride. i have something many in the world don't have. thankyou so much for the portrayal of who we are as an organization. may Jehovah use you again to let others know of who he is and what he has in store for mankind.  1/25/07
 Mark Banegas
 San Pedro Ca.
 I am a teacher for the Los Angeles Unified School District. I appreciated your unbiased work on Jehovah's Witnesses. its interesting to see how much of an effect that they have had on preserving the rights of all Americans in a round about way. I have seen the full DVD and those that have seen it are also planning on purchasing one for them selves and family.  1/19/07
 R G
 Apache Junction, AZ
 I just saw the trailer for this documentary and am very excited to see it. As a person who was raised as a Jehovah's Witness, stopped being one, and returned 10 years later, I know both sides of the mirror. This world is filled to the brim with horror stories and misconceptions about us and our beliefs. I am very pleased that someone, besides us, decided to take a non-biased look at who we are and what we believe. We are normal human beings with a strong faith living up to God's requirements to the best of our imperfect ability. Being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is LIVING the Golden Rule, a path not easily followed.
 To anyone who has ever heard anything good bad or otherwise and has never talked to one of us - please, please, take a look, you will be surprised.
 1/16/07
 Brittany Gulley
 Farmerville, Louisiana
 I am a young Jehovah's Witness and I have been associated with them all my life. I think it's great that they have a documentary about our faith, showing the truth about us, what we believe and who we stand for. I look forward to seeing it, and sharing it with others.  1/16/07
 Lulu
 Although I had some mixed feelings about the documentary, I was delighted it hear that the World Wide headquarters of Jehovah's Witnesses in Brooklyn, NY gave the approval for the production of such a film. It is truly interesting how Jehovah uses so many avenues and individuals to educate others. Now the world has been given a witness through the commonalities of the media and entertainment by people that aren't even one of Jehovah's Witnesses!  12/21/06
 Tim MacMillan
 Vancouver Canada
 Hi I married an athiest from Ukraine. Talk about not only a clash of cultures, but there was language and belief systems that were poles apart. My wife had never met a JW in Ukraine but heard terrible reports of them. She researched for 2 years on what was the truth, even going to an Orthodox priest for advice. In the end not only have we overcome the language and cultural barriers but now my wife goes out "knocking" with her 12 years old son to try to teach others the bible. It is an incredible turn around from a young woman who thought it all "ridiculous garbage" to teaching the bible to strangers. It is difficult for her as she is a shy person by nature but she demonstrates a courage that over 6 million other JW"s show on a daily basis. Iryna misses New Year and some othe other holidays but the trade off has been a happy family life and a hope for the future living in a paradise world without race or language barriers. Besides we have lots of fun at other times like "tubing" down Mt. Cypress last week. A s a family we enjoyed seeing a friend's "knocking" CD and now we will order our own copy. Well done to all those that participated in the documentary. Special thanks to Joel and Tom who collaborated to produce a riveting drama that unfolded to create an inspiring story. We are about to go to The Ukraine to live for the next year. If you would like to do a documentary of a father and 12 years old son travelling from Kiev to Yalta on the black sea then let me know. ukraine is an amazing place to make documentaries. There are so many stories there. The other idea I had was a documentary in Papua New Guinea searching to the Aleandra butterfly, the largest in the world. They are almost 1 foot in diameter and were rare when I was living there 25 years ago. The Awake journal did an article about the a few years ago. Thanks again to you all for your excellent presentation.  12/19/06
 Portland Or
 I thought this Documentary was portrayed in a non-biased way that was deeply moving and exciting to watch. It's hard as one of Jehovah's Wittiness to show or tell the whole world who we are and what our objective is without being ridiculed, called some sort of name, interrupted and or accused of or trying to brainwash someone just by talking to them. Having an interested outsider present this from his own viewpoint is a great way to show the whole world why we are willing to take time out from our own busy everyday living, to spend so many hours talking from door to door. I mean we have a personal life too just like anyone else. Instead of going to the beach for a day or sleeping in through the mornings we will spend it going door to door and if time permits then we engage in wholesome recreation like enjoying the beach and so forth. I think because of this people think we are crazy, that we would volunteer for this, give up our time for someone else, we don't even get paid or reimbursed for our gas or our time spent we are not peddlers of God's word. I'm sure some who volunteer at a soup kitchen would understand what I mean. Our work is just as important if not more.  12/19/06 Sara Coatesville, PA This documentary is really good for all to see. There are many misconceptions about what we as Witnesses believe. And this video clears many of those misconceptions. The DVD is available for purchase at the video's website: www.knocking.org Definitely a well-worth video to purchase.  12/19/06
 As one of Jehovah's Witnesses I am very pleased with your work and proud of my brothers and sisters featured in the film. It shows them to be neither "saints" nor pariahs, but as an earlier poster said, ordinary people living their faith to the best of their ability. That's all God requires of us and there is no group on earth with more genuine happiness and positive outlook on mankind's future.
 If you (readers) haven't yet, you should really take a few minutes next time they call and ask some really pointed questions - but be willing to hear the answers. Then check everything against your own Bible and ask God to grant you understanding - you may be pleasantly surprised.  11/15/06
 Broomfield, CO
 Where did you guys get to see this? Here it isnt playing on the TV until May, 2007. I would love to see this before then.. can you tell me where?  11/2/06
 It is easy to see who have axes to grind and who don't by the bitter words in the comments but I married into a family that has members who are Witnesses and who are not about 30 years ago. Other than the holiday's that they don't celebrate, all of them get along and care for one another. Some of them were witnesses at some point but left or stopped going to their church, and there is no superior hypocracy or secret cult-like vendeta that pulses beneath the surface of our visits. The documentary showed that some people are upset about the distance that is sometimes difficult for the rest of us. But it also showed that they are just normal people who have the same problems we have and are just doing the best they can to serve God according to their beliefs. I enjoyed the show very much. Thank you for the insight.  10/30/06
 Paul
 Eugene, OR
 I saw a showing of this film and found it very balaced about what the Jehovah's Witnesses bible teachings are and followed real examples of real witnesses as normal people and the issues they face in life just like everyone else.  10/16/06
 CM
 US
 I just finished viewing the documentary and absolutely loved it. I don't know what all these negative remarks are about. A documentary is founded on finding facts and backing them up. Joel found the facts and legitamately published them. What's the big deal? Leave the Witnesses alone.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_a.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/18/07
 J. Doe
 Seattle, Wa.
 Well, what can I say. I was not raised a JW but was a baptized member for over 30 yrs. During that time I met some wonderful people and some not so wonderful. Guess you can find that in just about any religion. The problem with the ones that I had dealings with was over money. They say they don't love money but their willing to ruin their relationships with friend and family over it. Then came the issue with my ex who was a baptized member longer than I. She ruined our marriage and abused our son (sexually) while under the pretense of being a JW. She is still a practicing member as far as I know. She is not the only one I knew that has abused children. While I strongly believe in their teachings I chose to leave because of the lack concern they exteneded to me and my son. My son is now a total athiest becaus of the hypocrisy he witnessed. The story could go on and on and I truly believe Jehovah is the only true God but his followers have a very long ways to go and just 1 movie or so isn't going t o change that.  4/18/07
 Bernie Diaz
 Ventura, California
 I want to thank you for this great documentary that deserves the attention of many non Jehovah's witnesses, such a honest portrayal of people living their faith, no stereotypes, slandering, or misguided ideas. Just an honest look at the reality of historical events and the present, just as the british broadcasting co. (Purple Triangles) (BBC) had portrayed true events..Thanks Greatly,, I enourage any one with questions in regards to this video or faith to contact www.watchtower.org  4/18/07
 Gary
 Jehovah's Witnesses are not Christians. Even though some are very devout, there is little similarities between the J.W.'s and the Christian faith. Do the research. They use the New World translation of the Bible which was translated mostly by Russel who never new Greek and has mistranslated John 1:1 incorrectly thereby showing that they are totally different from Christians. They believe Jesus was A god and not The God. So don't market them as present day Christians.  4/18/07
 I would like to add to my last comment that I find it rather intriguing that many of the comments posted on here are from Jehovah's Witnesses and they all bring out the same points. It goes to show that no matter where we live in the world we're still very much united even if we've never met becasue we share that exact same beliefs. This is most definitely a very encouraging thing to think about!  4/18/07
 I recently watched this film and I feel that it was totally amazing and upbuilding. I as one of Jehovah's Witnesses find it very interesting to see peoples' views of us in other parts of the world. It was also awesome to see our fellow brothers and sisters win when their faith was put to the test in such extreme ways. I agree with some of the other comments posted about using the word "expelled" and referring to us as a "cult" which we definitely are not. However I also found that other than that everything was very accurate. Many ones that I've talked to agree. I'm so glad that this documentary was made so that people who refuse to listen to us for whatever reason can look at their tv screen and get a basic understanding of what we're all about. The documentary was very encouraging and I hope that many get the chance to view it!!!  4/18/07
 Contrary to the many postings here, the underside of voluntarily leaving Jehovahs WItnesses is not addressed. Having been a witness for many years, I left because many of the teachings do not harmonize with the very scriptures they say they hold dear. Jehovah's WItnesses teach they alone have the truth, that it is wise to examine your religion, and if one decides to leave because the religion does not hold up to it's claims? They are shunned. The psychological ramifications of that act done in the so called name of love is a horrendous thing.Many leave because of a true love for God and Jesus. I was one who became a born again Christian after 35 years as a Jehovahs Witness. The film truly needed to speak with those who voluntarily left not for unamed sins, but because of genuine disagreement over doctrine.
 The Jehovah's WItnesses are not just another denomination who has gotten bad press occasionally and struggle mightily against bad public relations. I am very surprised, being a journalist myself, that more in depth digging wasn't done to see if the failed prophecies, back and forth teachings that changes with the wind, and some pretty strong theological tap dancing isn't the cause for a lot of the so called misconceptions. If people knew what went on behind the scenes( WItnesses are strongly encouraged NOT to check what they are taught)and died because of lack of blood transfusions, marriages that exploded because of shunning and the fact that many of a certain age weren'teven encouraged to seek higher education until a few years back, so they could devote more time to the *Organization* in the end times it might boggle their eyes. It is heart rending to see some of the things taught as the *truth*
 I would suggest ANYONE who would look at this documentary to be sure to do some mighty strong follow up when it comes to research of their teachings. AFter all truth can stand scrutiny.It is sad so many Jehovahs WItnesses won't check what they have been taught in depth.  4/18/07
 I was so delighted to see the 25 minute preview of this film "Knocking". I loved seeing my brothers & sisters out and about doing the preaching work that our earlier brothers fought so hard for us to have the right to do.And I was esp. thankful for the great Wittness that it is giving about our wonderful Heavenly Father, Jehovah.Its nice to see something "positive" about us in the media. Thank you.  4/18/07
 Unbiased is a word that is used often in the comments here, but surely we know that when a film is edited it is done according to someone's idea of what they want the movie to say. Call it what you want, but it is still one person's preferences and that is a form of bias.There are more former Jehovah's Witnesses in the world than tive ones and they have a different story to tell about a religion that has been rejected by 99% of the world who has heard the Jehovah's Witness message that in essence is this- "We have the Truth, you don't and Jehovah will destroy you , if you don't accept our teachings about the invisible return of Jesus in 1914 and become one of us."  4/18/07
 OUR FELLOW AMERICANS HAVE THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE THEIR OWN RELIGION, THANK GOD. HOWEVER, I MUST SAY, AS ONE WHO IS 73 YEARS OLD, A PROTESTANT SINCE THE AGE OF 10, A PIANIST AND ORGANIST AT MY CHURCH SINCE THE AGE OF 10, THAT THESE PEOPLE INTRUDE ON OUR PRIVACY. THEY COME IN GROUPS AND BANG ON OUR DOOR. SOMETIMES THEY AWAKE ME, FOR I HAVE HEALTH PROBLEMS AND AM SLEEPING OR CANNOT GET DOWN THE STEPS TO THE DOOR. RECENTLY THEY CAME TO OUR CULDESAC--GOING FROM ONE HOUSE TO THE OTHER OVER AND OVER. IN THIS DANGEROUS TIME, THEY WERE LUCKY SOME OF US DID NOT CALL 911. THEY NEED A DIFFERENT WAY TO WITNESS!!!!  4/18/07
 Selected submissions? Already suspicious here...Look, every time I meet a JW, they want me to read their literature, which I am happy to do if they read mine. They refuse. They are not allowed. Restraining intellectual debate thru restricting reading is a form of mind control. When I looked into the history of JW...also very suspicious. Pastor Russell's overpriced "miracle wheat" and ever changing doctrines is just a little bizarre. He claimed Christ, who had returned invisibly in 1874, would call the remnant of 144,000 to heaven in 1914. The millennium of Revelation 20:2 would commence and humanity would have a second chance at life on a paradise Earth. Several missed prophesies ensued. JW's? Most nice folks...but misled nonetheless. Have no clue of the shady history.  4/18/07
 Very well done. I applaude you. Many people are misinformed about Jehovah's Witnesses. As one of the persons mentioned, they thought that they knew JW's through the stories, jokes, media coverage, etc. but found out that they actually "did not know" much about them. Such as: not believing in Jesus Christ, not believing in the Bible, not accepting medical treatments, etc. To find out exactly what JW's believe, take the time to listen, ponder, and ask them questions directly. Don't ask your minister, priest, or reverend, what the Witnesses believe, because they don't know either and you will never know the truth. As an older person once told me, "if you want to know about a Chevrolet, do you ask the Ford dealer? If you want to know about a Cadillac, do you ask the Lincoln dealer? Absolutely not! So if you want to know about Jehovah's Witnesses, who do you ask? The Witnesses". Joel, thank you for your unbiased and enlightening film and editorial!  4/18/07
 I know nothing about JW, however, I am looking forward to watching the movie when it comes out. I hope I am home to watch it or I can record it. I'm 30, and my whole life, my family shut the door in JW face when they knocked on the door. Same with Mormans. But I can say, both are more faithful than what church I attend. I've never been out "knocking" in my church. I look forward to this film.  4/18/07
 It was rather bothersome to read the write up on this film and see writer try to pass off Jehovah's witnesses as Christians. They are NOT Christians, period. For that matter, niether are Mormons. Do a word study on the name Christian and you will find that it is a name specifically given to followers of Jesus Christ. A different Jesus than the one portraid by both JW's and Mormons. The Christian Jesus is both fully God and fully man, after all, thats what the Scripture teach. Don't just take what your being indoctrinated with to heart with out doing your own studies. the original language clearly portray's Jesus as God. I truly do Love both JW's and Mormons and it's my hope and prayer that you both search the Scriptures with an open heart in order to recieve all that God has for you. If you did, you would not only find that Jesus is God, but that the verses you use concerning blood transfusion is out of context. God bless you all!  4/18/07
 S. Conyers
 Dallas Texas
 I was a JW for more than 15 years and I have to say this, this is not a religion, this is a cult. I was abused, mislead and tormented not only while in the JW "organization" but was forced to cut off from my family becz they were not JW's. The mind set of a JW is that they are perfect or "right" or "the truth" when in actuality they are living in fear and guilt and shame. It wasn't until I left after so many years of abuse and so many false prophesies that never came to pass that I saw, clearly, that the JW's are not a Christian religion, they are a cult that uses the Lord to try to paint a "pretty picture" and "pretend " to be a Christian religion. I am a Christian now and I truly believe that films like this mislead the public into trusting a cult that not only abuses its members but allows pedophiles, woman beaters and more to not get punished. (and yes, I was abused in such a way and yes, the ones who hurt me in this way were not even reprimanded)SEE the truth, explore the lies that the JW's have told for over 100 years and see that they are not a true religion, they are false prophets.  4/18/07
 april
 tulsa, ok
 I was raised jehovah's witness, we went door to door since I was two years old, i was trained and taught how to preach "the truth" as a very young, scared child always being told the world was going to end, the end would be here at any time and all was going to hell except "the chosen 144,000" and those that were chosen to live forever on earth AFTER it and all that sin was destroyed. on many occasions i was put in a room with 4 or 5 elders of the church to convince me that i was a sinner and would not live forever or go to heaven, if i kissed a boy or went to a school dance or listened to rock music or even played holiday songs in the band. i was told women should not work or have a career, they should be obedient wives and continue to go door to door full time. at age 18 i dissassociated myself from "the truth", i told THEM that their religion was like a horrible fiction fantasy novel. My family disowned me for years, i was among the worldly where i had never been, i lost every friend i had since child hood. RECENTLY I JOINED THE UNITED STATES ARMY & I LOVE MY COUNTRY, AMERICANS AND I LOVE MY GOD!!!! IF MY MOTHER OR FATHER'S LIFE WAS AT STAKE I WOULD NOT HESITATE TO TELL THE DR. TO GIVE THEM BLOOD CAUSE I LOVE THEM & WOULD STOP AT NOTHING TO SAVE THEM OR ANY OF MY FAMILY.  4/18/07
 Ashley Sparks
 Royal, AR
 Being a Jehovah Witness to me means that I know where I belong. People dont understand us. I know our religion is weird casue we dont celebrate holidays but we are people to and were called cristians to. I'm only 13 yrs old and nobody told me to become a witness I did it on my own. When you have a problem they are there to listen to you and to support you and you know that they are clean and decent people.The only thing that I care about it that my nena comes back into the truth and that people who are witnesses stay because it takes courage not to sulete the flag and all that kind of stuff. We do put alot into faith but our health is also imporant that is why we dont do drugs or or smoke or drink. God wanted us to be healthy and that is what we are!  4/18/07
 shawn
 TX
 I didn't see the movie but I wonder if they mentioned that the JW cult was started by a man who just made the watch towers to sell and make money. Or that they only call God "Jehovah" because that was his true name. Or that they believe everyone else is wrong to call him God, when in fact they now know that God was first called "Yahweh". Religion is something in your heart, something between you and God. Not something you call yourself or some cult you're in. If Jw's are the only ones that are right, what happens to all the souls that were here on earth and lived good Christian lives before the watch tower was started? Just accept God as your Lord and Savior, obey the Ten Commandments, and use the rest of the Bible as stories on how to live your life.  4/18/07
 Shawn Herrold
 I think that they shouldnt show this movie or show, because I dont believe in J.W's. How can they say that they are Christians when they dont believe in the Holy Trinity or Rapture. Someday, if the Lord Terries, I know where I'm going to be and in the bible it says that if you aren't a Child of God and know him as your personal saviour, then you wont be seeing the Kingdom of God, and you will be judged at the Great White Throne Judgement. Rev 21: 12-14 says that all unsaved believers will be judged there.  4/18/07
 Irene
 I grow up as a jw, didn't like it, and i think im really miss up in the head, what they put in your head can really fear you for the rest of your life.  4/18/07
 Leave the Jehovah's Witnesses alone. They are doing what they believe God wants them to do. It is in their mind, and their hearts. Many of us believe differently. They have always been very nice when they knocked on my door. I politely tell them I am not interested, and they politely walk away.  4/18/07
 Gina
 Baltimore Maryland
 I guess we'll see if you post this remark, because as a former JW I am all to aware of the fact that JW's hide enything and EVERYTHING negative about this religion. Why not present a documentary about the sexual, verbal and emotional abuse by their own people in relation to their own family members. Why not discuss the fact that the JW religion has a higher rate of sexual abuse (over 10,000 reported cases)than the Catholics! Tell the story of how the JW's hide what really goes on behind closed doors. I was raised and lived in their world for the better part of my life - and fortunately did not die in either of my two suicide attempts because of what I underwent with my family.
 Are you aware they believe unless you are a JW you will be killed at Armageddon? They plan to live in a paradise earth forever while the rest of the world perish. Are you aware they feel they belong to the only true religion and that there are no others worthy of God's love. Are you aware they disown their sons and daug hters because of their beliefs?
 So they fought for the right to not pledge allegiance to a government and they chose concentration camps instead of war. that's great! Can you think of any other religous groups who have done similiar and even greater things with their beliefs? Do your homework people.Nice piece, but don't believe everything you're told. Do a little more digging. You may be sickened by what you find.  4/18/07
 Chris Browne
 Rock Island, IL
 Christians were faced with the same choice of fighting for the Third Reich or the concentration camps; the Jehovah Witnesses were no different, although their numbers were considerably smaller, and they drew attention because they were different and a minority. This is not typical of the 'balance' with which Cathoics have been treated; i.e., assume guilt until otherwise proven, and refuse to admit the veracity of the proof offered. Do a documentrary on the campaign against Catholicism in the early years of the Nazi ascendency. The Nazis knew that the Catholic Church was one of the significant obstacles to its plan, and saw to it that it was, in effect, crippled within Germany before proceeding with the "Final Solution".  4/18/07
 Michael Musok
 Binghamton, New York
 I enjoyed the DVD very much and was pleasantly surprised that outside sources (non - Jehovah's Witnesses)pointed out positives rather than negative inaccuracies that have been associated with some tv news articles and programs in the past. I do think, however, that the statement that thousands are disfellowshiped each year could have been expanded upon, explaining that some 90 percent of those thousands are reinstated and back with the organization within one year.  4/18/07
 EMR
 New York City
 I have yet to see the film on the Jehova's Witnesses as it will air in NY on May 22. I'm looking forward to seeing it as i enjoy the high quality documentaries produced by Independent Lens. Having said this, i hope i will not be discualified from having my view posted.
 As most of the comments i read are very positive, this leads me to suspect the film to be a "politically correct potrayal" or just showing a fraction of very positive contributions by this organization. I on the other hand, had a very different experience of the Organization and the people in it. Seeing the organization from the "inside" as a non JW was very troubling. I married someone who was raised a JW but was not practicing when we were dating. Shortly after the first year we were married (which by the way, the marriage ended after eight and a half years) he became an active participant in the organization -full force! I kept an open mind and began listening to what he and his JW friends had to say as well as attended their meetings and began years of personal research. There is much evidence out there for those who truly dedicate their time to find the facts on their beliefs and practices. Their rigid beliefs of faith and views on what to celebrate or not lead me on a personal journey and challenged my own beliefs (i had been raised in a home of an athiest father and Christian mother-but God was not a reality in my life). During this journey, which i'm still on, i have discovered the words of Jesus very freeing when he said "take my yoke upon you for is easy and light". Religious practices i.e. do's and don'ts of each organization are such a burden which no one can ever fulfill but in this search and journey i find that to have a relationship with God as a friend i can talk to about all my unbelief, doubt, fears, hopes and dreams AND personal demons- such freedom! Now this is worth living for, not that i will not please God because of fear to give blood to my child who may die for not givig it blood (which by the way was an Old testament Law given for health purposes) or celebrating a birthday. Wether or not a person believes in God or not i think most would agree that we must celebrate Life and not death, freedom and peace. Lastly, let The Almighty God reveal who He truly is in a personal way to each person and let us mere humans stop trying to define Him or put Him in a box! Thank you for the opportunity to express my experience.  4/18/07
 P. S. Theilen
 Del Valle, Texas
 Jahovah's Witnesses are not a Misunderstood Christian Faith they are not Christian's (Christ like).They do not follow Jesus Christ.They follow God. They do not believe that Jesus Christ is the Way, Truth,and the Light.They do not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.  4/18/07
 Stan Knowles
 ilmington, NC
 Why would you people refer to Jehovah's Witnesses as people who are misunderstood regarding their "chrisian faith?" The truth is...you people don't know what you are talking about. Jehovah's Witnesses are NOT CHRISTIANS. Ask any Jehovah's Witness if Jesus Christ is the Son of God...as He said He was... or if Jesus is God...as He said He was...and they will tell you unequivocably, "NO!" You people need to get your facts straight. Only a follower and believer in Jesus Christ as Savior....is a Christian! That's not being judgmental.... that's the truth!  4/18/07
 Tov
 stroudsburg, pa
 I live and let live. I have no problem with freedom of speech. The issue, as I see it, is not about the JW's devotion to their beliefs. Many people are clearly impassioned about their schools of thought. Obviously we will know most certainly when we cross the other side. We can naturally find some political and/or social virtues in almost anything. The problem I have with the JW's is the meticulous alteration of everythign concerning Jesus/Jeshua in the documents produced by the Jews -- the Tenach and the New Testament. These changes were not based on scholarship, since there were no, not one Hebrew or Greek scholar who made the changes. The changes were made exclusively by the personal inspiration of Charles Russel. That spells personal agenda.  4/18/07
 Elijah L. Mason
 Mooresville, NC
 Just to tell you Jehovah Witnesses aren't Christians. They don't believe that Jesus is God (which is the definition of a Christian). I feel sorry for them though. They don't celebrate and they don't think they're going to heaven (or something like that). I didn't watch the show so I wouldnt know. I like them and everything but I think it's sad that they don't vote. Maybe abortion would have ended by now if they did.  4/18/07
 Keri
 While they may be misunderstood and controversial, jehovah's witnesses are not to be confused with Christians. Their doctrines, dogmas and core beliefs are not based upon the biblical teachings of Jesus Christ.  4/18/07
 Bri
 Im am one of jehovahs witnesses and i cant wait to see the film! I dont understand why people would think we are a cult. Jehovah gives you a choice, you choose to do his will, or you dont. Simple as that. I feel and see my prayers answered everyday and Jehovah truly is the only one who can help you find happiness in this WICKED WORLD.
 my fav scripture
 >>>>John 3:16<<<<  4/18/07
 Lillian
 My mother was a Witness and my father was a Jew. Quite a way to be raised. I will say that it was a completely miserable childhood. Having no tolerance for other religeons and tryig to make the world a place where there are no grey areas. You were right or wrong, evil or good in my mothers eyes. I watched as my friends celebrated their birthdays, Christmas, Halloween. It was a childhood COMPLETELY void of fun. Honestly, we all know there is one God who created us and loves us. Pigeon holing ourselves into relgeons who refuse or even begin to think that maybe it is OK to live and let live and to just love and be kind to each other. Why can't that just be enough?  4/18/07
 Todd
 Southfield, MI
 I don't know why people insist on including Jehovah's Witnesses as a Christian denomination. It is not a Christian faith. It is one entirely of its own. They may talk about Jesus, or even believe some things to be true about him; but ultimately, they do not believe that Jesus is who he says he is (according to the original, unedited canon) and so they are not Christian. It's quite possible there are Christians within that religion, but odds are they are few, and dangerously close to being led astray.  4/18/07
 Kay
 I was not surprised to see the statement "Selected submissions will be posted"... after studying the J.W.'s beliefs I realized that putting a religion before your own children's health and welfare was not for me. God gave kids parents to take the best care of them. Going door to door is extremely dangerous! Extricating a member who questions something not quite understood is extreme, demeaning and does not show support. Also, if you live in this wonderful country, you should respect it....not saluting the flag is just disrespectful.  4/18/07
 Sam
 I thought the video was refreshing for a change. I was raised in the religion, but no longer attend. I still believe in Jehovah with all my heart and even though I have been deeply hurt by those in the religion by no means do I consider them all bad. I wish things would have been different ... I really do!
 I do admire those who can go to the doors of others and talk to them about Jehovah and his kingdom, but at the same time do not foreget those who are suffering tremendous hardships that maybe only Jehovah knows about. Don't judge too quickly. Take a couple Saturdays and visit those you have not seen at the meetings in a while and spend genuine time with them. It is not just about reaching new ones, but also about believing in the ones who are at the meetings.God does not count our hours of service, he reads our hearts. Remember the story about the lady who gave all she had. Please in the future don't be quick to judge for you never know what battle someone is fighting behind closed doors. I love you all and wish life was not so unkind.  4/18/07
 Anna
 I haven't seen the documentary, but I know I lived part of it. A little background. I grew up Catholic, one of six children. My Mother's best friend is a JW and in grade school and middle scool I was frequently 'farmed out' to her on weekends. Just so you know, to this day I send her a Mother's Day card. Anyway, here I was, being Catholic educated and finding Fri night meetings very inspirational. Went 'knocking' on Sat morns, meeting again on Sunday. For 12 years of Catholic education I learned more about the Bible from my interactions with the JW's (Tues nite Bible study helped). I was so accepted at meetings that I was allowed to give my own talks. These people were family. One Sat (I was pretty young) we were knocking and a woman answered her door, I had the Watchtower, and she told me she was Catholic and could'nt listen. Imagine her surprise when I said "I'm Catholic, too. It never hurts to read about the Bible." I loved knocking - gave me a chance to make people think. What I learned about the Bible gave me a chance to have the nuns and priests who 'taught' me religion scramble when I challenged what they told me the Bible said (lot's of fun for someone in high school). I'm 51 now and no longer go knocking, but I'm always courteous to the JW's who come to my door with the Watchtower and Awake, because, know what? It never hurts to read about the Bible.  4/18/07
 David Dzubin
 1/2 of my life was spent in the Witnesses and the more recent half has been spent out of the witnesses. This movie is refreshing. Many questions unanswered to others who just didn't understand. I am who I am today because of the teachings, trainings of the Witnesses and Do not Regret for a moment what I 'missed out on" because of what I had gained. My lifestyle does not allow me to be a member of their organization as I'm following my heart, yet I know that NO ORGANIZATION or One person is perfect so I pray that I too will be included in Gods Master plan, if not in this life time, in another.  4/18/07
 I do not believe Jehovahs witnesses are Christian so this misrepresents them. A Christian is one who believes in A triune God(the Father , son and Holy Spirit. They don't and believe in them as seperate intities. Also, the Translinear Bible is not the Bible that the Christians study and believe,many words big and small were changed to suit the beliefs of these people, they don't believe that the Christian Bible is the true word of God. Also, they follow a man who made many predictions including the end of the world, that never came to pass. A Christian is a Christian and it doesn't matter what denomination you are within the Christian faith, it is simply Jesus +0=salvation(heaven and eternal life) not by works(knocking) are you saved but by your acceptance of what Christ did on the cross(payment of sin)their is nothing that we can do physically to buy forgiveness or our way to heaven. When something doesn't come to pass that their leaders reveal as prophesy they just change the words of their book or back track. The Bible does not support this. It is in recent years that they are referred to as Christians along with the Mormons, it simply isn't true. Christianity is not a new idea as the Mormons and the Jehovahs(mid1800'S) PEOPLE HAVE BEEN CHANGING THE LAWS AND THE WORLD SINCE THE TIME OF CHRIST AND BEFORE AS WELL AS STANDING UP FOR THEIR BELIEFS AND DYING FOR THEM. tHIS COUNTRY CAME TO BE BY THESE BRAVE PEOPLE WILLING TO DIE FOR cHRIST. 4/18/07
 There is nothing wrong in the universe with living or dieing for your beliefs, as long as you follow the basic rules, don't hate-but love, don't judge-but forgive, don't hurt but help. Of all of these forgiveness and love are the strongest. BUT TO PUT A CAP ON IT DON'T BE MISLED INTO ANOTHER JONESTOWN.  4/18/07
 WB
 CA
 From Charles Taze Russell to Don Adams.The TNW (thier version of the Bible) they have done nothing but Ignore,"The Truth" Some Very important Questions. Is the Watchtower Society's translation of the Bible accurate? Is the Society's teaching on salvation bibical? No and NO..

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_b.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/18/07
 J. Doe
 Seattle, Wa.
 Well, what can I say. I was not raised a JW but was a baptized member for over 30 yrs. During that time I met some wonderful people and some not so wonderful. Guess you can find that in just about any religion. The problem with the ones that I had dealings with was over money. They say they don't love money but their willing to ruin their relationships with friend and family over it. Then came the issue with my ex who was a baptized member longer than I. She ruined our marriage and abused our son (sexually) while under the pretense of being a JW. She is still a practicing member as far as I know. She is not the only one I knew that has abused children. While I strongly believe in their teachings I chose to leave because of the lack concern they exteneded to me and my son. My son is now a total athiest becaus of the hypocrisy he witnessed. The story could go on and on and I truly believe Jehovah is the only true God but his followers have a very long ways to go and just 1 movie or so isn't going t o change that.  4/18/07
 Bernie Diaz
 Ventura, California
 I want to thank you for this great documentary that deserves the attention of many non Jehovah's witnesses, such a honest portrayal of people living their faith, no stereotypes, slandering, or misguided ideas. Just an honest look at the reality of historical events and the present, just as the british broadcasting co. (Purple Triangles) (BBC) had portrayed true events..Thanks Greatly,, I enourage any one with questions in regards to this video or faith to contact www.watchtower.org  4/18/07
 Gary
 Jehovah's Witnesses are not Christians. Even though some are very devout, there is little similarities between the J.W.'s and the Christian faith. Do the research. They use the New World translation of the Bible which was translated mostly by Russel who never new Greek and has mistranslated John 1:1 incorrectly thereby showing that they are totally different from Christians. They believe Jesus was A god and not The God. So don't market them as present day Christians.  4/18/07
 I would like to add to my last comment that I find it rather intriguing that many of the comments posted on here are from Jehovah's Witnesses and they all bring out the same points. It goes to show that no matter where we live in the world we're still very much united even if we've never met becasue we share that exact same beliefs. This is most definitely a very encouraging thing to think about!  4/18/07
 I recently watched this film and I feel that it was totally amazing and upbuilding. I as one of Jehovah's Witnesses find it very interesting to see peoples' views of us in other parts of the world. It was also awesome to see our fellow brothers and sisters win when their faith was put to the test in such extreme ways. I agree with some of the other comments posted about using the word "expelled" and referring to us as a "cult" which we definitely are not. However I also found that other than that everything was very accurate. Many ones that I've talked to agree. I'm so glad that this documentary was made so that people who refuse to listen to us for whatever reason can look at their tv screen and get a basic understanding of what we're all about. The documentary was very encouraging and I hope that many get the chance to view it!!!  4/18/07
 Contrary to the many postings here, the underside of voluntarily leaving Jehovahs WItnesses is not addressed. Having been a witness for many years, I left because many of the teachings do not harmonize with the very scriptures they say they hold dear. Jehovah's WItnesses teach they alone have the truth, that it is wise to examine your religion, and if one decides to leave because the religion does not hold up to it's claims? They are shunned. The psychological ramifications of that act done in the so called name of love is a horrendous thing.Many leave because of a true love for God and Jesus. I was one who became a born again Christian after 35 years as a Jehovahs Witness. The film truly needed to speak with those who voluntarily left not for unamed sins, but because of genuine disagreement over doctrine.
 The Jehovah's WItnesses are not just another denomination who has gotten bad press occasionally and struggle mightily against bad public relations. I am very surprised, being a journalist myself, that more in depth digging wasn't done to see if the failed prophecies, back and forth teachings that changes with the wind, and some pretty strong theological tap dancing isn't the cause for a lot of the so called misconceptions. If people knew what went on behind the scenes( WItnesses are strongly encouraged NOT to check what they are taught)and died because of lack of blood transfusions, marriages that exploded because of shunning and the fact that many of a certain age weren'teven encouraged to seek higher education until a few years back, so they could devote more time to the *Organization* in the end times it might boggle their eyes. It is heart rending to see some of the things taught as the *truth*
 I would suggest ANYONE who would look at this documentary to be sure to do some mighty strong follow up when it comes to research of their teachings. AFter all truth can stand scrutiny.It is sad so many Jehovahs WItnesses won't check what they have been taught in depth.  4/18/07
 I was so delighted to see the 25 minute preview of this film "Knocking". I loved seeing my brothers & sisters out and about doing the preaching work that our earlier brothers fought so hard for us to have the right to do.And I was esp. thankful for the great Wittness that it is giving about our wonderful Heavenly Father, Jehovah.Its nice to see something "positive" about us in the media. Thank you.  4/18/07
 Unbiased is a word that is used often in the comments here, but surely we know that when a film is edited it is done according to someone's idea of what they want the movie to say. Call it what you want, but it is still one person's preferences and that is a form of bias.There are more former Jehovah's Witnesses in the world than tive ones and they have a different story to tell about a religion that has been rejected by 99% of the world who has heard the Jehovah's Witness message that in essence is this- "We have the Truth, you don't and Jehovah will destroy you , if you don't accept our teachings about the invisible return of Jesus in 1914 and become one of us."  4/18/07
 OUR FELLOW AMERICANS HAVE THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE THEIR OWN RELIGION, THANK GOD. HOWEVER, I MUST SAY, AS ONE WHO IS 73 YEARS OLD, A PROTESTANT SINCE THE AGE OF 10, A PIANIST AND ORGANIST AT MY CHURCH SINCE THE AGE OF 10, THAT THESE PEOPLE INTRUDE ON OUR PRIVACY. THEY COME IN GROUPS AND BANG ON OUR DOOR. SOMETIMES THEY AWAKE ME, FOR I HAVE HEALTH PROBLEMS AND AM SLEEPING OR CANNOT GET DOWN THE STEPS TO THE DOOR. RECENTLY THEY CAME TO OUR CULDESAC--GOING FROM ONE HOUSE TO THE OTHER OVER AND OVER. IN THIS DANGEROUS TIME, THEY WERE LUCKY SOME OF US DID NOT CALL 911. THEY NEED A DIFFERENT WAY TO WITNESS!!!!  4/18/07
 Selected submissions? Already suspicious here...Look, every time I meet a JW, they want me to read their literature, which I am happy to do if they read mine. They refuse. They are not allowed. Restraining intellectual debate thru restricting reading is a form of mind control. When I looked into the history of JW...also very suspicious. Pastor Russell's overpriced "miracle wheat" and ever changing doctrines is just a little bizarre. He claimed Christ, who had returned invisibly in 1874, would call the remnant of 144,000 to heaven in 1914. The millennium of Revelation 20:2 would commence and humanity would have a second chance at life on a paradise Earth. Several missed prophesies ensued. JW's? Most nice folks...but misled nonetheless. Have no clue of the shady history.  4/18/07
 Very well done. I applaude you. Many people are misinformed about Jehovah's Witnesses. As one of the persons mentioned, they thought that they knew JW's through the stories, jokes, media coverage, etc. but found out that they actually "did not know" much about them. Such as: not believing in Jesus Christ, not believing in the Bible, not accepting medical treatments, etc. To find out exactly what JW's believe, take the time to listen, ponder, and ask them questions directly. Don't ask your minister, priest, or reverend, what the Witnesses believe, because they don't know either and you will never know the truth. As an older person once told me, "if you want to know about a Chevrolet, do you ask the Ford dealer? If you want to know about a Cadillac, do you ask the Lincoln dealer? Absolutely not! So if you want to know about Jehovah's Witnesses, who do you ask? The Witnesses". Joel, thank you for your unbiased and enlightening film and editorial!  4/18/07
 I know nothing about JW, however, I am looking forward to watching the movie when it comes out. I hope I am home to watch it or I can record it. I'm 30, and my whole life, my family shut the door in JW face when they knocked on the door. Same with Mormans. But I can say, both are more faithful than what church I attend. I've never been out "knocking" in my church. I look forward to this film.  4/18/07
 It was rather bothersome to read the write up on this film and see writer try to pass off Jehovah's witnesses as Christians. They are NOT Christians, period. For that matter, niether are Mormons. Do a word study on the name Christian and you will find that it is a name specifically given to followers of Jesus Christ. A different Jesus than the one portraid by both JW's and Mormons. The Christian Jesus is both fully God and fully man, after all, thats what the Scripture teach. Don't just take what your being indoctrinated with to heart with out doing your own studies. the original language clearly portray's Jesus as God. I truly do Love both JW's and Mormons and it's my hope and prayer that you both search the Scriptures with an open heart in order to recieve all that God has for you. If you did, you would not only find that Jesus is God, but that the verses you use concerning blood transfusion is out of context. God bless you all!  4/18/07
 S. Conyers
 Dallas Texas
 I was a JW for more than 15 years and I have to say this, this is not a religion, this is a cult. I was abused, mislead and tormented not only while in the JW "organization" but was forced to cut off from my family becz they were not JW's. The mind set of a JW is that they are perfect or "right" or "the truth" when in actuality they are living in fear and guilt and shame. It wasn't until I left after so many years of abuse and so many false prophesies that never came to pass that I saw, clearly, that the JW's are not a Christian religion, they are a cult that uses the Lord to try to paint a "pretty picture" and "pretend " to be a Christian religion. I am a Christian now and I truly believe that films like this mislead the public into trusting a cult that not only abuses its members but allows pedophiles, woman beaters and more to not get punished. (and yes, I was abused in such a way and yes, the ones who hurt me in this way were not even reprimanded)SEE the truth, explore the lies that the JW's have told for over 100 years and see that they are not a true religion, they are false prophets.  4/18/07
 april
 tulsa, ok
 I was raised jehovah's witness, we went door to door since I was two years old, i was trained and taught how to preach "the truth" as a very young, scared child always being told the world was going to end, the end would be here at any time and all was going to hell except "the chosen 144,000" and those that were chosen to live forever on earth AFTER it and all that sin was destroyed. on many occasions i was put in a room with 4 or 5 elders of the church to convince me that i was a sinner and would not live forever or go to heaven, if i kissed a boy or went to a school dance or listened to rock music or even played holiday songs in the band. i was told women should not work or have a career, they should be obedient wives and continue to go door to door full time. at age 18 i dissassociated myself from "the truth", i told THEM that their religion was like a horrible fiction fantasy novel. My family disowned me for years, i was among the worldly where i had never been, i lost every friend i had since child hood. RECENTLY I JOINED THE UNITED STATES ARMY & I LOVE MY COUNTRY, AMERICANS AND I LOVE MY GOD!!!! IF MY MOTHER OR FATHER'S LIFE WAS AT STAKE I WOULD NOT HESITATE TO TELL THE DR. TO GIVE THEM BLOOD CAUSE I LOVE THEM & WOULD STOP AT NOTHING TO SAVE THEM OR ANY OF MY FAMILY.  4/18/07
 Ashley Sparks
 Royal, AR
 Being a Jehovah Witness to me means that I know where I belong. People dont understand us. I know our religion is weird casue we dont celebrate holidays but we are people to and were called cristians to. I'm only 13 yrs old and nobody told me to become a witness I did it on my own. When you have a problem they are there to listen to you and to support you and you know that they are clean and decent people.The only thing that I care about it that my nena comes back into the truth and that people who are witnesses stay because it takes courage not to sulete the flag and all that kind of stuff. We do put alot into faith but our health is also imporant that is why we dont do drugs or or smoke or drink. God wanted us to be healthy and that is what we are!  4/18/07
 shawn
 TX
 I didn't see the movie but I wonder if they mentioned that the JW cult was started by a man who just made the watch towers to sell and make money. Or that they only call God "Jehovah" because that was his true name. Or that they believe everyone else is wrong to call him God, when in fact they now know that God was first called "Yahweh". Religion is something in your heart, something between you and God. Not something you call yourself or some cult you're in. If Jw's are the only ones that are right, what happens to all the souls that were here on earth and lived good Christian lives before the watch tower was started? Just accept God as your Lord and Savior, obey the Ten Commandments, and use the rest of the Bible as stories on how to live your life.  4/18/07
 Shawn Herrold
 I think that they shouldnt show this movie or show, because I dont believe in J.W's. How can they say that they are Christians when they dont believe in the Holy Trinity or Rapture. Someday, if the Lord Terries, I know where I'm going to be and in the bible it says that if you aren't a Child of God and know him as your personal saviour, then you wont be seeing the Kingdom of God, and you will be judged at the Great White Throne Judgement. Rev 21: 12-14 says that all unsaved believers will be judged there.  4/18/07
 Irene
 I grow up as a jw, didn't like it, and i think im really miss up in the head, what they put in your head can really fear you for the rest of your life.  4/18/07
 Leave the Jehovah's Witnesses alone. They are doing what they believe God wants them to do. It is in their mind, and their hearts. Many of us believe differently. They have always been very nice when they knocked on my door. I politely tell them I am not interested, and they politely walk away.  4/18/07
 Gina
 Baltimore Maryland
 I guess we'll see if you post this remark, because as a former JW I am all to aware of the fact that JW's hide enything and EVERYTHING negative about this religion. Why not present a documentary about the sexual, verbal and emotional abuse by their own people in relation to their own family members. Why not discuss the fact that the JW religion has a higher rate of sexual abuse (over 10,000 reported cases)than the Catholics! Tell the story of how the JW's hide what really goes on behind closed doors. I was raised and lived in their world for the better part of my life - and fortunately did not die in either of my two suicide attempts because of what I underwent with my family.
 Are you aware they believe unless you are a JW you will be killed at Armageddon? They plan to live in a paradise earth forever while the rest of the world perish. Are you aware they feel they belong to the only true religion and that there are no others worthy of God's love. Are you aware they disown their sons and daug hters because of their beliefs?
 So they fought for the right to not pledge allegiance to a government and they chose concentration camps instead of war. that's great! Can you think of any other religous groups who have done similiar and even greater things with their beliefs? Do your homework people.Nice piece, but don't believe everything you're told. Do a little more digging. You may be sickened by what you find.  4/18/07
 Chris Browne
 Rock Island, IL
 Christians were faced with the same choice of fighting for the Third Reich or the concentration camps; the Jehovah Witnesses were no different, although their numbers were considerably smaller, and they drew attention because they were different and a minority. This is not typical of the 'balance' with which Cathoics have been treated; i.e., assume guilt until otherwise proven, and refuse to admit the veracity of the proof offered. Do a documentrary on the campaign against Catholicism in the early years of the Nazi ascendency. The Nazis knew that the Catholic Church was one of the significant obstacles to its plan, and saw to it that it was, in effect, crippled within Germany before proceeding with the "Final Solution".  4/18/07
 Michael Musok
 Binghamton, New York
 I enjoyed the DVD very much and was pleasantly surprised that outside sources (non - Jehovah's Witnesses)pointed out positives rather than negative inaccuracies that have been associated with some tv news articles and programs in the past. I do think, however, that the statement that thousands are disfellowshiped each year could have been expanded upon, explaining that some 90 percent of those thousands are reinstated and back with the organization within one year.  4/18/07
 EMR
 New York City
 I have yet to see the film on the Jehova's Witnesses as it will air in NY on May 22. I'm looking forward to seeing it as i enjoy the high quality documentaries produced by Independent Lens. Having said this, i hope i will not be discualified from having my view posted.
 As most of the comments i read are very positive, this leads me to suspect the film to be a "politically correct potrayal" or just showing a fraction of very positive contributions by this organization. I on the other hand, had a very different experience of the Organization and the people in it. Seeing the organization from the "inside" as a non JW was very troubling. I married someone who was raised a JW but was not practicing when we were dating. Shortly after the first year we were married (which by the way, the marriage ended after eight and a half years) he became an active participant in the organization -full force! I kept an open mind and began listening to what he and his JW friends had to say as well as attended their meetings and began years of personal research. There is much evidence out there for those who truly dedicate their time to find the facts on their beliefs and practices. Their rigid beliefs of faith and views on what to celebrate or not lead me on a personal journey and challenged my own beliefs (i had been raised in a home of an athiest father and Christian mother-but God was not a reality in my life). During this journey, which i'm still on, i have discovered the words of Jesus very freeing when he said "take my yoke upon you for is easy and light". Religious practices i.e. do's and don'ts of each organization are such a burden which no one can ever fulfill but in this search and journey i find that to have a relationship with God as a friend i can talk to about all my unbelief, doubt, fears, hopes and dreams AND personal demons- such freedom! Now this is worth living for, not that i will not please God because of fear to give blood to my child who may die for not givig it blood (which by the way was an Old testament Law given for health purposes) or celebrating a birthday. Wether or not a person believes in God or not i think most would agree that we must celebrate Life and not death, freedom and peace. Lastly, let The Almighty God reveal who He truly is in a personal way to each person and let us mere humans stop trying to define Him or put Him in a box! Thank you for the opportunity to express my experience.  4/18/07
 P. S. Theilen
 Del Valle, Texas
 Jahovah's Witnesses are not a Misunderstood Christian Faith they are not Christian's (Christ like).They do not follow Jesus Christ.They follow God. They do not believe that Jesus Christ is the Way, Truth,and the Light.They do not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.  4/18/07
 Stan Knowles
 ilmington, NC
 Why would you people refer to Jehovah's Witnesses as people who are misunderstood regarding their "chrisian faith?" The truth is...you people don't know what you are talking about. Jehovah's Witnesses are NOT CHRISTIANS. Ask any Jehovah's Witness if Jesus Christ is the Son of God...as He said He was... or if Jesus is God...as He said He was...and they will tell you unequivocably, "NO!" You people need to get your facts straight. Only a follower and believer in Jesus Christ as Savior....is a Christian! That's not being judgmental.... that's the truth!  4/18/07
 Tov
 stroudsburg, pa
 I live and let live. I have no problem with freedom of speech. The issue, as I see it, is not about the JW's devotion to their beliefs. Many people are clearly impassioned about their schools of thought. Obviously we will know most certainly when we cross the other side. We can naturally find some political and/or social virtues in almost anything. The problem I have with the JW's is the meticulous alteration of everythign concerning Jesus/Jeshua in the documents produced by the Jews -- the Tenach and the New Testament. These changes were not based on scholarship, since there were no, not one Hebrew or Greek scholar who made the changes. The changes were made exclusively by the personal inspiration of Charles Russel. That spells personal agenda.  4/18/07
 Elijah L. Mason
 Mooresville, NC
 Just to tell you Jehovah Witnesses aren't Christians. They don't believe that Jesus is God (which is the definition of a Christian). I feel sorry for them though. They don't celebrate and they don't think they're going to heaven (or something like that). I didn't watch the show so I wouldnt know. I like them and everything but I think it's sad that they don't vote. Maybe abortion would have ended by now if they did.  4/18/07
 Keri
 While they may be misunderstood and controversial, jehovah's witnesses are not to be confused with Christians. Their doctrines, dogmas and core beliefs are not based upon the biblical teachings of Jesus Christ.  4/18/07
 Bri
 Im am one of jehovahs witnesses and i cant wait to see the film! I dont understand why people would think we are a cult. Jehovah gives you a choice, you choose to do his will, or you dont. Simple as that. I feel and see my prayers answered everyday and Jehovah truly is the only one who can help you find happiness in this WICKED WORLD.
 my fav scripture
 >>>>John 3:16<<<<  4/18/07
 Lillian
 My mother was a Witness and my father was a Jew. Quite a way to be raised. I will say that it was a completely miserable childhood. Having no tolerance for other religeons and tryig to make the world a place where there are no grey areas. You were right or wrong, evil or good in my mothers eyes. I watched as my friends celebrated their birthdays, Christmas, Halloween. It was a childhood COMPLETELY void of fun. Honestly, we all know there is one God who created us and loves us. Pigeon holing ourselves into relgeons who refuse or even begin to think that maybe it is OK to live and let live and to just love and be kind to each other. Why can't that just be enough?  4/18/07
 Todd
 Southfield, MI
 I don't know why people insist on including Jehovah's Witnesses as a Christian denomination. It is not a Christian faith. It is one entirely of its own. They may talk about Jesus, or even believe some things to be true about him; but ultimately, they do not believe that Jesus is who he says he is (according to the original, unedited canon) and so they are not Christian. It's quite possible there are Christians within that religion, but odds are they are few, and dangerously close to being led astray.  4/18/07
 Kay
 I was not surprised to see the statement "Selected submissions will be posted"... after studying the J.W.'s beliefs I realized that putting a religion before your own children's health and welfare was not for me. God gave kids parents to take the best care of them. Going door to door is extremely dangerous! Extricating a member who questions something not quite understood is extreme, demeaning and does not show support. Also, if you live in this wonderful country, you should respect it....not saluting the flag is just disrespectful.  4/18/07
 Sam
 I thought the video was refreshing for a change. I was raised in the religion, but no longer attend. I still believe in Jehovah with all my heart and even though I have been deeply hurt by those in the religion by no means do I consider them all bad. I wish things would have been different ... I really do!
 I do admire those who can go to the doors of others and talk to them about Jehovah and his kingdom, but at the same time do not foreget those who are suffering tremendous hardships that maybe only Jehovah knows about. Don't judge too quickly. Take a couple Saturdays and visit those you have not seen at the meetings in a while and spend genuine time with them. It is not just about reaching new ones, but also about believing in the ones who are at the meetings.God does not count our hours of service, he reads our hearts. Remember the story about the lady who gave all she had. Please in the future don't be quick to judge for you never know what battle someone is fighting behind closed doors. I love you all and wish life was not so unkind.  4/18/07
 Anna
 I haven't seen the documentary, but I know I lived part of it. A little background. I grew up Catholic, one of six children. My Mother's best friend is a JW and in grade school and middle scool I was frequently 'farmed out' to her on weekends. Just so you know, to this day I send her a Mother's Day card. Anyway, here I was, being Catholic educated and finding Fri night meetings very inspirational. Went 'knocking' on Sat morns, meeting again on Sunday. For 12 years of Catholic education I learned more about the Bible from my interactions with the JW's (Tues nite Bible study helped). I was so accepted at meetings that I was allowed to give my own talks. These people were family. One Sat (I was pretty young) we were knocking and a woman answered her door, I had the Watchtower, and she told me she was Catholic and could'nt listen. Imagine her surprise when I said "I'm Catholic, too. It never hurts to read about the Bible." I loved knocking - gave me a chance to make people think. What I learned about the Bible gave me a chance to have the nuns and priests who 'taught' me religion scramble when I challenged what they told me the Bible said (lot's of fun for someone in high school). I'm 51 now and no longer go knocking, but I'm always courteous to the JW's who come to my door with the Watchtower and Awake, because, know what? It never hurts to read about the Bible.  4/18/07
 David Dzubin
 1/2 of my life was spent in the Witnesses and the more recent half has been spent out of the witnesses. This movie is refreshing. Many questions unanswered to others who just didn't understand. I am who I am today because of the teachings, trainings of the Witnesses and Do not Regret for a moment what I 'missed out on" because of what I had gained. My lifestyle does not allow me to be a member of their organization as I'm following my heart, yet I know that NO ORGANIZATION or One person is perfect so I pray that I too will be included in Gods Master plan, if not in this life time, in another.  4/18/07
 I do not believe Jehovahs witnesses are Christian so this misrepresents them. A Christian is one who believes in A triune God(the Father , son and Holy Spirit. They don't and believe in them as seperate intities. Also, the Translinear Bible is not the Bible that the Christians study and believe,many words big and small were changed to suit the beliefs of these people, they don't believe that the Christian Bible is the true word of God. Also, they follow a man who made many predictions including the end of the world, that never came to pass. A Christian is a Christian and it doesn't matter what denomination you are within the Christian faith, it is simply Jesus +0=salvation(heaven and eternal life) not by works(knocking) are you saved but by your acceptance of what Christ did on the cross(payment of sin)their is nothing that we can do physically to buy forgiveness or our way to heaven. When something doesn't come to pass that their leaders reveal as prophesy they just change the words of their book or back track. The Bible does not support this. It is in recent years that they are referred to as Christians along with the Mormons, it simply isn't true. Christianity is not a new idea as the Mormons and the Jehovahs(mid1800'S) PEOPLE HAVE BEEN CHANGING THE LAWS AND THE WORLD SINCE THE TIME OF CHRIST AND BEFORE AS WELL AS STANDING UP FOR THEIR BELIEFS AND DYING FOR THEM. tHIS COUNTRY CAME TO BE BY THESE BRAVE PEOPLE WILLING TO DIE FOR cHRIST. 4/18/07
 There is nothing wrong in the universe with living or dieing for your beliefs, as long as you follow the basic rules, don't hate-but love, don't judge-but forgive, don't hurt but help. Of all of these forgiveness and love are the strongest. BUT TO PUT A CAP ON IT DON'T BE MISLED INTO ANOTHER JONESTOWN.  4/18/07
 WB
 CA
 From Charles Taze Russell to Don Adams.The TNW (thier version of the Bible) they have done nothing but Ignore,"The Truth" Some Very important Questions. Is the Watchtower Society's translation of the Bible accurate? Is the Society's teaching on salvation bibical? No and NO..

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_b.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/20/07
 Paul Leonard
 Murrieta, California
 I thought the presentation was very balanced. Jehovah's Witnesses will enjoy it, as will many who do not know much about Jehovah's Witnesses. Obviously those who disagree will be unhappy that their own pet issues are not addressed.I feel one of the best features of documentaries like this is that it will stir up honest (and unfortunately some not so honest) discussion between Jehovah's Witnesses and non Jehovah's Witnesses.Too many people get information about others from extremely biased sources. This presentation is to be applauded for achieving a very good balance by simply presenting facts without bias.  4/20/07
 Randy Reed
 Nashville, TN
 I have seen the DVD. I enjoyed it greatly. On the DVD there are the views ao many more non-Jehovah's Witnesses. In the comments I have seen there are many views by former and non Jehovah's Witnesses, and I find them very intresting. Perception is not reality but remain a determing factor. Obviously there are doctrinal differences, this is not the forum to discuss those. There are several who are former JWs and as most former anything they are digruntaled. And JWs never claim to be perfect, far from it we quite plainly state we are imperfect. There have been mistakes made, but great efforts are made to redress these. The 'Knocking' documentary in is DVD form gives a full and ballanced view of the 'people' who are Jehovah's Witnesses. In as much as 2 families can be representitive of any grup made up of 7 million members. To find more on the orginazation check out www.watchtower.org or ask the next Jehovah's withess who comes by your door. Thanks PBS.  4/19/07
 Laura Perez
 I've seen the Documentary on Knocking for the Jehovah's Witnesses and it was really intresting. I liked it a lot!  4/19/07
 Mario Yepez
 NJ
 I sent my comment today at an earlier time. Your piec on Jehovahs Witneses was great and many people like me did not know the good these people has done for the world in general, expecially the civil rights in the USA and medicine.  4/19/07
 Amelia
 Kennewick
 Im one of the jehovahs witnessess and Having jehovah god there for one is one of the best things that can ever happen its optimistic to know that soon this terrible pain, and violence is going to be over.I mean the world and the violence is getting worst everyday and one needs protection.Its good to know there is someone (GOD)who can change this world and make it an everlasting life!  4/19/07
 Bill Turpen
 Berlin, NJ
 I agree with the recent posts regarding how nice additional clarification of some points would be. Even so, this film is WELL WORTH VIEWING...several times. Thanks, too, to "IndependentLens" and PBS for broadcasting it. It will be very well received, I am sure.  4/19/07
 Blinn
 Northwood N.H
 I was so impressed with the video, it is so nice to see ourselves potrayed as we really are, people who truly care for their fellow man and who love and respect our loving Father , I so look forward to the program so others can see what a wonderful hope their is for us all.  4/19/07
 Noell
 Philippi, WV
 I haven't seen the documentary yet, I do not get a good playback on my computer, but I am eager to. What I get from the blurb and from comments of those who have seen it is a little disturbing though. I am a disfellowshipped JW. I was raised in the "truth" since I was 2 and was disfellowshipped at 18 and again at 25. I do not see any feedback from people like me. Where are the myriad of stories told about what really happens to get one disfellowshipped? What about how their families "shun" them until they come back into the "truth"? About how they suffer for years to come with doubt about who they really are and what they really believe?
 More importantly, what about how they finally come to realize they CAN pray to God and not feel condemned because they have finally, after many years, found they did not turn their backs on God, but on a religion that seeks to control them and stifle any sense of personal freedom. I am all for a documentary about the JW, just try to get the "whole truth" next time.  4/19/07
 Darcy
 For those who choose their religion over their own health and welfare, then they also choose to suffer whatever consequences that come with that choice.  4/19/07
 San Diego, CA
 I just noticed this documentary through AOL and have struggled for quite a few years with my beliefs. I was expelled and after seeing this brief 25 minute documentary it has compelled me to want to return to my beliefs once again. I have a family now and want to secure there lives with the knowledge of Jehovah and the future he has in store. I look forward to seeing this on May 22nd with my unbelieving husband. This documentary could not have come at a better time. Finally, through this documentary I do not have to defend my once instilled beliefs to my family. They will see for themselves who Jehovah's Witnesses really are and why they take such sacred stands. This documentary has perhaps saved me.  4/19/07
 Lona Smith
 Newark, New Jersey
 I have watched my personal copy of this video many times over, alone and in the company of friends. Each viewing has Left me feeling proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses as I have for the past 52 yrs. Finally someone has gotten our story right! Despite some minor unexplained issues. I felt they were amply addressed in the lecture portion of the video. There our beliefs were addressed in a very detailed and honest manner. Kudos to all involved in this project,for wittingly or otherwise,I personally feel that it has added luster to the name of the God we worship. Thank you, thank you thank you!  4/19/07
 Amy
 You should have done your research. Jehovah's Witnesses are a cult that was founded by Charles Taze Russell. He believed that the Pyramids of Egypt gave him divine revelation. He also believed he was the wise and faithful servant Jesus spoke of in the New Testament. The Witnesses also believe that Jesus Christ is really Michael the Archangel. They do not permit their members to read other literature (one marker of a cult), they believe that the watchtower organization is God's "channel of communication" for today. Today the Watchtower forbids blood transfusions and if a member has one they are expelled. Several decades ago, heart and kidney transplants were also forbidden and worthy of expulsion (which entails losing your eternal life-so they teach- and being shunned by family and friends who are JW's). People *were* disfellowshipped, and their lives were ruined, because of transplants. Later, the watchtower changed their minds about transplants and said they were permissible after all. Who will apologize when they change their minds about blood transfusions? How many will die until then? This is a mind-control cult. They repeat and repeat the same information, asking questions answered only by the text, discouraging *thinking*. You would have been wise to interview ex-JW's who can *witness* to the fact that this is a non-Christian cult of false teachings, without a doubt.  4/19/07
 Jerry Billings
 Portland, OR
 I once knew a man who had a fall in his barn which, as I was told, resulted in a broken pelvis. I understand from his sister that he was bleeding to death internally. His doctor told him that he required blood transfusions but the man, a JW, refused. The result was that he died leaving a widow and two orphaned children. He also had mortgaged his farm which was lost to the bank. What a waste. His religion caused him to be concerned only about himself apparently without concern for the results to his family who were left dirt poor.  4/19/07
 Dan Engstrom
 Seattle,
 JW's are the most harmless folks on the planet and if you believe in live and let live there’s not a problem. I grew up as a JW with relentless bible study and door knocking, while secretly hiding the fact that I was gay. This is an issue that the Witnesses have a difficulty addressing. It is especially difficult for those of us who knew we were gay since the day we were born. Homosexuals who engage in homosexuality are not allowed! Gays coming out, leave because they are denied the right to be who they are!
 The real debate that’s glazed over is the authenticity of the Bible. It’s a given that the book is the word of God. Look deeply and anyone could have serious doubts, however it is the total basis for their belief. If you do not have absolute faith in the Bible then there is not much of a foundation. I find it hard to believe that God is going to destroy everyone except JW's. Take a close look, that’s the bottom line!
 In the end, does it really matter as long as they’re not hurting anyone? Regardless of overt differences, for the most part they are good law-abiding citizens and they do stand for some very positive principles. Would the world be a better place if everyone were a JW? Well, given the state of the world today I guess the answer would have to be yes!  4/19/07
 LINDA
 NAMPA, IDAHO
 IM SURE YOU WONT POST THIS. I WAS A JW SINCE THE AGE OF 5 AND GOT OUT IN 1988. THEY DISFELLOWSHIP ON JUST CHANGING YOUR MIND AND NOT WANTING TO BE A JW. AND YOU ARE TREATED LIKE TRASH. THE DENIAL OF SEXUAL ABUSE WITH THE JWS IS STAGGERING, FROM THE ELDERS WHO ARE UNEDUCATED ON DOWN. I KNOW, THE BROTHER THAT MOLESTED ME....STAYED IN THE CONGREGATION. THE ELDERS TOLD ME TO "PRETEND NOTHING HAPPENED AND JUST SHOW UP FOR MEETINGS."
 SO I HAD MY SAY. PEOPLE NEED TO KNOW THAT ONCE THEY ARE IN. THEY CANT LEAVE WITH THEIR JW FAMILY. SO SPOUSES THAT CHOSE TO LEAVE THE JWS, BETTER OPEN UP A CHECKBOOK FOR SPOUSAL AND CHILD SUPPORT. BECAUSE THEY ARE THROWN OUT ON THE STREET LIKE TRASH.  4/19/07
 Tampa Florid
 Why dont you check with families who have disowned their own children because they no longer believe. my own mother has not had a relationship with me for 25 years. I am decent person, raised great kids and spent my entire life doing voluteer work, all of which they scorn. YOU WHO HAVE GRACIOULSY SHOWED THEIR, WILL NOT GET THE SAME RESPECT. they have their own lingo. if a person is a Jehovah's witness, they 'are in the truth'. they want you to read their literature but if you take literature from someone else they trash it immediately. 25 years ago it was canniblism to accept an organ transplant, now it is a matter of conscience. they are extremely intolerant of anyone elses beliefs and if you CHALLENGE THEM IN ANYWAY AND QUESITON THEM, THEN YOUR APOSTATE, A WORD THAT IS THROWN AROUND FOR THOSE THAT DONT BELIEVE LIKE THEM. I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU MADE THIS FILM WITH OUT CHECKING WITH OTHERS THAT LEFT THIS CULT. IT PERSONALLY CAUSED ME TO GIVE UP MY FORMAL EDUCATION AND BE RAISED IN A FANATICAL RELIGION. DONT MI STAKEN COWARDICE WITH MORALITY. THUSLY IF YOU HAD TO DEPEND ON THEM TO LIBERATE YOU FROM A CONCENTRATION CAMP, THEIR ANSWER WOULD HAVE BEEN, WE DONT GET INVOLVED. I REST MY CASE.  4/19/07
 Timshell
 I just watched the 25 minute trailer on AOL. I am not a Witness, but I really found the film very interesting, and enjoyed the history of their faith. I never knew about their resistance to the Nazi's or how they founded rights for all of us. I can't wait to see the film in its entirety.  4/19/07
 Tampa, Florida
 I was born and raised a Jehovah's Witness. It ruined my life. there is a dark side that I am sure you were not allowed to see. They are anti education, always pushing me to be a full time minister and having to turn down scholarships. They are only nice to each other and put a poker face on to the rest of the world. do not volunteer nor do they believe in doing anything to make this world better. They shun most organizations such as PTA. To be really fair, why dont you do a documentary on those that have broke away, whose lives they have ruined!  4/19/07
 Jesus said he IS the WAY, THE TRUTH & LIFE... Not Just A Great Man. IT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO BE A CHRISTIAN and not accept Christ as the WAY, THE TRUTH, AND LIFE. It fine if they are not Christian, as Christian they are not. The Russelites, International Watchtower Society, Aka The Jehovahs Witness are false prophets who give rise to the Anti-Christ AND WHERE FOUNDED IN 1870s, not historically relative to any of the teaching Of Christ or His Church, and they are NOT CHRISTIAN. They are impostures as they reduce the foundation of Faith to a "great man"
 IF...they where the Truth, then Charles Russell theire founder would be a great man. Jesus is far more than a great man, HE alone is the Son of God who became man for the Salvation of Mankind.
 They give rise to the Anti-Christ as they effectively teach man redeemed man, this is Anti-Christ. They murder children and adults alike with a false relation with pagan practices of drinking animal blood,... with legitimate medical use. Ironically they eat pork/bacon, called by the same scripture..an abomination. Why? Because they lack discreation that these laws where relative to Jewish laws of what was clean...not a moral command for the CHRISTIAN.
 4/19/07
 I was a baptized witness for many years. I disasociated myself because I saw many negative issues. My children could not participate in school sports it was considered hero worship. College education was not permitted people were told it was too much worldly association. We were not permitted to read any other religious literature. It almost felt that they wanted people to be unhealthy and uneducated. Most witnesses that I associated with elders and wives were had alcohol problems "Jesus drank" and secretly celebrated holidays, "buying a turkey dinner but having it the day before, loading presents up the wall not under a tree. I am a very educated woman and yes a bookworm. I dont knock what works for some, but I saw more harm than good.  4/19/07
 I think they are deluded. So what if they do some things that are good? It is stupid to refute Darwin and refuse to accept the benefits of science. There is no basis for religion other than man's desire for community and a hope to escape death. People do have a right to be deluded if they want, but I feel it is too bad.  4/19/07
 Jehovah Witnesses are in a cult,because they refuse to accept the scriptures in God's Holy Bible. They have intentionally changed the "HOLY WORD". They have written their own version of God's Word and face damnation. Study THE HOLY BIBLE AND COMPARE IT WITH WHAT THEY HAVE WROTE AND ANYONE CAN SEE THE DIFFERENCES. THEY SAY JESUS CHRIST IS MICHAEL THE ARC ANGEL WHICH IS A TOTAL LIE OF THE DEVIL. JESUS CHRIST IS THE "LORD" AND IF THEY DO NOT COME TO HIM THEY WILL BE DESTINED TO BE SENTENCED TO THE "LAKE OF FIRE"WHICH THEY ALSO REFUSE TO BELIEVE IN. ONE DAY THE REALITY WILL BE THEIR FINAL DAMNATION,IF THEY KEEP REFUSING TO BELIEVE THE "TRUTH".  4/19/07
 It may have been a good film but the truth of the matter is there is no basis for their belief in the Bible. The wittness get in side your mind. Ask them about the trinity? Do they believe? no..Films like these are meant to show you how loving and caring and how christian they are. The film is good PR. When they come to my door I treat them with kindness and explain that I am Babtist and they turn around and leave.  4/19/07
 ONTARIO, CA
 THE JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ARE JUST LIKE OTHER SINCERE AND WELL INTENTIONED PEOPLE WHO ARE WRONG.
 ALL FALSE RELIGIONS, SUCH AS JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES, MORMONS AND ISLAMS, DENY THAT JESUS CHRIST IS GOD IN HUMAN FLESH.
 THEY DENY AND PERVERT THE CLEAR TEACHING OF THE BIBLE. COLOSSIANS 2:9 9. For in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily;
 4/18/07
 Angela
 Downey,CA
 I haven't see the film yet. I look forward to seeing it. However, I have to disagree with someone of the postings re: being expelled. One post said "the jw is given every opportunity before being expelled". This is so untrue my daughter had unplanned sex "once" and the brothers took it upon themselves to judge her without question. Asking such questions if she had an "organism" or did she use a "condom". The teachings of the bible are most accurate but from a human aspect of judging this is wrong. This can damage a person forever because of one incident. We are only human. What I can't understand is why Jehovahs' Witnesses are so down on fornication, adultery, drunkardness but when it comes to gluttony they are silent. Gluttony is in the same scripture where it mentions adultery and fornicators. Have you ever been to a meeting? Check out all the fat and obese persons.  4/18/07
 Glen
 North Bend, WA
 The problem with the wording in the movie ad I read is that they are confusing Jehovah's Witnesses with Christianity. Sadly, JW's are a cult, not a Christian group. They answer to the Watchtower Society rather than follow the Bible (though they have invented their own version of it). They reject the basic tenets of biblical Christianity and therefore must be listed as a cult of Christianity.  4/18/07
 Fred
 Upland, Ca
 For the last 36+ years I have been talking to Jehovah Witness's. Since I always use their New World Translation when I speak to them, I humbly must state that this organization has utterly corrupted God's word, the bible.  4/18/07
 Dickie Thomas
 Jacksonville, Florida
v I don't know about New York Jehovah Witnesses but i can tell you..i haven't met any like the ones on the film.The film also is rather boring.According to the Holy Word. Jesus was not only a part of God but he was actually God incarnate. Jehovah Witnesses do not believe this. The simple wonderful truth is God is in three persons Father, Son, and Holy Spirit . A jehovah witness would never agree to this.  4/18/07
 Stan Knowles
 Wilmington, NC
 Why would you refer to Jehovah's. Witnesses as people who are misunderstood egarding their "CHRISTIAN FAITH?" The fact is...Jehovah's Witnesses are NOT CHRISTIANS! You need to check outthe truth before you print or publish such words. I challenge you to ask any Jehovah's Witness if he or she believes that Jesus Christ is, not only the Son of God, as He said He was, but that He, Jesus, is also God, whom He said He was! They will vehemently deny it!
 A Christian is a person who believes and ollows Jesus Christ, a person who has been SAVED by Jesus! This is the truth! Jehovah's Witnessess are NOT CHRISTIANS! You people need to tell the truth!  4/18/07
 Tom Baker
 Oak Harbor, Ohio
 I find it interesting that so many responses to this "documentary" are from the same group of enlightened individuals who refused to watch the Dateline program addressing pedophilia within the Watchtower organization. To state this is a documentary providing fair, equal and unbiased information is a discredit to PBS. The biblical truths that this publishing company promote are nothing more than Orwellian doublespeak. I personally have been subjected to the cruelty and hypocrisy of this organization and can state for a certainty that the Golden Rule is NOT one of the characteristics that this group promotes. Where are their works? My mother claims that the works she provides are "free home bible studies". I must have missed that part of the Good Samaritan offering a home bible study to the tax collector lying on the edge of the road. Why do I no longer argue with my mother regarding her "Truth"? It is pitiful and sad to watch an individual suffer from cognitive dissonance in order to reconcile a lifetime of wasted "door to door ministry" Knocking and knocking and knocking.........Only to watch the generation THAT WILL BY NO MEANS PASS AWAY.....be dismissed as an adjustment from Gods Organization.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_c.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/20/07
 Paul Leonard
 Murrieta, California
 I thought the presentation was very balanced. Jehovah's Witnesses will enjoy it, as will many who do not know much about Jehovah's Witnesses. Obviously those who disagree will be unhappy that their own pet issues are not addressed.I feel one of the best features of documentaries like this is that it will stir up honest (and unfortunately some not so honest) discussion between Jehovah's Witnesses and non Jehovah's Witnesses.Too many people get information about others from extremely biased sources. This presentation is to be applauded for achieving a very good balance by simply presenting facts without bias.  4/20/07
 Randy Reed
 Nashville, TN
 I have seen the DVD. I enjoyed it greatly. On the DVD there are the views ao many more non-Jehovah's Witnesses. In the comments I have seen there are many views by former and non Jehovah's Witnesses, and I find them very intresting. Perception is not reality but remain a determing factor. Obviously there are doctrinal differences, this is not the forum to discuss those. There are several who are former JWs and as most former anything they are digruntaled. And JWs never claim to be perfect, far from it we quite plainly state we are imperfect. There have been mistakes made, but great efforts are made to redress these. The 'Knocking' documentary in is DVD form gives a full and ballanced view of the 'people' who are Jehovah's Witnesses. In as much as 2 families can be representitive of any grup made up of 7 million members. To find more on the orginazation check out www.watchtower.org or ask the next Jehovah's withess who comes by your door. Thanks PBS.  4/19/07
 Laura Perez
 I've seen the Documentary on Knocking for the Jehovah's Witnesses and it was really intresting. I liked it a lot!  4/19/07
 Mario Yepez
 NJ
 I sent my comment today at an earlier time. Your piec on Jehovahs Witneses was great and many people like me did not know the good these people has done for the world in general, expecially the civil rights in the USA and medicine.  4/19/07
 Amelia
 Kennewick
 Im one of the jehovahs witnessess and Having jehovah god there for one is one of the best things that can ever happen its optimistic to know that soon this terrible pain, and violence is going to be over.I mean the world and the violence is getting worst everyday and one needs protection.Its good to know there is someone (GOD)who can change this world and make it an everlasting life!  4/19/07
 Bill Turpen
 Berlin, NJ
 I agree with the recent posts regarding how nice additional clarification of some points would be. Even so, this film is WELL WORTH VIEWING...several times. Thanks, too, to "IndependentLens" and PBS for broadcasting it. It will be very well received, I am sure.  4/19/07
 Blinn
 Northwood N.H
 I was so impressed with the video, it is so nice to see ourselves potrayed as we really are, people who truly care for their fellow man and who love and respect our loving Father , I so look forward to the program so others can see what a wonderful hope their is for us all.  4/19/07
 Noell
 Philippi, WV
 I haven't seen the documentary yet, I do not get a good playback on my computer, but I am eager to. What I get from the blurb and from comments of those who have seen it is a little disturbing though. I am a disfellowshipped JW. I was raised in the "truth" since I was 2 and was disfellowshipped at 18 and again at 25. I do not see any feedback from people like me. Where are the myriad of stories told about what really happens to get one disfellowshipped? What about how their families "shun" them until they come back into the "truth"? About how they suffer for years to come with doubt about who they really are and what they really believe?
 More importantly, what about how they finally come to realize they CAN pray to God and not feel condemned because they have finally, after many years, found they did not turn their backs on God, but on a religion that seeks to control them and stifle any sense of personal freedom. I am all for a documentary about the JW, just try to get the "whole truth" next time.  4/19/07
 Darcy
 For those who choose their religion over their own health and welfare, then they also choose to suffer whatever consequences that come with that choice.  4/19/07
 San Diego, CA
 I just noticed this documentary through AOL and have struggled for quite a few years with my beliefs. I was expelled and after seeing this brief 25 minute documentary it has compelled me to want to return to my beliefs once again. I have a family now and want to secure there lives with the knowledge of Jehovah and the future he has in store. I look forward to seeing this on May 22nd with my unbelieving husband. This documentary could not have come at a better time. Finally, through this documentary I do not have to defend my once instilled beliefs to my family. They will see for themselves who Jehovah's Witnesses really are and why they take such sacred stands. This documentary has perhaps saved me.  4/19/07
 Lona Smith
 Newark, New Jersey
 I have watched my personal copy of this video many times over, alone and in the company of friends. Each viewing has Left me feeling proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses as I have for the past 52 yrs. Finally someone has gotten our story right! Despite some minor unexplained issues. I felt they were amply addressed in the lecture portion of the video. There our beliefs were addressed in a very detailed and honest manner. Kudos to all involved in this project,for wittingly or otherwise,I personally feel that it has added luster to the name of the God we worship. Thank you, thank you thank you!  4/19/07
 Amy
 You should have done your research. Jehovah's Witnesses are a cult that was founded by Charles Taze Russell. He believed that the Pyramids of Egypt gave him divine revelation. He also believed he was the wise and faithful servant Jesus spoke of in the New Testament. The Witnesses also believe that Jesus Christ is really Michael the Archangel. They do not permit their members to read other literature (one marker of a cult), they believe that the watchtower organization is God's "channel of communication" for today. Today the Watchtower forbids blood transfusions and if a member has one they are expelled. Several decades ago, heart and kidney transplants were also forbidden and worthy of expulsion (which entails losing your eternal life-so they teach- and being shunned by family and friends who are JW's). People *were* disfellowshipped, and their lives were ruined, because of transplants. Later, the watchtower changed their minds about transplants and said they were permissible after all. Who will apologize when they change their minds about blood transfusions? How many will die until then? This is a mind-control cult. They repeat and repeat the same information, asking questions answered only by the text, discouraging *thinking*. You would have been wise to interview ex-JW's who can *witness* to the fact that this is a non-Christian cult of false teachings, without a doubt.  4/19/07
 Jerry Billings
 Portland, OR
 I once knew a man who had a fall in his barn which, as I was told, resulted in a broken pelvis. I understand from his sister that he was bleeding to death internally. His doctor told him that he required blood transfusions but the man, a JW, refused. The result was that he died leaving a widow and two orphaned children. He also had mortgaged his farm which was lost to the bank. What a waste. His religion caused him to be concerned only about himself apparently without concern for the results to his family who were left dirt poor.  4/19/07
 Dan Engstrom
 Seattle,
 JW's are the most harmless folks on the planet and if you believe in live and let live there’s not a problem. I grew up as a JW with relentless bible study and door knocking, while secretly hiding the fact that I was gay. This is an issue that the Witnesses have a difficulty addressing. It is especially difficult for those of us who knew we were gay since the day we were born. Homosexuals who engage in homosexuality are not allowed! Gays coming out, leave because they are denied the right to be who they are!
 The real debate that’s glazed over is the authenticity of the Bible. It’s a given that the book is the word of God. Look deeply and anyone could have serious doubts, however it is the total basis for their belief. If you do not have absolute faith in the Bible then there is not much of a foundation. I find it hard to believe that God is going to destroy everyone except JW's. Take a close look, that’s the bottom line!
 In the end, does it really matter as long as they’re not hurting anyone? Regardless of overt differences, for the most part they are good law-abiding citizens and they do stand for some very positive principles. Would the world be a better place if everyone were a JW? Well, given the state of the world today I guess the answer would have to be yes!  4/19/07
 LINDA
 NAMPA, IDAHO
 IM SURE YOU WONT POST THIS. I WAS A JW SINCE THE AGE OF 5 AND GOT OUT IN 1988. THEY DISFELLOWSHIP ON JUST CHANGING YOUR MIND AND NOT WANTING TO BE A JW. AND YOU ARE TREATED LIKE TRASH. THE DENIAL OF SEXUAL ABUSE WITH THE JWS IS STAGGERING, FROM THE ELDERS WHO ARE UNEDUCATED ON DOWN. I KNOW, THE BROTHER THAT MOLESTED ME....STAYED IN THE CONGREGATION. THE ELDERS TOLD ME TO "PRETEND NOTHING HAPPENED AND JUST SHOW UP FOR MEETINGS."
 SO I HAD MY SAY. PEOPLE NEED TO KNOW THAT ONCE THEY ARE IN. THEY CANT LEAVE WITH THEIR JW FAMILY. SO SPOUSES THAT CHOSE TO LEAVE THE JWS, BETTER OPEN UP A CHECKBOOK FOR SPOUSAL AND CHILD SUPPORT. BECAUSE THEY ARE THROWN OUT ON THE STREET LIKE TRASH.  4/19/07
 Tampa Florid
 Why dont you check with families who have disowned their own children because they no longer believe. my own mother has not had a relationship with me for 25 years. I am decent person, raised great kids and spent my entire life doing voluteer work, all of which they scorn. YOU WHO HAVE GRACIOULSY SHOWED THEIR, WILL NOT GET THE SAME RESPECT. they have their own lingo. if a person is a Jehovah's witness, they 'are in the truth'. they want you to read their literature but if you take literature from someone else they trash it immediately. 25 years ago it was canniblism to accept an organ transplant, now it is a matter of conscience. they are extremely intolerant of anyone elses beliefs and if you CHALLENGE THEM IN ANYWAY AND QUESITON THEM, THEN YOUR APOSTATE, A WORD THAT IS THROWN AROUND FOR THOSE THAT DONT BELIEVE LIKE THEM. I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU MADE THIS FILM WITH OUT CHECKING WITH OTHERS THAT LEFT THIS CULT. IT PERSONALLY CAUSED ME TO GIVE UP MY FORMAL EDUCATION AND BE RAISED IN A FANATICAL RELIGION. DONT MI STAKEN COWARDICE WITH MORALITY. THUSLY IF YOU HAD TO DEPEND ON THEM TO LIBERATE YOU FROM A CONCENTRATION CAMP, THEIR ANSWER WOULD HAVE BEEN, WE DONT GET INVOLVED. I REST MY CASE.  4/19/07
 Timshell
 I just watched the 25 minute trailer on AOL. I am not a Witness, but I really found the film very interesting, and enjoyed the history of their faith. I never knew about their resistance to the Nazi's or how they founded rights for all of us. I can't wait to see the film in its entirety.  4/19/07
 Tampa, Florida
 I was born and raised a Jehovah's Witness. It ruined my life. there is a dark side that I am sure you were not allowed to see. They are anti education, always pushing me to be a full time minister and having to turn down scholarships. They are only nice to each other and put a poker face on to the rest of the world. do not volunteer nor do they believe in doing anything to make this world better. They shun most organizations such as PTA. To be really fair, why dont you do a documentary on those that have broke away, whose lives they have ruined!  4/19/07
 Jesus said he IS the WAY, THE TRUTH & LIFE... Not Just A Great Man. IT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO BE A CHRISTIAN and not accept Christ as the WAY, THE TRUTH, AND LIFE. It fine if they are not Christian, as Christian they are not. The Russelites, International Watchtower Society, Aka The Jehovahs Witness are false prophets who give rise to the Anti-Christ AND WHERE FOUNDED IN 1870s, not historically relative to any of the teaching Of Christ or His Church, and they are NOT CHRISTIAN. They are impostures as they reduce the foundation of Faith to a "great man"
 IF...they where the Truth, then Charles Russell theire founder would be a great man. Jesus is far more than a great man, HE alone is the Son of God who became man for the Salvation of Mankind.
 They give rise to the Anti-Christ as they effectively teach man redeemed man, this is Anti-Christ. They murder children and adults alike with a false relation with pagan practices of drinking animal blood,... with legitimate medical use. Ironically they eat pork/bacon, called by the same scripture..an abomination. Why? Because they lack discreation that these laws where relative to Jewish laws of what was clean...not a moral command for the CHRISTIAN.
 4/19/07
 I was a baptized witness for many years. I disasociated myself because I saw many negative issues. My children could not participate in school sports it was considered hero worship. College education was not permitted people were told it was too much worldly association. We were not permitted to read any other religious literature. It almost felt that they wanted people to be unhealthy and uneducated. Most witnesses that I associated with elders and wives were had alcohol problems "Jesus drank" and secretly celebrated holidays, "buying a turkey dinner but having it the day before, loading presents up the wall not under a tree. I am a very educated woman and yes a bookworm. I dont knock what works for some, but I saw more harm than good.  4/19/07
 I think they are deluded. So what if they do some things that are good? It is stupid to refute Darwin and refuse to accept the benefits of science. There is no basis for religion other than man's desire for community and a hope to escape death. People do have a right to be deluded if they want, but I feel it is too bad.  4/19/07
 Jehovah Witnesses are in a cult,because they refuse to accept the scriptures in God's Holy Bible. They have intentionally changed the "HOLY WORD". They have written their own version of God's Word and face damnation. Study THE HOLY BIBLE AND COMPARE IT WITH WHAT THEY HAVE WROTE AND ANYONE CAN SEE THE DIFFERENCES. THEY SAY JESUS CHRIST IS MICHAEL THE ARC ANGEL WHICH IS A TOTAL LIE OF THE DEVIL. JESUS CHRIST IS THE "LORD" AND IF THEY DO NOT COME TO HIM THEY WILL BE DESTINED TO BE SENTENCED TO THE "LAKE OF FIRE"WHICH THEY ALSO REFUSE TO BELIEVE IN. ONE DAY THE REALITY WILL BE THEIR FINAL DAMNATION,IF THEY KEEP REFUSING TO BELIEVE THE "TRUTH".  4/19/07
 It may have been a good film but the truth of the matter is there is no basis for their belief in the Bible. The wittness get in side your mind. Ask them about the trinity? Do they believe? no..Films like these are meant to show you how loving and caring and how christian they are. The film is good PR. When they come to my door I treat them with kindness and explain that I am Babtist and they turn around and leave.  4/19/07
 ONTARIO, CA
 THE JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ARE JUST LIKE OTHER SINCERE AND WELL INTENTIONED PEOPLE WHO ARE WRONG.
 ALL FALSE RELIGIONS, SUCH AS JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES, MORMONS AND ISLAMS, DENY THAT JESUS CHRIST IS GOD IN HUMAN FLESH.
 THEY DENY AND PERVERT THE CLEAR TEACHING OF THE BIBLE. COLOSSIANS 2:9 9. For in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily;
 4/18/07
 Angela
 Downey,CA
 I haven't see the film yet. I look forward to seeing it. However, I have to disagree with someone of the postings re: being expelled. One post said "the jw is given every opportunity before being expelled". This is so untrue my daughter had unplanned sex "once" and the brothers took it upon themselves to judge her without question. Asking such questions if she had an "organism" or did she use a "condom". The teachings of the bible are most accurate but from a human aspect of judging this is wrong. This can damage a person forever because of one incident. We are only human. What I can't understand is why Jehovahs' Witnesses are so down on fornication, adultery, drunkardness but when it comes to gluttony they are silent. Gluttony is in the same scripture where it mentions adultery and fornicators. Have you ever been to a meeting? Check out all the fat and obese persons.  4/18/07
 Glen
 North Bend, WA
 The problem with the wording in the movie ad I read is that they are confusing Jehovah's Witnesses with Christianity. Sadly, JW's are a cult, not a Christian group. They answer to the Watchtower Society rather than follow the Bible (though they have invented their own version of it). They reject the basic tenets of biblical Christianity and therefore must be listed as a cult of Christianity.  4/18/07
 Fred
 Upland, Ca
 For the last 36+ years I have been talking to Jehovah Witness's. Since I always use their New World Translation when I speak to them, I humbly must state that this organization has utterly corrupted God's word, the bible.  4/18/07
 Dickie Thomas
 Jacksonville, Florida
v I don't know about New York Jehovah Witnesses but i can tell you..i haven't met any like the ones on the film.The film also is rather boring.According to the Holy Word. Jesus was not only a part of God but he was actually God incarnate. Jehovah Witnesses do not believe this. The simple wonderful truth is God is in three persons Father, Son, and Holy Spirit . A jehovah witness would never agree to this.  4/18/07
 Stan Knowles
 Wilmington, NC
 Why would you refer to Jehovah's. Witnesses as people who are misunderstood egarding their "CHRISTIAN FAITH?" The fact is...Jehovah's Witnesses are NOT CHRISTIANS! You need to check outthe truth before you print or publish such words. I challenge you to ask any Jehovah's Witness if he or she believes that Jesus Christ is, not only the Son of God, as He said He was, but that He, Jesus, is also God, whom He said He was! They will vehemently deny it!
 A Christian is a person who believes and ollows Jesus Christ, a person who has been SAVED by Jesus! This is the truth! Jehovah's Witnessess are NOT CHRISTIANS! You people need to tell the truth!  4/18/07
 Tom Baker
 Oak Harbor, Ohio
 I find it interesting that so many responses to this "documentary" are from the same group of enlightened individuals who refused to watch the Dateline program addressing pedophilia within the Watchtower organization. To state this is a documentary providing fair, equal and unbiased information is a discredit to PBS. The biblical truths that this publishing company promote are nothing more than Orwellian doublespeak. I personally have been subjected to the cruelty and hypocrisy of this organization and can state for a certainty that the Golden Rule is NOT one of the characteristics that this group promotes. Where are their works? My mother claims that the works she provides are "free home bible studies". I must have missed that part of the Good Samaritan offering a home bible study to the tax collector lying on the edge of the road. Why do I no longer argue with my mother regarding her "Truth"? It is pitiful and sad to watch an individual suffer from cognitive dissonance in order to reconcile a lifetime of wasted "door to door ministry" Knocking and knocking and knocking.........Only to watch the generation THAT WILL BY NO MEANS PASS AWAY.....be dismissed as an adjustment from Gods Organization.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_c.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/25/07
 Stan
 New York, NY
 I thought this was more fun to watch and actually more accurate. I use to be a JW several years ago. "Mulberry Street"
 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rg-pK_twCbM  4/25/07
 Carolyn Leaf
 New York, NY
 Thanks so much for this wonderful website on "Knocking." I think it is very well done and informative. Very professional. I am also one of Jehovah's Witnesses and have seen the film twice; however, I do hope you are planning to air it on my local NYC PBS station(s) in May as previously stated. Thanks again.  4/25/07
 Jackie Zucco
 West Alexandria, OH
 It was great to see that you obviously researched Jehovah's Witnesses and what they really do believe in. As a Jehovah's Witness I just wanted to thank you for bringing out truth instead of lies! As Psalms 121:2 says, My help is from Jehovah. Regards  4/25/07
 Janet Powell
 Miami Florida
 I LOVE the website for "Knocking" on the Independent Lens site. I'm sending the link to many of my friends.  4/25/07
 Kristen
 PA
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, and I noticed that many have commented that Jehovah's Witnesses are not allowed to read other literature. I know many Witnesses who were encouraged to do research and prove to themselves whether it was the truth that they were learning. I myself have read other literature and simply did not agree with it because it was not in line with what I had read from the scriptures, and the different teachings of other religions together did not make sense to me. They just weren't for me. I have also used other Bibles, not just the New World Translation, and I tell others that we can use other translations in our Bible discussions. Sometimes, we end up using the New World Translation anyway because the language is easier to read, but that is by the Bible student's choice. It is true, however, that I do not like to read literature that is overly critical and negative. I try to stick to the upbuilding and informative reading!  4/25/07
 Victoria, BC
 I enjoyed the DVD very much and watched all the extras with interest. As one of Jw's for 17 years, you did a fine job. I found it very accurate. I am glad that many of those who have posted a message say they were once disfellowshipped and then returned and were glad for the discipline it gave them. I know many that have come back, and have become some of my favorite people, very spiritually minded and focussed in their life. I liked the comment by the one brother who said the Isrealites were Jehovah's people and yet they failed many times to live up to his standard. We aren't perfect, but we certainly do our best to be good people and live by Bible principles. Many of the neg comments have come from those who have been out of the organization for many years, we always move forward and try to improve. You would find that things have changed since you were associated. Many of the things you were concerned about have probably changed. Your comments are no longer as accurate as you once thought. We correct mistakes when we see them. The DVD is an accurate portrayal of us. Maybe it will help some people see us differently, understand why we do what we do. Understanding and knowledge are power. Thanks for giving it to us and others.  4/25/07
 Emmanuel Aisuebeogun
 Boston, MA
 We give thanks to Jehovah for his loving kindness publicly expressed once again through this video. It is so interesting to hear those who "do not seem to have time" to learn about him, comment favorably about our work. Let those who have ears listen now!  4/25/07
 Erica
 Chico, CA
 I haven't seen the documentary just yet and was reading the comments that others have left. I am a student at a four year university and was raised with Witness believes, but I haven‚t yet got baptized. I am grateful to see a film from an outside perspective of who Jehovah Witnesses are and what they preach. I still study with the Witnesses because I want to and not because my parents force me or because I feel guilty. I have studied on my own and read the scriptures on my own. For me this is the truth, and I know it is the path to happiness. I don‚t want to be biases but trying to give a fair answer. As a student and living on my own away from parents temptations are raised to young people. I feel that having biblical understanding and faith have protected me from making bad decisions and kept me safe. Growing up with Witness believes never hinder me as a child.
 Yes, Jehovah Witnesses don‚t celebrate birthdays or Christmas, but I never felt left out. These holidays have good intentions from religious perspective to family gatherings. However, I can still have family gatherings anytime of the year. I can give and receive gifts anytime of the year. Although, I am not active and don‚t assist the meetings consecutively I respect Jehovah Witnesses and I hope others have an open mind about who they are. They never force upon their believes they only want to help.  4/25/07
 David
 I have seen the video and was very impressed. There is not time to fully explain some of the aspects mentioned in the film, but, found what was presented as accurate. Thank you for the forum and a useful dicussion on a serious topic. It does make you think!  4/25/07
 Willmar Acevedo
 Frederiksted Virgin Islands
 I ordered the video and saw it several times to absorb the message. I thank you for such a competent job and outstanding research. Jehovah´s Witnesses have taken to all the world a message from the Bible. Some of the basic principles of liberty to do this were gained in the legal arena of the United States or Canada yet the rest of the world has benefited. I look forward to wathching this video on TV in May.  4/25/07
 roni
 i was raised third generation witness. and the sad thing about that is that my grandmother is the one that has all of the mentally insane issues and adheres to the witness dogma as if every fraction of the letter of their laws are inscrutable.she converted from being raised a methodist and yet instead of totally dropping whatever hellfire doctrine that her birth faith has, she switched it over to "anything you do means you're going to die at armagedon no matter how small of an error it was." my grandmother is so overbearing and controlling that three of her five children aren't witnesses and never really have wanted to be at all. sadly, i was born to one of her two children that is still a witness. but even my mother admits that she's not happy being a witness. she's had several breakdowns wherein she swears she doesn't want to be a witness anymore but because it's all she knows she doesn't have the free will god gave a a five year old to spare herself the agony she keeps going through day after day. the only joy my mom finds to use to help her get up in the morning is the thought of getting to go mountain biking, not going to the meetings. she doesn't even stay long enough after the last amen is said to take another breath. she's gone as soon as the meeting is done. what does that tell you all?  4/20/07
 Nelson A. Herle, Jr.
 Apple Vallley, CA
 I was very interested to read the comments on the "Knocking" presentation and the views of others who have watched the film. I have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses for 56 years. I invite any who wish to consider the questions some have raised on the "New World Translation" and the doctrine of the Trinity, etc. I have prepared a CD-ROM with over seven hundred pages of research, early Church and modern, and would gladly send a copy free of charge to anyone who wishes to read it. You may publish my E-mail address in your "comments" section if you so desire. Thank you. Nelsonaherle@AOL.com  4/20/07
 I saw the video a few months ago and plan on watching it again. I thought it was great. Thank you for telling this story. I also found it interesting all the 'insight' people outside JW seem to have. It's quite comical to listen to people tell us what we beleive. That's the beauty of free choice and expression. Being raised in the truth, this is what I know. What I also know is the outside, having been disfellowshipped twice. What I learned during that time is Humility is a wonderful thing. This is Jehovah's organization and if things don't seem to be handled correctly, He will correct it for sure. No earthly organization is perfect, we ALL make mistakes, but ultimately, it's between you and Jehovah. This is the truth, no doubt.Who else teaches PS.37:9-11,29? Who else has a Worldwide Brotherhood? For those who have negative experiences, Jehovah didn't do it to you. People are people, and imperfect. Don't allow people to separate you from him. Humbly submit to Jehovah, He will lead you, if you humbly let Him. I know this myself first hand. thanks again.  4/20/07
 Nadia Halasz
 Seattle, Wa
 We would like to see the entire program. Very interesting to know this group of people publicly.To know who they are since we know them from "doors" and as respectful, kind co-workers. Thank you.  4/20/07
 Randy Reed
 Nashville, TN
 Thanks for the ballanced perspective. I am looking forward to seeing the program. Thanks PBS for airing this. Randy Reed  4/20/07
 Sally Weimer
 Josephine, Pennsylvania
 Thank you for the information contained on your web site. Rather than present a negative view, you presented truthful statements about a much misunderstood organization.  4/20/07
 Sam and Linda Bender
 Somers Point, NJ
 This is wonderful. We are JWs but we have a lot of friends, coworkers and calls in the ministry that will find this website very interesting. We appreciate PBS and programs like Independent Lens airing such unique programs. It certainly presents a varied view and helps to educate the public in an objective manner not associated with us Jehovah's Witnesses about who we really are. We notice this is done on PBS a lot of times about a lot of subjects. Knowledge is always good and important to make available. Keep up the good work!  4/20/07
 Elizabeth Phillips
 East Orange, NJ
 It sure seems that the negative comments are being weeded out on this site. I am a former witness who is aware of many of the negative things about the cult of Jehovah's Witnesses.JWs themselves aren't allowed to see anything negative about this mind-controlling organization, but "Crisis of Conscience" by Ray Franz should be required reading for anyone considering a "Bible" study.
 The Bible "translation" the JWs use is full of inaccuracies - not surprising considering it was "translated" by men who had no expertise in the Bible languages. The practice of allowing pedophiles to continue to associate with children is reprehensible. And not even allowing the parents of accusers to warn other parents makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. There has to be at least one other witness to the abuse to be considered as proof. How many pedophiles allow there to be witnesses to their crimes? It's just insane! www.silentlambs.org
 The definition of a cult includes the belief that there is only "onetrue religion" - that all other religions are from Satan. One of the first things the JWs teach is that they are the only true religion. They even call it "The Truth".If you're considering joining this group, please do some research. Be willing to at least look at the negative or critical things others say about it. Decide for yourself whether you're willing to sign your life over to them.  4/20/07
 Martha S
 LaFayette Hill, PA
 Thank you so much for this documentary. Jehovah's Witnesses, their families and friends are looking forward to viewing this on PBS. Reading other comments I wanted to add the following:
 To be "expelled" or as we say "disfellowshipped" is a last resort. Privately and unknown to congregation members, Elders work with individuals by utilizing the Bible and help them to see where they need to bring themselves into line with Bible Principles. Remorse, repentance and effort to turn around are necessary in order to remain a part of the Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses. Disfellowshipping is a Bible based necessity in order to keep the congregation clean. 1 Corinthians 5:9-13  4/20/07
 Although I haven't seen it yet, I want to thank you for making this documentary available to the general public, and I surely look forward to seeing it and owning my own copy. Thanks too for hosting this web site that helps set the record straight, while clarifying and making known the good that Jehovah's Witnesses have done and continue to do. A thousand thank-yous to all involved. - One of Jehovah's Witnesses  4/20/07
 Solomon Landers
 Thank you, PBS, Independent Lens, and Joel P. Engardio. This is an excellent piece of work and a fine undertaking. Jehovah's Witnesses are controversial, often misunderstood, often purposely misrepresented. It is good to get "Knocking"'s unbiased view out to the public.I have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses for over 50 years. It has been the best part of my life. And I trust that in my ministry, my life has been a blessing to others.  4/20/07
 Clarissa Ortiz
 Brawley, Ca
 My warmest congratulations to the makers of this film. it took great courage to put out who we are. i learned "the truth" almost fifty years ago. i have to admit that i have many faults, and that actually this earthly organization is made up entirely of imperfect individuals. the comments of many of your viewers sadden me that they refuse to see us for what and who we really are. the comments of some who at one time were in our fold don't help. i know that we can talk ourselves til we're blue in the face and they will refuse to recognize us as the true religion. the time is just about upon us when it will be discovered that everything we have ever preached about will be proven true. those that insist that jesus is god incarnate, and that we have a distorted version of the bible will realize how wrong they were, but then it will be too late. this is indeed the organization that Jehovah God is utilizing to warn the world about the end of this system of things, just as he used the nation of Israel as his organization. even though israel had many flaws because they were all imperfect, it was still his nation. so it is today, and i am determined to continue faithful to Jehovah God and his organization. Jehovah will correct any (including me)who needs correcting. i will remain loyal!  4/20/07
 Dave
 Lots of misinformed people on this board. Witnesses are indeed Christians since they follow the teachings of Jesus. They also believe that Jesus was the son of God, contrary to what some people here claim. Those who are "shunned" have every opportunity to make amends and are encouraged to do so. If they don't make amends, it's their own choice. The JW translation of the bible is the most accurate translation of the Greek and Hebrew scriptures; an independent study proved it. Read the book "Truth in Translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament" by Jason BeDuhn.  4/20/07
 Nick
 There's no journalistic integrity in this film. this was watchtower society approved. it's really important to go into the history, even back 10-20 years, to get an idea of the damage of disfellowshipping. depression and mental illness were looked upon as signs that a person was secretly sinning. my father was an elder for nine years, had a breakdown, and was witch hunted by two different congregations w/o any regard for his illness, our grief and situation. i have two friends who left and killed themselves b/c of guilt. the wtbts will never take responsibility for their past policies and only invoke new ones to keep an organization that is on the brink of falling apart, together macgyver style. jws think if you're not one of them, you're dead, then they will back talk that as 'only god knows' to the media, but being in the wtbts for many years i know what's really said and thought.
 the only reason this film is getting air time is b/c the directors recruited jws to attend the screenings over and over. if this documentary had truth in it, jws wouldn't have supported it and it would've never made the pbs radar.to that i say the filmmakers are brilliant with this strategy and i'm planning my pro-LDS documentary right now. i need the money.  4/20/07
 Dallas, Texas
 As one of Jehovah's witnesses for more than 58 years I am pleased to say that I have lived a good life because of following Bible standards in my life. Thank you for publishing, from an outside source, a good account of Jehovah's witnesses and their fight for religious freedom not only in the U.S. of American but all around the world. In answer to those negative comments.I am sorry that those people have such a negative attitude about an organization that is working hard for the good of all. I would say they need to do some heart searching and Bible study to readjust that negative attitude. I have this DVD and have enjoyed viewing it. Serving a loving God with your whole heart in union with a very loving brotherhood is the best thing that can happen to anyone.  4/20/07
 Jen
 I've seen this organization from inside and out and feel that the documentary isn't far from wrong. It saddens me that so many who have posted here are filled with so much hatred which blinds them to see facts as they are. Could it possibly be that Jehovah's Witnesses are the true Christians Jesus speaks of since he said his followers would be hated just as he was?  4/20/07
 Ft Worth, Tx
 Thank you so much Mr Engardio and Mr. Shepard! you are both to be commended for such a fine job in gathering accurate facts about Jehovah's people! it's not everyday that we (Jehovah's Witnesses) hear positive things about our Organization! to those who didn't get the point I guess you never will!back in early '70's when I began learning about Jehovah's purpose for the Earth and it's Inhabitants, I was amazed to learn that all Seven (Egypt,Assyria,Babylon,Medo-Persia, Greece,Rome and American-British) World Governments were spoken about in God's Word the Bible!! and that on his (Jehovah's) timetable these Governments will be dealt with! and to always remember that we as humans can not direct our own steps!let alone resolve mankind's problems, after all humans think their riches can buy them - happiness,health and whatever their hearts desire! well, take a good look at this system of things and for whose eyes are wide open to the Truth can see MONEY can not resolve anything!! Seek Jehovah while you still can!! Again, Thank you.  4/20/07
 Candace
 My family is protestant. We never believed in the Trinity. We always believed Jesus was the son, and the father is God, and that they are not the same person. Does that mean we are not Christian? I am now one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I still believe that they are not the same person. I am the only one from my side of the family that is one of JW. I take my child to my mother's house every day. She watches him while I work. Does it seem like I have shunned my "unbelieving" family? I have had 2 surgeries(1 emergency, 1 voluntary)without the use of blood. My husband who was raised as one of JW was PRESSURED by high school coaches to join sports. He didn't. He hates sports, even though he could do any of them. My DH also went to college, as did I after becoming one of JW. I have researched every position JW took b4 I became one. I am not a drunk, glutton, or pedophile. I read all versions of the bible. But you will still say whatever you want to negative about JW's because YOU WON'T LISTEN. It's because of peopl e like you that I listened to JW's. So I want to say thank you for the reverse psychology. It worked!  4/20/07
 JS
 SB CA
 This video is amazing. I am so happy that the Witnesses have been portrayed in an accurate light. It would have been interesting to see more information on dis-fellowshipping. I myself was once dis-fellowshipped. It was the best thing that every happened for my spirituality and my relationship with Jehovah. Because I understood the basis and purpose for it and had the proper attitude about it, I was able to see it as the positive and loving provision that it is. My family never made me feel bad as a person. And I always knew my Brothers and Sisters loved me and only wanted to best for me. I can only hope for those who are currently dis-fellowshipped to cultivate the right attitude as well and reap the benefits.  4/20/07
 I read several of the letters that some have written. and it sad, that they dont read their oun bibles . but let man teach them lies. Jesus said that there would be wolves in sheep clothing tricking the people. telling lies. how can the relgions in the world say they are christians when they bless the war emmblems to kill others that were in the same religion as they were????? this happen in world war I and II. that is being a Christian. the bible tells us no one has seen God and lived. so if Jesus is God did people see him??? Jesus said his father was greater then he was. anyway thank you for Knocking. it was wonderful.  4/20/07
 Grand Junction, Co
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and I must say that I thought that this was one of the fairest programs I have ever seen about the Witnesses. Most people don't really know much about our beliefs or about how the Witnesses have helped secure American freedoms of conscience. This film helps create much needed understanding.  4/20/07
 North Bergen, NJ
 As a baptized Witness for the past 10 years, I appreciate the objective work in documenting the lives of Jehovah's Witnesses. With so much false, hateful propaganda spread about Witnesses, it is extremely refreshing to see such a fair, well made documentary.  4/20/07
 Kim
 Roch. , Ny
 Unfortunatly people still seem to be confused...JW ARE Christians, we do believe in Jesus Christ we do believe that he is Lord and Savior, Do we believe that he is God? No!! They are two separate beings. As for things disfellowshipped ones are saying, they chose that course, there are guidelines that Jehovah sets out for all of his servents and if you choose to ignore his standards you cannot be allowed to defile the congregation. We are not like other religions that turn their cheek on blatent wrongdoing. I am speaking from experience, i was once too disfellowshipped but i chose to learn subjection to Jehovahs rightous standards and the authority that the elders have to keep the congregation spiritually clean. I am now reinstated and couldn't be happier or stronger in my faith. Humans are not perfect and make mistakes but will be held accountable for their actions.  4/20/07
 John
 Fort Worth, Tx
 I saw your sample clips and was very impressed with your unbiased approach. Being a Jehovah's Christian Witness my entire life I can tell a lot of people here that I have lived a very normal life. For example, Im a college graduate, and a organ recipient but you would never know from meeting me, because Im just a average guy who likes talking about cars, girls, and sports etc. Thanks again for the documentary.  4/20/07
 Cat
 NH
 I wish the many sides of the Jehovah's Witnesses had been more thoroughly researched before this documentary was created. I was born and raised as a JW, and it was extremely damaging to me. They are obsessed with the imminent coming of Armageddon. They are obsessed with Satan and demons, and often tell children they are demonized (i.e. possessed) when they are misbehaving. They constantly worry about being demonized if they watch or listen to or read anything the perceive as putting doubts in their minds about the Watchtower Society. They will burn items that they think are demonized. They use cult mind control to indoctrinate all members; "independent thought" is forbidden, and you can be disfellowshipped for questioning anything that comes from the "Governing Body" (i.e Watchtower Society); you are forbidden to read any literature that comes from another religion or theology; you must never enter a church or other religion's house of worship; you must not research the Watchtower Society or read anything coming from a former member of the JWs, you are not allowed to associate with anyone outside the religion. I could go on and on about the rules. You can be disfellowshipped (shunned by all JWs, including your own family) for things such as: apostacy (leaving the JW religion or joining or attending another church), reporting abuse or sexual abuse to the police (because you are sullying Jehovah's name by reporting that such things are done by Jehovah's Witnesses), smoking, and sex outside of marriage. You won't be disfellowshipped if you beat your wife or children, sexually abuse anyone, or rape someone. The victim of these things is councilled by the elders to be more obedient, go out door to door more regularly, be more faithful, but are never advised to leave the abusive situation or to report it to the authorities.  4/20/07
 T.E.
 The truth of the matter is that being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is not for everyone. There are some definate sacrifices that you need to make. If you make a faithful study of the scriptures then you will see that most all the "negative" situations that people talk about are actually mandated by the bible. For those who dont understand, I am sure one of Jehovah's Witnesses would be glad to explain. Knocking does wonders to alleviate some of the myths surrounding the group. Thank you for your diligence.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_d.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 4/25/07
 Stan
 New York, NY
 I thought this was more fun to watch and actually more accurate. I use to be a JW several years ago. "Mulberry Street"
 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rg-pK_twCbM  4/25/07
 Carolyn Leaf
 New York, NY
 Thanks so much for this wonderful website on "Knocking." I think it is very well done and informative. Very professional. I am also one of Jehovah's Witnesses and have seen the film twice; however, I do hope you are planning to air it on my local NYC PBS station(s) in May as previously stated. Thanks again.  4/25/07
 Jackie Zucco
 West Alexandria, OH
 It was great to see that you obviously researched Jehovah's Witnesses and what they really do believe in. As a Jehovah's Witness I just wanted to thank you for bringing out truth instead of lies! As Psalms 121:2 says, My help is from Jehovah. Regards  4/25/07
 Janet Powell
 Miami Florida
 I LOVE the website for "Knocking" on the Independent Lens site. I'm sending the link to many of my friends.  4/25/07
 Kristen
 PA
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, and I noticed that many have commented that Jehovah's Witnesses are not allowed to read other literature. I know many Witnesses who were encouraged to do research and prove to themselves whether it was the truth that they were learning. I myself have read other literature and simply did not agree with it because it was not in line with what I had read from the scriptures, and the different teachings of other religions together did not make sense to me. They just weren't for me. I have also used other Bibles, not just the New World Translation, and I tell others that we can use other translations in our Bible discussions. Sometimes, we end up using the New World Translation anyway because the language is easier to read, but that is by the Bible student's choice. It is true, however, that I do not like to read literature that is overly critical and negative. I try to stick to the upbuilding and informative reading!  4/25/07
 Victoria, BC
 I enjoyed the DVD very much and watched all the extras with interest. As one of Jw's for 17 years, you did a fine job. I found it very accurate. I am glad that many of those who have posted a message say they were once disfellowshipped and then returned and were glad for the discipline it gave them. I know many that have come back, and have become some of my favorite people, very spiritually minded and focussed in their life. I liked the comment by the one brother who said the Isrealites were Jehovah's people and yet they failed many times to live up to his standard. We aren't perfect, but we certainly do our best to be good people and live by Bible principles. Many of the neg comments have come from those who have been out of the organization for many years, we always move forward and try to improve. You would find that things have changed since you were associated. Many of the things you were concerned about have probably changed. Your comments are no longer as accurate as you once thought. We correct mistakes when we see them. The DVD is an accurate portrayal of us. Maybe it will help some people see us differently, understand why we do what we do. Understanding and knowledge are power. Thanks for giving it to us and others.  4/25/07
 Emmanuel Aisuebeogun
 Boston, MA
 We give thanks to Jehovah for his loving kindness publicly expressed once again through this video. It is so interesting to hear those who "do not seem to have time" to learn about him, comment favorably about our work. Let those who have ears listen now!  4/25/07
 Erica
 Chico, CA
 I haven't seen the documentary just yet and was reading the comments that others have left. I am a student at a four year university and was raised with Witness believes, but I haven‚t yet got baptized. I am grateful to see a film from an outside perspective of who Jehovah Witnesses are and what they preach. I still study with the Witnesses because I want to and not because my parents force me or because I feel guilty. I have studied on my own and read the scriptures on my own. For me this is the truth, and I know it is the path to happiness. I don‚t want to be biases but trying to give a fair answer. As a student and living on my own away from parents temptations are raised to young people. I feel that having biblical understanding and faith have protected me from making bad decisions and kept me safe. Growing up with Witness believes never hinder me as a child.
 Yes, Jehovah Witnesses don‚t celebrate birthdays or Christmas, but I never felt left out. These holidays have good intentions from religious perspective to family gatherings. However, I can still have family gatherings anytime of the year. I can give and receive gifts anytime of the year. Although, I am not active and don‚t assist the meetings consecutively I respect Jehovah Witnesses and I hope others have an open mind about who they are. They never force upon their believes they only want to help.  4/25/07
 David
 I have seen the video and was very impressed. There is not time to fully explain some of the aspects mentioned in the film, but, found what was presented as accurate. Thank you for the forum and a useful dicussion on a serious topic. It does make you think!  4/25/07
 Willmar Acevedo
 Frederiksted Virgin Islands
 I ordered the video and saw it several times to absorb the message. I thank you for such a competent job and outstanding research. Jehovah´s Witnesses have taken to all the world a message from the Bible. Some of the basic principles of liberty to do this were gained in the legal arena of the United States or Canada yet the rest of the world has benefited. I look forward to wathching this video on TV in May.  4/25/07
 roni
 i was raised third generation witness. and the sad thing about that is that my grandmother is the one that has all of the mentally insane issues and adheres to the witness dogma as if every fraction of the letter of their laws are inscrutable.she converted from being raised a methodist and yet instead of totally dropping whatever hellfire doctrine that her birth faith has, she switched it over to "anything you do means you're going to die at armagedon no matter how small of an error it was." my grandmother is so overbearing and controlling that three of her five children aren't witnesses and never really have wanted to be at all. sadly, i was born to one of her two children that is still a witness. but even my mother admits that she's not happy being a witness. she's had several breakdowns wherein she swears she doesn't want to be a witness anymore but because it's all she knows she doesn't have the free will god gave a a five year old to spare herself the agony she keeps going through day after day. the only joy my mom finds to use to help her get up in the morning is the thought of getting to go mountain biking, not going to the meetings. she doesn't even stay long enough after the last amen is said to take another breath. she's gone as soon as the meeting is done. what does that tell you all?  4/20/07
 Nelson A. Herle, Jr.
 Apple Vallley, CA
 I was very interested to read the comments on the "Knocking" presentation and the views of others who have watched the film. I have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses for 56 years. I invite any who wish to consider the questions some have raised on the "New World Translation" and the doctrine of the Trinity, etc. I have prepared a CD-ROM with over seven hundred pages of research, early Church and modern, and would gladly send a copy free of charge to anyone who wishes to read it. You may publish my E-mail address in your "comments" section if you so desire. Thank you. Nelsonaherle@AOL.com  4/20/07
 I saw the video a few months ago and plan on watching it again. I thought it was great. Thank you for telling this story. I also found it interesting all the 'insight' people outside JW seem to have. It's quite comical to listen to people tell us what we beleive. That's the beauty of free choice and expression. Being raised in the truth, this is what I know. What I also know is the outside, having been disfellowshipped twice. What I learned during that time is Humility is a wonderful thing. This is Jehovah's organization and if things don't seem to be handled correctly, He will correct it for sure. No earthly organization is perfect, we ALL make mistakes, but ultimately, it's between you and Jehovah. This is the truth, no doubt.Who else teaches PS.37:9-11,29? Who else has a Worldwide Brotherhood? For those who have negative experiences, Jehovah didn't do it to you. People are people, and imperfect. Don't allow people to separate you from him. Humbly submit to Jehovah, He will lead you, if you humbly let Him. I know this myself first hand. thanks again.  4/20/07
 Nadia Halasz
 Seattle, Wa
 We would like to see the entire program. Very interesting to know this group of people publicly.To know who they are since we know them from "doors" and as respectful, kind co-workers. Thank you.  4/20/07
 Randy Reed
 Nashville, TN
 Thanks for the ballanced perspective. I am looking forward to seeing the program. Thanks PBS for airing this. Randy Reed  4/20/07
 Sally Weimer
 Josephine, Pennsylvania
 Thank you for the information contained on your web site. Rather than present a negative view, you presented truthful statements about a much misunderstood organization.  4/20/07
 Sam and Linda Bender
 Somers Point, NJ
 This is wonderful. We are JWs but we have a lot of friends, coworkers and calls in the ministry that will find this website very interesting. We appreciate PBS and programs like Independent Lens airing such unique programs. It certainly presents a varied view and helps to educate the public in an objective manner not associated with us Jehovah's Witnesses about who we really are. We notice this is done on PBS a lot of times about a lot of subjects. Knowledge is always good and important to make available. Keep up the good work!  4/20/07
 Elizabeth Phillips
 East Orange, NJ
 It sure seems that the negative comments are being weeded out on this site. I am a former witness who is aware of many of the negative things about the cult of Jehovah's Witnesses.JWs themselves aren't allowed to see anything negative about this mind-controlling organization, but "Crisis of Conscience" by Ray Franz should be required reading for anyone considering a "Bible" study.
 The Bible "translation" the JWs use is full of inaccuracies - not surprising considering it was "translated" by men who had no expertise in the Bible languages. The practice of allowing pedophiles to continue to associate with children is reprehensible. And not even allowing the parents of accusers to warn other parents makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. There has to be at least one other witness to the abuse to be considered as proof. How many pedophiles allow there to be witnesses to their crimes? It's just insane! www.silentlambs.org
 The definition of a cult includes the belief that there is only "onetrue religion" - that all other religions are from Satan. One of the first things the JWs teach is that they are the only true religion. They even call it "The Truth".If you're considering joining this group, please do some research. Be willing to at least look at the negative or critical things others say about it. Decide for yourself whether you're willing to sign your life over to them.  4/20/07
 Martha S
 LaFayette Hill, PA
 Thank you so much for this documentary. Jehovah's Witnesses, their families and friends are looking forward to viewing this on PBS. Reading other comments I wanted to add the following:
 To be "expelled" or as we say "disfellowshipped" is a last resort. Privately and unknown to congregation members, Elders work with individuals by utilizing the Bible and help them to see where they need to bring themselves into line with Bible Principles. Remorse, repentance and effort to turn around are necessary in order to remain a part of the Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses. Disfellowshipping is a Bible based necessity in order to keep the congregation clean. 1 Corinthians 5:9-13  4/20/07
 Although I haven't seen it yet, I want to thank you for making this documentary available to the general public, and I surely look forward to seeing it and owning my own copy. Thanks too for hosting this web site that helps set the record straight, while clarifying and making known the good that Jehovah's Witnesses have done and continue to do. A thousand thank-yous to all involved. - One of Jehovah's Witnesses  4/20/07
 Solomon Landers
 Thank you, PBS, Independent Lens, and Joel P. Engardio. This is an excellent piece of work and a fine undertaking. Jehovah's Witnesses are controversial, often misunderstood, often purposely misrepresented. It is good to get "Knocking"'s unbiased view out to the public.I have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses for over 50 years. It has been the best part of my life. And I trust that in my ministry, my life has been a blessing to others.  4/20/07
 Clarissa Ortiz
 Brawley, Ca
 My warmest congratulations to the makers of this film. it took great courage to put out who we are. i learned "the truth" almost fifty years ago. i have to admit that i have many faults, and that actually this earthly organization is made up entirely of imperfect individuals. the comments of many of your viewers sadden me that they refuse to see us for what and who we really are. the comments of some who at one time were in our fold don't help. i know that we can talk ourselves til we're blue in the face and they will refuse to recognize us as the true religion. the time is just about upon us when it will be discovered that everything we have ever preached about will be proven true. those that insist that jesus is god incarnate, and that we have a distorted version of the bible will realize how wrong they were, but then it will be too late. this is indeed the organization that Jehovah God is utilizing to warn the world about the end of this system of things, just as he used the nation of Israel as his organization. even though israel had many flaws because they were all imperfect, it was still his nation. so it is today, and i am determined to continue faithful to Jehovah God and his organization. Jehovah will correct any (including me)who needs correcting. i will remain loyal!  4/20/07
 Dave
 Lots of misinformed people on this board. Witnesses are indeed Christians since they follow the teachings of Jesus. They also believe that Jesus was the son of God, contrary to what some people here claim. Those who are "shunned" have every opportunity to make amends and are encouraged to do so. If they don't make amends, it's their own choice. The JW translation of the bible is the most accurate translation of the Greek and Hebrew scriptures; an independent study proved it. Read the book "Truth in Translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament" by Jason BeDuhn.  4/20/07
 Nick
 There's no journalistic integrity in this film. this was watchtower society approved. it's really important to go into the history, even back 10-20 years, to get an idea of the damage of disfellowshipping. depression and mental illness were looked upon as signs that a person was secretly sinning. my father was an elder for nine years, had a breakdown, and was witch hunted by two different congregations w/o any regard for his illness, our grief and situation. i have two friends who left and killed themselves b/c of guilt. the wtbts will never take responsibility for their past policies and only invoke new ones to keep an organization that is on the brink of falling apart, together macgyver style. jws think if you're not one of them, you're dead, then they will back talk that as 'only god knows' to the media, but being in the wtbts for many years i know what's really said and thought.
 the only reason this film is getting air time is b/c the directors recruited jws to attend the screenings over and over. if this documentary had truth in it, jws wouldn't have supported it and it would've never made the pbs radar.to that i say the filmmakers are brilliant with this strategy and i'm planning my pro-LDS documentary right now. i need the money.  4/20/07
 Dallas, Texas
 As one of Jehovah's witnesses for more than 58 years I am pleased to say that I have lived a good life because of following Bible standards in my life. Thank you for publishing, from an outside source, a good account of Jehovah's witnesses and their fight for religious freedom not only in the U.S. of American but all around the world. In answer to those negative comments.I am sorry that those people have such a negative attitude about an organization that is working hard for the good of all. I would say they need to do some heart searching and Bible study to readjust that negative attitude. I have this DVD and have enjoyed viewing it. Serving a loving God with your whole heart in union with a very loving brotherhood is the best thing that can happen to anyone.  4/20/07
 Jen
 I've seen this organization from inside and out and feel that the documentary isn't far from wrong. It saddens me that so many who have posted here are filled with so much hatred which blinds them to see facts as they are. Could it possibly be that Jehovah's Witnesses are the true Christians Jesus speaks of since he said his followers would be hated just as he was?  4/20/07
 Ft Worth, Tx
 Thank you so much Mr Engardio and Mr. Shepard! you are both to be commended for such a fine job in gathering accurate facts about Jehovah's people! it's not everyday that we (Jehovah's Witnesses) hear positive things about our Organization! to those who didn't get the point I guess you never will!back in early '70's when I began learning about Jehovah's purpose for the Earth and it's Inhabitants, I was amazed to learn that all Seven (Egypt,Assyria,Babylon,Medo-Persia, Greece,Rome and American-British) World Governments were spoken about in God's Word the Bible!! and that on his (Jehovah's) timetable these Governments will be dealt with! and to always remember that we as humans can not direct our own steps!let alone resolve mankind's problems, after all humans think their riches can buy them - happiness,health and whatever their hearts desire! well, take a good look at this system of things and for whose eyes are wide open to the Truth can see MONEY can not resolve anything!! Seek Jehovah while you still can!! Again, Thank you.  4/20/07
 Candace
 My family is protestant. We never believed in the Trinity. We always believed Jesus was the son, and the father is God, and that they are not the same person. Does that mean we are not Christian? I am now one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I still believe that they are not the same person. I am the only one from my side of the family that is one of JW. I take my child to my mother's house every day. She watches him while I work. Does it seem like I have shunned my "unbelieving" family? I have had 2 surgeries(1 emergency, 1 voluntary)without the use of blood. My husband who was raised as one of JW was PRESSURED by high school coaches to join sports. He didn't. He hates sports, even though he could do any of them. My DH also went to college, as did I after becoming one of JW. I have researched every position JW took b4 I became one. I am not a drunk, glutton, or pedophile. I read all versions of the bible. But you will still say whatever you want to negative about JW's because YOU WON'T LISTEN. It's because of peopl e like you that I listened to JW's. So I want to say thank you for the reverse psychology. It worked!  4/20/07
 JS
 SB CA
 This video is amazing. I am so happy that the Witnesses have been portrayed in an accurate light. It would have been interesting to see more information on dis-fellowshipping. I myself was once dis-fellowshipped. It was the best thing that every happened for my spirituality and my relationship with Jehovah. Because I understood the basis and purpose for it and had the proper attitude about it, I was able to see it as the positive and loving provision that it is. My family never made me feel bad as a person. And I always knew my Brothers and Sisters loved me and only wanted to best for me. I can only hope for those who are currently dis-fellowshipped to cultivate the right attitude as well and reap the benefits.  4/20/07
 I read several of the letters that some have written. and it sad, that they dont read their oun bibles . but let man teach them lies. Jesus said that there would be wolves in sheep clothing tricking the people. telling lies. how can the relgions in the world say they are christians when they bless the war emmblems to kill others that were in the same religion as they were????? this happen in world war I and II. that is being a Christian. the bible tells us no one has seen God and lived. so if Jesus is God did people see him??? Jesus said his father was greater then he was. anyway thank you for Knocking. it was wonderful.  4/20/07
 Grand Junction, Co
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and I must say that I thought that this was one of the fairest programs I have ever seen about the Witnesses. Most people don't really know much about our beliefs or about how the Witnesses have helped secure American freedoms of conscience. This film helps create much needed understanding.  4/20/07
 North Bergen, NJ
 As a baptized Witness for the past 10 years, I appreciate the objective work in documenting the lives of Jehovah's Witnesses. With so much false, hateful propaganda spread about Witnesses, it is extremely refreshing to see such a fair, well made documentary.  4/20/07
 Kim
 Roch. , Ny
 Unfortunatly people still seem to be confused...JW ARE Christians, we do believe in Jesus Christ we do believe that he is Lord and Savior, Do we believe that he is God? No!! They are two separate beings. As for things disfellowshipped ones are saying, they chose that course, there are guidelines that Jehovah sets out for all of his servents and if you choose to ignore his standards you cannot be allowed to defile the congregation. We are not like other religions that turn their cheek on blatent wrongdoing. I am speaking from experience, i was once too disfellowshipped but i chose to learn subjection to Jehovahs rightous standards and the authority that the elders have to keep the congregation spiritually clean. I am now reinstated and couldn't be happier or stronger in my faith. Humans are not perfect and make mistakes but will be held accountable for their actions.  4/20/07
 John
 Fort Worth, Tx
 I saw your sample clips and was very impressed with your unbiased approach. Being a Jehovah's Christian Witness my entire life I can tell a lot of people here that I have lived a very normal life. For example, Im a college graduate, and a organ recipient but you would never know from meeting me, because Im just a average guy who likes talking about cars, girls, and sports etc. Thanks again for the documentary.  4/20/07
 Cat
 NH
 I wish the many sides of the Jehovah's Witnesses had been more thoroughly researched before this documentary was created. I was born and raised as a JW, and it was extremely damaging to me. They are obsessed with the imminent coming of Armageddon. They are obsessed with Satan and demons, and often tell children they are demonized (i.e. possessed) when they are misbehaving. They constantly worry about being demonized if they watch or listen to or read anything the perceive as putting doubts in their minds about the Watchtower Society. They will burn items that they think are demonized. They use cult mind control to indoctrinate all members; "independent thought" is forbidden, and you can be disfellowshipped for questioning anything that comes from the "Governing Body" (i.e Watchtower Society); you are forbidden to read any literature that comes from another religion or theology; you must never enter a church or other religion's house of worship; you must not research the Watchtower Society or read anything coming from a former member of the JWs, you are not allowed to associate with anyone outside the religion. I could go on and on about the rules. You can be disfellowshipped (shunned by all JWs, including your own family) for things such as: apostacy (leaving the JW religion or joining or attending another church), reporting abuse or sexual abuse to the police (because you are sullying Jehovah's name by reporting that such things are done by Jehovah's Witnesses), smoking, and sex outside of marriage. You won't be disfellowshipped if you beat your wife or children, sexually abuse anyone, or rape someone. The victim of these things is councilled by the elders to be more obedient, go out door to door more regularly, be more faithful, but are never advised to leave the abusive situation or to report it to the authorities.  4/20/07
 T.E.
 The truth of the matter is that being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is not for everyone. There are some definate sacrifices that you need to make. If you make a faithful study of the scriptures then you will see that most all the "negative" situations that people talk about are actually mandated by the bible. For those who dont understand, I am sure one of Jehovah's Witnesses would be glad to explain. Knocking does wonders to alleviate some of the myths surrounding the group. Thank you for your diligence.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_d.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/1/07
 Tara Sykes
 Western Australia
 It would be interesting to have a face off with practicing Jejovah Wittnesses and people who have left the Watchtower organisation. Ive read on the feedback forum statistical data relevant to the hours spent door knocking, the numbers of active publishers etc. What hasnt been published is the statistical numbers of people who have left the Watchtower Org on their own free will never to return.I keep forgetting that these ones are labellled "Inactive". Therefore, I assert again that once your in your always going to be labelled a Jehovah Wittness wether you want to be or not. Ive read many of the posts presented by active JW's and they read perfect text book doctrine that is the retorical resonance of the Watch Tower rganisation. I left on my own free will and have been dogged by these fanatical people ten years after the fact.They tell everyone I'm an apostate and to keep away from me......Im privelaged to be a constant thorn in their side for evermore. Did you know that they will never put there slanderous acussations in writing and sign their names to it....yep thats right.....they will avoid legal action at any cost.  4/27/07
 ShirleyAmy
 Idaho
 I can't say enough how much I enjoyed this documentary. I bought it during the early release period and have been sharing it with many of my friends. I thank you for the balanced view portrayed of Witnesses and their beliefs. I also appreciated the "opposing" views of those family members of the families in the video. I think it's important to show that these children were in no way kept away from their grandmother, even though she did not agree. I know that many think that Witnesses can only associate with fellow Witnesses, even shunning non-witness family members, but this program clearly demonstrates that this is not true. Thank you...  4/27/07
 Shirley
 The Witnesses are good, decent, dedicated people....but they have been deceived. The Watchtower Society is one of the largest cults in the world; masquerading as Christian. In fact, they believe all TRUE Christian churches are of the devil! The WTS has had numerous false prophesies; they have changed their beliefs many times; their stand on not accepting blood transfusions has cost the lives of literally thousands of good people, and has in turn caused tremendous suffering among the surviving family members. Jehovah Witnesses are told what to believe, what to read, how to interpet it, & how to live their lives. When you sign on as a JW, you are signing away your life, your freedoms & your non-believing family members. You are not allowed to question their leadership or anything that they teach you. They believe they are God's ONLY TRUE organization on earth. This is definitely a very dangerous MIND CONTROL cult. ANY church, any organization, any person who claims this exclusivity should make you want to RUN IN THE OTHER DIRECTION. Only Jesus is the Way, the Truth, & the Life. For it's only through Him that we can be saved. If you are thinking of joining the WTS, please think again.....  4/27/07
 martha
 I made a very grave mistake when I was in my early 20s, I became a Jehovahs Wittness. I did not reseach the religion like I should of. Once you say the governing body in NY is Gods representative on earth and get baptised you can never have the freedom to leave the organization without shunning. I left after 25 years for the same reason I got in I wanted to serve God in "truth" I found out the "truth" was based on lies. People have given up so much for this religion because "soon" Armaggedon was coming.......its a dangerous religion that saps the life out of its members. Freedom is only felt when you leave. If you hear the knock...don't answer!  4/27/07
 Philip Nelson
 Largo, MD
 I truely feel that this video will be an excellent denunciation of the myths surrounding Jehovah's Witnesses. I too am one and am grateful that even non-believers such as yourself still see the positive of our religion. Hopefully, in time maybe you might join our ranks in the brotherhood.  4/27/07
 Mark Smith
 I am anxious to see the entire "knocking" movie. The JW lifestyle is not for everyone. I spent over 10,000 hrs doing the work of the JW ministry and I was never able to convince anyone that it was the "Truth". I only wasted about 20% of my life before I figured out they were not God's true church. I feel sorry for the ones who will end up wasting their entire life in the Kingdom Hall.  4/25/07
 Catherine Cerniglia
 Lake Forest, CA
 Thank you for this outstanding website and the opportunity to view "Knocking" on public television.  4/25/07
 Hope Gonzalez
 Merced California
 I have not yet seen the "Knocking" program. It is scheduled to air here in our are on May 22 at 10pm. However,I am thoroughly looking forward to it because I have heard very,very good reviews from others who have had the opportunity to see it already or have purchased the DVD. Thankyou so much for showing this program to help people see who and what Jehovah's Witnesses really are.  4/25/07
 Serena Simmons
 Dallas, Texas
 Thank you PBS for presenting this page on Knocking. I am a regular viewer of PBS and appreciate the the excellent programming you do.  4/25/07
 Randall Watters
 Manhattan Beach, CA
 Witnesses were once fighters for certain good things in our laws, but the organization has evolved full circle into a bunch of hypocritical old men who remain in a severe Victorian world where they hole up and say, "We are the only true religion!" They are declining the last two years in many parts of the earth due to THIS, the internet, the very thing they are encouraged to avoid because it makes them look so bad. Follow any of the links about Jehovah's Witnesses in the search engines and you will find the record of false prophecies, flip-flops in doctrine, phony dates, and bloodguilt over wrongful deaths, including those from following their ever-changing stance on blood transfusions.  4/25/07
 Danny Haszard
 Bangor Maine
 A heads up on the Jehovah Witnesses The core dogma of the Watchtower organization is that Jesus had his second coming 'invisibly' in the year 1914.Their entire doctrinal superstructure is built on this falsehood. There is good and valid reasons why there is such an outrage against the Watchtower for misleading millions of followers.Many have invested everything in the 'imminent' apocalyptic promises of the Jehovah's Witnesses and have died broken and beaten.  4/25/07
 Kristin Eddinger
 Weston, Florida
 This documentary was refreshing and relieving. I've seen a lot of non-witness-produced documentaries about us that have twisted our words and have presented out-right falsities about us. But this is the first that I've seen that has had a balanced and accurate view. Thankyou.  4/25/07
 Brighton
 My parents became JW's when I was about 5 years old. I was baptised in 1980 at the age of 16. They have been turbulent years , interspersed with happiness and alot of sadness. I know many who have been disfellowshipped, myself included.Of those that have been disfellowshipped, 2 have committed suicide. Three others committed suicide while still active. The WTS claims that repentant persons, can be reinststed, and while this is true. The process can itself be painful and humiliating and usually takes a year or longer, with persons required to cease all association with non Witnesses, while attending meetings with no-one being allowed to speak to you or associate with you until reinstatement. It means sitting at the back of the Kingdom Hall durring meetings and not being allowed to participate - the shunning continues untill sufficient time passes and the Elders decide , that they are satisfied that there is enough outward proof of repentance.So one is completely isolated until then, the loneliness can be unbearable. Witnesses claim this is biblical and that the wrondoer brings this hardship upon themselves. How differnt to the story of the prodigal son, and the father who runs to meet him, while he is yet along way off!  4/25/07
 Ana
 Sammamish Washington
 When I saw this website, I got very excited. I am so happy that somebody has finally put some good information about us on the web. This is one of the few sites out there that really tell what we are about. We are a loving community who reach out to help others. I've been raised as a Jehovah's Witness and just recently got baptized, and I am just extremely happy. Thank you for making this website. I have seen the previews for Knocking, and I can't wait! Thank you again.  4/25/07
 Thank you for making a movie that Jehovah's people for who they really are. There are numerous misconceptions about Jehovah's Witnessnes but this was foretold in the Bible when Jesus said that the world would hate those that follow in his footsteps. By refusing blood it has forced the medical community to step up and come up with better techniques and methods of operations and so on. I know it is controversial but it is spelled out so clear to abstain from blood. Thank you for your fair and unbiased look at the lives of Jehovah's Witnesses.  4/25/07
 Claude Kenneson
 Tallahassee, Florida
 Do any of you realize that the Watchtower Society claims that the early Christians who were martyred by the Roman government were really "nominal Christians," who had wandered away from the truth? They died in vain. And this from a people who make so much over their own persecution by the Nazis!  4/25/07
 Australia
 In regard to the "Knocking" documentary. you claim the witnesses set a precedent for asserting their right to freedom of speech etc. What you didnt present in your documentary is the fact that once baptised and in the "truth" you actually give up the right to your free will to question any of the Jehovah Witness doctrines. In regard to child abuse, it is a well documented fact that victims and their families who have gone to the police have been persecuted by their congregation and the watchtower society. You are told to keep it quiet and have it dealt with internally. The watchtower society has shelled out millions in out of court settlements as they avoid negative publicity.religious freedom is just that....true religious freedom allows the individual to practice freedom of will without fear of retribution by people who claim that they are gods chosen people.  4/25/07
 Albert S.
 Wethersfield, CT
 The "Independent Lens" series is one of my favorite things on television, consistently bringing interesting programs and featuring compelling stories. I'm not a Jehovahs Witness myself, but its hard to miss the impact they've had on preconceived notions about Nazi camp techniques and Supreme Court law. What more do I need to know?
 Based on this impressive website, there is a LOT more to this religion! My family already plans to watch "Knocking" on PBS, and I anticipate buying the DVD sometime after than. I'm guessing I'll enjoy lending in out to my less tolerant acquaintances! Thanks for a really detailed website on this film!  4/25/07
 Cat
 NH
 I was a Jehovahs' Witness for 20 years. If the Jehovah's Witnesses are so proud of fighting for freedom of speech, why are their members forbidden from having "independent thought" or questioning anything that the Watchtower Society says? There is no freedom of speech or thought within the JWs. If you say the wrong thing, someone will report you to the elders, and if you don't stop questioning or saying things that make them uncomfortable, they will disfellowship you. The Watchtower Society controls everything the members do, say, and think. They use fear to keep everyone under their control. I wish you had shown all sides of the JWs in your documentary.  4/25/07
 Greg Grew
 Woodbury, CT
 I have seen the documentary and appreciated its balanced point of view. I look forward to the PBS broadcast. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. The misconceptions and predjudicial views of outsiders go with the territory and are to be expected. It has no effect on my own decisions and beliefs. It is refreshing, however, to see a media source present both sides and also show the public that we not a fanatical group or cult.  4/25/07
 Vancouver, WA
 IN REPLY TO YOUR QUESTION:
 Do you have family members whose beliefs you disagree with, or vice versa? YES, many.
 Do you think there is a way that such families can peacefully co-exist, despite their disagreements?YES - RESPECT AND LOVE.
 The Bible tells us how to show respect and love to our family who are unbelievers.(1 Peter 3:1-2) In our family, that has resulted in some enbracing our faith and others not. We never agrue, but always come from a place of love and thoughtfulness.Even Jesus Christ had persons in his own family that did not accept him. He told his followers that he came put a sword - "wife against mother-in-law." He further said that one's enemies would be in their own households. (Matthew 10:32-37) So we should not be surprised when family members disagree with our beliefs.
 Further, the scriptures speak of those who will speak abusively when one discontinues immoral ways. (1 Peter 4:4) This absolutely happened to us and we took great comfort from the scriptures and the experience strengthened our faith and resolve.Lastly, we pray for our family and friends to understand and join us serving Jehovah God and benefiting from his instruction. Thankfully, many of those prayers have been answered.  4/25/07
 francisco torres
 toa alta, puerto rico
 a truly fine film about a group that has been misunderstood for many years.ihope many fairminded people will see thru this excelent docu who really are jehovahs witnesses.it should win many awards,sadly here in puerto rico i do not believe that the two pbs affiliated stations will not transmit this excellent docu.they do not transmit independent lens.  4/25/07
 MS
 L H, PA
 There are almost 7 Million Jehovah's Witnesses in over 230 lands. It is important to know that this number reflects ACTIVE PUBLISHERS, those individuals who are active in the ministry work. Young ones that are not baptized and therefore not submitting time in the ministry AND inactive members (not in the ministry) are NOT counted in this 7 Million number. It is important to note that at the anniversary of the death of Jesus, over 16 MILLION worldwide attended this observance. This is very telling of the number of those who are..inactive but baptized, young ones prior to baptism and persons studying the Bible with Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Worldwide Numbers:
 *Nearly 7 Million Actively Preaching
 *Over 16 Million Attending Anniversary of Jesus Sacrificial Death
 *More than 1 Billion 300 Hundred Million Hours Jehovah's Witnesses spent in the Worldwide
 Preaching Work for Service Year of 2006.
 *Women (Sisters) are, as Prophesied, Having A Very Large Share in the Preaching of the Good News. "Jehovah him self gives the saying; The women telling the good news are a large army." Psalms 68:11 The original Hebrew Language of Psalm 68:11 tanslates into WOMEN which is the SAME HEBREW LANGUAGE in Exodus 15:20. (See King James Bible for Exodus 15:20.)
 Other scriptures below found in the King James Bible where the Original Language translates into WOMEN.
 HEBREW-1 Samuel 18:6
 GREEK-Acts 8:12
 If you translate the Original Language to "women" for scriptures in one part of the Bible, you have to translate this Original Language into "women" in the other scriptures of the Bible. Psalms 68:11 in the Origianl Hebrew Language is NOT in the past tense.
 If necessary consult original manuscripts.  4/25/07
 Sonia V. Vizcaino
 New York, NY
 I am amazed and pleased with the well researched information that you have presented on this website. As one of Jehovah's Witneses, I am very happy to see that there are those who are interested in portraying us as we are, normal, law abiding citizens who just want to live peacefully while we share our message with our neighbors. I have not had an opportunity to see the documentary yet, but have heard very positive remarks, and am making plans to veiw it soon.  4/25/07
 Brenda
 Lawton Oklahoma
 Thank you to PBS for supporting and airing this and other films that show an objective view of people, organizations and the world in general. As one of Jehovah's Witnesses I cringed at some of the comments made in the film but applaud the fact that it showed the reality of what people both in and out of this organization think.I have many family members who are not Jehovah's Witnesses and I love them all. Our interactions with each other are just as good or even better than before I joined JWs. We disagree on many things but we always have.
 Additionally I would like to address one of the comments made by another that had nothing to do with the film. They stated "The practice of allowing pedophiles to continue to associate with children is reprehensible." JWs expel unrepentant wrong doers of all kinds instead of allowing hypocrisy. Accused pedophiles even if repentant are not allowed to have any privileges of service within the organization. As a victim of abuse myself I appreciate the stand this organization has taken to protect the people within it.  4/25/07
 BBraxton
 Detroit MI
 I look forward to seeing it,I read the comments here and some centered on a personal experience of ex-witnesses and how they felt about being disfellowship or shunned by family, important thing to remember immorality offends GOD and when we diliberately disobey him we expell ourselves from fellowship with others our actions indicate that We no longer want God or our family as friends, The Christ died for our Sins, because he know's were not perfect however many are just looking for an excuse to do what pleases them and not God so please stop blaming JW's or the Watchtower Society you had the freedom to chose your course that's why you left no one is forced to stay a JW. Those who want to do what's right will, those who don't will do what they want. we want to do the crime without the consequences how sad I will pray that their hearts will be receptive to Gods Word as the Authority Thank You  4/25/07
 Thank you for this heartwarming video about kind-hearted, sincere folks who simply seek to do what they feel is right and to help others. At age 19 I chose to become a witness, and now 37 years later I lead a fulfilled, purpose-drive life where I help others. Though our 'knocking' is not welcome by all, we attempt to be respectful... and, to find those who are in need of help. And they ARE out there, isolated, in pain, in need, hungry.
 We offer spiritual, Bible-based conversations about God and his beloved Son Jesus, about Christ's kingdom, about why God permits these terrible world conditions. We use whatever Bible they prefer. If they choose to continue further, we welcome them; if they discontinue discussions, we regret the loss of our time together, but move on to find others who welcome us. To offer a different perspective than some of the comments here: I was raised in a Protestant home with 'righteous' parents who were pillars of the church and community, yet I secretly suffered years of abuse (sexual, physical, emotional) at their hands. But, I don't go to that church's website and rant nor do I target that church in other ways. I recognize the failures of them as individuals, and I simply go 'knocking' to talk in positive ways about God's goodness and a hope for a time of earthwide peace and safety under Jesus Christ's kingship.  4/25/07
 Greg Grew
 Woodbury, CT
 I have seen the documentary and appreciated its balanced point of view. I look forward to the PBS broadcast. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. The misconceptions and predjudicial views of outsiders go with the territory and are to be expected. It has no effect on my own decisions and beliefs. It is refreshing, however, to see a media source present both sides and also show the public that we not a fanatical group or cult.  4/25/07
 M S
 LH, PA
 Excellent information from the BBC link on the IndependentLens presents Knocking page. Link below.
 http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/witnesses/  4/25/07
 Hermogenes
 Miami
 RE: "In 1995, the Witnesses officially ended their belief that tied the coming of Armageddon to the lifespan of anyone alive today. Now, many young Witnesses attend college."
 I‚ve yet to see this film, but i strongly feel that the quote above has been misinterpreted. The Jehovah Witnesses have always & will continue to believe that no one knows the day or the hour that Jehovah God will unleash Armageddon upon the Earth.Biblical Calculation: At least one Holocaust survivor must remain alive in order to witness the destruction of the old system. How old could the youngest survivor of that terror storm be in 2007 ( ? )

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_e.html







PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/1/07
 Tara Sykes
 Western Australia
 It would be interesting to have a face off with practicing Jejovah Wittnesses and people who have left the Watchtower organisation. Ive read on the feedback forum statistical data relevant to the hours spent door knocking, the numbers of active publishers etc. What hasnt been published is the statistical numbers of people who have left the Watchtower Org on their own free will never to return.I keep forgetting that these ones are labellled "Inactive". Therefore, I assert again that once your in your always going to be labelled a Jehovah Wittness wether you want to be or not. Ive read many of the posts presented by active JW's and they read perfect text book doctrine that is the retorical resonance of the Watch Tower rganisation. I left on my own free will and have been dogged by these fanatical people ten years after the fact.They tell everyone I'm an apostate and to keep away from me......Im privelaged to be a constant thorn in their side for evermore. Did you know that they will never put there slanderous acussations in writing and sign their names to it....yep thats right.....they will avoid legal action at any cost.  4/27/07
 ShirleyAmy
 Idaho
 I can't say enough how much I enjoyed this documentary. I bought it during the early release period and have been sharing it with many of my friends. I thank you for the balanced view portrayed of Witnesses and their beliefs. I also appreciated the "opposing" views of those family members of the families in the video. I think it's important to show that these children were in no way kept away from their grandmother, even though she did not agree. I know that many think that Witnesses can only associate with fellow Witnesses, even shunning non-witness family members, but this program clearly demonstrates that this is not true. Thank you...  4/27/07
 Shirley
 The Witnesses are good, decent, dedicated people....but they have been deceived. The Watchtower Society is one of the largest cults in the world; masquerading as Christian. In fact, they believe all TRUE Christian churches are of the devil! The WTS has had numerous false prophesies; they have changed their beliefs many times; their stand on not accepting blood transfusions has cost the lives of literally thousands of good people, and has in turn caused tremendous suffering among the surviving family members. Jehovah Witnesses are told what to believe, what to read, how to interpet it, & how to live their lives. When you sign on as a JW, you are signing away your life, your freedoms & your non-believing family members. You are not allowed to question their leadership or anything that they teach you. They believe they are God's ONLY TRUE organization on earth. This is definitely a very dangerous MIND CONTROL cult. ANY church, any organization, any person who claims this exclusivity should make you want to RUN IN THE OTHER DIRECTION. Only Jesus is the Way, the Truth, & the Life. For it's only through Him that we can be saved. If you are thinking of joining the WTS, please think again.....  4/27/07
 martha
 I made a very grave mistake when I was in my early 20s, I became a Jehovahs Wittness. I did not reseach the religion like I should of. Once you say the governing body in NY is Gods representative on earth and get baptised you can never have the freedom to leave the organization without shunning. I left after 25 years for the same reason I got in I wanted to serve God in "truth" I found out the "truth" was based on lies. People have given up so much for this religion because "soon" Armaggedon was coming.......its a dangerous religion that saps the life out of its members. Freedom is only felt when you leave. If you hear the knock...don't answer!  4/27/07
 Philip Nelson
 Largo, MD
 I truely feel that this video will be an excellent denunciation of the myths surrounding Jehovah's Witnesses. I too am one and am grateful that even non-believers such as yourself still see the positive of our religion. Hopefully, in time maybe you might join our ranks in the brotherhood.  4/27/07
 Mark Smith
 I am anxious to see the entire "knocking" movie. The JW lifestyle is not for everyone. I spent over 10,000 hrs doing the work of the JW ministry and I was never able to convince anyone that it was the "Truth". I only wasted about 20% of my life before I figured out they were not God's true church. I feel sorry for the ones who will end up wasting their entire life in the Kingdom Hall.  4/25/07
 Catherine Cerniglia
 Lake Forest, CA
 Thank you for this outstanding website and the opportunity to view "Knocking" on public television.  4/25/07
 Hope Gonzalez
 Merced California
 I have not yet seen the "Knocking" program. It is scheduled to air here in our are on May 22 at 10pm. However,I am thoroughly looking forward to it because I have heard very,very good reviews from others who have had the opportunity to see it already or have purchased the DVD. Thankyou so much for showing this program to help people see who and what Jehovah's Witnesses really are.  4/25/07
 Serena Simmons
 Dallas, Texas
 Thank you PBS for presenting this page on Knocking. I am a regular viewer of PBS and appreciate the the excellent programming you do.  4/25/07
 Randall Watters
 Manhattan Beach, CA
 Witnesses were once fighters for certain good things in our laws, but the organization has evolved full circle into a bunch of hypocritical old men who remain in a severe Victorian world where they hole up and say, "We are the only true religion!" They are declining the last two years in many parts of the earth due to THIS, the internet, the very thing they are encouraged to avoid because it makes them look so bad. Follow any of the links about Jehovah's Witnesses in the search engines and you will find the record of false prophecies, flip-flops in doctrine, phony dates, and bloodguilt over wrongful deaths, including those from following their ever-changing stance on blood transfusions.  4/25/07
 Danny Haszard
 Bangor Maine
 A heads up on the Jehovah Witnesses The core dogma of the Watchtower organization is that Jesus had his second coming 'invisibly' in the year 1914.Their entire doctrinal superstructure is built on this falsehood. There is good and valid reasons why there is such an outrage against the Watchtower for misleading millions of followers.Many have invested everything in the 'imminent' apocalyptic promises of the Jehovah's Witnesses and have died broken and beaten.  4/25/07
 Kristin Eddinger
 Weston, Florida
 This documentary was refreshing and relieving. I've seen a lot of non-witness-produced documentaries about us that have twisted our words and have presented out-right falsities about us. But this is the first that I've seen that has had a balanced and accurate view. Thankyou.  4/25/07
 Brighton
 My parents became JW's when I was about 5 years old. I was baptised in 1980 at the age of 16. They have been turbulent years , interspersed with happiness and alot of sadness. I know many who have been disfellowshipped, myself included.Of those that have been disfellowshipped, 2 have committed suicide. Three others committed suicide while still active. The WTS claims that repentant persons, can be reinststed, and while this is true. The process can itself be painful and humiliating and usually takes a year or longer, with persons required to cease all association with non Witnesses, while attending meetings with no-one being allowed to speak to you or associate with you until reinstatement. It means sitting at the back of the Kingdom Hall durring meetings and not being allowed to participate - the shunning continues untill sufficient time passes and the Elders decide , that they are satisfied that there is enough outward proof of repentance.So one is completely isolated until then, the loneliness can be unbearable. Witnesses claim this is biblical and that the wrondoer brings this hardship upon themselves. How differnt to the story of the prodigal son, and the father who runs to meet him, while he is yet along way off!  4/25/07
 Ana
 Sammamish Washington
 When I saw this website, I got very excited. I am so happy that somebody has finally put some good information about us on the web. This is one of the few sites out there that really tell what we are about. We are a loving community who reach out to help others. I've been raised as a Jehovah's Witness and just recently got baptized, and I am just extremely happy. Thank you for making this website. I have seen the previews for Knocking, and I can't wait! Thank you again.  4/25/07
 Thank you for making a movie that Jehovah's people for who they really are. There are numerous misconceptions about Jehovah's Witnessnes but this was foretold in the Bible when Jesus said that the world would hate those that follow in his footsteps. By refusing blood it has forced the medical community to step up and come up with better techniques and methods of operations and so on. I know it is controversial but it is spelled out so clear to abstain from blood. Thank you for your fair and unbiased look at the lives of Jehovah's Witnesses.  4/25/07
 Claude Kenneson
 Tallahassee, Florida
 Do any of you realize that the Watchtower Society claims that the early Christians who were martyred by the Roman government were really "nominal Christians," who had wandered away from the truth? They died in vain. And this from a people who make so much over their own persecution by the Nazis!  4/25/07
 Australia
 In regard to the "Knocking" documentary. you claim the witnesses set a precedent for asserting their right to freedom of speech etc. What you didnt present in your documentary is the fact that once baptised and in the "truth" you actually give up the right to your free will to question any of the Jehovah Witness doctrines. In regard to child abuse, it is a well documented fact that victims and their families who have gone to the police have been persecuted by their congregation and the watchtower society. You are told to keep it quiet and have it dealt with internally. The watchtower society has shelled out millions in out of court settlements as they avoid negative publicity.religious freedom is just that....true religious freedom allows the individual to practice freedom of will without fear of retribution by people who claim that they are gods chosen people.  4/25/07
 Albert S.
 Wethersfield, CT
 The "Independent Lens" series is one of my favorite things on television, consistently bringing interesting programs and featuring compelling stories. I'm not a Jehovahs Witness myself, but its hard to miss the impact they've had on preconceived notions about Nazi camp techniques and Supreme Court law. What more do I need to know?
 Based on this impressive website, there is a LOT more to this religion! My family already plans to watch "Knocking" on PBS, and I anticipate buying the DVD sometime after than. I'm guessing I'll enjoy lending in out to my less tolerant acquaintances! Thanks for a really detailed website on this film!  4/25/07
 Cat
 NH
 I was a Jehovahs' Witness for 20 years. If the Jehovah's Witnesses are so proud of fighting for freedom of speech, why are their members forbidden from having "independent thought" or questioning anything that the Watchtower Society says? There is no freedom of speech or thought within the JWs. If you say the wrong thing, someone will report you to the elders, and if you don't stop questioning or saying things that make them uncomfortable, they will disfellowship you. The Watchtower Society controls everything the members do, say, and think. They use fear to keep everyone under their control. I wish you had shown all sides of the JWs in your documentary.  4/25/07
 Greg Grew
 Woodbury, CT
 I have seen the documentary and appreciated its balanced point of view. I look forward to the PBS broadcast. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. The misconceptions and predjudicial views of outsiders go with the territory and are to be expected. It has no effect on my own decisions and beliefs. It is refreshing, however, to see a media source present both sides and also show the public that we not a fanatical group or cult.  4/25/07
 Vancouver, WA
 IN REPLY TO YOUR QUESTION:
 Do you have family members whose beliefs you disagree with, or vice versa? YES, many.
 Do you think there is a way that such families can peacefully co-exist, despite their disagreements?YES - RESPECT AND LOVE.
 The Bible tells us how to show respect and love to our family who are unbelievers.(1 Peter 3:1-2) In our family, that has resulted in some enbracing our faith and others not. We never agrue, but always come from a place of love and thoughtfulness.Even Jesus Christ had persons in his own family that did not accept him. He told his followers that he came put a sword - "wife against mother-in-law." He further said that one's enemies would be in their own households. (Matthew 10:32-37) So we should not be surprised when family members disagree with our beliefs.
 Further, the scriptures speak of those who will speak abusively when one discontinues immoral ways. (1 Peter 4:4) This absolutely happened to us and we took great comfort from the scriptures and the experience strengthened our faith and resolve.Lastly, we pray for our family and friends to understand and join us serving Jehovah God and benefiting from his instruction. Thankfully, many of those prayers have been answered.  4/25/07
 francisco torres
 toa alta, puerto rico
 a truly fine film about a group that has been misunderstood for many years.ihope many fairminded people will see thru this excelent docu who really are jehovahs witnesses.it should win many awards,sadly here in puerto rico i do not believe that the two pbs affiliated stations will not transmit this excellent docu.they do not transmit independent lens.  4/25/07
 MS
 L H, PA
 There are almost 7 Million Jehovah's Witnesses in over 230 lands. It is important to know that this number reflects ACTIVE PUBLISHERS, those individuals who are active in the ministry work. Young ones that are not baptized and therefore not submitting time in the ministry AND inactive members (not in the ministry) are NOT counted in this 7 Million number. It is important to note that at the anniversary of the death of Jesus, over 16 MILLION worldwide attended this observance. This is very telling of the number of those who are..inactive but baptized, young ones prior to baptism and persons studying the Bible with Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Worldwide Numbers:
 *Nearly 7 Million Actively Preaching
 *Over 16 Million Attending Anniversary of Jesus Sacrificial Death
 *More than 1 Billion 300 Hundred Million Hours Jehovah's Witnesses spent in the Worldwide
 Preaching Work for Service Year of 2006.
 *Women (Sisters) are, as Prophesied, Having A Very Large Share in the Preaching of the Good News. "Jehovah him self gives the saying; The women telling the good news are a large army." Psalms 68:11 The original Hebrew Language of Psalm 68:11 tanslates into WOMEN which is the SAME HEBREW LANGUAGE in Exodus 15:20. (See King James Bible for Exodus 15:20.)
 Other scriptures below found in the King James Bible where the Original Language translates into WOMEN.
 HEBREW-1 Samuel 18:6
 GREEK-Acts 8:12
 If you translate the Original Language to "women" for scriptures in one part of the Bible, you have to translate this Original Language into "women" in the other scriptures of the Bible. Psalms 68:11 in the Origianl Hebrew Language is NOT in the past tense.
 If necessary consult original manuscripts.  4/25/07
 Sonia V. Vizcaino
 New York, NY
 I am amazed and pleased with the well researched information that you have presented on this website. As one of Jehovah's Witneses, I am very happy to see that there are those who are interested in portraying us as we are, normal, law abiding citizens who just want to live peacefully while we share our message with our neighbors. I have not had an opportunity to see the documentary yet, but have heard very positive remarks, and am making plans to veiw it soon.  4/25/07
 Brenda
 Lawton Oklahoma
 Thank you to PBS for supporting and airing this and other films that show an objective view of people, organizations and the world in general. As one of Jehovah's Witnesses I cringed at some of the comments made in the film but applaud the fact that it showed the reality of what people both in and out of this organization think.I have many family members who are not Jehovah's Witnesses and I love them all. Our interactions with each other are just as good or even better than before I joined JWs. We disagree on many things but we always have.
 Additionally I would like to address one of the comments made by another that had nothing to do with the film. They stated "The practice of allowing pedophiles to continue to associate with children is reprehensible." JWs expel unrepentant wrong doers of all kinds instead of allowing hypocrisy. Accused pedophiles even if repentant are not allowed to have any privileges of service within the organization. As a victim of abuse myself I appreciate the stand this organization has taken to protect the people within it.  4/25/07
 BBraxton
 Detroit MI
 I look forward to seeing it,I read the comments here and some centered on a personal experience of ex-witnesses and how they felt about being disfellowship or shunned by family, important thing to remember immorality offends GOD and when we diliberately disobey him we expell ourselves from fellowship with others our actions indicate that We no longer want God or our family as friends, The Christ died for our Sins, because he know's were not perfect however many are just looking for an excuse to do what pleases them and not God so please stop blaming JW's or the Watchtower Society you had the freedom to chose your course that's why you left no one is forced to stay a JW. Those who want to do what's right will, those who don't will do what they want. we want to do the crime without the consequences how sad I will pray that their hearts will be receptive to Gods Word as the Authority Thank You  4/25/07
 Thank you for this heartwarming video about kind-hearted, sincere folks who simply seek to do what they feel is right and to help others. At age 19 I chose to become a witness, and now 37 years later I lead a fulfilled, purpose-drive life where I help others. Though our 'knocking' is not welcome by all, we attempt to be respectful... and, to find those who are in need of help. And they ARE out there, isolated, in pain, in need, hungry.
 We offer spiritual, Bible-based conversations about God and his beloved Son Jesus, about Christ's kingdom, about why God permits these terrible world conditions. We use whatever Bible they prefer. If they choose to continue further, we welcome them; if they discontinue discussions, we regret the loss of our time together, but move on to find others who welcome us. To offer a different perspective than some of the comments here: I was raised in a Protestant home with 'righteous' parents who were pillars of the church and community, yet I secretly suffered years of abuse (sexual, physical, emotional) at their hands. But, I don't go to that church's website and rant nor do I target that church in other ways. I recognize the failures of them as individuals, and I simply go 'knocking' to talk in positive ways about God's goodness and a hope for a time of earthwide peace and safety under Jesus Christ's kingship.  4/25/07
 Greg Grew
 Woodbury, CT
 I have seen the documentary and appreciated its balanced point of view. I look forward to the PBS broadcast. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. The misconceptions and predjudicial views of outsiders go with the territory and are to be expected. It has no effect on my own decisions and beliefs. It is refreshing, however, to see a media source present both sides and also show the public that we not a fanatical group or cult.  4/25/07
 M S
 LH, PA
 Excellent information from the BBC link on the IndependentLens presents Knocking page. Link below.
 http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/witnesses/  4/25/07
 Hermogenes
 Miami
 RE: "In 1995, the Witnesses officially ended their belief that tied the coming of Armageddon to the lifespan of anyone alive today. Now, many young Witnesses attend college."
 I‚ve yet to see this film, but i strongly feel that the quote above has been misinterpreted. The Jehovah Witnesses have always & will continue to believe that no one knows the day or the hour that Jehovah God will unleash Armageddon upon the Earth.Biblical Calculation: At least one Holocaust survivor must remain alive in order to witness the destruction of the old system. How old could the youngest survivor of that terror storm be in 2007 ( ? )

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_e.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/5/07
 J. Blue
 Chico, CA
 I was brought up as one of Jehovah's Witness, in the south. I have seen a lot of things that were done by people in a lot of different congreations of our faith disturbing. I remember asking my mother once what is the difference between Jehovah�s Witness and people of other faiths, her answer was the greatest gift that she ever gave me. She said, �Don�t look at the people but at the message. For the message will always be beneficial and reliable but imperfect people no matter what position they hold will not.� So if you are looking for perfect people you won�t find them in any Kingdom Hall and if you did you would feel out of place because you wouldn�t fit in. Oh by the way I too left the organization once, I disassociated myself because I didn�t remember those inspiring words that were given to me as a child of 8. Oh how nice it.  5/5/07
 Chuck
 Colorado
 I would like to address the Dr from the UK. While I do not advocate blood transfusions it should be an individuals decision to make their own health decisions and not that of a religious organization imposing a mandate. I think it is quite remiss of you to say that only a small number have lost their lives from refusing one. What about those who died refusing an organ transplant when that was at one time considered a sin in Gods eyes? Isn�t an organization that says any particular action is a sin against God, then later changes that rule, blood guilty if even one person has lost their life? Also, you said that if a person committed suicide they had a more complex psychiatric issue. If a person truly has mental problems, then doesn�t it seem rather harsh to disfellowship them? Wouldn�t extra care be needed in handling a disturbed person? Please search your heart for some compassion. Where is the love shown to the hurting individual? I would also suggest that you study the psychological profile of a cult. There is plenty on the subject.  5/5/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow
 Several said JWs are not Christians. My Webster's defines Christian as "A person accepting or professing the teachings of Christ." JWs accept ALL Christ's teachings and try hard to live by them. The Bible makes no mention of Christ's followers having to believe in the Trinity to be a Christian. Such doctrine was never believed or taught by Jesus or any early follower. In fact, the doctrine didn't exist until later councils. The council of Nicaea in 325 A.D. assirted Christ wasthe same substance as God, laying the foundation for later Trinitarian theology, but didn't establish the Trinity, as there was no mention of a 3rd Person, holy spirit, a foreign idea at that time. The council at Constantinople in 381 A.D. clarified the doctrine. Whoever came up with a Christian being one who accepts the Trinity eliminates ALL early Christians, including Jesus' initial disciples from being Christians! Jesus does tell us how to recognize his disciples at John 13:34,35: "I am giving you a new commandment that you lo ve one another, just as I have loved you... By this all will know that you are my disciples, if you have love among yourselves." Christendom's many religious adherants through the centuries have been notorious for killing one another in war. How can they "love one another" and kill them too? That doesn't compute no matter what justifications are presented. JWs are CHRISTIANS who refuse war in any capacity or kill neither brother nor stranger in warfare. What army would Jesus & his disciples fignt and kill in? History is clear on that!  5/5/07
 Gerry
 Wisconsin
 I am not a JW but my wife is, so I have studied this religion from different perspectives. I quickly came to the conclusion that the Watchtower (JW) is a cult that uses fear for mind control: For example, their magazines repeatedly ask to NOT use independent thinking, do NOT question the doctrines and do not verify facts or WT's past history. I have finally brought my wife to her senses and she is being treated for post-cult trauma. She is still officially a member but now she now can chose who to marry (me, a worldly unbeliever and feed-for-the-birds), can chose where to live, what to wear, where to go, what to read, what to watch, AND WHAT TO THINK. By the way, her family treat her now as if dead or "Satanized" because she has chosen to have a direct spirituality with God, not through a Brooklyn office....at the request of their elders. How is that "loving"?
 The Knocking documentary fails misserably at mentioning these critical points: *Religious motivation to suicide (how many per year?? *Discouragement of independent thinking. *Disfunctional family & social dynamics. *Watchtower's failure to aknowledge the police authority and thus, not reporting crimes such as child sexual abuse and wife beating. 'New Light' is a cult tool to handle its members. Truth has no expiry date. And God can not be frechized.  5/5/07
 Lynn
 CA
 Jehovah�s organization has warned us that those who speak against the organization are to be avoided. They are among the wicked that will be destroyed by Jehovah. In the Dec. 1, 2005 Watchtower on page 6, the organization has told us that, "God must eliminate such "pests" � the incorrigibly wicked � for the sake of the righteous." They help us as true Christians to understand that "a concerned homeowner should safeguard the health and well-being of his family by exterminating the pests." Anyone who stands against Jehovah�s true people is a wicked person and God himself will deal with them. Why should we feel sorry for them?  5/4/07
 Ruth
 Downers Grove, IL
 Disfellowshipped ones are not counted among the inactive.
 However, all disfellowshipped are welcome to attend meetings, the Memorial of Jesus Christs Sacraficial Death, Assemblies and Conventions.
 All meetings, assemblies and conventions are open to the public.  5/4/07
 There are several people who have a lot of anger directed toward JWs. I would like to try and shed some light on this. When a person is taught and ultimately they believe whole heartedly that a certain religious group is 100% true and that this group would never lie or mislead them in anyway, but they find out otherwise, they feel very betrayed. The trusted source has let them down. It�s similar to believing in a mate only to find out they have been cheating on you for years. This is what happens when you decide to trust and follow a manmade organization. I would like to say that every manmade group will end up failing and that is why everyone needs to put their faith in Jesus. He is the one that God sent to save mankind and he is the only real �truth�. Truth is not a religion, it is Jesus. He said, �I am the way, THE TRUTH, and the life. NO ONE comes to the Father, but by ME.� He is the object of faith and he is the one we are to follow. Not a religion. This is the will of the Father (Jehovah).
 He says to become followers and imitators of his son. So if you are looking for a religion to be the truth, you are looking in the wrong place.  5/4/07
 A. Lee Lucas
 Minneapolis, MN
 I used to attend Jehovah's Witness meetings until 2002. I stopped because I saw how my elders in my community pretty much reverted to ad hominem attacks on a local woman that sued the JW's for being lax in their prevention of her molestation instead of showing righteous indignation against the person that molested her. They said she was disgracing the name of Jehovah in this lawsuit.
 My eyes were opened at that moment and I saw how the religion doesn't really look out for their members, it just looks out for themselves and their interests.
 I just wish this documentary would be a bit more critical of the other side of JW's and how they try to stop distending opinions in their religion.
 Take care.  5/4/07
 Tyrone Georgia
 Considering that the film was made by individuals who are not Jehovah's Witnesses, the research was thourough and articulated in detail by various individuals who also were not Jehovah's Witnesses. The point of this film was not to debate the validity of the religion as some of the comments from disgruntled opposers seem to indicate. But rather it was simply to bring to public awareness the contributions Jehovah's Witnesses have made to Civil liberties, which allows these opposers the right to voice their angry opinions. In addition, the film shows the medical advances in blood trasfusions that came about primarily because of the millions of Witnesses who refused Blood transfusions and sought alternatives from which many of their opposers will benefit. Finally the film shows how one relgious group out of many, refused to allow the pressures of nationalism to change their views on how they were to serve God. These were the points brought out in the film and it was not addressing all the other disjointed rhetoric that some of the comments seemed to state. Yes, most Jehovah's Witnesses get along very well with their non Jehovah's Witnesses family members. Different view points among family members encompass more than just religion. We must also keep in mind that the ex- Witness famiy members, bear just as much responsibilty for a splintered family as those family members who stay true to their faith. Perhaps one day, these ex Witness family members can get someone to make a film on the 'flip floppers' of the world mindset.  5/4/07
 Royal Palm Beach, Florida
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and enjoyed the video which I own very much. I am looking forward to watching it on PBS when it aires in my city. I just want to say that those people that wrote in and are ex Witnesses or have family that are Witnesses and clain that they have no relationship with their families may have something to do with their own attitude towards them. Perhaps those that were once Witnesses have closed their door to their oun relationship with their family out of guilt feelings for leaving the organization As a Witness, I have many family members that do not practice my religion including my youngest son and I can assure everone that I make an extra effort to have a good and loving relationship with him and other family members. We do things together and are in constant communication. The Bible teaches us to love our neighbor as ourselves and that includes our family regardless of the religin that they practice. The only reason why we would not have a relationship with a particular family member would be if they practuced things that God hates and could hurt us or our family with their practices. This is the view point of most witnesses. I say most because like in every organization there are those that do not always do things correctly, but as a whole, we do maintain a good and loving relationship with family.  5/3/07
 martha j
 brooklyn, ny
 I REALLY ENJOYED and APPRECIATED the program having bought several copies to give to friends, etc. I appreciate the non-biased, true approach to our faith. I have read many of the comments regarding this DVD - those favorable and those not. As one of Jehovah's Witnesses, all I can say is if anyone TRULY has the mind and the humility to see and conform to what Jehovah's LOVING standards are and what the BIBLE says, they will understand that our faith puts those priorities FIRST - whether or not anyone else agrees with it or not. Those negative comments were probably made by disgruntled persons who probably were not seeking Jehovah's agenda but their own. HUMILITY AND FAITH ARE NOT A RESULT OF MIND-CONTROL!!! We all need to make adjustments - and doing things Jehovah's way is the most loving beneficial way to live. I had been disfellowshipped also and am now re-instated. All I can say is that whenever someone has a SCRIPTURAL and spiritual "time-out" they appreciate and value their relationship with Jehovah all the more and Jehovah and ALL his children DO WELCOME AND ENCOURAGE THOSE RETURNING TO THE FOLD. Our faith is one of LOVE and our relationship with Jehovah God should be our main focus for a happy, LONG life.  5/3/07
 Gayle Rice
 Lake City, SC
 Have not yet seen the documentary but looking forward to it. I have been a Witness for forty eight years in various congregations in four different states and cannot imagine where people who were purportedly once Witnesses come up with their stories. As someone else mentioned, I actually had to laugh at some of them. No one forced me to be a Witness and no one forces me to remain one. I serve Jehovah of my own free will though you detractors say I have none. News to me.  5/3/07
 HEATHER
 MISHAWAKA INDIANA
 I APPRECIATE THE EFFERT PUT FORTH IN EDUCATING ONE IN THE PUBIC ABOUT JEHOVAH WITNESSESS. MANY PEOPLE HAVE A MISCONCEPTION ABOUT OUR RELIGION BECAUSE OF THOSE WHO SPREAD LIES ABOUT OUR BELIEFS. IT IS TRUE THAT PEOPLE WHO DECIDE TO BECOME ONE OF JEHOVAH WITNESSES ARE ASK THE BASIC KNOWLEDGE AND IF THEY DO THEN THEY CAN GET BAPTIZED. THOSE WHO DON'T APPRECIATE THE COMMANDMENTS IN THE BIBLE USUALLY WILL GET INVOLVE IN WAYS THAT ARE CONTRARY TO GOD REQUIREMENTS AND AFTER NOT ACCEPTING COUNSEL THEY ARE DISFELLOWSHIPPED BUT, CAN RETURN WITH A REPENTIVE ATTITUDE. OTHERS WANT TO BE HYPOCRITICAL AND STILL BE ACCEPTED AND THAT IS NOT ACCECPTIABLE. THEY REFUSE TO LIVE ACORDINGLY TO BIBLE STANDARDS AND DO NOT WANT TO BE REINSTATED. THEREFORE THEY SPEAK AGAINST OUR RELIGION. WE HAVE A VERY FULL AND HAPPY LIFE WITH THOUGHTS OF RESPECT FOR EVERYONE BECAUSE OF OUR LOVE FOR JEHOVAH AND THE SACRIFICE OF HIS SON JESUS CHRIST. WE ARE ALWAYS FREE TO MAKE DECISIONS BUT, LIKE ALL THINGS IN LIFE THERE ARE CONSEQUENCES RATHER IT BE GOOD OR BAD. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE TIME YOU PUT INTO THIS PROGRAM TO TEACH OTHERS ABOUT JEHOVAHS ORGANIZATION.  5/3/07
 S.W.
 MS
 Whether biased for or against JWs. what can be said about them is that they keep their word.
 Although they catch flack for "shuning" as its called they should be commended for standing for what they teach. By becoming one you don�t loose any freedom. They only expect you to do for God what you say you will.
 You can disagree with the Pope, use condoms and still be catholic. You can have sex out of marriage and still be Methodist. You can be openly gay and still be Baptist. You can do anything you want and profess any religion that is Christian. I�m not saying that any of the above actions are wrong, those churches make that claim; what I�m saying is that they tolerate the things they say are wrong. Jehovah�s Witnesses don�t!! Every religion has good adherents and bad ones EXCEPT JWs. JWs say Blood transfusions are wrong and they don�t tolerate it. JWs say sex out of marriage is wrong and they don�t tolerate it. If you do those things they will put you out. The people they put out know this from the outset because it takes months to years of STUDY to qualify to be one. So if you gonna get a transfusion or have a few babies without marriage don�t join! Whether you like them or not they ARE CERTIANLY NOT hypocrites. Reserve that name for any religion that tolerates the things it defines as wrong. Who does the shoe fit�..?  5/3/07
 Vanessa
 Auburn, WA
 I am 18 years old and as a teenager, being a Jehova's Witness was the best thing that i could have done, and will ever do in my life. I read a comment stating that we only believe in Jehova and not Jesus...wow do they have there facts wrong! We DO believe in Jesus! He is our savior but who created him? Yes, Jehova did, and thats why he is the only one and only who can recive all the honor! I love Jehova with all my heart and an strongly believe that he will bring justice the this cruel world and to all who dont believe, ...and to all who dont believe, all i can say that they will be just like the people who choose not to listen to Noah in his time, they choose not to listen to the message that jehova had sent him. And they vanished in the great flood! Just like cruel people will too in the NEAR future!  5/3/07
 Cathy Laszewski
 As for the woman who said that it is not true that JW's shun family members...I would like to share with her my experience. We were JW's for over 40 years and came to the point where we found them to be dogmatic, hypocritical and unloving. Though neither myself or my husband are disfellowshipped or disassociated...we ARE shunned publicly by JW's we have known for all those decades. My own mother and sister have not spoken to me for over 5 years...merely because we chose to leave. I would dearly love to see this filmmaker do a documentary on the THOUSANDS of families who have been ripped apart by JW doctrine. There is nothing worse than sugar coating a religion that is, in my opinion, a terrorist organization. I say this because JW's believe they are the only ones who will survive the mass destruction at Armageddon. Kind of like the holocaust done in "Jehovah's" name. They personally won't kill off millions of people but they'll happily let their god do it for them.  5/3/07
 E. Louise
 Ozone Park, New York
 Now I realize what a great and very necessary station PBS is. IndependentLens is indispensable.
 Thank you for airing the unbiased documentary KNOCKING,it is a masterpiece of research and a demonstration of the humanness of Jehovah's witnesses.
 Subjects of all forms of human government should know that what makes a good citizen is not pledging allegiance or singing the national anthem (hardcore criminals do that too), but rather, not cheating on your taxes (the way some patriots do), treating your neighbor the way you in fact want to be treated (including meaningful although not always visible) disaster relief efforts, good work habits (the paper clips and rubber bands are the property of employers not employees so too the excessive use of cyberspace and land lines), etc.
 Before mobbing them, the Jews in Borough Park should remember who spoke up when no one else did during, Hitler's Germany.
 BRAVO PBS for tellin' it like it is!  5/3/07
 Brenda Lee
 Golden, CO
 Mr. Engardio stated: "..Jehovah's Witnesses don't begrudge those who hold differing worldviews. They acknowledge that a right is not a right unless it belongs to everyone."
 If that's true, then why do JWs SHUN family members who simply want to pursue their own spiritual path? Isn't that "begruding those who hold differing worldviews?" Shouldn't former former JWs be afforded the same rights as current JWs? And since JWs clearly aren't affording others these rights, then one must inquire: why are they deceiving the general population? Isn't deception the trademark of a cult?
 My mother, brother, sister, four nephews and niece haven't spoken to me in 25 years and yet I was never excommunicated (disfellowshipped) for any sin. I am one of MILLIONS of people who are being shunned for NO BIBLICAL REASON.
 Shunning means no communication at all, not even when a relative dies; no invitations to family events or weddings; no cards or phone calls; no acknowledgment whatsoever. Being rejected by an organiz
 ation that professes to be "family oriented" has been both painful and satirical for cult survivors. Sometimes we don't know whether to laugh or cry.
 Does this film really tell THE whole TRUTH about "The Truth"? Isn't it a miscarriage of journalism to present the Watchtower organization as benign to the general public when it has been responsible for family genocide on a global scale?  5/1/07
 If the Watchtower organization cooperated with the production, I imagine the film makes no mention of their vast history of false prophecies. I also imagine there is no mention of grandparents silently shunning teenaged grandchildren for deciding not to be Jehovah's Witnesses. The Myths and Reality page says JW's are not a cult, but the film's makers need to do more research. A mind control cult uses deceptive recruiting techniques and coercive retainment practices. WT doesn't inform potential recruits about disfellowshipping and makes current members fear God's disapproval if they try to leave the organization. Cult, cult, cult.  5/1/07
 Bette Witt
 Oakwood, PA
 Having seen the documentary twice - I can say with certainty that Jehovah's Witnesses and their parent organization, The Watchtower Bible & Tract Society, have NEVER intended to support the freedom of religion and press of general populations. Any court cases that might have benefited others, was FIRST intended to support and benefit their own organizaion. They have no interest in providing legal help or assistance to any group outside their own organization, unless it primarily benefits them.
 Despite the information presented in "Knocking", they are not a Christian religion. They are a pseudo Jewish religion - and do not follow the tenets of Christ.  5/1/07
 Janice
 Colorado, Spring
 Im looking foward to this film I always known that they good people and it looks likes they are expected much from them but they really feel that way, also i dont think their are hiding anything from anyone for those that talk dirt about them, you are worst then dirt.  5/1/07
 Janice
 EVERYTHING that Jehovah's Wittnesses believe is based 100% completely on the Bible. My Daughter is a Jehovahs Wittness and she has taught me so much. Those who view them as a ridiculous cult should take a better and deeper look at their Bible's they've been storing without opening for years. Once you truly grasp the understanding of the Bible, then we'll see what you have to say. Isaiah 43:10; Matthew 24:14; Psalm 83:18; John 15:9,10. Ask any Wittness to give you the book What The Bible Really Teaches, no cost. READ THESE AND TRUST ME, YOU WILL SEE.  5/1/07
 Deborah Marsh
 Antelope, California
 My husband and I are "born and raised" JW's. Our grown children and 4 grandsons are not. Yes, the holiday seasons are difficult. We decided to make it clear that we do not celebrate the holiday and would not participate but, out of respect and love, we give the kids gifts either shortly before or after the holiday. We are so proud of the families in the documentary. Their struggle to maintain their Bible-based decision not to accept blood was living proof that JWs are not mindless robots. We educate ourselves and make our PERSONAL decision after prayerful consideration.
 In contrast to the humble and respectful answers to questions posed to them by the Elders, I hope that thinking people will see through the venom of some of the comments posted here. I'm thankful Jesus didn't believe salvation to be a personal matter but began an educational (evangelizing) work and sent out his disciples to preach the good news in all the inhabited earth - in two's. (Luke 4:43-44; 9:1-6 & 10:1)Thank you for this well-done and very professional documentary. We wonder what your next project will be.  5/1/07
 Paul
 Long Beach
 I am looking forward to enjoy the film and the DVD. Many people strongly disagree with JW's, but most of them don't realize that many of the freedoms they enjoy are thanks to the work witnesses are doing. On the other hand, people who claim that they were witnesses, but that have been disfellowshipped are twisting the reality of what being a witness is. Simply put: if you are part of an organization (any kind of organization) you are subject to the guidelines of such, or else you lose whatever privileges you might enjoy for being part of it. I.E: If you are an U.S. citizen, you HAVE to obey the law, if you do not, there will be a punishment, since you are "damaging" the structure of the society. Good citizens don't complain that their freedoms are limited, but enjoy the privileges given to them for what they do. Same in the Jehovah's witnesses organization, if you are willing to be part of it, you know that you'll be following Bible's guidelines, and by doing so, your freedom (of thinking and speech included) is not limited, and you are sure there is not such a ridiculous "mind control" scheme behind the organization. A non-biased portrayal of Witnesses is never going to be very popular, but we can live with it, same as we peacefully coexist with our neighbors and relatives.  5/1/07
 Tara McKenney
 Billerica, MA
 I am a former Jehovah's Witness who disassociated myself from the organization. I urge everyone who watches this documentary and comes away with a favorable opinion of Jehovah's Witnesses to please research this dangerous, mind controlling cult. I wish I had done so before I became one. Most Jehovah's Witnesses are truly nice, well intentioned people, but they are run by a group of old men in Brooklyn, NY who rule the organization through fear and guilt(the Watchtower Society). They call themselves "the only true Christian religion...the Truth", but in reality they deny the importance of Jesus. Some of the posters here have said that JWs do not shun non-believing family members, but that is untrue. Not everyone is disfellowshipped for immorality, either, as someone implied in an earlier post. Some have been disfellowshipped for merely questioning some of the Watchtower Society's teachings when they clearly are against what the Bible teaches. Their policies against pedophiles are inadequate. The accuser is not even begun to be believed unless there are two witnesses to the crime. They also condone spousal abuse, telling their members not to go to the police in order not to bring reproach upon Jehovah's name. They discourage higher education telling their members the time is better spent preaching the word of God. If they come knocking on your door, don't answer it.  5/1/07
 lily
 san diego, ca.
 I'm one of Jehovah's witnesses. I thoroughly researched other religous beliefs before making my EDUCATED decision. I do extensive volunteer work with various children and womens charities (causes close to my heart). I am a PTA member, last year acting as the director of special programs. My children have more than most will ever get in lifetime, including an amazing hope for the furture. As for being uneduacated,there is only one person in my family that does not have a degree (though she runs her own successful company). My children attend a private school where they recieve a wonderful education. Combining that with the Bible knowledge they receive weekly at the meetings,makes them happy well-rounded children. The orginazation is full of intelligent people, all who volunteer their time and money!
 It's really disturbing how many random statements have been presented as facts! So many have complained about being told what to believe, not question what they are taught, and how once becoming a JW you loose the freedom to think for yourself or to research other religions. I feel that an individual who makes the huge commitment of embracing a religion to the point of getting baptized without researching what it was all about, failed to exercise their freedom to think for themselves long before they decided to become JW's.
 I studied with JW's out of the King James version of the Bible that was originally my grandmothers (a devout Catholic). Out of that Bible, and not the NWT, I first learned God's name. Jehovah. I was Disfellowshiped for a while also. I know how devastating it can be, and how unfair it feels at the time. It was one of the hardest times of my life, but it made me realize how special Jehovah's orginazation is. My appreciation has never been stronger. My heart goes out to all those who have been through similar situations. I hope you find peace and comfort, wherever it may be...  5/1/07
 D.O
 United Kingdom
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, albeit a very enlightened one. I'm a Medical doctor living and working in the UK. I read many of the comments with a tinge of amusement, because many of the commentators are really uninformed, and their opinions are not evidenced based. I also suspect a bit of bitterness in the comments, especially from those who have been "disfellowshipped". There is no single religion on earth that is fully understood, and I believe everyone has a right to believe in what gives them a sense of purpose and direction in life. A balanced view should be adopted by the critics; while a small number of Witnesses have lost their lives from refusing transfusions, several thousand lives have also been saved from refusing blood. The individuals who supposedly commited suicide after being disfellowshiped (as mentioned by one writer), most likely had deeper, more complex psychosocial issues they were grappling with; The DSM-IV lists suicide/attempted suicide as a psychiatric disorder irrespective of the individuals' religious affiliation. Writers should refrain from making sweeping generalisations. Many of them will never understand Jehovah's witnesses. But that is understandable. Many of us will never understand Muslims, Buddhists, and Grail followers either, but we should endevour to respect one another's beliefs.  5/1/07
 I have not seen the film yet but look forward to seeing soon. Not only do I appreciate what appears to be a unbiased look at JWs, but I find this topic of religious freedom and free speech very interesting. Suggested reading "Judging Jehovah's Witnesses: Religious Persecution and the Dawn of the Rights Revolution" by Shawn Francis Peters. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and it's important to note that we would publish Jehovah's name and his righteous Kingdom even if we were not given the "right" by secular authorities. It is our privilege and a command given us by the king of that kingdom,Jesus Christ. But we are a peaceful & law-abiding people and wish to work within the framework of laws of the land. Hence the rigorous work of ensuring religious freedoms continue so that we may reach those searching for truth, which is why we do what we do-knock. Love of God and love of neighbor.  5/1/07
 Richard
 New York
 I look forward to the local broadcast of Knocking. I spent the first 12 years of my adult life knocking on doors with Jehovah's Witnesses, getting out of the cult for good in 1990. My life has been ever so much more genuinely happy since then. Having recently read Steve Hassan's book "Combatting Cult Mind Control", I was able to appreciate that the identifying marks of a cult fit Jehovah's Witnesses to a "T"! My three oldest children are all JWs, and have been shunning me for years; I'm not even allowed to see my granddaughter. It is a heartless 'religion'. I hope a follow-up show might emphasize the dark side of the cult, with a special focus on silentlambs.org.  5/1/07
 Debbie
 Western Australia
 I saw the preview and it looks to be a promising film. There are a lot of misconceptions about the Witnesses and I'm glad that there will be a film to clear a lot of up. Some here seem to think that their "freedom" has been taken away. Jehovah said that he only wants "willing" people to follow Him. If you're not willing then there is something wrong with your point of view. I don't agree with the people who say the Witnesses are a cult. Cults don't let you see your family or friends. I go to see my parents, who are not Witnesses, every week. The Apostle Paul said that if you don't take care of your family first, then you are a person without faith. He didn't say that they had to be of the same faith. I look forward to seeing the film on May 22nd at 10 p.m. Thanks for all that you've done on it!

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_f.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/5/07
 J. Blue
 Chico, CA
 I was brought up as one of Jehovah's Witness, in the south. I have seen a lot of things that were done by people in a lot of different congreations of our faith disturbing. I remember asking my mother once what is the difference between Jehovah�s Witness and people of other faiths, her answer was the greatest gift that she ever gave me. She said, �Don�t look at the people but at the message. For the message will always be beneficial and reliable but imperfect people no matter what position they hold will not.� So if you are looking for perfect people you won�t find them in any Kingdom Hall and if you did you would feel out of place because you wouldn�t fit in. Oh by the way I too left the organization once, I disassociated myself because I didn�t remember those inspiring words that were given to me as a child of 8. Oh how nice it.  5/5/07
 Chuck
 Colorado
 I would like to address the Dr from the UK. While I do not advocate blood transfusions it should be an individuals decision to make their own health decisions and not that of a religious organization imposing a mandate. I think it is quite remiss of you to say that only a small number have lost their lives from refusing one. What about those who died refusing an organ transplant when that was at one time considered a sin in Gods eyes? Isn�t an organization that says any particular action is a sin against God, then later changes that rule, blood guilty if even one person has lost their life? Also, you said that if a person committed suicide they had a more complex psychiatric issue. If a person truly has mental problems, then doesn�t it seem rather harsh to disfellowship them? Wouldn�t extra care be needed in handling a disturbed person? Please search your heart for some compassion. Where is the love shown to the hurting individual? I would also suggest that you study the psychological profile of a cult. There is plenty on the subject.  5/5/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow
 Several said JWs are not Christians. My Webster's defines Christian as "A person accepting or professing the teachings of Christ." JWs accept ALL Christ's teachings and try hard to live by them. The Bible makes no mention of Christ's followers having to believe in the Trinity to be a Christian. Such doctrine was never believed or taught by Jesus or any early follower. In fact, the doctrine didn't exist until later councils. The council of Nicaea in 325 A.D. assirted Christ wasthe same substance as God, laying the foundation for later Trinitarian theology, but didn't establish the Trinity, as there was no mention of a 3rd Person, holy spirit, a foreign idea at that time. The council at Constantinople in 381 A.D. clarified the doctrine. Whoever came up with a Christian being one who accepts the Trinity eliminates ALL early Christians, including Jesus' initial disciples from being Christians! Jesus does tell us how to recognize his disciples at John 13:34,35: "I am giving you a new commandment that you lo ve one another, just as I have loved you... By this all will know that you are my disciples, if you have love among yourselves." Christendom's many religious adherants through the centuries have been notorious for killing one another in war. How can they "love one another" and kill them too? That doesn't compute no matter what justifications are presented. JWs are CHRISTIANS who refuse war in any capacity or kill neither brother nor stranger in warfare. What army would Jesus & his disciples fignt and kill in? History is clear on that!  5/5/07
 Gerry
 Wisconsin
 I am not a JW but my wife is, so I have studied this religion from different perspectives. I quickly came to the conclusion that the Watchtower (JW) is a cult that uses fear for mind control: For example, their magazines repeatedly ask to NOT use independent thinking, do NOT question the doctrines and do not verify facts or WT's past history. I have finally brought my wife to her senses and she is being treated for post-cult trauma. She is still officially a member but now she now can chose who to marry (me, a worldly unbeliever and feed-for-the-birds), can chose where to live, what to wear, where to go, what to read, what to watch, AND WHAT TO THINK. By the way, her family treat her now as if dead or "Satanized" because she has chosen to have a direct spirituality with God, not through a Brooklyn office....at the request of their elders. How is that "loving"?
 The Knocking documentary fails misserably at mentioning these critical points: *Religious motivation to suicide (how many per year?? *Discouragement of independent thinking. *Disfunctional family & social dynamics. *Watchtower's failure to aknowledge the police authority and thus, not reporting crimes such as child sexual abuse and wife beating. 'New Light' is a cult tool to handle its members. Truth has no expiry date. And God can not be frechized.  5/5/07
 Lynn
 CA
 Jehovah�s organization has warned us that those who speak against the organization are to be avoided. They are among the wicked that will be destroyed by Jehovah. In the Dec. 1, 2005 Watchtower on page 6, the organization has told us that, "God must eliminate such "pests" � the incorrigibly wicked � for the sake of the righteous." They help us as true Christians to understand that "a concerned homeowner should safeguard the health and well-being of his family by exterminating the pests." Anyone who stands against Jehovah�s true people is a wicked person and God himself will deal with them. Why should we feel sorry for them?  5/4/07
 Ruth
 Downers Grove, IL
 Disfellowshipped ones are not counted among the inactive.
 However, all disfellowshipped are welcome to attend meetings, the Memorial of Jesus Christs Sacraficial Death, Assemblies and Conventions.
 All meetings, assemblies and conventions are open to the public.  5/4/07
 There are several people who have a lot of anger directed toward JWs. I would like to try and shed some light on this. When a person is taught and ultimately they believe whole heartedly that a certain religious group is 100% true and that this group would never lie or mislead them in anyway, but they find out otherwise, they feel very betrayed. The trusted source has let them down. It�s similar to believing in a mate only to find out they have been cheating on you for years. This is what happens when you decide to trust and follow a manmade organization. I would like to say that every manmade group will end up failing and that is why everyone needs to put their faith in Jesus. He is the one that God sent to save mankind and he is the only real �truth�. Truth is not a religion, it is Jesus. He said, �I am the way, THE TRUTH, and the life. NO ONE comes to the Father, but by ME.� He is the object of faith and he is the one we are to follow. Not a religion. This is the will of the Father (Jehovah).
 He says to become followers and imitators of his son. So if you are looking for a religion to be the truth, you are looking in the wrong place.  5/4/07
 A. Lee Lucas
 Minneapolis, MN
 I used to attend Jehovah's Witness meetings until 2002. I stopped because I saw how my elders in my community pretty much reverted to ad hominem attacks on a local woman that sued the JW's for being lax in their prevention of her molestation instead of showing righteous indignation against the person that molested her. They said she was disgracing the name of Jehovah in this lawsuit.
 My eyes were opened at that moment and I saw how the religion doesn't really look out for their members, it just looks out for themselves and their interests.
 I just wish this documentary would be a bit more critical of the other side of JW's and how they try to stop distending opinions in their religion.
 Take care.  5/4/07
 Tyrone Georgia
 Considering that the film was made by individuals who are not Jehovah's Witnesses, the research was thourough and articulated in detail by various individuals who also were not Jehovah's Witnesses. The point of this film was not to debate the validity of the religion as some of the comments from disgruntled opposers seem to indicate. But rather it was simply to bring to public awareness the contributions Jehovah's Witnesses have made to Civil liberties, which allows these opposers the right to voice their angry opinions. In addition, the film shows the medical advances in blood trasfusions that came about primarily because of the millions of Witnesses who refused Blood transfusions and sought alternatives from which many of their opposers will benefit. Finally the film shows how one relgious group out of many, refused to allow the pressures of nationalism to change their views on how they were to serve God. These were the points brought out in the film and it was not addressing all the other disjointed rhetoric that some of the comments seemed to state. Yes, most Jehovah's Witnesses get along very well with their non Jehovah's Witnesses family members. Different view points among family members encompass more than just religion. We must also keep in mind that the ex- Witness famiy members, bear just as much responsibilty for a splintered family as those family members who stay true to their faith. Perhaps one day, these ex Witness family members can get someone to make a film on the 'flip floppers' of the world mindset.  5/4/07
 Royal Palm Beach, Florida
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and enjoyed the video which I own very much. I am looking forward to watching it on PBS when it aires in my city. I just want to say that those people that wrote in and are ex Witnesses or have family that are Witnesses and clain that they have no relationship with their families may have something to do with their own attitude towards them. Perhaps those that were once Witnesses have closed their door to their oun relationship with their family out of guilt feelings for leaving the organization As a Witness, I have many family members that do not practice my religion including my youngest son and I can assure everone that I make an extra effort to have a good and loving relationship with him and other family members. We do things together and are in constant communication. The Bible teaches us to love our neighbor as ourselves and that includes our family regardless of the religin that they practice. The only reason why we would not have a relationship with a particular family member would be if they practuced things that God hates and could hurt us or our family with their practices. This is the view point of most witnesses. I say most because like in every organization there are those that do not always do things correctly, but as a whole, we do maintain a good and loving relationship with family.  5/3/07
 martha j
 brooklyn, ny
 I REALLY ENJOYED and APPRECIATED the program having bought several copies to give to friends, etc. I appreciate the non-biased, true approach to our faith. I have read many of the comments regarding this DVD - those favorable and those not. As one of Jehovah's Witnesses, all I can say is if anyone TRULY has the mind and the humility to see and conform to what Jehovah's LOVING standards are and what the BIBLE says, they will understand that our faith puts those priorities FIRST - whether or not anyone else agrees with it or not. Those negative comments were probably made by disgruntled persons who probably were not seeking Jehovah's agenda but their own. HUMILITY AND FAITH ARE NOT A RESULT OF MIND-CONTROL!!! We all need to make adjustments - and doing things Jehovah's way is the most loving beneficial way to live. I had been disfellowshipped also and am now re-instated. All I can say is that whenever someone has a SCRIPTURAL and spiritual "time-out" they appreciate and value their relationship with Jehovah all the more and Jehovah and ALL his children DO WELCOME AND ENCOURAGE THOSE RETURNING TO THE FOLD. Our faith is one of LOVE and our relationship with Jehovah God should be our main focus for a happy, LONG life.  5/3/07
 Gayle Rice
 Lake City, SC
 Have not yet seen the documentary but looking forward to it. I have been a Witness for forty eight years in various congregations in four different states and cannot imagine where people who were purportedly once Witnesses come up with their stories. As someone else mentioned, I actually had to laugh at some of them. No one forced me to be a Witness and no one forces me to remain one. I serve Jehovah of my own free will though you detractors say I have none. News to me.  5/3/07
 HEATHER
 MISHAWAKA INDIANA
 I APPRECIATE THE EFFERT PUT FORTH IN EDUCATING ONE IN THE PUBIC ABOUT JEHOVAH WITNESSESS. MANY PEOPLE HAVE A MISCONCEPTION ABOUT OUR RELIGION BECAUSE OF THOSE WHO SPREAD LIES ABOUT OUR BELIEFS. IT IS TRUE THAT PEOPLE WHO DECIDE TO BECOME ONE OF JEHOVAH WITNESSES ARE ASK THE BASIC KNOWLEDGE AND IF THEY DO THEN THEY CAN GET BAPTIZED. THOSE WHO DON'T APPRECIATE THE COMMANDMENTS IN THE BIBLE USUALLY WILL GET INVOLVE IN WAYS THAT ARE CONTRARY TO GOD REQUIREMENTS AND AFTER NOT ACCEPTING COUNSEL THEY ARE DISFELLOWSHIPPED BUT, CAN RETURN WITH A REPENTIVE ATTITUDE. OTHERS WANT TO BE HYPOCRITICAL AND STILL BE ACCEPTED AND THAT IS NOT ACCECPTIABLE. THEY REFUSE TO LIVE ACORDINGLY TO BIBLE STANDARDS AND DO NOT WANT TO BE REINSTATED. THEREFORE THEY SPEAK AGAINST OUR RELIGION. WE HAVE A VERY FULL AND HAPPY LIFE WITH THOUGHTS OF RESPECT FOR EVERYONE BECAUSE OF OUR LOVE FOR JEHOVAH AND THE SACRIFICE OF HIS SON JESUS CHRIST. WE ARE ALWAYS FREE TO MAKE DECISIONS BUT, LIKE ALL THINGS IN LIFE THERE ARE CONSEQUENCES RATHER IT BE GOOD OR BAD. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE TIME YOU PUT INTO THIS PROGRAM TO TEACH OTHERS ABOUT JEHOVAHS ORGANIZATION.  5/3/07
 S.W.
 MS
 Whether biased for or against JWs. what can be said about them is that they keep their word.
 Although they catch flack for "shuning" as its called they should be commended for standing for what they teach. By becoming one you don�t loose any freedom. They only expect you to do for God what you say you will.
 You can disagree with the Pope, use condoms and still be catholic. You can have sex out of marriage and still be Methodist. You can be openly gay and still be Baptist. You can do anything you want and profess any religion that is Christian. I�m not saying that any of the above actions are wrong, those churches make that claim; what I�m saying is that they tolerate the things they say are wrong. Jehovah�s Witnesses don�t!! Every religion has good adherents and bad ones EXCEPT JWs. JWs say Blood transfusions are wrong and they don�t tolerate it. JWs say sex out of marriage is wrong and they don�t tolerate it. If you do those things they will put you out. The people they put out know this from the outset because it takes months to years of STUDY to qualify to be one. So if you gonna get a transfusion or have a few babies without marriage don�t join! Whether you like them or not they ARE CERTIANLY NOT hypocrites. Reserve that name for any religion that tolerates the things it defines as wrong. Who does the shoe fit�..?  5/3/07
 Vanessa
 Auburn, WA
 I am 18 years old and as a teenager, being a Jehova's Witness was the best thing that i could have done, and will ever do in my life. I read a comment stating that we only believe in Jehova and not Jesus...wow do they have there facts wrong! We DO believe in Jesus! He is our savior but who created him? Yes, Jehova did, and thats why he is the only one and only who can recive all the honor! I love Jehova with all my heart and an strongly believe that he will bring justice the this cruel world and to all who dont believe, ...and to all who dont believe, all i can say that they will be just like the people who choose not to listen to Noah in his time, they choose not to listen to the message that jehova had sent him. And they vanished in the great flood! Just like cruel people will too in the NEAR future!  5/3/07
 Cathy Laszewski
 As for the woman who said that it is not true that JW's shun family members...I would like to share with her my experience. We were JW's for over 40 years and came to the point where we found them to be dogmatic, hypocritical and unloving. Though neither myself or my husband are disfellowshipped or disassociated...we ARE shunned publicly by JW's we have known for all those decades. My own mother and sister have not spoken to me for over 5 years...merely because we chose to leave. I would dearly love to see this filmmaker do a documentary on the THOUSANDS of families who have been ripped apart by JW doctrine. There is nothing worse than sugar coating a religion that is, in my opinion, a terrorist organization. I say this because JW's believe they are the only ones who will survive the mass destruction at Armageddon. Kind of like the holocaust done in "Jehovah's" name. They personally won't kill off millions of people but they'll happily let their god do it for them.  5/3/07
 E. Louise
 Ozone Park, New York
 Now I realize what a great and very necessary station PBS is. IndependentLens is indispensable.
 Thank you for airing the unbiased documentary KNOCKING,it is a masterpiece of research and a demonstration of the humanness of Jehovah's witnesses.
 Subjects of all forms of human government should know that what makes a good citizen is not pledging allegiance or singing the national anthem (hardcore criminals do that too), but rather, not cheating on your taxes (the way some patriots do), treating your neighbor the way you in fact want to be treated (including meaningful although not always visible) disaster relief efforts, good work habits (the paper clips and rubber bands are the property of employers not employees so too the excessive use of cyberspace and land lines), etc.
 Before mobbing them, the Jews in Borough Park should remember who spoke up when no one else did during, Hitler's Germany.
 BRAVO PBS for tellin' it like it is!  5/3/07
 Brenda Lee
 Golden, CO
 Mr. Engardio stated: "..Jehovah's Witnesses don't begrudge those who hold differing worldviews. They acknowledge that a right is not a right unless it belongs to everyone."
 If that's true, then why do JWs SHUN family members who simply want to pursue their own spiritual path? Isn't that "begruding those who hold differing worldviews?" Shouldn't former former JWs be afforded the same rights as current JWs? And since JWs clearly aren't affording others these rights, then one must inquire: why are they deceiving the general population? Isn't deception the trademark of a cult?
 My mother, brother, sister, four nephews and niece haven't spoken to me in 25 years and yet I was never excommunicated (disfellowshipped) for any sin. I am one of MILLIONS of people who are being shunned for NO BIBLICAL REASON.
 Shunning means no communication at all, not even when a relative dies; no invitations to family events or weddings; no cards or phone calls; no acknowledgment whatsoever. Being rejected by an organiz
 ation that professes to be "family oriented" has been both painful and satirical for cult survivors. Sometimes we don't know whether to laugh or cry.
 Does this film really tell THE whole TRUTH about "The Truth"? Isn't it a miscarriage of journalism to present the Watchtower organization as benign to the general public when it has been responsible for family genocide on a global scale?  5/1/07
 If the Watchtower organization cooperated with the production, I imagine the film makes no mention of their vast history of false prophecies. I also imagine there is no mention of grandparents silently shunning teenaged grandchildren for deciding not to be Jehovah's Witnesses. The Myths and Reality page says JW's are not a cult, but the film's makers need to do more research. A mind control cult uses deceptive recruiting techniques and coercive retainment practices. WT doesn't inform potential recruits about disfellowshipping and makes current members fear God's disapproval if they try to leave the organization. Cult, cult, cult.  5/1/07
 Bette Witt
 Oakwood, PA
 Having seen the documentary twice - I can say with certainty that Jehovah's Witnesses and their parent organization, The Watchtower Bible & Tract Society, have NEVER intended to support the freedom of religion and press of general populations. Any court cases that might have benefited others, was FIRST intended to support and benefit their own organizaion. They have no interest in providing legal help or assistance to any group outside their own organization, unless it primarily benefits them.
 Despite the information presented in "Knocking", they are not a Christian religion. They are a pseudo Jewish religion - and do not follow the tenets of Christ.  5/1/07
 Janice
 Colorado, Spring
 Im looking foward to this film I always known that they good people and it looks likes they are expected much from them but they really feel that way, also i dont think their are hiding anything from anyone for those that talk dirt about them, you are worst then dirt.  5/1/07
 Janice
 EVERYTHING that Jehovah's Wittnesses believe is based 100% completely on the Bible. My Daughter is a Jehovahs Wittness and she has taught me so much. Those who view them as a ridiculous cult should take a better and deeper look at their Bible's they've been storing without opening for years. Once you truly grasp the understanding of the Bible, then we'll see what you have to say. Isaiah 43:10; Matthew 24:14; Psalm 83:18; John 15:9,10. Ask any Wittness to give you the book What The Bible Really Teaches, no cost. READ THESE AND TRUST ME, YOU WILL SEE.  5/1/07
 Deborah Marsh
 Antelope, California
 My husband and I are "born and raised" JW's. Our grown children and 4 grandsons are not. Yes, the holiday seasons are difficult. We decided to make it clear that we do not celebrate the holiday and would not participate but, out of respect and love, we give the kids gifts either shortly before or after the holiday. We are so proud of the families in the documentary. Their struggle to maintain their Bible-based decision not to accept blood was living proof that JWs are not mindless robots. We educate ourselves and make our PERSONAL decision after prayerful consideration.
 In contrast to the humble and respectful answers to questions posed to them by the Elders, I hope that thinking people will see through the venom of some of the comments posted here. I'm thankful Jesus didn't believe salvation to be a personal matter but began an educational (evangelizing) work and sent out his disciples to preach the good news in all the inhabited earth - in two's. (Luke 4:43-44; 9:1-6 & 10:1)Thank you for this well-done and very professional documentary. We wonder what your next project will be.  5/1/07
 Paul
 Long Beach
 I am looking forward to enjoy the film and the DVD. Many people strongly disagree with JW's, but most of them don't realize that many of the freedoms they enjoy are thanks to the work witnesses are doing. On the other hand, people who claim that they were witnesses, but that have been disfellowshipped are twisting the reality of what being a witness is. Simply put: if you are part of an organization (any kind of organization) you are subject to the guidelines of such, or else you lose whatever privileges you might enjoy for being part of it. I.E: If you are an U.S. citizen, you HAVE to obey the law, if you do not, there will be a punishment, since you are "damaging" the structure of the society. Good citizens don't complain that their freedoms are limited, but enjoy the privileges given to them for what they do. Same in the Jehovah's witnesses organization, if you are willing to be part of it, you know that you'll be following Bible's guidelines, and by doing so, your freedom (of thinking and speech included) is not limited, and you are sure there is not such a ridiculous "mind control" scheme behind the organization. A non-biased portrayal of Witnesses is never going to be very popular, but we can live with it, same as we peacefully coexist with our neighbors and relatives.  5/1/07
 Tara McKenney
 Billerica, MA
 I am a former Jehovah's Witness who disassociated myself from the organization. I urge everyone who watches this documentary and comes away with a favorable opinion of Jehovah's Witnesses to please research this dangerous, mind controlling cult. I wish I had done so before I became one. Most Jehovah's Witnesses are truly nice, well intentioned people, but they are run by a group of old men in Brooklyn, NY who rule the organization through fear and guilt(the Watchtower Society). They call themselves "the only true Christian religion...the Truth", but in reality they deny the importance of Jesus. Some of the posters here have said that JWs do not shun non-believing family members, but that is untrue. Not everyone is disfellowshipped for immorality, either, as someone implied in an earlier post. Some have been disfellowshipped for merely questioning some of the Watchtower Society's teachings when they clearly are against what the Bible teaches. Their policies against pedophiles are inadequate. The accuser is not even begun to be believed unless there are two witnesses to the crime. They also condone spousal abuse, telling their members not to go to the police in order not to bring reproach upon Jehovah's name. They discourage higher education telling their members the time is better spent preaching the word of God. If they come knocking on your door, don't answer it.  5/1/07
 lily
 san diego, ca.
 I'm one of Jehovah's witnesses. I thoroughly researched other religous beliefs before making my EDUCATED decision. I do extensive volunteer work with various children and womens charities (causes close to my heart). I am a PTA member, last year acting as the director of special programs. My children have more than most will ever get in lifetime, including an amazing hope for the furture. As for being uneduacated,there is only one person in my family that does not have a degree (though she runs her own successful company). My children attend a private school where they recieve a wonderful education. Combining that with the Bible knowledge they receive weekly at the meetings,makes them happy well-rounded children. The orginazation is full of intelligent people, all who volunteer their time and money!
 It's really disturbing how many random statements have been presented as facts! So many have complained about being told what to believe, not question what they are taught, and how once becoming a JW you loose the freedom to think for yourself or to research other religions. I feel that an individual who makes the huge commitment of embracing a religion to the point of getting baptized without researching what it was all about, failed to exercise their freedom to think for themselves long before they decided to become JW's.
 I studied with JW's out of the King James version of the Bible that was originally my grandmothers (a devout Catholic). Out of that Bible, and not the NWT, I first learned God's name. Jehovah. I was Disfellowshiped for a while also. I know how devastating it can be, and how unfair it feels at the time. It was one of the hardest times of my life, but it made me realize how special Jehovah's orginazation is. My appreciation has never been stronger. My heart goes out to all those who have been through similar situations. I hope you find peace and comfort, wherever it may be...  5/1/07
 D.O
 United Kingdom
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, albeit a very enlightened one. I'm a Medical doctor living and working in the UK. I read many of the comments with a tinge of amusement, because many of the commentators are really uninformed, and their opinions are not evidenced based. I also suspect a bit of bitterness in the comments, especially from those who have been "disfellowshipped". There is no single religion on earth that is fully understood, and I believe everyone has a right to believe in what gives them a sense of purpose and direction in life. A balanced view should be adopted by the critics; while a small number of Witnesses have lost their lives from refusing transfusions, several thousand lives have also been saved from refusing blood. The individuals who supposedly commited suicide after being disfellowshiped (as mentioned by one writer), most likely had deeper, more complex psychosocial issues they were grappling with; The DSM-IV lists suicide/attempted suicide as a psychiatric disorder irrespective of the individuals' religious affiliation. Writers should refrain from making sweeping generalisations. Many of them will never understand Jehovah's witnesses. But that is understandable. Many of us will never understand Muslims, Buddhists, and Grail followers either, but we should endevour to respect one another's beliefs.  5/1/07
 I have not seen the film yet but look forward to seeing soon. Not only do I appreciate what appears to be a unbiased look at JWs, but I find this topic of religious freedom and free speech very interesting. Suggested reading "Judging Jehovah's Witnesses: Religious Persecution and the Dawn of the Rights Revolution" by Shawn Francis Peters. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and it's important to note that we would publish Jehovah's name and his righteous Kingdom even if we were not given the "right" by secular authorities. It is our privilege and a command given us by the king of that kingdom,Jesus Christ. But we are a peaceful & law-abiding people and wish to work within the framework of laws of the land. Hence the rigorous work of ensuring religious freedoms continue so that we may reach those searching for truth, which is why we do what we do-knock. Love of God and love of neighbor.  5/1/07
 Richard
 New York
 I look forward to the local broadcast of Knocking. I spent the first 12 years of my adult life knocking on doors with Jehovah's Witnesses, getting out of the cult for good in 1990. My life has been ever so much more genuinely happy since then. Having recently read Steve Hassan's book "Combatting Cult Mind Control", I was able to appreciate that the identifying marks of a cult fit Jehovah's Witnesses to a "T"! My three oldest children are all JWs, and have been shunning me for years; I'm not even allowed to see my granddaughter. It is a heartless 'religion'. I hope a follow-up show might emphasize the dark side of the cult, with a special focus on silentlambs.org.  5/1/07
 Debbie
 Western Australia
 I saw the preview and it looks to be a promising film. There are a lot of misconceptions about the Witnesses and I'm glad that there will be a film to clear a lot of up. Some here seem to think that their "freedom" has been taken away. Jehovah said that he only wants "willing" people to follow Him. If you're not willing then there is something wrong with your point of view. I don't agree with the people who say the Witnesses are a cult. Cults don't let you see your family or friends. I go to see my parents, who are not Witnesses, every week. The Apostle Paul said that if you don't take care of your family first, then you are a person without faith. He didn't say that they had to be of the same faith. I look forward to seeing the film on May 22nd at 10 p.m. Thanks for all that you've done on it!

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_f.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/12/07
 Cate
 California
 I am not one of Jehovah's, but have an aunt and cousins that are. It's true, they don't participate in our holiday plans. There is no shunning going on though. Even though we live in different states, we visit each other a couple of times a year, write, e-mail, and send packages back and forth all the time. I am definiately not one of the most religious people around, but everything I have learned in the way of religion was taught to me by my cousins using my own "non-JW" bible.
 So I find it hard to believe some of these posts claiming JW make up their own special "truths", or beliefs up. I also find it difficult to take many of these statements as anything more that angry, bitter rants. Anyone that has that much hostility against one particular group of peopole isn't really the most trusted source of information on them. It would be LIKE asking a member of the KKK to educate you on the Civil Rights Movement. Maybe a little inaccurate or one-sided?
 I am not saying any one person or group is bad, or wholey right. I just can't help but notice that you don't see JW's attacking people on this forum. They just seem happy.
 5/12/07
 Colorado
 When I was kicked out of the Witnesses 11 years ago for not agreeing with everything they taught (not for any sin committed on my part), my son was only 7. My mother, a devout JW, told her young grandson that his parents didn't love him and that Jehovah was going to kill him if we did not raise him as a JW. What kind of mind game is that to play on a child? What kind of love is that? I know a woman who when she was a teenager made a mistake and ended up pregnant. She was disfellowshipped. That was 20+ years ago. She has since married and become the mother of four. She in no way lives an immoral life today. One time she talked to her mother on the phone who is a devout JW. Her mother has not met her grandchildren by choice. She told her mother that she was really missing out on knowing some very wonderful people, her grandchildren. Her mother's response was, "Why would I want to know them when Jehovah is just going to destroy them anyway?" How twisted can a religion be if it's teachings result in grandmothers behaving this way? Is this the kind of love Christ taught?
 5/12/07
 Dear Chuck, no name here. By slacking off I mean just that - missing meetings, not putting in the national average hours knocking door-to-door, etc. One's entire spirituality is questioned by a lack of carrying these duties out. Please don't pretend that's not true. Being kicked out, in my experience, is often the first thing the elders do. This IS my experience and my observations over 36 years as a JW. Others have posted similar experiences. You call me a Pharisee for speaking out about a lack of compassion within the organization and leadership. The Pharisees put high demands on the people. Jesus said of the Pharisees in Matt. 23:4, "They bind up heavy loads and put them upon the shoulders of men." They followed the letter of the law instead of the spirit of law. The spirit of the law is love, not judgment. I believe that the average JW is a good person trying to do their best, but they often buckle under the weight. I've seen it over and over in my 36 years. I was guilty of carrying out harsh judgment and I am not proud of that. My loyalty to the organization blinded me. In time, I began to see that this is not the love that Jesus taught. I had to readjust my life to be more Christ-like. It was not an easy journey and it meant great losses for me. But loyalty to God had to take precedent over loyalty to man.
 5/12/07
 Linda
 For those scholarly readers, you might want to read : Truth in translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament. Written by Jason David BeDuhn. His credentials are most noteworthy, including MTS in New Testament and Christian origins from HARVARD DIVINITY SCHOOL.
 His findings?
 The most accurately translated of the 8 most popular modern translations of the New Testament is:
 The New World Translation
 Happy reading........
 5/12/07
 Linda
 To the person who worked in the hospital and found Jehovah's Witnesses, while not accepting blood products, not participating in war, etc., DID accept governmental medical/financial help and wondered why?
 Jehovah's Witnesses are quick to pay their taxes; as United States citizens, they are thereby, entitled to participate in governmental programs providing medical/financial assistance.
 5/12/07
 "If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching, never receive him into your homes or say a greeting to him. For he that says a greeting to him is a sharer in his wicked works." (2 John 10, 11)
 Exposing ourselves to apostate teachings through the various means of modern communication is just as harmful as receiving the apostate himself into our homes.
 5/11/07
 Claudia
 Moreno Valley, Ca
 JW's are NOT to be considered Christians. They do not believe JESUS IS GOD. They seperate the the two on the stance that the Trinity does not exist. They claim that Jesus Christ is Michael the Archangel.But they fail to study outside of the New world Translation they call a Bible. And with the use of the magazines Awake and the Watchtower. This bible they use has been altered and twisted to thier own strange beliefs, by unscholared elders in New York. With lack of theological knowledge. Jehovah was a misreprestation of the true name of God which is Yaweh, and pronounced that way too. In Hebrew. The first name for this organization was 'Russellites' after the ignorant Taze Russell. Not Jehovah Witness as they know now. They are not persecuted for what they believe as they are led to think but for thier actions. The lack of charity towards people is so sad and disheartening. I consider this congregation of sorts a High Control group that cannot think outside of reality or go deep into true Christain history. If only they were allowed to study the beginnings of this false religion maybe they would think before staying. Truth does not change. God does not contradict himself.
 5/11/07
 Vic Warren
 Brisbane Australia
 This is a concern of a relative of my regarding the film and the possibility that it is a scam to make money.
 The reasoning is that there would be two markets where JW's would buy the video and as you know there are a lot.
 Of course the other market would be the general public who would buy the video for reasons best known to themselves. Another one that I didn't think about was that anti-JW's persons will buy it.
 The potential is that a lot of money could be made by this.
 I guess the relative may be cynical but I guess there is a valid point to consider.
 Can you assure your audience that you are not a money makinging racket as Judge Rutherford may say. ( I am just kidding. )
 By the way I ordered your video just recently but I haven't received it as yet, so I look forward to viewing it.
 Do you think your film is similar to "Faith in The March"?
 I have seen parts of your film and I wish to congratulate on your expertise and professionalism.
 5/11/07
 giovanni ciccone
 JW in Italy we are second large religion after the cattolic, COM OVER Knockin!! Is goin to bee a KNOCKAUT!!ciao ci vediamoOOOOOO!!
 5/11/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 To: no name, no city, 5/9/07: You said: "If you slack off in any way you come under harsh judgment. That simply is not true, unless you equate "slacking off" with fornication or other things mentioned at 1 Cor. 5:9-13. Being "kicked out" is the last thing elders want to have to do, and is only done when the wrongdoer is not repentant. Many disfellowshiped ones come back after repentance. Some never do and many of these become bitter and pass along all sort of lies, half-truths or distortions. As one who has been a JW for 50 years, I've never seen what you have described as your experience. It's regretable if true. But, why do you judge an entire religion for the alleged actions of a few imperfect individuals? Who is being like the Pharisees now? Instead of looking at personalities, please step up to the plate and PROVE to us what we teach is unscriptural. Your comments remind me of Ezekiel 18;25,29 where at one point the Israelites said of Jehovah: "The way of Jehovah is not admjusted right." Je hovah answered: "As for my ways, are they not adjusted right, O house of Israel? Are not the ways of you people the ones that are not adjusted right?
 5/11/07
 To be honest, I was prepared to be offended when I sat down to watch this film. However, I was pleasantly surprised in the honesty and non-judgemental attitude taken by the writer/director etc. To often people see or hear of JW's and become quite vocal in their often time mis-informed opinions of the group. I chose to become one of Jehovah's Witnesses while in my teens, but since I was a small child I have heard some of the most outlandish stories about JW's, so thank you for your movie.
 5/11/07
 J. Blue
 Chico, CA
 I was brought up as one of Jehovah's Witness, in the south. I have seen a lot of things that were done by people in a lot of different congreations of our faith disturbing. I remember asking my mother once what is the difference between Jehovah�s Witness and people of other faiths, her answer was the greatest gift that she ever gave me. She said, �Don�t look at the people but at the message. For the message will always be beneficial and reliable but imperfect people no matter what position they hold will not.� So if you are looking for perfect people you won�t find them in any Kingdom Hall and if you did you would feel out of place because you wouldn�t fit in. Oh by the way I too left the organization once, I disassociated myself because I didn�t remember those inspiring words that were given to me as a child of 8. Oh how nice it is to be home
 5/10/07
 John 6:
 53 Accordingly Jesus said to them: Most truly I say to YOU, Unless YOU eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, YOU have no life in yourselves. 60 Therefore many of his disciples, when they heard this, said: This speech is shocking; who can listen to it? 61 But Jesus, knowing in himself that his disciples were murmuring about this, said to them: ;Does this stumble YOU?
 66 Owing to this many of his disciples went off to the things behind and would no longer walk with him. 67 Therefore Jesus said to the twelve: YOU do not want to go also, do YOU? 68 Simon Peter answered him: ;Lord, whom shall we go away to? You have sayings of everlasting life.
 The difference between a shepherd and a wolf is that a wolf scatters and a shepherd gathers...


 5/10/07
 I would like to try & explain why JWs shun people that are former members. They are taught that all truth comes from the organization & if anyone questions that authority it is the same as questioning Gods authority. Therefore there is no valid reason a person can leave the group. When a person does leave for reasons of conscience, they are considered evil & requiring members to shun them eliminates the possibility of anyone sharing any of their views with other members. Heaven forbid anyone have a chance to say why they are leaving. There is no freedom of speech. Current members do not seek to find out why a person left, but take the ruling body of Elders word on it. No questions asked. Questioning might lead to their own disfellowshipping. They are taught that God hates the person that leaves & they must also. After all God hates evil & everyone who leaves is evil regardless of reason. They believe that they are doing the will of God by treating all who leave as if they do not exist, turning their backs on them in public (literally) & never saying Hello. When a religious group teaches that hate is love & that it is God’s will to act upon that belief, you can get them to do anything – even fly a plane into a building. So why not shun family and friends. My prayer is that they will be set free to love people as Jesus would.
 5/10/07
 Lynn
 CA
 Dear Brother/Sister Franklin from Birmingham, you said we (JWs) are encouraged to be wary of forums discussing religion, especially ours. Although that is true, doesn’t that make us sound like we have something to hide or fear? We have the truth, so why do we need to be afraid of talking to anyone? You said we do not need to make a defense of our faith, but that is not what we are told in the Bible. 1 Peter 3:15 says, "always be ready to make a defense before everyone that demands of you a reason for the hope in you…" That says anyone. We should not be afraid of what people say here or anywhere. I want to defend my faith.
 5/10/07
 David
 Colorado
 When people exhibit behavior and rationalize actions that demonstrate a lack of rational thought and objectivity, you can be sure that it all began with mind control techniques – and it is always the same. Whether Nazi Germany, Islamic Terrorists, or Jehovah’s Witnesses, to name just a few, the indoctrination always follows this method:
 1. Find people who are in a vulnerable state. 2. Convince them that you have a special, unique “TRUTH” and that you want to share it out of your love and concern for them. 3. Convince them of a higher purpose. For example, that your organization is the only direct link to God and that all other groups (Jews, Infidels, Non-Jehovah’s Witnesses) are from Satan.
 Once this is accomplished, the final step is to control information. This was certainly the case during Nazi Germany, just as it is the case with all cults. Jehovah’s Witnesses are regularly warned to trust no other source but the Watchtower Society and its ever-changing doctrines. Once you can get a persn to trust only one source and doubt all others, the battle for their mind is complete. Then, they can be led anywhere. Loyalty to the source of this “TRUTH” will always take precedent even in the face of contradictory teachings. It becomes the only lens with which they can then view life. They have made this “TRUTH” their own and are only able to exhibit behavior that supports, perpetuates and reinforces this belief system. They have fallen into a trap.
 5/9/07
 I was a 5th generation JW. I believed it was the only true religion. I never doubted that. I obeyed everything, never questioning. As I grew older, I began to see huge discrepancies between words they said & how they really lived. They claim they are the only true Christians in the world & all other Christian groups are of the Devil. I believed this too until I began to see otherwise. They claim they are the only ones with Gods true love. Reality is that once in the group judgment begins. If you begin to slack off in anyway you come under harsh judgment. They are one of the most intolerant & judgmental groups on the planet. I always obeyed, but I watched others be mistreated over & over. When a person was going through some of the most difficult times of their lives, ie: a failing marriage or moral mistake, instead of helping them they were turned on, criticized, abused & kicked out, which meant total ostracism from family & friends. One in my hall committed suicide because the stigma was just too much for him. I was sick at the lack of true love shown to people in need. I began to pray & ask God to help me understand how this group I believed the only true Christians could act so un-Christ like. As I sought answers in the Bible, it became clear to me that these religious leaders were just like the Pharisees that Jesus denounced continually.
 5/9/07
 Troy
 Boston, MA
 Jehovah's Witness have contributed to discussions about religious freedom, and constitutional protections. As with any groupthink there can be negative consequences. It is ironic that the filmmaker challenges "us versus them." Jehovah's Witnesses are no part of this world and do not tolerate any other religion; Christendom, is "the world empire of false religion." Their message is that all non-Jehovah's Witness will die at Armeggedon, there is no compromise. They are quick to judge. The environment of "us and them" is created by Jehovah's Witnesses. They believe that God is love. In practice, and in postings, we can see that this brand of groupthink has created a very harsh and cruel response, however. One Jehovah's Witness asks, "Why should we care about pests?" Jehovah's Witnesses have little tolerance for the Catholic Church or the Pope, yet Jehovah's Witnesses believe in the direction of the "governing body." It is hypocritical to attack Catholics. I agree with Jehovah�s Witnesses regarding th e role religion should play in civic society � None. Peaceable co-existence among family members often calls for compromise. They are not being persecuted or harmed. They should be allowed to believe whatever they want and be responsible for their harms to others, like anyone else.
 5/9/07
 Jean
 Tulsa, OK
 As a Catholic, my father was strongly opposed to JWs. He would burn my mother's clothes when we went to meetings. Years later he softened and while he was dying with cancer, he told me to have the funeral however I wanted. He knew he was giving me permission to have a JW do the funeral. He was born to an unwed mother so knew he could not be buried in a Catholic plot. The brother who gave the talk knew of course, that my dad was not a JW but of course that was not an issue. What did matter was that he gave a wonderful upbuilding sermon focusing on the hope of resurrection that all humans have. I have been a JW for 40 years and have loved every minute. I feel sorry for those who have left but they can always come back. Thank you for a wonderful documentary.
 5/9/07
 Franklin
 Birmingham, AL
 Keep your senses completely.�1 Pet. 1:13. When we face decisions, we must be alert to possible dangers and guard against being deceived by first impressions. w 3/1/06 1, 2a JW's are encouraged to be wary of forums discussing religion - especially ours since it brings out the apostates and wolves who with smooth speech and deception try to impose their own ideas and manifestations. My fellow Brothers and Sisters, please be careful. There are many wolves, especially in this blog who are trying to manipulate your minds. Jehovah draws true worshipers "with the right heart condition" to him. We can't give any explanation to those who strongly oppose the TRUTH because they don't have the right heart condition. We need not make a defense for our faith on the internet. Satan wants to trap us by using such "puppets" to lure us into doubt and then the snare will have been set. Oppose the devil with your actions and let your preaching be your response. Jehovah can defend himself. We need not get caught up in petty bickering with disgruntled, blinded opposers.
 5/8/07
 Lawrenceville, NJ
 This documentary was well done, and honest, as most of the comments show: As for the negative comments: Minimal research in the Bible reveals that the same kinds of accusations were made against the first century Christians. Jesus himself was accused of being a cult leader, follower of Satan, blasphemer, seditionist and a sinner. He foretold that his followers would be treated likewise. Cleverly crafted accusations were made against the Apostle Paul, and he suffered greatly as a result. True Christians were in the minority when compared to the "established" religions and popular philosophies, and the historical record reveals they suffered all manner of accusation as a result. It was even foretold that many of these accusers would come from within the congregation itself, notably those who found fault with Jehovah�s moral standards or arrangement. NONE of the emotional criticisms presented provide proof that, as an organization, Jehovah�s Witnesses fail to closely follow the teachings of Jesus. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible speaks of two basic groups of worshippers: the false and true. Jesus himself warned that �many� would be false worshippers. Are JW�s among them? In one beautifully simple verse, Jesus helps any honest-hearted person to see which of the thousands of religions make up his genuine followers: �By this all will know that you are my disciples, if you have LOVE AMONGST YOURSELVES.� (John 13:35). No religion could achieve such love and unity INTERNATIONALLY as the Witnesses have unless they had God�s backing.
 5/8/07
 Phil
 Jacksonville, FL
 Interesting to see the comments posted. Obviously, despite the producing of this video, there are people who have formed their own opinions and no one can tell them differently. The Watchtower teaches only the fear that is mentioned in the Bible... the fear of God. And that includes anything that displeases him. Intake of blood, be in through the mouth or intraveinously, is spoken against by the Bible. Being 'unevenly yoked' with an unbeliever is a scriptural teaching. The WT Society has never said "You can't," because they don't have that right. What they share is the wisdom that history has shown time and again that the wisest course is to follow the teaching of Christ and the preaching of Jehovah's kingdom in his hands. If you choose to go against Bible teachings then you truly will "reap what you sow." Men keep trying to say "I can worship God my way," and then wonder why God doesn't listen to their prayers. Worship Jehovah in the way he demands, as taught by the Bible, and the blessings will be yours.
 5/8/07
 Dennis Drew
 Platte City, MO
 I greatly enjoyed your website with the sole exception of the myth/reality page. My discomfort there were several areas that contained either misleading comments-- or actual inaccuracy. If you would be interested in details of this, please let me know and I will forward such to you. Since it appears the purpose of your site is to present the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses and alleviate the propagation of propaganda and misconceptions regarding the faith, I feel confident you'll agree it is best to have the myth/reality page present as accurate a picture as possible.
 5/8/07
 Leanna
 Avondale, AZ
 I just read in the "myth or reality" section bout JW's politically neutral stand...I work with the public, dealing with insurance. JW's may not give allegiance to any earthly governments but they sure don't mind taking health care from the government. Why is that? Sounds contradicting to me. If you are against something, why take handouts from them? Why put yourself in a place to depend on the very thing you claim to be against? Not so strong in the faith? It seems to contradict itself.
 5/8/07
 MMarshell
 Stockton, CA
 Well, i am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. As for all of the people that had negative things to say, and especially to the guy whose wife was one of Jhovah's Witneeses, it's unfortunate that you think that we're a cult. I have to agree with some of the blogs, saying how religions accept things that are OBVIOUSLY not tolerated in the Bible. Heres the bottom line, no matter what JW's claim to believe in, people are always going to want to do what they WANT to do, and if they feel that a "church" is telling them not to do something, then it must not be from God, and it must be a cult. If you as a person don't want to follow the standards of what Jehovah set for us in the Bible, then thats your choice. And as for those "shunned" from the congregation, they are ALWAYS welcome to come back. The night Jesus died, he knew that Judas was going to disown him 3 times, and he dismissed him from the table. So, since that time, Jesus set the standards from then on. If you want to eat from the table of the demons, then do so, but you can't do both. You have to choice one, and then chose it whole-heartedly. Even if its something you dont want to do. Because being imperfect, were ALWAYS going to want to do what we want to do, but if we do what Jehovah wants us to do, then things will always go well with us. Think about it......
 5/8/07
 MM
 Philadelphia
 I want to thank Mr. Engardio and Mr. Shepard for this outstanding documentary. I am very happy to see it received 4 Film Festival Awards which are listed on Knocking.org Brothers Kempler and Thomas and Sister Gobitas-Klose were very kind to give us their personal stories of upholding their integrity in the face of very difficult circumstances.
 I want to thank all those involved in the making of this documentary as well as my Brothers and Sisters who made appearances. I would be remiss not to mention family members of Jehovah's Witnesses and others who gave us their honest views on our work and organization.
 5/8/07
 J P
 Salt Lake City, UT
 If I may add to a comment made by Ruth as my Sister forgot to include: We DO Invite the Public to Attend the "Memorial of Jesus Christ's Death."
 This past Memorial Jehovah's Witnesses had presented a World Wide Invitation distributing it to all those we met in our ministry. The invitation also invited the public to the annual Special Talk that had been given World Wide at all congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses. We always look forward to having the public attend the Memorial and Special Talk. We look forward to having them with us next year.
 5/8/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 A misconception many have is "JWs do not believe in Jesus" or that he is "the Son of God." Wrong on both charges! We consistently proclaim Jesus is the Son of God! As far as "not believing in Jesus", on the inside cover of every Watchtower Magazine are found these words as part of the "Purpose of the Watchtower": "It encourages faith in God's now-reigning king, Jesus Christ, whose shed blood opens the way to eternal life." Does that statement support these false claims? Those who foster this have been seriously misled. I wonder what other misleading things they distort about us. Better to ask JWs directly what we really believe instead of believing opposers who often speak falsy about us. If you lived in the First Century and wanted to know about Jesus, would you have asked the chief priests and Pharisees about Him, or would you have gone directly to Jesus or one of his disciples? Do you think you would get the truth out of his opposers? His enemies called him a drunkard, a glutton, Sabbath breaker, false witness, blasphemer of God, subversive, and a messenger of Satan. (Matt. 9:34; 11:19; 12:24; 26:65; John 8:13; 9:16; 19:12). His disciples were also meligned. Acts 28:22 states: "But we think it proper to hear from you what your thoughts are, for truly, as regards this sect it is known to us that everywhere it is spoken against." Can true Christians expect anything different?
 5/8/07
 Lynn on 5/5 quoted the Watchtower saying, "a concerned homeowner (referring to God) should safeguard the health and well-being of his family by exterminating the pests�God must eliminate such "pests" � the incorrigibly wicked � for the sake of the righteous."
 Doesn�t it seem odd that an organization that is getting so much press in this documentary as standing against Hitler and his extermination of the Jews, uses the same terminology about those who are outside their organization? Isn�t that extreme hate speech and intolerance on holocaust levels? Does anyone see a huge problem with this? I sure do. I do not believe God views his creation as pests like Hitler did! "For God loved the world so much that he gave his only Son, in order that everyone exercising faith in him might not be destroyed, but have everlasting life." Jo. 3:16 Does that sound like a God who thinks of humans as pests?
 5/8/07
 Martha S
 LaFayette Hill, PA
 Dear Sisters:
 I appreciate all your comments. I am addressing sisters as I am also a sister.Perhaps it would be wise of us not to read some of the posts. We miss friends and family that used to associate with us. Everyone has the opportunity to comment even if the world can see what some may say.We can be kind and thoughtful in response to those who are not Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Think about and commend the good others do. Throughout the earth people are involved in various good works. These things may be spiritual even though we know there is a parting of ways. How are we to know the heart of any man? 2 Chronicles 16:9a; John 3:16; Acts 15:8a Heartfelt neighborly love, empathy, concern and humility; these must be prayerfully cultivated and genuine. Mark 12:30-31; 1 Corinthians 13:1-7; Mark 6:34; Romans 12:9a
 We are hurt by what is usually portrayed in the media about Jehovah's Witnesses. I have seen the same for other religions and stopped getting my information from these sources. Information can be incomplete, one sided, even slanderous. Knocking" is accurate and was produced to inform the public, not to detail or convince them of our hope.
 5/8/07
 Dave
 California
 As a Jehovahs Witness for 20 years, I have had to deal with my parents leaving the truth. As a member of the only true religion, we are taught to cut off any family member who leaves the truth. The organization teaches us that the only hope for them to come to their senses is by completely cutting off all communication with them so I have not spoken to them for several years. Last year they even sent me a Christmas card which I promptly threw in the trash. How mean of them to send it when they know that it is a pagan holiday! I still do not know all the details of their disfellowshiping because I have never talked to them since it happened but I trust the elders decisions. If my parents have a good heart they will return to the organization, if not Jehovah will destroy them at Armageddon. As much as I love them, my obedience to Jehovahs organization must come first and I cannot risk my own life by talking to them. I look forward to this film because I have heard so many good comments about it at the Kingdom Hall. Who knows, maybe my parents will see it, repent of their sins and start the long process of coming back to the true religion.
 5/8/07
 Colorado
 The following is on the myths link of the Knocking site: "The congregation does not shun inactive individuals for the life they lead if they no longer identify themselves publicly as Witnesses or participate in the door-to-door ministry." This is an outright lie! I am living proof. I stopped attending (12 yrs ago) & was quietly going about my own life. 1 year later the Elders knocked on my door. They heard I no longer believed this religion was "The Truth", a title used for their religion. So they asked me if this was true. Since I am a person who is utmost concerned about truth, I had to tell them 'yes'. They replied, "We will make an announcement that you have disassociated yourself." I told them I did not wish to be disassociated as this would cut me off from everyone I loved. But that did not matter to them. They passed judgment & I was kicked out, simply because I didn't go along with everything they taught as true. As a result I was immediately cut off from everyone I loved, all life long friends & all my family. My son was only 7 at the time & has never been able to know any of his relatives as they will not speak to us. After that I found victims (like me) of different cults. Their experience has also resulted in them being cut off from the people they love. They are from JWs, Mormons, 7th Day Adventists.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_g.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/12/07
 Cate
 California
 I am not one of Jehovah's, but have an aunt and cousins that are. It's true, they don't participate in our holiday plans. There is no shunning going on though. Even though we live in different states, we visit each other a couple of times a year, write, e-mail, and send packages back and forth all the time. I am definiately not one of the most religious people around, but everything I have learned in the way of religion was taught to me by my cousins using my own "non-JW" bible.
 So I find it hard to believe some of these posts claiming JW make up their own special "truths", or beliefs up. I also find it difficult to take many of these statements as anything more that angry, bitter rants. Anyone that has that much hostility against one particular group of peopole isn't really the most trusted source of information on them. It would be LIKE asking a member of the KKK to educate you on the Civil Rights Movement. Maybe a little inaccurate or one-sided?
 I am not saying any one person or group is bad, or wholey right. I just can't help but notice that you don't see JW's attacking people on this forum. They just seem happy.
 5/12/07
 Colorado
 When I was kicked out of the Witnesses 11 years ago for not agreeing with everything they taught (not for any sin committed on my part), my son was only 7. My mother, a devout JW, told her young grandson that his parents didn't love him and that Jehovah was going to kill him if we did not raise him as a JW. What kind of mind game is that to play on a child? What kind of love is that? I know a woman who when she was a teenager made a mistake and ended up pregnant. She was disfellowshipped. That was 20+ years ago. She has since married and become the mother of four. She in no way lives an immoral life today. One time she talked to her mother on the phone who is a devout JW. Her mother has not met her grandchildren by choice. She told her mother that she was really missing out on knowing some very wonderful people, her grandchildren. Her mother's response was, "Why would I want to know them when Jehovah is just going to destroy them anyway?" How twisted can a religion be if it's teachings result in grandmothers behaving this way? Is this the kind of love Christ taught?
 5/12/07
 Dear Chuck, no name here. By slacking off I mean just that - missing meetings, not putting in the national average hours knocking door-to-door, etc. One's entire spirituality is questioned by a lack of carrying these duties out. Please don't pretend that's not true. Being kicked out, in my experience, is often the first thing the elders do. This IS my experience and my observations over 36 years as a JW. Others have posted similar experiences. You call me a Pharisee for speaking out about a lack of compassion within the organization and leadership. The Pharisees put high demands on the people. Jesus said of the Pharisees in Matt. 23:4, "They bind up heavy loads and put them upon the shoulders of men." They followed the letter of the law instead of the spirit of law. The spirit of the law is love, not judgment. I believe that the average JW is a good person trying to do their best, but they often buckle under the weight. I've seen it over and over in my 36 years. I was guilty of carrying out harsh judgment and I am not proud of that. My loyalty to the organization blinded me. In time, I began to see that this is not the love that Jesus taught. I had to readjust my life to be more Christ-like. It was not an easy journey and it meant great losses for me. But loyalty to God had to take precedent over loyalty to man.
 5/12/07
 Linda
 For those scholarly readers, you might want to read : Truth in translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament. Written by Jason David BeDuhn. His credentials are most noteworthy, including MTS in New Testament and Christian origins from HARVARD DIVINITY SCHOOL.
 His findings?
 The most accurately translated of the 8 most popular modern translations of the New Testament is:
 The New World Translation
 Happy reading........
 5/12/07
 Linda
 To the person who worked in the hospital and found Jehovah's Witnesses, while not accepting blood products, not participating in war, etc., DID accept governmental medical/financial help and wondered why?
 Jehovah's Witnesses are quick to pay their taxes; as United States citizens, they are thereby, entitled to participate in governmental programs providing medical/financial assistance.
 5/12/07
 "If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching, never receive him into your homes or say a greeting to him. For he that says a greeting to him is a sharer in his wicked works." (2 John 10, 11)
 Exposing ourselves to apostate teachings through the various means of modern communication is just as harmful as receiving the apostate himself into our homes.
 5/11/07
 Claudia
 Moreno Valley, Ca
 JW's are NOT to be considered Christians. They do not believe JESUS IS GOD. They seperate the the two on the stance that the Trinity does not exist. They claim that Jesus Christ is Michael the Archangel.But they fail to study outside of the New world Translation they call a Bible. And with the use of the magazines Awake and the Watchtower. This bible they use has been altered and twisted to thier own strange beliefs, by unscholared elders in New York. With lack of theological knowledge. Jehovah was a misreprestation of the true name of God which is Yaweh, and pronounced that way too. In Hebrew. The first name for this organization was 'Russellites' after the ignorant Taze Russell. Not Jehovah Witness as they know now. They are not persecuted for what they believe as they are led to think but for thier actions. The lack of charity towards people is so sad and disheartening. I consider this congregation of sorts a High Control group that cannot think outside of reality or go deep into true Christain history. If only they were allowed to study the beginnings of this false religion maybe they would think before staying. Truth does not change. God does not contradict himself.
 5/11/07
 Vic Warren
 Brisbane Australia
 This is a concern of a relative of my regarding the film and the possibility that it is a scam to make money.
 The reasoning is that there would be two markets where JW's would buy the video and as you know there are a lot.
 Of course the other market would be the general public who would buy the video for reasons best known to themselves. Another one that I didn't think about was that anti-JW's persons will buy it.
 The potential is that a lot of money could be made by this.
 I guess the relative may be cynical but I guess there is a valid point to consider.
 Can you assure your audience that you are not a money makinging racket as Judge Rutherford may say. ( I am just kidding. )
 By the way I ordered your video just recently but I haven't received it as yet, so I look forward to viewing it.
 Do you think your film is similar to "Faith in The March"?
 I have seen parts of your film and I wish to congratulate on your expertise and professionalism.
 5/11/07
 giovanni ciccone
 JW in Italy we are second large religion after the cattolic, COM OVER Knockin!! Is goin to bee a KNOCKAUT!!ciao ci vediamoOOOOOO!!
 5/11/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 To: no name, no city, 5/9/07: You said: "If you slack off in any way you come under harsh judgment. That simply is not true, unless you equate "slacking off" with fornication or other things mentioned at 1 Cor. 5:9-13. Being "kicked out" is the last thing elders want to have to do, and is only done when the wrongdoer is not repentant. Many disfellowshiped ones come back after repentance. Some never do and many of these become bitter and pass along all sort of lies, half-truths or distortions. As one who has been a JW for 50 years, I've never seen what you have described as your experience. It's regretable if true. But, why do you judge an entire religion for the alleged actions of a few imperfect individuals? Who is being like the Pharisees now? Instead of looking at personalities, please step up to the plate and PROVE to us what we teach is unscriptural. Your comments remind me of Ezekiel 18;25,29 where at one point the Israelites said of Jehovah: "The way of Jehovah is not admjusted right." Je hovah answered: "As for my ways, are they not adjusted right, O house of Israel? Are not the ways of you people the ones that are not adjusted right?
 5/11/07
 To be honest, I was prepared to be offended when I sat down to watch this film. However, I was pleasantly surprised in the honesty and non-judgemental attitude taken by the writer/director etc. To often people see or hear of JW's and become quite vocal in their often time mis-informed opinions of the group. I chose to become one of Jehovah's Witnesses while in my teens, but since I was a small child I have heard some of the most outlandish stories about JW's, so thank you for your movie.
 5/11/07
 J. Blue
 Chico, CA
 I was brought up as one of Jehovah's Witness, in the south. I have seen a lot of things that were done by people in a lot of different congreations of our faith disturbing. I remember asking my mother once what is the difference between Jehovah�s Witness and people of other faiths, her answer was the greatest gift that she ever gave me. She said, �Don�t look at the people but at the message. For the message will always be beneficial and reliable but imperfect people no matter what position they hold will not.� So if you are looking for perfect people you won�t find them in any Kingdom Hall and if you did you would feel out of place because you wouldn�t fit in. Oh by the way I too left the organization once, I disassociated myself because I didn�t remember those inspiring words that were given to me as a child of 8. Oh how nice it is to be home
 5/10/07
 John 6:
 53 Accordingly Jesus said to them: Most truly I say to YOU, Unless YOU eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, YOU have no life in yourselves. 60 Therefore many of his disciples, when they heard this, said: This speech is shocking; who can listen to it? 61 But Jesus, knowing in himself that his disciples were murmuring about this, said to them: ;Does this stumble YOU?
 66 Owing to this many of his disciples went off to the things behind and would no longer walk with him. 67 Therefore Jesus said to the twelve: YOU do not want to go also, do YOU? 68 Simon Peter answered him: ;Lord, whom shall we go away to? You have sayings of everlasting life.
 The difference between a shepherd and a wolf is that a wolf scatters and a shepherd gathers...


 5/10/07
 I would like to try & explain why JWs shun people that are former members. They are taught that all truth comes from the organization & if anyone questions that authority it is the same as questioning Gods authority. Therefore there is no valid reason a person can leave the group. When a person does leave for reasons of conscience, they are considered evil & requiring members to shun them eliminates the possibility of anyone sharing any of their views with other members. Heaven forbid anyone have a chance to say why they are leaving. There is no freedom of speech. Current members do not seek to find out why a person left, but take the ruling body of Elders word on it. No questions asked. Questioning might lead to their own disfellowshipping. They are taught that God hates the person that leaves & they must also. After all God hates evil & everyone who leaves is evil regardless of reason. They believe that they are doing the will of God by treating all who leave as if they do not exist, turning their backs on them in public (literally) & never saying Hello. When a religious group teaches that hate is love & that it is God’s will to act upon that belief, you can get them to do anything – even fly a plane into a building. So why not shun family and friends. My prayer is that they will be set free to love people as Jesus would.
 5/10/07
 Lynn
 CA
 Dear Brother/Sister Franklin from Birmingham, you said we (JWs) are encouraged to be wary of forums discussing religion, especially ours. Although that is true, doesn’t that make us sound like we have something to hide or fear? We have the truth, so why do we need to be afraid of talking to anyone? You said we do not need to make a defense of our faith, but that is not what we are told in the Bible. 1 Peter 3:15 says, "always be ready to make a defense before everyone that demands of you a reason for the hope in you…" That says anyone. We should not be afraid of what people say here or anywhere. I want to defend my faith.
 5/10/07
 David
 Colorado
 When people exhibit behavior and rationalize actions that demonstrate a lack of rational thought and objectivity, you can be sure that it all began with mind control techniques – and it is always the same. Whether Nazi Germany, Islamic Terrorists, or Jehovah’s Witnesses, to name just a few, the indoctrination always follows this method:
 1. Find people who are in a vulnerable state. 2. Convince them that you have a special, unique “TRUTH” and that you want to share it out of your love and concern for them. 3. Convince them of a higher purpose. For example, that your organization is the only direct link to God and that all other groups (Jews, Infidels, Non-Jehovah’s Witnesses) are from Satan.
 Once this is accomplished, the final step is to control information. This was certainly the case during Nazi Germany, just as it is the case with all cults. Jehovah’s Witnesses are regularly warned to trust no other source but the Watchtower Society and its ever-changing doctrines. Once you can get a persn to trust only one source and doubt all others, the battle for their mind is complete. Then, they can be led anywhere. Loyalty to the source of this “TRUTH” will always take precedent even in the face of contradictory teachings. It becomes the only lens with which they can then view life. They have made this “TRUTH” their own and are only able to exhibit behavior that supports, perpetuates and reinforces this belief system. They have fallen into a trap.
 5/9/07
 I was a 5th generation JW. I believed it was the only true religion. I never doubted that. I obeyed everything, never questioning. As I grew older, I began to see huge discrepancies between words they said & how they really lived. They claim they are the only true Christians in the world & all other Christian groups are of the Devil. I believed this too until I began to see otherwise. They claim they are the only ones with Gods true love. Reality is that once in the group judgment begins. If you begin to slack off in anyway you come under harsh judgment. They are one of the most intolerant & judgmental groups on the planet. I always obeyed, but I watched others be mistreated over & over. When a person was going through some of the most difficult times of their lives, ie: a failing marriage or moral mistake, instead of helping them they were turned on, criticized, abused & kicked out, which meant total ostracism from family & friends. One in my hall committed suicide because the stigma was just too much for him. I was sick at the lack of true love shown to people in need. I began to pray & ask God to help me understand how this group I believed the only true Christians could act so un-Christ like. As I sought answers in the Bible, it became clear to me that these religious leaders were just like the Pharisees that Jesus denounced continually.
 5/9/07
 Troy
 Boston, MA
 Jehovah's Witness have contributed to discussions about religious freedom, and constitutional protections. As with any groupthink there can be negative consequences. It is ironic that the filmmaker challenges "us versus them." Jehovah's Witnesses are no part of this world and do not tolerate any other religion; Christendom, is "the world empire of false religion." Their message is that all non-Jehovah's Witness will die at Armeggedon, there is no compromise. They are quick to judge. The environment of "us and them" is created by Jehovah's Witnesses. They believe that God is love. In practice, and in postings, we can see that this brand of groupthink has created a very harsh and cruel response, however. One Jehovah's Witness asks, "Why should we care about pests?" Jehovah's Witnesses have little tolerance for the Catholic Church or the Pope, yet Jehovah's Witnesses believe in the direction of the "governing body." It is hypocritical to attack Catholics. I agree with Jehovah�s Witnesses regarding th e role religion should play in civic society � None. Peaceable co-existence among family members often calls for compromise. They are not being persecuted or harmed. They should be allowed to believe whatever they want and be responsible for their harms to others, like anyone else.
 5/9/07
 Jean
 Tulsa, OK
 As a Catholic, my father was strongly opposed to JWs. He would burn my mother's clothes when we went to meetings. Years later he softened and while he was dying with cancer, he told me to have the funeral however I wanted. He knew he was giving me permission to have a JW do the funeral. He was born to an unwed mother so knew he could not be buried in a Catholic plot. The brother who gave the talk knew of course, that my dad was not a JW but of course that was not an issue. What did matter was that he gave a wonderful upbuilding sermon focusing on the hope of resurrection that all humans have. I have been a JW for 40 years and have loved every minute. I feel sorry for those who have left but they can always come back. Thank you for a wonderful documentary.
 5/9/07
 Franklin
 Birmingham, AL
 Keep your senses completely.�1 Pet. 1:13. When we face decisions, we must be alert to possible dangers and guard against being deceived by first impressions. w 3/1/06 1, 2a JW's are encouraged to be wary of forums discussing religion - especially ours since it brings out the apostates and wolves who with smooth speech and deception try to impose their own ideas and manifestations. My fellow Brothers and Sisters, please be careful. There are many wolves, especially in this blog who are trying to manipulate your minds. Jehovah draws true worshipers "with the right heart condition" to him. We can't give any explanation to those who strongly oppose the TRUTH because they don't have the right heart condition. We need not make a defense for our faith on the internet. Satan wants to trap us by using such "puppets" to lure us into doubt and then the snare will have been set. Oppose the devil with your actions and let your preaching be your response. Jehovah can defend himself. We need not get caught up in petty bickering with disgruntled, blinded opposers.
 5/8/07
 Lawrenceville, NJ
 This documentary was well done, and honest, as most of the comments show: As for the negative comments: Minimal research in the Bible reveals that the same kinds of accusations were made against the first century Christians. Jesus himself was accused of being a cult leader, follower of Satan, blasphemer, seditionist and a sinner. He foretold that his followers would be treated likewise. Cleverly crafted accusations were made against the Apostle Paul, and he suffered greatly as a result. True Christians were in the minority when compared to the "established" religions and popular philosophies, and the historical record reveals they suffered all manner of accusation as a result. It was even foretold that many of these accusers would come from within the congregation itself, notably those who found fault with Jehovah�s moral standards or arrangement. NONE of the emotional criticisms presented provide proof that, as an organization, Jehovah�s Witnesses fail to closely follow the teachings of Jesus. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible speaks of two basic groups of worshippers: the false and true. Jesus himself warned that �many� would be false worshippers. Are JW�s among them? In one beautifully simple verse, Jesus helps any honest-hearted person to see which of the thousands of religions make up his genuine followers: �By this all will know that you are my disciples, if you have LOVE AMONGST YOURSELVES.� (John 13:35). No religion could achieve such love and unity INTERNATIONALLY as the Witnesses have unless they had God�s backing.
 5/8/07
 Phil
 Jacksonville, FL
 Interesting to see the comments posted. Obviously, despite the producing of this video, there are people who have formed their own opinions and no one can tell them differently. The Watchtower teaches only the fear that is mentioned in the Bible... the fear of God. And that includes anything that displeases him. Intake of blood, be in through the mouth or intraveinously, is spoken against by the Bible. Being 'unevenly yoked' with an unbeliever is a scriptural teaching. The WT Society has never said "You can't," because they don't have that right. What they share is the wisdom that history has shown time and again that the wisest course is to follow the teaching of Christ and the preaching of Jehovah's kingdom in his hands. If you choose to go against Bible teachings then you truly will "reap what you sow." Men keep trying to say "I can worship God my way," and then wonder why God doesn't listen to their prayers. Worship Jehovah in the way he demands, as taught by the Bible, and the blessings will be yours.
 5/8/07
 Dennis Drew
 Platte City, MO
 I greatly enjoyed your website with the sole exception of the myth/reality page. My discomfort there were several areas that contained either misleading comments-- or actual inaccuracy. If you would be interested in details of this, please let me know and I will forward such to you. Since it appears the purpose of your site is to present the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses and alleviate the propagation of propaganda and misconceptions regarding the faith, I feel confident you'll agree it is best to have the myth/reality page present as accurate a picture as possible.
 5/8/07
 Leanna
 Avondale, AZ
 I just read in the "myth or reality" section bout JW's politically neutral stand...I work with the public, dealing with insurance. JW's may not give allegiance to any earthly governments but they sure don't mind taking health care from the government. Why is that? Sounds contradicting to me. If you are against something, why take handouts from them? Why put yourself in a place to depend on the very thing you claim to be against? Not so strong in the faith? It seems to contradict itself.
 5/8/07
 MMarshell
 Stockton, CA
 Well, i am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. As for all of the people that had negative things to say, and especially to the guy whose wife was one of Jhovah's Witneeses, it's unfortunate that you think that we're a cult. I have to agree with some of the blogs, saying how religions accept things that are OBVIOUSLY not tolerated in the Bible. Heres the bottom line, no matter what JW's claim to believe in, people are always going to want to do what they WANT to do, and if they feel that a "church" is telling them not to do something, then it must not be from God, and it must be a cult. If you as a person don't want to follow the standards of what Jehovah set for us in the Bible, then thats your choice. And as for those "shunned" from the congregation, they are ALWAYS welcome to come back. The night Jesus died, he knew that Judas was going to disown him 3 times, and he dismissed him from the table. So, since that time, Jesus set the standards from then on. If you want to eat from the table of the demons, then do so, but you can't do both. You have to choice one, and then chose it whole-heartedly. Even if its something you dont want to do. Because being imperfect, were ALWAYS going to want to do what we want to do, but if we do what Jehovah wants us to do, then things will always go well with us. Think about it......
 5/8/07
 MM
 Philadelphia
 I want to thank Mr. Engardio and Mr. Shepard for this outstanding documentary. I am very happy to see it received 4 Film Festival Awards which are listed on Knocking.org Brothers Kempler and Thomas and Sister Gobitas-Klose were very kind to give us their personal stories of upholding their integrity in the face of very difficult circumstances.
 I want to thank all those involved in the making of this documentary as well as my Brothers and Sisters who made appearances. I would be remiss not to mention family members of Jehovah's Witnesses and others who gave us their honest views on our work and organization.
 5/8/07
 J P
 Salt Lake City, UT
 If I may add to a comment made by Ruth as my Sister forgot to include: We DO Invite the Public to Attend the "Memorial of Jesus Christ's Death."
 This past Memorial Jehovah's Witnesses had presented a World Wide Invitation distributing it to all those we met in our ministry. The invitation also invited the public to the annual Special Talk that had been given World Wide at all congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses. We always look forward to having the public attend the Memorial and Special Talk. We look forward to having them with us next year.
 5/8/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 A misconception many have is "JWs do not believe in Jesus" or that he is "the Son of God." Wrong on both charges! We consistently proclaim Jesus is the Son of God! As far as "not believing in Jesus", on the inside cover of every Watchtower Magazine are found these words as part of the "Purpose of the Watchtower": "It encourages faith in God's now-reigning king, Jesus Christ, whose shed blood opens the way to eternal life." Does that statement support these false claims? Those who foster this have been seriously misled. I wonder what other misleading things they distort about us. Better to ask JWs directly what we really believe instead of believing opposers who often speak falsy about us. If you lived in the First Century and wanted to know about Jesus, would you have asked the chief priests and Pharisees about Him, or would you have gone directly to Jesus or one of his disciples? Do you think you would get the truth out of his opposers? His enemies called him a drunkard, a glutton, Sabbath breaker, false witness, blasphemer of God, subversive, and a messenger of Satan. (Matt. 9:34; 11:19; 12:24; 26:65; John 8:13; 9:16; 19:12). His disciples were also meligned. Acts 28:22 states: "But we think it proper to hear from you what your thoughts are, for truly, as regards this sect it is known to us that everywhere it is spoken against." Can true Christians expect anything different?
 5/8/07
 Lynn on 5/5 quoted the Watchtower saying, "a concerned homeowner (referring to God) should safeguard the health and well-being of his family by exterminating the pests�God must eliminate such "pests" � the incorrigibly wicked � for the sake of the righteous."
 Doesn�t it seem odd that an organization that is getting so much press in this documentary as standing against Hitler and his extermination of the Jews, uses the same terminology about those who are outside their organization? Isn�t that extreme hate speech and intolerance on holocaust levels? Does anyone see a huge problem with this? I sure do. I do not believe God views his creation as pests like Hitler did! "For God loved the world so much that he gave his only Son, in order that everyone exercising faith in him might not be destroyed, but have everlasting life." Jo. 3:16 Does that sound like a God who thinks of humans as pests?
 5/8/07
 Martha S
 LaFayette Hill, PA
 Dear Sisters:
 I appreciate all your comments. I am addressing sisters as I am also a sister.Perhaps it would be wise of us not to read some of the posts. We miss friends and family that used to associate with us. Everyone has the opportunity to comment even if the world can see what some may say.We can be kind and thoughtful in response to those who are not Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Think about and commend the good others do. Throughout the earth people are involved in various good works. These things may be spiritual even though we know there is a parting of ways. How are we to know the heart of any man? 2 Chronicles 16:9a; John 3:16; Acts 15:8a Heartfelt neighborly love, empathy, concern and humility; these must be prayerfully cultivated and genuine. Mark 12:30-31; 1 Corinthians 13:1-7; Mark 6:34; Romans 12:9a
 We are hurt by what is usually portrayed in the media about Jehovah's Witnesses. I have seen the same for other religions and stopped getting my information from these sources. Information can be incomplete, one sided, even slanderous. Knocking" is accurate and was produced to inform the public, not to detail or convince them of our hope.
 5/8/07
 Dave
 California
 As a Jehovahs Witness for 20 years, I have had to deal with my parents leaving the truth. As a member of the only true religion, we are taught to cut off any family member who leaves the truth. The organization teaches us that the only hope for them to come to their senses is by completely cutting off all communication with them so I have not spoken to them for several years. Last year they even sent me a Christmas card which I promptly threw in the trash. How mean of them to send it when they know that it is a pagan holiday! I still do not know all the details of their disfellowshiping because I have never talked to them since it happened but I trust the elders decisions. If my parents have a good heart they will return to the organization, if not Jehovah will destroy them at Armageddon. As much as I love them, my obedience to Jehovahs organization must come first and I cannot risk my own life by talking to them. I look forward to this film because I have heard so many good comments about it at the Kingdom Hall. Who knows, maybe my parents will see it, repent of their sins and start the long process of coming back to the true religion.
 5/8/07
 Colorado
 The following is on the myths link of the Knocking site: "The congregation does not shun inactive individuals for the life they lead if they no longer identify themselves publicly as Witnesses or participate in the door-to-door ministry." This is an outright lie! I am living proof. I stopped attending (12 yrs ago) & was quietly going about my own life. 1 year later the Elders knocked on my door. They heard I no longer believed this religion was "The Truth", a title used for their religion. So they asked me if this was true. Since I am a person who is utmost concerned about truth, I had to tell them 'yes'. They replied, "We will make an announcement that you have disassociated yourself." I told them I did not wish to be disassociated as this would cut me off from everyone I loved. But that did not matter to them. They passed judgment & I was kicked out, simply because I didn't go along with everything they taught as true. As a result I was immediately cut off from everyone I loved, all life long friends & all my family. My son was only 7 at the time & has never been able to know any of his relatives as they will not speak to us. After that I found victims (like me) of different cults. Their experience has also resulted in them being cut off from the people they love. They are from JWs, Mormons, 7th Day Adventists.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_g.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/21/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 Although Jehovah�s witnesses are a peaceful non-violent organization, well noted for their neutrality and passivity, they nonetheless employ a pedagogy that encourages religious intolerance among its members and a myopic view of the world. Their recent campaign last October touting the end of false religion as being near seems only to add the noise of religious extremism that seems to be so pervasive in much of the world today. Even mainstream Christianity has garnered some notable attention with the pope�s denunciation of Islamic faiths as being fundamentally violent in the teachings - for which he later apologized. Yet the witnesses consistently raise their rhetoric calling for divine intervention to bring an end to religions apart from theirs. They preach a warning message of coming divine retribution upon all religions who have kept people in spiritual darkness and dire consequences to those who fail to heed the warning to leave their religions. Borrowing symbolic expressions from the book of Revelation they lump all religions apart from theirs into a figurative �Babylon the Great� -world empire of false religion and as religious harlots who prostitute themselves with the nations of the world because of not remaining neutral to political affairs. Their condemnation of other religious can at best be termed unskillful � a term used to define religions that are agonistic towards individuals that share differing beliefs. Rather than seeking common ground through an understanding of other religious ideas and beliefs their message is one that drives a wedge between them and others.
 5/21/07
 Huntington Beach, California
 There is so much ignorance and misinformation, even on this message board, and people who ignorantly and emotionally rant without knowledge or experience, or knowing their facts. I am a Jehovah's Witness for 32 years now, and I want to thank the makers of this film for their candid and accurate portrayal of my faith. I will share this documentary with all of my non-witness friends (yes I do have them) and relatives in an effort for them to better understand ME and why I do the things I do.
 This documentary is excellently executed and I highly recommend it, even to the ones on this board who I know haven't even seen it....It makes me PROUD to call myself one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/21/07
 Ralph
 Boston Massachusetts
 Although the film Knocking showed Jehovah's Witnesses in a Favorable light. I cannot help but think how my mother lost all her friends when Jehovah's Witnesses began to study with her. They told me that they saw a big change in her personality and that she seemed like a different person. They thought she was being indoctrinated. After a while my mother abandoned her friends and soley focused on the demands of her new religion
 5/18/07
 Seth
 Britain
 I was born in 1965 to Jehovah�s Witness parents, one of four children. I had a great childhood. Raised by two parents who loved and cherished all their children. We enjoyed such good times. My dad was a zealous minister and instilled in me a weekly ministry. Each Saturday morning we would be out �knocking�. I live in Britain and the only problem was that on a Saturday morning Happy Days featuring the Fonz was aired, a program I really enjoyed. It didn�t go out until 11:30 though and each week we were out �knocking� we always seemed to end up in front of a T.V. either back at ours or a friends house by 11:30. I took it all for granted at the time but looking back I realize that my being able to watch my favourite T.V. show was no accident. I relate this in the hope that it gives some kind of insight as to how my parents approached parenthood as Jehovah�s Witnesses. I could recount many other examples of such a loving balanced approach by two people trying their sincere best to give their children the best start they could in life. And today? All four children (I have a brother and two sisters) are baptized JW�s happy active members of their congregations. Looking forward to the future, particularly the day we welcome our dad back at the resurrection. Finally, my 15 year old enjoys watching the re-runs of "Happy Days." And I remember happy days.
 5/18/07
 Rob S.
 St. Louis, MO
 I have not seen this film yet as it will be airing very soon but after reading the website and some of the other comments here i have to say that i was not born to a family of JW's but my dad married my stepmom who was and wheni moved in with them in my mid teens i began to study and decided to get baptized(all the while struggling with my hidden secret that i was gay) thinking that this would cure me but that was not the case and i got disfellowshipped...i love my dad and stepmom very much and think them for my up-bringing as even tho i live my life for me instead of jehovah's ways i still follow most of the things that i was taught & i do still beleive everything that i was taught. but because of my leaving i have lost all contact with my dad and stepmom to which i would very much like to have that bond that we once had back but i know that will never happen. it is very hard at times for me to try to explain my beliefs to my life-partner so i am hoping that this film will help him understand many of my beliefs that i have like the stand on blood and holidays...again thank you very much for this film.
 5/18/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Some have accused JWs of using "mind control techniques" to "convert" people. Over the past 50 years, I have had the privilege of helping 50 people to come to know Bible truth and dedicate themselves to serving Jehovah. I have never used any "mind control techniques". In fact, I don't have a clue as to what mind control techniques are, and wouldn't use such even if I knew what they were! Why not? Because Jehovah wants willing worshipers and servants! At Ps. 110:3 it says that Jehovah's people will offer themselves willingly. Just as Jehovah rejected the offering up of sick & blemished animals at one time by his ancient people, our motives must be pure and clean. Worship and service to Jehovah must come from our hearts out of love for God and mankind to be acceptable to Him. So there is no room (or need) to employ such techniques on anyone. No one is ever forced to worship or serve God. Such accusations are simply more false lies. Remember: "He, convinced against his will, is of the same opinion still!"
 5/18/07
 Dan
 Washington
 In responds to Leanna in Avondale, AZ on 5/8/07. If you feel JW�s should not accept health care from the government and hand outs then why should they pay taxes to support these hand outs? Also if one would consider JW�s as a cult then check out the information at the website http://www.adherents.com/adh_rb.html
 5/18/07
 George Miller
 Ft. Worth, Texas
 I was raised as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I respect many of the religions teachings. Some of the values I gained from the religion: honesty, racial equality, respect for the elderly and disabled, environmental responsibility, courage. I need to mention these positive aspects first because now, 20 years after leaving, I am finally dealing with the deep resentments I have about my childhood. The faith instilled in me a very deep and destructive paranoia. I was told daily by my mother, friends, everyone, that the world was on the brink of destruction. My responsibility was to be free of sin or die in that destruction. The desire to commit a sin meant destruction as well. And God monitors my every desire. I was taught to fear an Angry God. Because I happened to be one of "God's Chosen People," I also had to constantly be on guard against the VERY REAL prescence of Satan and his demons. I was in constant peril, particularly when I was alone or at school. I practiced in the event that demons invaded my elementary school classroom and started an attack on my classmates. Anything could cause them to come but the T.V. shows "Bewitched" or "I Dream of Jeanie" and plastic figurines of "Smurfs" were a sure-fire way to conjure thier prescence. These terrors seem comical now, they certainly were not when I was a boy. I can only submit 250 words today. I'll write more later.
 5/18/07
 Thank you Joel for producing this film, it was realistic. We who are Jehovah's Witnesses realize were imperfect and make mistakes and we do not apply the Bible perfectly, no one in the world does. Jesus Christ was the only man on Earth who could, so there will always be someone to critize us, it is to be expected. We're all trying to do what is right and we do need to be kind to our families who are not JW's and how we interact with them is our business we do not need to answer to anyone about that. I do feel this site is going to be aconstant attack on us and that is a shame because you tried to get discussion on religion and personal freedoms. Good for you.
 5/18/07
 As a child growing up a JW, it was a very sheltered, suppressed life. I do not study anymore but I do base my morals on some of the things I learned.Though JW can seem unrelenting, I respect them. Everyone has a right to choose their path. If you choose this path then it only seems right that you follow that path to the fullest.I choose no religion. For the path that I must take is a personal path between myself and God. As selfish as that my sound to you, that's how I view it.
 I don't agree with shunning family and friends as I don't believe Jehovah or Jesus would do that, no matter what. I don't agree with telling children the end of the world is coming soon. Putting this type of nightmare in young children is hypocritical. Yet Parents protect their children from violent TV, movies, video games etc. This alone made my childhood terrifying, and I would not wish it upon any other child.
 5/18/07
 unbelievable!!! just reading the negative responses to this documentary sickens me. what you think about the beliefs of this religious group, or how you feel about them is not the issue here. because of their fight for religious freedom. their tenacity and fight for upholding their rights and your rights as united states citizens has won you, yes YOU the right to be who you are, and have freedom of speech, say what you want to say, and uphold your own constitutional rights according to the constitutional law of the united states. need i say more????? PLEASE!!!!!!
 5/15/07
 It appears "Myths & Realities" content was written using only JW sources, who seem adept at polishing sharp edges off their dogmas to appear righteous. There are beliefs listed here that have glossy surface explanations, but don't hit the truth. One example: "Jehovah's Witnesses do not fit the definition of a cult." It is a SMALL religion: it never registers on any country�s religion statistics and they represent ~.1% of the world�s population. www.dictionary.com defines CULT as "a religion or sect considered to be false, unorthodox, or extremist, with members often living outside of conventional society under the direction of a charismatic leader." JWs primarily deny they are a cult because there isn�t one human who represents a charismatic leader. However, they are directed by a small, all-male, all-white governing body that claims to get its direction directly from Jehovah via prayer and their bible; they are extreme in enforcing their belief system; and they do live outside conventional society. It is a fact most JW children are only allowed JW friends; many children are home-schooled to prevent them from interacting with non-believers; voting is prohibited, as is involvement in any non-JW cause. Non-JWs are viewed as either potential JWs or sadly lost. JWs consider themselves "no part of this world" even though physically living amongst non-believers. JWs mince words to say the term CULT doesn't apply to them, but the therapy process for recovering JWs is uncannily similar to the therapy process offered to recovering cult members.
 5/15/07
 Dear Cate (5-12) I'm glad that your JW aunt and cousins associate with you. The religion does not require that they do not associate with family that has never been a member. Ask them if they are taught to not speak to or associate with a person who is a former member and you will find that the answer is yes. For those of us who are former members, we would love to be able to visit our families a couple times a year, write and be written to, e-mail, and send packages back and forth as you do. We cannot have the same relationship that you have. We do not hate them, we love them and miss them and want desperately to have a relationship with them. What we are "ranting" about as you call it, is that this religion forces it's people to shun us. So please do not confuse the treatment you receive with the experience that we former members have. We do not hate Jehovah's Witnesses, but they are taught to hate us.
 As for your KKK comment, let me ask you this. Would you go to the KKK to find out about the inside workings of the group or would you go to a former member who is trying to expose the evil? It's the same concept here. Those of us who were on the inside at one time know the real story. And yes, there are plenty of JWs attacking people on this forum.
 5/15/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Claudia: You say JWs aren't Christians and they don't believe Jesus is God. Where in God's Word does it say one must believe the Trinity Doctrine to be a Christian? If that were true, that eliminates all Jesus' disciples and all early Christians until the end of the 4th Century when the doctrine was forced upon Christians under the threat of death. Contrary to using only the NWT, I use many translations. Who told you these things? You say the NWT has been altered and twisted to our beliefs. Greek scholar (a NON-JW) Dr. Jason BeDuhn of the University of Northern Arizona doesn't agree with you. His book: Truth in Translation, (University Press of America) states that in his comparison of 8 translations, "the NWT emerges as the most accurate of the translations compared. Holding a close second to the NWT in its accuracy...is the NAB....The translators [of both] managed to produce works relatively MORE ACCURATE and LESS BIASED than the translations produced by multi-denominational teams, as well as those produced by single individuals." I suggest you get a copy of Dr. BeDuhn's book. It will open your eyes, if you allow it. Your post makes me think you have read the same rantings of hate-books against JWs. Are you now an authority qualified to judge JWs by the prejudicial writings of others? Get to know JW's at their meetings, study the Bible with them to see what they really believe before you join in with the falsehoods others have espoused.
 5/15/07
 Tanya
 Oregon
 Thank you for the very balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses shown in the documentary, "Knocking". I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses 25 years ago after much religious searching. I attended many different churches, read about religion, studied several different religions and beliefs of different "christian" denominations. I used many different bible versions and translations and after over five years of study, came to believe through searching the scriptures and comparing JW's beliefs and activities, that I had found the truth of Jehovah God and Christ. The Witness who studied with me encouraged me to read, and ask questions and search for the truth I'm very sorry for those who have had bad experiences. I have neither experienced nor seen others(in several different congregations)experience such things. I knew about disfellow-shipping before I was baptized. JW's more than most denominations, IMHO, know what we're getting into before we're baptized. There is such a permissive society in many countries today and many people seem to think they will not experience consequences to their actions...that they will not reap what they sow. I thank Jehovah daily for leading me to Christ.
 5/15/07
 There needs to be some clarification. Jehovah's Witnesses DO associate with family members that are not JW, as long as they never were. However, if they were formerly a baptized JW, but are not one any longer, then they are shunned. Once you are a baptized JW the rules change. You never can leave & maintain any of the relationships you had within the organization. No matter how hard you try to be tolerant of their beliefs, they are completely intolerant of yours. I have cousins that were raised in the JWs & left when they grew up, but since they were not baptized JWs they can still associate with the rest of the family. Some of these left to pursue immoral lifestyles, but since they were not baptized, the rule of shunning doesn't apply. I left because I just didn't agree with some of the things I was taught. I've NEVER been an immoral person. I love Jehovah, follow his son, & live a very Christian life. But I did not agree with & accept everything they taught. My biggest mistake was getting baptized as a child. While my cousins did not get baptized & are not shunned, I have been completely cut out of the family. If my family wants to stay in this religion, that is their choice. It's not my job to change them. I love them no matter what & would never shun them. However, I am not afforded that same respect. I am shunned.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_h.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/21/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 Although Jehovah�s witnesses are a peaceful non-violent organization, well noted for their neutrality and passivity, they nonetheless employ a pedagogy that encourages religious intolerance among its members and a myopic view of the world. Their recent campaign last October touting the end of false religion as being near seems only to add the noise of religious extremism that seems to be so pervasive in much of the world today. Even mainstream Christianity has garnered some notable attention with the pope�s denunciation of Islamic faiths as being fundamentally violent in the teachings - for which he later apologized. Yet the witnesses consistently raise their rhetoric calling for divine intervention to bring an end to religions apart from theirs. They preach a warning message of coming divine retribution upon all religions who have kept people in spiritual darkness and dire consequences to those who fail to heed the warning to leave their religions. Borrowing symbolic expressions from the book of Revelation they lump all religions apart from theirs into a figurative �Babylon the Great� -world empire of false religion and as religious harlots who prostitute themselves with the nations of the world because of not remaining neutral to political affairs. Their condemnation of other religious can at best be termed unskillful � a term used to define religions that are agonistic towards individuals that share differing beliefs. Rather than seeking common ground through an understanding of other religious ideas and beliefs their message is one that drives a wedge between them and others.
 5/21/07
 Huntington Beach, California
 There is so much ignorance and misinformation, even on this message board, and people who ignorantly and emotionally rant without knowledge or experience, or knowing their facts. I am a Jehovah's Witness for 32 years now, and I want to thank the makers of this film for their candid and accurate portrayal of my faith. I will share this documentary with all of my non-witness friends (yes I do have them) and relatives in an effort for them to better understand ME and why I do the things I do.
 This documentary is excellently executed and I highly recommend it, even to the ones on this board who I know haven't even seen it....It makes me PROUD to call myself one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/21/07
 Ralph
 Boston Massachusetts
 Although the film Knocking showed Jehovah's Witnesses in a Favorable light. I cannot help but think how my mother lost all her friends when Jehovah's Witnesses began to study with her. They told me that they saw a big change in her personality and that she seemed like a different person. They thought she was being indoctrinated. After a while my mother abandoned her friends and soley focused on the demands of her new religion
 5/18/07
 Seth
 Britain
 I was born in 1965 to Jehovah�s Witness parents, one of four children. I had a great childhood. Raised by two parents who loved and cherished all their children. We enjoyed such good times. My dad was a zealous minister and instilled in me a weekly ministry. Each Saturday morning we would be out �knocking�. I live in Britain and the only problem was that on a Saturday morning Happy Days featuring the Fonz was aired, a program I really enjoyed. It didn�t go out until 11:30 though and each week we were out �knocking� we always seemed to end up in front of a T.V. either back at ours or a friends house by 11:30. I took it all for granted at the time but looking back I realize that my being able to watch my favourite T.V. show was no accident. I relate this in the hope that it gives some kind of insight as to how my parents approached parenthood as Jehovah�s Witnesses. I could recount many other examples of such a loving balanced approach by two people trying their sincere best to give their children the best start they could in life. And today? All four children (I have a brother and two sisters) are baptized JW�s happy active members of their congregations. Looking forward to the future, particularly the day we welcome our dad back at the resurrection. Finally, my 15 year old enjoys watching the re-runs of "Happy Days." And I remember happy days.
 5/18/07
 Rob S.
 St. Louis, MO
 I have not seen this film yet as it will be airing very soon but after reading the website and some of the other comments here i have to say that i was not born to a family of JW's but my dad married my stepmom who was and wheni moved in with them in my mid teens i began to study and decided to get baptized(all the while struggling with my hidden secret that i was gay) thinking that this would cure me but that was not the case and i got disfellowshipped...i love my dad and stepmom very much and think them for my up-bringing as even tho i live my life for me instead of jehovah's ways i still follow most of the things that i was taught & i do still beleive everything that i was taught. but because of my leaving i have lost all contact with my dad and stepmom to which i would very much like to have that bond that we once had back but i know that will never happen. it is very hard at times for me to try to explain my beliefs to my life-partner so i am hoping that this film will help him understand many of my beliefs that i have like the stand on blood and holidays...again thank you very much for this film.
 5/18/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Some have accused JWs of using "mind control techniques" to "convert" people. Over the past 50 years, I have had the privilege of helping 50 people to come to know Bible truth and dedicate themselves to serving Jehovah. I have never used any "mind control techniques". In fact, I don't have a clue as to what mind control techniques are, and wouldn't use such even if I knew what they were! Why not? Because Jehovah wants willing worshipers and servants! At Ps. 110:3 it says that Jehovah's people will offer themselves willingly. Just as Jehovah rejected the offering up of sick & blemished animals at one time by his ancient people, our motives must be pure and clean. Worship and service to Jehovah must come from our hearts out of love for God and mankind to be acceptable to Him. So there is no room (or need) to employ such techniques on anyone. No one is ever forced to worship or serve God. Such accusations are simply more false lies. Remember: "He, convinced against his will, is of the same opinion still!"
 5/18/07
 Dan
 Washington
 In responds to Leanna in Avondale, AZ on 5/8/07. If you feel JW�s should not accept health care from the government and hand outs then why should they pay taxes to support these hand outs? Also if one would consider JW�s as a cult then check out the information at the website http://www.adherents.com/adh_rb.html
 5/18/07
 George Miller
 Ft. Worth, Texas
 I was raised as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I respect many of the religions teachings. Some of the values I gained from the religion: honesty, racial equality, respect for the elderly and disabled, environmental responsibility, courage. I need to mention these positive aspects first because now, 20 years after leaving, I am finally dealing with the deep resentments I have about my childhood. The faith instilled in me a very deep and destructive paranoia. I was told daily by my mother, friends, everyone, that the world was on the brink of destruction. My responsibility was to be free of sin or die in that destruction. The desire to commit a sin meant destruction as well. And God monitors my every desire. I was taught to fear an Angry God. Because I happened to be one of "God's Chosen People," I also had to constantly be on guard against the VERY REAL prescence of Satan and his demons. I was in constant peril, particularly when I was alone or at school. I practiced in the event that demons invaded my elementary school classroom and started an attack on my classmates. Anything could cause them to come but the T.V. shows "Bewitched" or "I Dream of Jeanie" and plastic figurines of "Smurfs" were a sure-fire way to conjure thier prescence. These terrors seem comical now, they certainly were not when I was a boy. I can only submit 250 words today. I'll write more later.
 5/18/07
 Thank you Joel for producing this film, it was realistic. We who are Jehovah's Witnesses realize were imperfect and make mistakes and we do not apply the Bible perfectly, no one in the world does. Jesus Christ was the only man on Earth who could, so there will always be someone to critize us, it is to be expected. We're all trying to do what is right and we do need to be kind to our families who are not JW's and how we interact with them is our business we do not need to answer to anyone about that. I do feel this site is going to be aconstant attack on us and that is a shame because you tried to get discussion on religion and personal freedoms. Good for you.
 5/18/07
 As a child growing up a JW, it was a very sheltered, suppressed life. I do not study anymore but I do base my morals on some of the things I learned.Though JW can seem unrelenting, I respect them. Everyone has a right to choose their path. If you choose this path then it only seems right that you follow that path to the fullest.I choose no religion. For the path that I must take is a personal path between myself and God. As selfish as that my sound to you, that's how I view it.
 I don't agree with shunning family and friends as I don't believe Jehovah or Jesus would do that, no matter what. I don't agree with telling children the end of the world is coming soon. Putting this type of nightmare in young children is hypocritical. Yet Parents protect their children from violent TV, movies, video games etc. This alone made my childhood terrifying, and I would not wish it upon any other child.
 5/18/07
 unbelievable!!! just reading the negative responses to this documentary sickens me. what you think about the beliefs of this religious group, or how you feel about them is not the issue here. because of their fight for religious freedom. their tenacity and fight for upholding their rights and your rights as united states citizens has won you, yes YOU the right to be who you are, and have freedom of speech, say what you want to say, and uphold your own constitutional rights according to the constitutional law of the united states. need i say more????? PLEASE!!!!!!
 5/15/07
 It appears "Myths & Realities" content was written using only JW sources, who seem adept at polishing sharp edges off their dogmas to appear righteous. There are beliefs listed here that have glossy surface explanations, but don't hit the truth. One example: "Jehovah's Witnesses do not fit the definition of a cult." It is a SMALL religion: it never registers on any country�s religion statistics and they represent ~.1% of the world�s population. www.dictionary.com defines CULT as "a religion or sect considered to be false, unorthodox, or extremist, with members often living outside of conventional society under the direction of a charismatic leader." JWs primarily deny they are a cult because there isn�t one human who represents a charismatic leader. However, they are directed by a small, all-male, all-white governing body that claims to get its direction directly from Jehovah via prayer and their bible; they are extreme in enforcing their belief system; and they do live outside conventional society. It is a fact most JW children are only allowed JW friends; many children are home-schooled to prevent them from interacting with non-believers; voting is prohibited, as is involvement in any non-JW cause. Non-JWs are viewed as either potential JWs or sadly lost. JWs consider themselves "no part of this world" even though physically living amongst non-believers. JWs mince words to say the term CULT doesn't apply to them, but the therapy process for recovering JWs is uncannily similar to the therapy process offered to recovering cult members.
 5/15/07
 Dear Cate (5-12) I'm glad that your JW aunt and cousins associate with you. The religion does not require that they do not associate with family that has never been a member. Ask them if they are taught to not speak to or associate with a person who is a former member and you will find that the answer is yes. For those of us who are former members, we would love to be able to visit our families a couple times a year, write and be written to, e-mail, and send packages back and forth as you do. We cannot have the same relationship that you have. We do not hate them, we love them and miss them and want desperately to have a relationship with them. What we are "ranting" about as you call it, is that this religion forces it's people to shun us. So please do not confuse the treatment you receive with the experience that we former members have. We do not hate Jehovah's Witnesses, but they are taught to hate us.
 As for your KKK comment, let me ask you this. Would you go to the KKK to find out about the inside workings of the group or would you go to a former member who is trying to expose the evil? It's the same concept here. Those of us who were on the inside at one time know the real story. And yes, there are plenty of JWs attacking people on this forum.
 5/15/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Claudia: You say JWs aren't Christians and they don't believe Jesus is God. Where in God's Word does it say one must believe the Trinity Doctrine to be a Christian? If that were true, that eliminates all Jesus' disciples and all early Christians until the end of the 4th Century when the doctrine was forced upon Christians under the threat of death. Contrary to using only the NWT, I use many translations. Who told you these things? You say the NWT has been altered and twisted to our beliefs. Greek scholar (a NON-JW) Dr. Jason BeDuhn of the University of Northern Arizona doesn't agree with you. His book: Truth in Translation, (University Press of America) states that in his comparison of 8 translations, "the NWT emerges as the most accurate of the translations compared. Holding a close second to the NWT in its accuracy...is the NAB....The translators [of both] managed to produce works relatively MORE ACCURATE and LESS BIASED than the translations produced by multi-denominational teams, as well as those produced by single individuals." I suggest you get a copy of Dr. BeDuhn's book. It will open your eyes, if you allow it. Your post makes me think you have read the same rantings of hate-books against JWs. Are you now an authority qualified to judge JWs by the prejudicial writings of others? Get to know JW's at their meetings, study the Bible with them to see what they really believe before you join in with the falsehoods others have espoused.
 5/15/07
 Tanya
 Oregon
 Thank you for the very balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses shown in the documentary, "Knocking". I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses 25 years ago after much religious searching. I attended many different churches, read about religion, studied several different religions and beliefs of different "christian" denominations. I used many different bible versions and translations and after over five years of study, came to believe through searching the scriptures and comparing JW's beliefs and activities, that I had found the truth of Jehovah God and Christ. The Witness who studied with me encouraged me to read, and ask questions and search for the truth I'm very sorry for those who have had bad experiences. I have neither experienced nor seen others(in several different congregations)experience such things. I knew about disfellow-shipping before I was baptized. JW's more than most denominations, IMHO, know what we're getting into before we're baptized. There is such a permissive society in many countries today and many people seem to think they will not experience consequences to their actions...that they will not reap what they sow. I thank Jehovah daily for leading me to Christ.
 5/15/07
 There needs to be some clarification. Jehovah's Witnesses DO associate with family members that are not JW, as long as they never were. However, if they were formerly a baptized JW, but are not one any longer, then they are shunned. Once you are a baptized JW the rules change. You never can leave & maintain any of the relationships you had within the organization. No matter how hard you try to be tolerant of their beliefs, they are completely intolerant of yours. I have cousins that were raised in the JWs & left when they grew up, but since they were not baptized JWs they can still associate with the rest of the family. Some of these left to pursue immoral lifestyles, but since they were not baptized, the rule of shunning doesn't apply. I left because I just didn't agree with some of the things I was taught. I've NEVER been an immoral person. I love Jehovah, follow his son, & live a very Christian life. But I did not agree with & accept everything they taught. My biggest mistake was getting baptized as a child. While my cousins did not get baptized & are not shunned, I have been completely cut out of the family. If my family wants to stay in this religion, that is their choice. It's not my job to change them. I love them no matter what & would never shun them. However, I am not afforded that same respect. I am shunned.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_h.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/21/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 Although Jehovah�s witnesses are a peaceful non-violent organization, well noted for their neutrality and passivity, they nonetheless employ a pedagogy that encourages religious intolerance among its members and a myopic view of the world. Their recent campaign last October touting the end of false religion as being near seems only to add the noise of religious extremism that seems to be so pervasive in much of the world today. Even mainstream Christianity has garnered some notable attention with the pope�s denunciation of Islamic faiths as being fundamentally violent in the teachings - for which he later apologized. Yet the witnesses consistently raise their rhetoric calling for divine intervention to bring an end to religions apart from theirs. They preach a warning message of coming divine retribution upon all religions who have kept people in spiritual darkness and dire consequences to those who fail to heed the warning to leave their religions. Borrowing symbolic expressions from the book of Revelation they lump all religions apart from theirs into a figurative �Babylon the Great� -world empire of false religion and as religious harlots who prostitute themselves with the nations of the world because of not remaining neutral to political affairs. Their condemnation of other religious can at best be termed unskillful � a term used to define religions that are agonistic towards individuals that share differing beliefs. Rather than seeking common ground through an understanding of other religious ideas and beliefs their message is one that drives a wedge between them and others.
 5/21/07
 Huntington Beach, California
 There is so much ignorance and misinformation, even on this message board, and people who ignorantly and emotionally rant without knowledge or experience, or knowing their facts. I am a Jehovah's Witness for 32 years now, and I want to thank the makers of this film for their candid and accurate portrayal of my faith. I will share this documentary with all of my non-witness friends (yes I do have them) and relatives in an effort for them to better understand ME and why I do the things I do.
 This documentary is excellently executed and I highly recommend it, even to the ones on this board who I know haven't even seen it....It makes me PROUD to call myself one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/21/07
 Ralph
 Boston Massachusetts
 Although the film Knocking showed Jehovah's Witnesses in a Favorable light. I cannot help but think how my mother lost all her friends when Jehovah's Witnesses began to study with her. They told me that they saw a big change in her personality and that she seemed like a different person. They thought she was being indoctrinated. After a while my mother abandoned her friends and soley focused on the demands of her new religion
 5/18/07
 Seth
 Britain
 I was born in 1965 to Jehovah�s Witness parents, one of four children. I had a great childhood. Raised by two parents who loved and cherished all their children. We enjoyed such good times. My dad was a zealous minister and instilled in me a weekly ministry. Each Saturday morning we would be out �knocking�. I live in Britain and the only problem was that on a Saturday morning Happy Days featuring the Fonz was aired, a program I really enjoyed. It didn�t go out until 11:30 though and each week we were out �knocking� we always seemed to end up in front of a T.V. either back at ours or a friends house by 11:30. I took it all for granted at the time but looking back I realize that my being able to watch my favourite T.V. show was no accident. I relate this in the hope that it gives some kind of insight as to how my parents approached parenthood as Jehovah�s Witnesses. I could recount many other examples of such a loving balanced approach by two people trying their sincere best to give their children the best start they could in life. And today? All four children (I have a brother and two sisters) are baptized JW�s happy active members of their congregations. Looking forward to the future, particularly the day we welcome our dad back at the resurrection. Finally, my 15 year old enjoys watching the re-runs of "Happy Days." And I remember happy days.
 5/18/07
 Rob S.
 St. Louis, MO
 I have not seen this film yet as it will be airing very soon but after reading the website and some of the other comments here i have to say that i was not born to a family of JW's but my dad married my stepmom who was and wheni moved in with them in my mid teens i began to study and decided to get baptized(all the while struggling with my hidden secret that i was gay) thinking that this would cure me but that was not the case and i got disfellowshipped...i love my dad and stepmom very much and think them for my up-bringing as even tho i live my life for me instead of jehovah's ways i still follow most of the things that i was taught & i do still beleive everything that i was taught. but because of my leaving i have lost all contact with my dad and stepmom to which i would very much like to have that bond that we once had back but i know that will never happen. it is very hard at times for me to try to explain my beliefs to my life-partner so i am hoping that this film will help him understand many of my beliefs that i have like the stand on blood and holidays...again thank you very much for this film.
 5/18/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Some have accused JWs of using "mind control techniques" to "convert" people. Over the past 50 years, I have had the privilege of helping 50 people to come to know Bible truth and dedicate themselves to serving Jehovah. I have never used any "mind control techniques". In fact, I don't have a clue as to what mind control techniques are, and wouldn't use such even if I knew what they were! Why not? Because Jehovah wants willing worshipers and servants! At Ps. 110:3 it says that Jehovah's people will offer themselves willingly. Just as Jehovah rejected the offering up of sick & blemished animals at one time by his ancient people, our motives must be pure and clean. Worship and service to Jehovah must come from our hearts out of love for God and mankind to be acceptable to Him. So there is no room (or need) to employ such techniques on anyone. No one is ever forced to worship or serve God. Such accusations are simply more false lies. Remember: "He, convinced against his will, is of the same opinion still!"
 5/18/07
 Dan
 Washington
 In responds to Leanna in Avondale, AZ on 5/8/07. If you feel JW�s should not accept health care from the government and hand outs then why should they pay taxes to support these hand outs? Also if one would consider JW�s as a cult then check out the information at the website http://www.adherents.com/adh_rb.html
 5/18/07
 George Miller
 Ft. Worth, Texas
 I was raised as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I respect many of the religions teachings. Some of the values I gained from the religion: honesty, racial equality, respect for the elderly and disabled, environmental responsibility, courage. I need to mention these positive aspects first because now, 20 years after leaving, I am finally dealing with the deep resentments I have about my childhood. The faith instilled in me a very deep and destructive paranoia. I was told daily by my mother, friends, everyone, that the world was on the brink of destruction. My responsibility was to be free of sin or die in that destruction. The desire to commit a sin meant destruction as well. And God monitors my every desire. I was taught to fear an Angry God. Because I happened to be one of "God's Chosen People," I also had to constantly be on guard against the VERY REAL prescence of Satan and his demons. I was in constant peril, particularly when I was alone or at school. I practiced in the event that demons invaded my elementary school classroom and started an attack on my classmates. Anything could cause them to come but the T.V. shows "Bewitched" or "I Dream of Jeanie" and plastic figurines of "Smurfs" were a sure-fire way to conjure thier prescence. These terrors seem comical now, they certainly were not when I was a boy. I can only submit 250 words today. I'll write more later.
 5/18/07
 Thank you Joel for producing this film, it was realistic. We who are Jehovah's Witnesses realize were imperfect and make mistakes and we do not apply the Bible perfectly, no one in the world does. Jesus Christ was the only man on Earth who could, so there will always be someone to critize us, it is to be expected. We're all trying to do what is right and we do need to be kind to our families who are not JW's and how we interact with them is our business we do not need to answer to anyone about that. I do feel this site is going to be aconstant attack on us and that is a shame because you tried to get discussion on religion and personal freedoms. Good for you.
 5/18/07
 As a child growing up a JW, it was a very sheltered, suppressed life. I do not study anymore but I do base my morals on some of the things I learned.Though JW can seem unrelenting, I respect them. Everyone has a right to choose their path. If you choose this path then it only seems right that you follow that path to the fullest.I choose no religion. For the path that I must take is a personal path between myself and God. As selfish as that my sound to you, that's how I view it.
 I don't agree with shunning family and friends as I don't believe Jehovah or Jesus would do that, no matter what. I don't agree with telling children the end of the world is coming soon. Putting this type of nightmare in young children is hypocritical. Yet Parents protect their children from violent TV, movies, video games etc. This alone made my childhood terrifying, and I would not wish it upon any other child.
 5/18/07
 unbelievable!!! just reading the negative responses to this documentary sickens me. what you think about the beliefs of this religious group, or how you feel about them is not the issue here. because of their fight for religious freedom. their tenacity and fight for upholding their rights and your rights as united states citizens has won you, yes YOU the right to be who you are, and have freedom of speech, say what you want to say, and uphold your own constitutional rights according to the constitutional law of the united states. need i say more????? PLEASE!!!!!!
 5/15/07
 It appears "Myths & Realities" content was written using only JW sources, who seem adept at polishing sharp edges off their dogmas to appear righteous. There are beliefs listed here that have glossy surface explanations, but don't hit the truth. One example: "Jehovah's Witnesses do not fit the definition of a cult." It is a SMALL religion: it never registers on any country�s religion statistics and they represent ~.1% of the world�s population. www.dictionary.com defines CULT as "a religion or sect considered to be false, unorthodox, or extremist, with members often living outside of conventional society under the direction of a charismatic leader." JWs primarily deny they are a cult because there isn�t one human who represents a charismatic leader. However, they are directed by a small, all-male, all-white governing body that claims to get its direction directly from Jehovah via prayer and their bible; they are extreme in enforcing their belief system; and they do live outside conventional society. It is a fact most JW children are only allowed JW friends; many children are home-schooled to prevent them from interacting with non-believers; voting is prohibited, as is involvement in any non-JW cause. Non-JWs are viewed as either potential JWs or sadly lost. JWs consider themselves "no part of this world" even though physically living amongst non-believers. JWs mince words to say the term CULT doesn't apply to them, but the therapy process for recovering JWs is uncannily similar to the therapy process offered to recovering cult members.
 5/15/07
 Dear Cate (5-12) I'm glad that your JW aunt and cousins associate with you. The religion does not require that they do not associate with family that has never been a member. Ask them if they are taught to not speak to or associate with a person who is a former member and you will find that the answer is yes. For those of us who are former members, we would love to be able to visit our families a couple times a year, write and be written to, e-mail, and send packages back and forth as you do. We cannot have the same relationship that you have. We do not hate them, we love them and miss them and want desperately to have a relationship with them. What we are "ranting" about as you call it, is that this religion forces it's people to shun us. So please do not confuse the treatment you receive with the experience that we former members have. We do not hate Jehovah's Witnesses, but they are taught to hate us.
 As for your KKK comment, let me ask you this. Would you go to the KKK to find out about the inside workings of the group or would you go to a former member who is trying to expose the evil? It's the same concept here. Those of us who were on the inside at one time know the real story. And yes, there are plenty of JWs attacking people on this forum.
 5/15/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Claudia: You say JWs aren't Christians and they don't believe Jesus is God. Where in God's Word does it say one must believe the Trinity Doctrine to be a Christian? If that were true, that eliminates all Jesus' disciples and all early Christians until the end of the 4th Century when the doctrine was forced upon Christians under the threat of death. Contrary to using only the NWT, I use many translations. Who told you these things? You say the NWT has been altered and twisted to our beliefs. Greek scholar (a NON-JW) Dr. Jason BeDuhn of the University of Northern Arizona doesn't agree with you. His book: Truth in Translation, (University Press of America) states that in his comparison of 8 translations, "the NWT emerges as the most accurate of the translations compared. Holding a close second to the NWT in its accuracy...is the NAB....The translators [of both] managed to produce works relatively MORE ACCURATE and LESS BIASED than the translations produced by multi-denominational teams, as well as those produced by single individuals." I suggest you get a copy of Dr. BeDuhn's book. It will open your eyes, if you allow it. Your post makes me think you have read the same rantings of hate-books against JWs. Are you now an authority qualified to judge JWs by the prejudicial writings of others? Get to know JW's at their meetings, study the Bible with them to see what they really believe before you join in with the falsehoods others have espoused.
 5/15/07
 Tanya
 Oregon
 Thank you for the very balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses shown in the documentary, "Knocking". I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses 25 years ago after much religious searching. I attended many different churches, read about religion, studied several different religions and beliefs of different "christian" denominations. I used many different bible versions and translations and after over five years of study, came to believe through searching the scriptures and comparing JW's beliefs and activities, that I had found the truth of Jehovah God and Christ. The Witness who studied with me encouraged me to read, and ask questions and search for the truth I'm very sorry for those who have had bad experiences. I have neither experienced nor seen others(in several different congregations)experience such things. I knew about disfellow-shipping before I was baptized. JW's more than most denominations, IMHO, know what we're getting into before we're baptized. There is such a permissive society in many countries today and many people seem to think they will not experience consequences to their actions...that they will not reap what they sow. I thank Jehovah daily for leading me to Christ.
 5/15/07
 There needs to be some clarification. Jehovah's Witnesses DO associate with family members that are not JW, as long as they never were. However, if they were formerly a baptized JW, but are not one any longer, then they are shunned. Once you are a baptized JW the rules change. You never can leave & maintain any of the relationships you had within the organization. No matter how hard you try to be tolerant of their beliefs, they are completely intolerant of yours. I have cousins that were raised in the JWs & left when they grew up, but since they were not baptized JWs they can still associate with the rest of the family. Some of these left to pursue immoral lifestyles, but since they were not baptized, the rule of shunning doesn't apply. I left because I just didn't agree with some of the things I was taught. I've NEVER been an immoral person. I love Jehovah, follow his son, & live a very Christian life. But I did not agree with & accept everything they taught. My biggest mistake was getting baptized as a child. While my cousins did not get baptized & are not shunned, I have been completely cut out of the family. If my family wants to stay in this religion, that is their choice. It's not my job to change them. I love them no matter what & would never shun them. However, I am not afforded that same respect. I am shunned.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_i.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/21/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 Although Jehovah�s witnesses are a peaceful non-violent organization, well noted for their neutrality and passivity, they nonetheless employ a pedagogy that encourages religious intolerance among its members and a myopic view of the world. Their recent campaign last October touting the end of false religion as being near seems only to add the noise of religious extremism that seems to be so pervasive in much of the world today. Even mainstream Christianity has garnered some notable attention with the pope�s denunciation of Islamic faiths as being fundamentally violent in the teachings - for which he later apologized. Yet the witnesses consistently raise their rhetoric calling for divine intervention to bring an end to religions apart from theirs. They preach a warning message of coming divine retribution upon all religions who have kept people in spiritual darkness and dire consequences to those who fail to heed the warning to leave their religions. Borrowing symbolic expressions from the book of Revelation they lump all religions apart from theirs into a figurative �Babylon the Great� -world empire of false religion and as religious harlots who prostitute themselves with the nations of the world because of not remaining neutral to political affairs. Their condemnation of other religious can at best be termed unskillful � a term used to define religions that are agonistic towards individuals that share differing beliefs. Rather than seeking common ground through an understanding of other religious ideas and beliefs their message is one that drives a wedge between them and others.
 5/21/07
 Huntington Beach, California
 There is so much ignorance and misinformation, even on this message board, and people who ignorantly and emotionally rant without knowledge or experience, or knowing their facts. I am a Jehovah's Witness for 32 years now, and I want to thank the makers of this film for their candid and accurate portrayal of my faith. I will share this documentary with all of my non-witness friends (yes I do have them) and relatives in an effort for them to better understand ME and why I do the things I do.
 This documentary is excellently executed and I highly recommend it, even to the ones on this board who I know haven't even seen it....It makes me PROUD to call myself one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/21/07
 Ralph
 Boston Massachusetts
 Although the film Knocking showed Jehovah's Witnesses in a Favorable light. I cannot help but think how my mother lost all her friends when Jehovah's Witnesses began to study with her. They told me that they saw a big change in her personality and that she seemed like a different person. They thought she was being indoctrinated. After a while my mother abandoned her friends and soley focused on the demands of her new religion
 5/18/07
 Seth
 Britain
 I was born in 1965 to Jehovah�s Witness parents, one of four children. I had a great childhood. Raised by two parents who loved and cherished all their children. We enjoyed such good times. My dad was a zealous minister and instilled in me a weekly ministry. Each Saturday morning we would be out �knocking�. I live in Britain and the only problem was that on a Saturday morning Happy Days featuring the Fonz was aired, a program I really enjoyed. It didn�t go out until 11:30 though and each week we were out �knocking� we always seemed to end up in front of a T.V. either back at ours or a friends house by 11:30. I took it all for granted at the time but looking back I realize that my being able to watch my favourite T.V. show was no accident. I relate this in the hope that it gives some kind of insight as to how my parents approached parenthood as Jehovah�s Witnesses. I could recount many other examples of such a loving balanced approach by two people trying their sincere best to give their children the best start they could in life. And today? All four children (I have a brother and two sisters) are baptized JW�s happy active members of their congregations. Looking forward to the future, particularly the day we welcome our dad back at the resurrection. Finally, my 15 year old enjoys watching the re-runs of "Happy Days." And I remember happy days.
 5/18/07
 Rob S.
 St. Louis, MO
 I have not seen this film yet as it will be airing very soon but after reading the website and some of the other comments here i have to say that i was not born to a family of JW's but my dad married my stepmom who was and wheni moved in with them in my mid teens i began to study and decided to get baptized(all the while struggling with my hidden secret that i was gay) thinking that this would cure me but that was not the case and i got disfellowshipped...i love my dad and stepmom very much and think them for my up-bringing as even tho i live my life for me instead of jehovah's ways i still follow most of the things that i was taught & i do still beleive everything that i was taught. but because of my leaving i have lost all contact with my dad and stepmom to which i would very much like to have that bond that we once had back but i know that will never happen. it is very hard at times for me to try to explain my beliefs to my life-partner so i am hoping that this film will help him understand many of my beliefs that i have like the stand on blood and holidays...again thank you very much for this film.
 5/18/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Some have accused JWs of using "mind control techniques" to "convert" people. Over the past 50 years, I have had the privilege of helping 50 people to come to know Bible truth and dedicate themselves to serving Jehovah. I have never used any "mind control techniques". In fact, I don't have a clue as to what mind control techniques are, and wouldn't use such even if I knew what they were! Why not? Because Jehovah wants willing worshipers and servants! At Ps. 110:3 it says that Jehovah's people will offer themselves willingly. Just as Jehovah rejected the offering up of sick & blemished animals at one time by his ancient people, our motives must be pure and clean. Worship and service to Jehovah must come from our hearts out of love for God and mankind to be acceptable to Him. So there is no room (or need) to employ such techniques on anyone. No one is ever forced to worship or serve God. Such accusations are simply more false lies. Remember: "He, convinced against his will, is of the same opinion still!"
 5/18/07
 Dan
 Washington
 In responds to Leanna in Avondale, AZ on 5/8/07. If you feel JW�s should not accept health care from the government and hand outs then why should they pay taxes to support these hand outs? Also if one would consider JW�s as a cult then check out the information at the website http://www.adherents.com/adh_rb.html
 5/18/07
 George Miller
 Ft. Worth, Texas
 I was raised as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I respect many of the religions teachings. Some of the values I gained from the religion: honesty, racial equality, respect for the elderly and disabled, environmental responsibility, courage. I need to mention these positive aspects first because now, 20 years after leaving, I am finally dealing with the deep resentments I have about my childhood. The faith instilled in me a very deep and destructive paranoia. I was told daily by my mother, friends, everyone, that the world was on the brink of destruction. My responsibility was to be free of sin or die in that destruction. The desire to commit a sin meant destruction as well. And God monitors my every desire. I was taught to fear an Angry God. Because I happened to be one of "God's Chosen People," I also had to constantly be on guard against the VERY REAL prescence of Satan and his demons. I was in constant peril, particularly when I was alone or at school. I practiced in the event that demons invaded my elementary school classroom and started an attack on my classmates. Anything could cause them to come but the T.V. shows "Bewitched" or "I Dream of Jeanie" and plastic figurines of "Smurfs" were a sure-fire way to conjure thier prescence. These terrors seem comical now, they certainly were not when I was a boy. I can only submit 250 words today. I'll write more later.
 5/18/07
 Thank you Joel for producing this film, it was realistic. We who are Jehovah's Witnesses realize were imperfect and make mistakes and we do not apply the Bible perfectly, no one in the world does. Jesus Christ was the only man on Earth who could, so there will always be someone to critize us, it is to be expected. We're all trying to do what is right and we do need to be kind to our families who are not JW's and how we interact with them is our business we do not need to answer to anyone about that. I do feel this site is going to be aconstant attack on us and that is a shame because you tried to get discussion on religion and personal freedoms. Good for you.
 5/18/07
 As a child growing up a JW, it was a very sheltered, suppressed life. I do not study anymore but I do base my morals on some of the things I learned.Though JW can seem unrelenting, I respect them. Everyone has a right to choose their path. If you choose this path then it only seems right that you follow that path to the fullest.I choose no religion. For the path that I must take is a personal path between myself and God. As selfish as that my sound to you, that's how I view it.
 I don't agree with shunning family and friends as I don't believe Jehovah or Jesus would do that, no matter what. I don't agree with telling children the end of the world is coming soon. Putting this type of nightmare in young children is hypocritical. Yet Parents protect their children from violent TV, movies, video games etc. This alone made my childhood terrifying, and I would not wish it upon any other child.
 5/18/07
 unbelievable!!! just reading the negative responses to this documentary sickens me. what you think about the beliefs of this religious group, or how you feel about them is not the issue here. because of their fight for religious freedom. their tenacity and fight for upholding their rights and your rights as united states citizens has won you, yes YOU the right to be who you are, and have freedom of speech, say what you want to say, and uphold your own constitutional rights according to the constitutional law of the united states. need i say more????? PLEASE!!!!!!
 5/15/07
 It appears "Myths & Realities" content was written using only JW sources, who seem adept at polishing sharp edges off their dogmas to appear righteous. There are beliefs listed here that have glossy surface explanations, but don't hit the truth. One example: "Jehovah's Witnesses do not fit the definition of a cult." It is a SMALL religion: it never registers on any country�s religion statistics and they represent ~.1% of the world�s population. www.dictionary.com defines CULT as "a religion or sect considered to be false, unorthodox, or extremist, with members often living outside of conventional society under the direction of a charismatic leader." JWs primarily deny they are a cult because there isn�t one human who represents a charismatic leader. However, they are directed by a small, all-male, all-white governing body that claims to get its direction directly from Jehovah via prayer and their bible; they are extreme in enforcing their belief system; and they do live outside conventional society. It is a fact most JW children are only allowed JW friends; many children are home-schooled to prevent them from interacting with non-believers; voting is prohibited, as is involvement in any non-JW cause. Non-JWs are viewed as either potential JWs or sadly lost. JWs consider themselves "no part of this world" even though physically living amongst non-believers. JWs mince words to say the term CULT doesn't apply to them, but the therapy process for recovering JWs is uncannily similar to the therapy process offered to recovering cult members.
 5/15/07
 Dear Cate (5-12) I'm glad that your JW aunt and cousins associate with you. The religion does not require that they do not associate with family that has never been a member. Ask them if they are taught to not speak to or associate with a person who is a former member and you will find that the answer is yes. For those of us who are former members, we would love to be able to visit our families a couple times a year, write and be written to, e-mail, and send packages back and forth as you do. We cannot have the same relationship that you have. We do not hate them, we love them and miss them and want desperately to have a relationship with them. What we are "ranting" about as you call it, is that this religion forces it's people to shun us. So please do not confuse the treatment you receive with the experience that we former members have. We do not hate Jehovah's Witnesses, but they are taught to hate us.
 As for your KKK comment, let me ask you this. Would you go to the KKK to find out about the inside workings of the group or would you go to a former member who is trying to expose the evil? It's the same concept here. Those of us who were on the inside at one time know the real story. And yes, there are plenty of JWs attacking people on this forum.
 5/15/07
 Chuck
 Broken Arrow, OK
 Claudia: You say JWs aren't Christians and they don't believe Jesus is God. Where in God's Word does it say one must believe the Trinity Doctrine to be a Christian? If that were true, that eliminates all Jesus' disciples and all early Christians until the end of the 4th Century when the doctrine was forced upon Christians under the threat of death. Contrary to using only the NWT, I use many translations. Who told you these things? You say the NWT has been altered and twisted to our beliefs. Greek scholar (a NON-JW) Dr. Jason BeDuhn of the University of Northern Arizona doesn't agree with you. His book: Truth in Translation, (University Press of America) states that in his comparison of 8 translations, "the NWT emerges as the most accurate of the translations compared. Holding a close second to the NWT in its accuracy...is the NAB....The translators [of both] managed to produce works relatively MORE ACCURATE and LESS BIASED than the translations produced by multi-denominational teams, as well as those produced by single individuals." I suggest you get a copy of Dr. BeDuhn's book. It will open your eyes, if you allow it. Your post makes me think you have read the same rantings of hate-books against JWs. Are you now an authority qualified to judge JWs by the prejudicial writings of others? Get to know JW's at their meetings, study the Bible with them to see what they really believe before you join in with the falsehoods others have espoused.
 5/15/07
 Tanya
 Oregon
 Thank you for the very balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses shown in the documentary, "Knocking". I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses 25 years ago after much religious searching. I attended many different churches, read about religion, studied several different religions and beliefs of different "christian" denominations. I used many different bible versions and translations and after over five years of study, came to believe through searching the scriptures and comparing JW's beliefs and activities, that I had found the truth of Jehovah God and Christ. The Witness who studied with me encouraged me to read, and ask questions and search for the truth I'm very sorry for those who have had bad experiences. I have neither experienced nor seen others(in several different congregations)experience such things. I knew about disfellow-shipping before I was baptized. JW's more than most denominations, IMHO, know what we're getting into before we're baptized. There is such a permissive society in many countries today and many people seem to think they will not experience consequences to their actions...that they will not reap what they sow. I thank Jehovah daily for leading me to Christ.
 5/15/07
 There needs to be some clarification. Jehovah's Witnesses DO associate with family members that are not JW, as long as they never were. However, if they were formerly a baptized JW, but are not one any longer, then they are shunned. Once you are a baptized JW the rules change. You never can leave & maintain any of the relationships you had within the organization. No matter how hard you try to be tolerant of their beliefs, they are completely intolerant of yours. I have cousins that were raised in the JWs & left when they grew up, but since they were not baptized JWs they can still associate with the rest of the family. Some of these left to pursue immoral lifestyles, but since they were not baptized, the rule of shunning doesn't apply. I left because I just didn't agree with some of the things I was taught. I've NEVER been an immoral person. I love Jehovah, follow his son, & live a very Christian life. But I did not agree with & accept everything they taught. My biggest mistake was getting baptized as a child. While my cousins did not get baptized & are not shunned, I have been completely cut out of the family. If my family wants to stay in this religion, that is their choice. It's not my job to change them. I love them no matter what & would never shun them. However, I am not afforded that same respect. I am shunned.



Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_i.html







PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/23/07
 TM
 Alabama
 Good and fair documentary! Despite many of the negative comments, there is a way for all of us to co-exist peacefully, and that is by following Jehovah's council and Jesus' example. Love is God's dominate quality, and it isn't hard to detemine who reflects it and who chooses not to. And for those who are depressed, please don't give up on Jehovah because you feel others have given up on you. Being the husband of a wonderful wife who happens to be bi-polar, I know first hand that due to all she goes through, she isn't always able to be positive and see things as they are. Our congregation loves her even though she may not be able to realize that through all her internal pain. But they try, none-the-less. I see it and she does too on her good days. And remember, everyone's everlasting future is in our own hands! Jehovah doesn't desire anyone to perish and provides ample opportunity for us all to put faith in Jesus' ransom sacrifice.
 5/23/07
 L.R
 CA
 To: claudia from Moreno Valley 5-11-07
 #1-we are christians because we follow Christ's steps
 #2-Why don't you compare your bible to ours? It will say the same, maybe the
problem is that you understand the bible your own way. #3- Yaweh is Jehova in hebrew-Jehova is in english....
 #4-Claudia read more watchtowers and learn more about us, you can't talk if you have not taken a bible study with us or if you don't read our literature, is like if I don't know you and start talking bad stuff with out even being your friend, so get to know Jehova better and find out how much he cares!
 5/23/07
 Penny
 Arkansas
 Thank you for the film - most excellent. Its coverage of the Witnesses during Worl War II makes me wonder how things might have gone differently if everyone who recognized the evils of the Third Reich had stood up as solidly against its coercion.
 5/23/07
 I enjoyed what I got to see of this film. I was raised in a spiritually divided home. My mother, a JW, and my father, nothing. My mother taught us about Jehovah, but never tried to force us to become a witness. (Matt 22:37)It was our decision of whether or not to get baptized. I chose not to and followed my own course in life. It didn't take me long to regret that decision! My world became turned upside down. I knew that the only way that I could cope was to draw close to Jehovah. I got baptized when I KNEW that I wanted to live my life for Jehovah. My spiritual brothers and sisters opened their arms and hearts to me. I've read some of these comments and it breaks my heart that some have had such bad experiences. Our brothers and sisters are imperfect! But Jehovah is not. His ways are just and He will take care of all things, in time. (Psalms 37:28, Luke 18:7, 2Peter 3:9) I have relatives that are disfellowshipped. Some of them don't feel it was deserved. But, 1 Peter 4:17 tells us that judging is going to start with the house of God. Do they not realize that Jehovah knows if there is an injustice going on? He will take care of it, in due time. Until then, endurance is needed! (Romans 5:3-5, 12:12; 1Peter 2:20) What would have become of Job had he not endured circumstances that he didn't understand? Rather, he remained faithful and was blessed by God! (Job 42:12-17)
 5/23/07
 Elaine Collins
 Maywood,IL
 Thank you so much for your unbiased, objective telling of the story of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have been one of JWs since November ,1979. I have never regretted my decision. I became one at the age of 25 years old. So I grew up in this wonderful organization. We do appreciate when non JWs make an effort to understand & respect us. Your recounting of our rich spiritual heritage; our unrelenting stand agaisnt Nazism, our testing the rights the U.S. Constitution all the way to the U.S. Supreme which has been to the benefit of all, and our unwavering demand for non-blood management of our medical care, which will soon establish the gold standard of medical care for all. This is greatest organization on the earth today. As one of JW's, scriptually we shun pride and boasting but as Jeremiah 9:24 states; '"But let the one bragging about himself brag about himself because of this very thing, the having of insight and the knowlegde of me, that I am Jehovah, the one exercising loving-kindness and righteousnes s in the earth; for in these things I do take delight," is the utterance or Jehovah.' Our accomplishments are because of Jehovah our God and all glory goes to him. But again Thank You for your sincere efforts.
 5/23/07
 Breckenridge, CO
 THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU! for such a moving and encouraging coverage of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have been a Jehovah's Witness for 26 years. People are usually so critical of us - this program was fair, respectful, and SO INTERESTING!! Thank you for your noble attempt to break down prejudice.
 5/23/07
 CA
 What a well made documentary. As a JW I really appreciated the personalized style the documentary has. Many people forget that we are normal people with families, jobs, hobbies and regular human interests. Many of my non-JW friends and my coworkers seem to assume that JW's do not have such basic human interests, so I will be sharing this documentary with them for sure. I am saddened to read some of the posts here, especially the Houston Texas post. Please continue to love and obey God as you are, as imperfect humans we often do not know how to deal with what scares us or that which we do not understand. I hope your congregation members educate themsleves on mental illness and start to provide you with the love you should have already been shown. For those who have left Jehovahs organiation, I truly pray you find your way back.
 5/23/07
 I am a Jehova's witness and what John says is not true. Young kids do not get abused. I have been raised as a Jehova's Witness and my parents never abused of me and never saw anybody do it to their children. On the contrary, they did tell us to be quiet during the meetings and to pay attention or take notes because naturally,young kids are distracted easily. I am 21 yrs old and I have a boyfriend and the brothers in our congregation see us hold hands or hug and its natural. They do not disfellowship us for that;) Thanks to the knowledge I have of the bible and since I grew up as a Jehova's Witness most of my life I am a very happy and satisfied individual because I have a close relationship with God and have friends. I know what is true about God because the bible is inspired by him(2 Timothy 3:16)I am able to identify theoris or doctrines that are false and contrary to what the bible says. I want to congratulate Joel P. Engardio because he did a fantastic job on his documentary. He strictly focused on what Jehova's Witnesses really believe and the kind of lifestyle we have. Most important he did not give his own opinion about it. Great show! Keep up the good work!
 5/23/07
 Anush Akopyan
 What you have posted up on your site about Jehovah's Witness is wrong...they believe in Christ, but dont celebrate his B-day..? What proff is there the Christ was born on Dec 25th...??? They value life and how Jehovah GOD views life, but yet they are willing to sacrifice their own LIFE for what they believe in??? What you have posted is completely MISLEADING!!!! Thank you.
 5/23/07
 B and T
 Garden Grove, Ca
 Thank you PBS for broadcasting such a fair and honest view of Jehovah's Witnesses. So often the dialog about Jehovah's Witnesses is negative. But, this viewing allowed the public to see our geninue desire to please God and help our neighbors.
 5/23/07
 Great Job. Appreciated your hard work.
 5/23/07
 E Farley Metzger
 Phoenix, AZ
 I wish the film had been more upfront about the consequences of a JW not following the rules for things like blood transfusions. According to JW policy, if the young man had decided to take a blood transfusion (in rejection of JW rules) his JW would have been required to shun him completely. I was also disappointed that, along with all the 'aren't they wonderful for winning those court cases for our freedom' there was NO mention of the court cases the Watchtower Society is currently dealing with, because of their policy of covering up child abuse and hiding pedophiles who are JWS (many of whom are out "knocking" at your doors)...unless there are 2 or more witnesses to the act of molestation. Victims and their families are threatened with excommunication *themselves* if they speak out about the abuse, and told not to go to the police because it would "bring reproach on Jehovah."
 5/23/07
 Aurora, Colorado
 I thought it was a very good film. Only a small part of a much larger story. Some one else can make a film about the darker side of the religon someday. I have seen both sides so my opinion of the Jehovah's Witnesses has not changed. It seems ironic to me that a group that has fought so hard for religious and personal freedoms is within the walls of the Kingdom Hall all about "us versus them"
 5/23/07
 I was raised as a witnessBut as I got older I had to decide if the faith was right for me. I eventually did so and was baptised at a fairly young age. Instead of this being a hinderance to me in my teenge years it actually was a protection for me. Thats not to say I wasnt faced with some of the same issues as any young person. But for me ,understanding the seriousness of my committment to God and all that entailed it helped me make the right decision,even when I was less inclined to do so. I had many friends that were raised in witness house holds as well that did not choose to follow the path of their parents.I never shunned any one who simply decided being a witness wasnt for them. But aside from a common background it eventually gets to the point where socially and spiritually youhave less in common with these ones. So there is a natural seperation that occurs over time. I dont even beleive its a conscientious thing but it happens to any of us as we grow and move on.. In life we are constantly face with challenges of a moral,ethical,or spiritual nature.I dont think there is particularly more merit in a person feeling more freedom because of a lack of accountability to someone or something. But when an idividual ,bothers to take the time to understand the real meaning of life they can get a handle on how to deal with it . My faith and PERSONAL relationship with Jehovah has certainly helped me to do just that.
 5/23/07
 Erica G.
 Dallas, Texas
 As a baptized Witness, I'm pleased to see how unbiased and well-informed this film was. It was a joy to see. Naturally, we Witnesses know we aren't going to be loved by everyone but that won't stop our preaching. Good people deserve to hear the good news of God's Kingdom.
 5/23/07
 Dallas, Texas
 If you happened to be up at 11:00 Dallas time and saw the Knocking film, you saw a film with real substance.
 1. Concentration Camp Survivor
 2. Surgury Survivor
 3. Stuff about Civil & Human Rights
 This is great TV.
 All that historical commentary certainly credits Jehovah's Witnesses as faithful to their beliefs. Can't think of another group that would voluntarily go through those things, can you?
 5/23/07
 The last thing an elder wants to do is DF a person. They only do it to help the person (disapline). Dating is fine and its normal to hold hands when dating. though you should be dating when looking/ready for merriage and not taking things TOO far (sex)
 5/23/07
 Children are disaplined for misbehaving. Which is normal in any home. Abuse is totally something else.
 5/23/07
 Brenda Lee
 Denver, CO
 Jehovah�s Witnesses are taught to lie. They call it �theocratic warfare.� I attended a KNOCKING premiere recently, which was followed by a question and answer session. If you go to my website you may listen to an audio of a Jehovah Witness woman in the audience saying, "We don't shun family." Then an Elder (leader) in the Watchtower organization lies by denying that she said this. And yet, the proof is in the recording. When I asked the Elder how he felt about the fact that another Jehovah Witness just lied to the entire audience, he never answered my question.. Is this Christian behavior? Why must they lie to outsiders?
 How do I know they lied? Because I have been shunned by my family for the last 25 years (simply for leaving the organization-I committed no "sin"), and I personally know thousands of others who have likewise been shunned. Brenda Lee, "Out of the Cocoon: A Young Woman's Courageous Flight from the Grip of a Religious Cult" www.outofthecocoon.net (AUDIO on website)
 5/23/07
 David Youngdahl
 Do you like the idea of confering with your Doctor, but then having the final word? (Informed Consent) Thank Jehovah's Witnesses, who secured that right for you in the Supreme Court. Do you appreciate the right to speak your mind in word AND action? Of course the Bill of Rights promises this but the practical application of these things has had to be fought for, every step of the way. Jehovah's Witnesses have been in the forefront of this battle. They have paid with their lives for their stand. They have accepted repression without becoming rebellious. We stand for Bible morality and seek to apply Scriptural guidance in our everyday lives. We do not tolerate flagrant rejection of clear Bible teachings by our members, but that is NOT the same thing as seeking to impose them on our neighbors, politically.
 You might not prefer our knock on your door in the morning, but it beats the knock on the door at midnight from oppresive government. It is not unrealistic to foresee so-called Christians forcing others to live as they believe. Jehovah's Witnesses just want to RECOMMEND what they believe. There's a big diference between them and right wing religious fundamentalism. That's the point of the film.
 5/23/07
 MD
 I thought the film was interesting. I think it was an unbiased glimpse into the world of Jehovah's Witnesses. Perhaps it will help open some of those closed doors the next time we go "Knocking".
 5/23/07
-Disfellowshipped- When a person does something wrong, sometimes they are disfellowshipped to help them get their selves back on track. (Ex) you tell a child not to do something, cause if they do that they will be punished. If that child does it anyways, you need to follow threw with the punishment. It helps correct the child. Same thing with disfellowshipping. It�s helping them to get their lives in order. When you do and you want to be part of the organization again, you are then reinstated. Being disfellowshipped isn�t the worst thing that can happen or that you can do. It�s turning your back on Jehovah that�s the problem. Wants you do that, I�m sorry. Plus you are mostly disfellowshipped by your attitude on the matter. So, there�s many things that go into that.
 5/23/07
 M. C. BROWN
 GARY, INDIANA
 THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR HISTORICAL ACCURACY, YOUR RESPECTFUL DISCUSSION OF OUR BEIEFS AND THE EXCELLENT DOCUMENTARY WORK. WE AS JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ALL HAVE FAMILY THAT ARE NOT WITNESSES. HOWEVER, WITH MUTUAL RESPECT AND LOVE, WE CAN SHARE MANY NON-HOLIDAY, FAMILY ACTIVITIES. WE WANT THEM TO UNDERSTAND US AND NOT GO ON HEARSAY. THIS DOCUMENTARY WILL HELP US TO BE BETTER UNDERSTOOD. I COMMEND YOUR EFFORTS TO SHOW THAT WE HAVE FOUGHT FOR THE RELIGIOUS FREEDOM OF ALL PEOPLE IN THE COURTS. ALSO, WE FIGHT FOR SPIRITUAL INLIGHTENMENT OF ALL PEOPLE IN OUR DOOR TO DOOR MINISTRY.
 5/23/07
 Rayk
 Florida
 I felt something was missing in the oh so respectful tone of the film. Whatever values a 'religion' has there are some religions that are aggressive - such as the Witnesses and Scientology. I personally have seen homes broken by Witnesses coming to the door, converting one part of a family then insisting the children join also and if the other part of the family will not join then they insist the family break up. I think this is a menace. Whatever the history and beliefs. The Witnesses take over more of a person's life than the person spontaneously would prefer. This is cult like. I am afraid of them.
 5/23/07
 It's amazing the number of dissidents. But that is to be expected of anyone from any religion or society that is put out...I am a JW(21yrs, 40yrs old),have a brother who is disfellowshipped...due to breaking God's law set out in the Bible, not some doctrine of men. I love him still very much and hope he returns. I would expect that if I commit a sin of a great magnitude I too should be disfellowshipped if I'm not repentent and sorry for offending the God I serve.I would hope that my family would do the same to me...otherwise it would mean it's okay to keep doing the sin. How many of us who work FT do whatever we want@work?If we steal or lie or cheat or are late repeatedly @ work, don't we expect to get fired?? Really people need to grow up and accept discipline.
 5/23/07
 Miriana
 I am a young person and much apprciated, but i am a Jahovah's Witness. It is better because we praise a god. and i saw this and gave it to my teachers and is against my school rules but they never found out. It is great and i enjoy being one because when I pray someone can acctually hear me unlike others. I have been mad that people at my school think im weird but at least i get some friends and my parents try to be nice and get even with me. most parents hit and most parents teach little ones to stay still by reading the bible to them and they stay. I rather be nice then hit someone and get hit back.
 5/23/07
 former youth follower
 Milwaukee, WI
 This documentary did a nice job of showing a side of the Witnesses that, I think, many people do not see or know about. I grew up as a JW but left when i was about 16. It has been my experience that they are very giving people. They helped my family out many times when we were in desperate need. However, this generosity was limited. Those who didn't, or couldn't meet every expectation were looked down on as less than the rest of the congergarion, making it difficult to stay in the organization. Such was the case with my mother, who was shunned during her struggle with depression.
 5/23/07
 Ed Reasonover
 Ottawa, IL
 I viewed the DVD at home long before the PBS boradcast and shared it with many others, everyone truly enjoyed it. What was presented in the DVD shows both sides of how we as JW live as well as how others outside of the JW organization see us and feel about us. It was honest and factual yet informative to the extent that whoever does not understand JW will possibly want to listen next time we come KNOCKING! I was not raised as a JW but as a Methodist. My family did not take too kindly my change to becoming one of Jehovah's Witnesses. It took almost 5 years before the changes were recognized. We understand each other and my beliefs are understood better now.
 5/23/07
 KL
 I also enjoyed hearing the truth on matters concerning Jehovah's Witnesses aired on National TV. s for John who is obviously a disfellowshipped person (No longer one of Jehovahs Witness)or a dis-associated person,I am now in my mid to late 30's and also grew up as a witness.Your statements are totaly unfounded and untrue.You are bitter because you couldnt do it your way.Stop spreading false stories to justify your actions. You know what you need to do to make it right.Time is running out on you!
 5/23/07
 WHEN YOU ARE OBSESSED WITH THE FACT THAT THE LIVING GOD IN HEBREW TRANSLATES AS JEHOVAH IN THE OLD TESTAMENT YOU DENY THE FACT THAT THE LIVING GOD IS THE MEANS WITH WHICH THE FATHER ALMIGHTY HAS ALWAYS COMMUNICATED WITH HUMAN BEINGS. THE WORD FOR GOD IS NOT JEHOVAH. GOD SPOKE TO NOAH. THE LIVING GOD SPOKE TO NOAH. TWO SEPARATE SPIRITS. GOD SPOKE TO ABRAM, ABRAHAM, MOSES, THROUGH JEHOVAH, THE LIVING GOD, YHWH, I AM, THE ALMIGHTY GOD (THROUGH THE MOUTH OF THE LIVING GOD, JEHOVAH). WHAT DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND? THAT GOD APPEARS IN THE FORM OF THE LIVING GOD AND TELLS THE LIVING GOD TO SAY "I AM ALMIGHTY GOD"? IS THAT REALLY THAT HARD TO GRASP? ALMIGHTY GOD NEVER APPEARED IN HIS OWN FORM TO ANYONE ON EARTH IN THE OLD TESTAMENT OR THE NEW TESTAMENT!!! ALMIGHTY GOD MAKES COVENANTS WITH NOAH, ABRAHAM, MOSES!!! HE COMMUNICATES HIS COVENANTS THROUGH JEHOVAH, THE LIVING GOD, YHWH, I AM, THE LORD GOD!!! WHAT DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND???)
 5/23/07
 Ronnie
 Houston, Tx
 Its about Time. Someone Finally Put out a fair Documentary, one that tells you everything. I too Grew up in a witness family, although, I my not be a shining star among them or perfect in my ministry, it is faith strengthening to see that the deeds of witnesses do not go unnoticed.I have a colorful history with the witnesses, anything good you hear about them is most likely true. Why? Because they are not prone to lying, violence or anything else of the sort. If you hear anything bad about the witnesses, its probably just made up, propaganda, or just general hate from people whom are prejudice against the witnesses. They are pleasant people, everyone should befriend them. Again, Just about everything negative against witnesses is probably not true, i myself may not accept the religion but i am not about to let someone damage their sterling record.
 5/23/07
 You have to keep in mind that Jehovah's earthly organization is made up of imperfect people. Personality conflicts and misunderstandings are going to happen. The bottom line is what does God want you to do to serve him? Whether you call yourself a JW or not does not matter. Following God's laws, principles, and guidelines as set out in the Bible does. As far as a factual and functional knowledge of the Bible, JW's seem to be right on.
 5/23/07
 PA
 I caught the last half hour of this film and I must say, I enjoyed it very much. I am a disfellowshipped (JW) member of my congregation and have been for the past year. The reasons why are truely against Jehovahs beliefs and it was my decision NOT to seek help. The elders DID try to help me and graciously welcome me back but I was a fool not to. Seeing a film like this makes me proud of who I was brought up to be and love Jehovah that much more. In my heart I know clearly that I am never and was never 'shunned' and that it was clearly my choice. There is a scripture that states, God punishes whom he loves. Seeing things from a 'worldly' perspective and that of a JW, in your heart you will always know you found the truth, and that is in Jehovah.
 5/23/07
 R
 Pennsylvania
 THANK YOU Joel. The film was encouraging and helped solidify that serving Jehovah is the best way of living. There hasn't been any better way of living or hope for the future out there since learning about Jehovah and his purposes for the earth and mankind. Until then...I keep knocking.
 5/23/07
 Excellent presentation....I feel that JW are right on track putting Jehovah 1st with Jesus in his proper position as our savior and lord......but as God's Son, not God himself. If only the world would open their eyes to this truth.....Also, JW teach from the Bible that the problems in the world are the result of Satan....he has to be taken off the scene before the world can change, and only Jehovah God can do this.....not man. Man will never eliminate evil....only Jehovah God. Time will tell.
 5/23/07
 Bryan
 Odessa,TX
 I have just seen "Knocking", focused on Jehovah's Witnesses. I believe it is the best piece I've seen on the Witnesses, which was unbiased, candid and positive. Thank you for focusing on the truth of who Jehovah's Witnesses really are.
 5/23/07
 I realy liked the video. But when I went on the blog I was surprised at the comments some are making against them. why so bitter? Your actions only make me want to learn more about them. You would not be atacking them if you were not so scared and bitter, you would have moved on with your lives. I for my self am serching for the answers to many questions I have......and I for one will open my door to the next one knocking on my door. Please try to be nice If you think you have made the right desicion for you then you would not have the need or had beed tought better by your religion not to atack others with such hatred. So Sad! Any way the video showed me alot that I was not awre of about the Jehovahs witnesses. Good Job. I hope you come knocking soon.
 5/23/07
 MS
 Tx
 I noticed you insisting JW's are not Christians you are sadly mistaken. If you look up the meaning of Christian you will notice this is an individual who follows Christ example to the best of his or hers capabilities.. So it seems many of those comenting on this site are truly not being "true Christians" or having a Chrisrlike Attitude-Behavior if you need you can review his qulaities on compassion, love, forgiveness and understanding.
 5/23/07
 M&M
 El Paso,TX
 I remember being one of those rude people at the door. But i was a Devout Catholic attending a Private School for true Christians!! I was taught what was convenient for the priest to teach, rarely ever Bible based. If you had a question it was a mystery... But the realiity is we have all been lied to by our different faiths, pastors and so on. The point made by Witnesses is look into YOUR copy of the Bible!! I look forward to viewing an unbiased program giving attention to how we should appreciate the leagal battles fought for all peoples of this nation..Thanks
 5/23/07
 Andrew
 Dana Point, CA
 I want to say that whoever posted that parents beat their kids in the bathrooms for not paying attention (and that the elders support it) is both right and wrong. To prove this, let me use an illustration: in school, are kids punished for not paying attention and being disruptive? Of course. Same principle applies here: if kids are disruptive, they are taken outisde so that they don't disrupt the rest of the congregation; the elders support this for that reason. And belive me, parents only really give stern lectures and maybe a reprimanding smack at worst; what's wrong with that? How would you discipline a screaming toddler? PS I'm 13 and I believe Jehovah's Witnesses are the true religion: no other ones make any sense.
 5/23/07
 A M
 St. Joseph, MI
 Wonderfully truthful yet candid documentary,unlike most of the comments disgruntled ex-witnesses are making on this board. Jehovah's witnesses are peace loving people who don't "beat" their children at Kingdom halls and the elders look the other way. That is ridiculous at best. Thanks goodness even non-witness people can see beyond these lies and present a truthful depiction of this wonderful faith that follows closely in Jesus Christ's footsteps.
 5/23/07
 Mumsy
 WI
 After being a "devout" JW for over 4 decades, which included many, many hours of "knocking"...we finally had some sense knocked into our heads and saw the light about this destructive cult. The JW's will certainly disagree that they are a cult; but they are and they destroy families and lives. I only wish that there would be a documentary from the viewpoint of all of us (and there are thousands) who have been betrayed by the JW community and governing body for no reason except that we chose to leave. Don't believe a sugar-coated version of what the lives of JW's are all about. I am thankful every day that we escaped even though we suffer the consequences of being shunned by family and so-called "friends". Take a look at some of the X-JW forums and see for yourself, through personal experiences, what Jehovah's Witnesses really do to members. And we thought slavery was abolished!! AND DON'T DRINK THE KOOL-AID!!
 5/23/07
 Dave
 Boston, MA
 To answer the filmmaker's questions to this forum-- first, we are privileged to be living in a "civic society" that even allows us to have this public debate and make these choices for ourselves. Many do not have that choice. Faith is a deeply personal choice- but truly a choice. Everyone who IS a Jehovah's Witness makes that choice- knowing the consequences and sacrifice; everyone who leaves or is shunned, and decides not to return, makes that choice as well- knowing the consequences and sacrifice. In a country which prides itself on freedom of choice (with so many things), and given that we are all blessed with self-determination rather than instinct, it is remarkable that so make the CHOICE to spend time criticizing others' deeply personal choice of how they worship God. Especially when they are clearly bitter about the consequences and sacrifices they must endure due to their own choices.
 To the filmmaker's second question of peaceful co-existence among disagreement, it IS possible. Again, it's a choice. Because it's a personal choice, it reflects upon the individual rather than society as a whole. It shows what's really in that person's heart, how much respect they have (or don't have) for both their fellow man's right of self-determination and the state of their "civic society."
 5/23/07
 Kyria Abrahams
 New York, New York
 I suppose all documentaries are biased in one way or the other, but having been raised as a Jehovah's Witness, it is extremely disconcerting to read the same disinformation we were served as children (Myths & Realities) on PBS.org. Yes, the Jehovah's Witnesses had an impact on several laws throughout history, including the right to refuse blood transfusions. But keep in mind that when I was a child, my parents would have let me die in the hospital if I had needed a blood transfusion. I guess it all depends on what you find more worthy of being covered in a documentary: the historical and legal implications of Jehovah's Witnesses, or the very real deaths of very real children. I look forward to seeing this documentary but fear that I may need to be restrained, lest I lunge at my television with a brick.
 5/23/07
 I was pleasently surprised by the movie and I will recommend it to others! I do wish you had stated that our belief (yes I am one of those JWs) in the 144,000 ruling as kings and priests is found at Rev 14:1 and not just something made up. Having been raised a Catholic and went to a Cath school has given me insight into how other people view us and I did most of my research in the Cath Encyclopedia and prayed a lot before becoming one of those people at the brunt of many jokes. Most of my search was done to convince my husband he was wrong when he began to study with JWs and look where that got me! Most people are such cowards when it comes to the bible, they are scared to open it up and really read what it says because they don't want to know they may be doing something wrong.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_j.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/23/07
 TM
 Alabama
 Good and fair documentary! Despite many of the negative comments, there is a way for all of us to co-exist peacefully, and that is by following Jehovah's council and Jesus' example. Love is God's dominate quality, and it isn't hard to detemine who reflects it and who chooses not to. And for those who are depressed, please don't give up on Jehovah because you feel others have given up on you. Being the husband of a wonderful wife who happens to be bi-polar, I know first hand that due to all she goes through, she isn't always able to be positive and see things as they are. Our congregation loves her even though she may not be able to realize that through all her internal pain. But they try, none-the-less. I see it and she does too on her good days. And remember, everyone's everlasting future is in our own hands! Jehovah doesn't desire anyone to perish and provides ample opportunity for us all to put faith in Jesus' ransom sacrifice.
 5/23/07
 L.R
 CA
 To: claudia from Moreno Valley 5-11-07
 #1-we are christians because we follow Christ's steps
 #2-Why don't you compare your bible to ours? It will say the same, maybe the
problem is that you understand the bible your own way. #3- Yaweh is Jehova in hebrew-Jehova is in english....
 #4-Claudia read more watchtowers and learn more about us, you can't talk if you have not taken a bible study with us or if you don't read our literature, is like if I don't know you and start talking bad stuff with out even being your friend, so get to know Jehova better and find out how much he cares!
 5/23/07
 Penny
 Arkansas
 Thank you for the film - most excellent. Its coverage of the Witnesses during Worl War II makes me wonder how things might have gone differently if everyone who recognized the evils of the Third Reich had stood up as solidly against its coercion.
 5/23/07
 I enjoyed what I got to see of this film. I was raised in a spiritually divided home. My mother, a JW, and my father, nothing. My mother taught us about Jehovah, but never tried to force us to become a witness. (Matt 22:37)It was our decision of whether or not to get baptized. I chose not to and followed my own course in life. It didn't take me long to regret that decision! My world became turned upside down. I knew that the only way that I could cope was to draw close to Jehovah. I got baptized when I KNEW that I wanted to live my life for Jehovah. My spiritual brothers and sisters opened their arms and hearts to me. I've read some of these comments and it breaks my heart that some have had such bad experiences. Our brothers and sisters are imperfect! But Jehovah is not. His ways are just and He will take care of all things, in time. (Psalms 37:28, Luke 18:7, 2Peter 3:9) I have relatives that are disfellowshipped. Some of them don't feel it was deserved. But, 1 Peter 4:17 tells us that judging is going to start with the house of God. Do they not realize that Jehovah knows if there is an injustice going on? He will take care of it, in due time. Until then, endurance is needed! (Romans 5:3-5, 12:12; 1Peter 2:20) What would have become of Job had he not endured circumstances that he didn't understand? Rather, he remained faithful and was blessed by God! (Job 42:12-17)
 5/23/07
 Elaine Collins
 Maywood,IL
 Thank you so much for your unbiased, objective telling of the story of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have been one of JWs since November ,1979. I have never regretted my decision. I became one at the age of 25 years old. So I grew up in this wonderful organization. We do appreciate when non JWs make an effort to understand & respect us. Your recounting of our rich spiritual heritage; our unrelenting stand agaisnt Nazism, our testing the rights the U.S. Constitution all the way to the U.S. Supreme which has been to the benefit of all, and our unwavering demand for non-blood management of our medical care, which will soon establish the gold standard of medical care for all. This is greatest organization on the earth today. As one of JW's, scriptually we shun pride and boasting but as Jeremiah 9:24 states; '"But let the one bragging about himself brag about himself because of this very thing, the having of insight and the knowlegde of me, that I am Jehovah, the one exercising loving-kindness and righteousnes s in the earth; for in these things I do take delight," is the utterance or Jehovah.' Our accomplishments are because of Jehovah our God and all glory goes to him. But again Thank You for your sincere efforts.
 5/23/07
 Breckenridge, CO
 THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU! for such a moving and encouraging coverage of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have been a Jehovah's Witness for 26 years. People are usually so critical of us - this program was fair, respectful, and SO INTERESTING!! Thank you for your noble attempt to break down prejudice.
 5/23/07
 CA
 What a well made documentary. As a JW I really appreciated the personalized style the documentary has. Many people forget that we are normal people with families, jobs, hobbies and regular human interests. Many of my non-JW friends and my coworkers seem to assume that JW's do not have such basic human interests, so I will be sharing this documentary with them for sure. I am saddened to read some of the posts here, especially the Houston Texas post. Please continue to love and obey God as you are, as imperfect humans we often do not know how to deal with what scares us or that which we do not understand. I hope your congregation members educate themsleves on mental illness and start to provide you with the love you should have already been shown. For those who have left Jehovahs organiation, I truly pray you find your way back.
 5/23/07
 I am a Jehova's witness and what John says is not true. Young kids do not get abused. I have been raised as a Jehova's Witness and my parents never abused of me and never saw anybody do it to their children. On the contrary, they did tell us to be quiet during the meetings and to pay attention or take notes because naturally,young kids are distracted easily. I am 21 yrs old and I have a boyfriend and the brothers in our congregation see us hold hands or hug and its natural. They do not disfellowship us for that;) Thanks to the knowledge I have of the bible and since I grew up as a Jehova's Witness most of my life I am a very happy and satisfied individual because I have a close relationship with God and have friends. I know what is true about God because the bible is inspired by him(2 Timothy 3:16)I am able to identify theoris or doctrines that are false and contrary to what the bible says. I want to congratulate Joel P. Engardio because he did a fantastic job on his documentary. He strictly focused on what Jehova's Witnesses really believe and the kind of lifestyle we have. Most important he did not give his own opinion about it. Great show! Keep up the good work!
 5/23/07
 Anush Akopyan
 What you have posted up on your site about Jehovah's Witness is wrong...they believe in Christ, but dont celebrate his B-day..? What proff is there the Christ was born on Dec 25th...??? They value life and how Jehovah GOD views life, but yet they are willing to sacrifice their own LIFE for what they believe in??? What you have posted is completely MISLEADING!!!! Thank you.
 5/23/07
 B and T
 Garden Grove, Ca
 Thank you PBS for broadcasting such a fair and honest view of Jehovah's Witnesses. So often the dialog about Jehovah's Witnesses is negative. But, this viewing allowed the public to see our geninue desire to please God and help our neighbors.
 5/23/07
 Great Job. Appreciated your hard work.
 5/23/07
 E Farley Metzger
 Phoenix, AZ
 I wish the film had been more upfront about the consequences of a JW not following the rules for things like blood transfusions. According to JW policy, if the young man had decided to take a blood transfusion (in rejection of JW rules) his JW would have been required to shun him completely. I was also disappointed that, along with all the 'aren't they wonderful for winning those court cases for our freedom' there was NO mention of the court cases the Watchtower Society is currently dealing with, because of their policy of covering up child abuse and hiding pedophiles who are JWS (many of whom are out "knocking" at your doors)...unless there are 2 or more witnesses to the act of molestation. Victims and their families are threatened with excommunication *themselves* if they speak out about the abuse, and told not to go to the police because it would "bring reproach on Jehovah."
 5/23/07
 Aurora, Colorado
 I thought it was a very good film. Only a small part of a much larger story. Some one else can make a film about the darker side of the religon someday. I have seen both sides so my opinion of the Jehovah's Witnesses has not changed. It seems ironic to me that a group that has fought so hard for religious and personal freedoms is within the walls of the Kingdom Hall all about "us versus them"
 5/23/07
 I was raised as a witnessBut as I got older I had to decide if the faith was right for me. I eventually did so and was baptised at a fairly young age. Instead of this being a hinderance to me in my teenge years it actually was a protection for me. Thats not to say I wasnt faced with some of the same issues as any young person. But for me ,understanding the seriousness of my committment to God and all that entailed it helped me make the right decision,even when I was less inclined to do so. I had many friends that were raised in witness house holds as well that did not choose to follow the path of their parents.I never shunned any one who simply decided being a witness wasnt for them. But aside from a common background it eventually gets to the point where socially and spiritually youhave less in common with these ones. So there is a natural seperation that occurs over time. I dont even beleive its a conscientious thing but it happens to any of us as we grow and move on.. In life we are constantly face with challenges of a moral,ethical,or spiritual nature.I dont think there is particularly more merit in a person feeling more freedom because of a lack of accountability to someone or something. But when an idividual ,bothers to take the time to understand the real meaning of life they can get a handle on how to deal with it . My faith and PERSONAL relationship with Jehovah has certainly helped me to do just that.
 5/23/07
 Erica G.
 Dallas, Texas
 As a baptized Witness, I'm pleased to see how unbiased and well-informed this film was. It was a joy to see. Naturally, we Witnesses know we aren't going to be loved by everyone but that won't stop our preaching. Good people deserve to hear the good news of God's Kingdom.
 5/23/07
 Dallas, Texas
 If you happened to be up at 11:00 Dallas time and saw the Knocking film, you saw a film with real substance.
 1. Concentration Camp Survivor
 2. Surgury Survivor
 3. Stuff about Civil & Human Rights
 This is great TV.
 All that historical commentary certainly credits Jehovah's Witnesses as faithful to their beliefs. Can't think of another group that would voluntarily go through those things, can you?
 5/23/07
 The last thing an elder wants to do is DF a person. They only do it to help the person (disapline). Dating is fine and its normal to hold hands when dating. though you should be dating when looking/ready for merriage and not taking things TOO far (sex)
 5/23/07
 Children are disaplined for misbehaving. Which is normal in any home. Abuse is totally something else.
 5/23/07
 Brenda Lee
 Denver, CO
 Jehovah�s Witnesses are taught to lie. They call it �theocratic warfare.� I attended a KNOCKING premiere recently, which was followed by a question and answer session. If you go to my website you may listen to an audio of a Jehovah Witness woman in the audience saying, "We don't shun family." Then an Elder (leader) in the Watchtower organization lies by denying that she said this. And yet, the proof is in the recording. When I asked the Elder how he felt about the fact that another Jehovah Witness just lied to the entire audience, he never answered my question.. Is this Christian behavior? Why must they lie to outsiders?
 How do I know they lied? Because I have been shunned by my family for the last 25 years (simply for leaving the organization-I committed no "sin"), and I personally know thousands of others who have likewise been shunned. Brenda Lee, "Out of the Cocoon: A Young Woman's Courageous Flight from the Grip of a Religious Cult" www.outofthecocoon.net (AUDIO on website)
 5/23/07
 David Youngdahl
 Do you like the idea of confering with your Doctor, but then having the final word? (Informed Consent) Thank Jehovah's Witnesses, who secured that right for you in the Supreme Court. Do you appreciate the right to speak your mind in word AND action? Of course the Bill of Rights promises this but the practical application of these things has had to be fought for, every step of the way. Jehovah's Witnesses have been in the forefront of this battle. They have paid with their lives for their stand. They have accepted repression without becoming rebellious. We stand for Bible morality and seek to apply Scriptural guidance in our everyday lives. We do not tolerate flagrant rejection of clear Bible teachings by our members, but that is NOT the same thing as seeking to impose them on our neighbors, politically.
 You might not prefer our knock on your door in the morning, but it beats the knock on the door at midnight from oppresive government. It is not unrealistic to foresee so-called Christians forcing others to live as they believe. Jehovah's Witnesses just want to RECOMMEND what they believe. There's a big diference between them and right wing religious fundamentalism. That's the point of the film.
 5/23/07
 MD
 I thought the film was interesting. I think it was an unbiased glimpse into the world of Jehovah's Witnesses. Perhaps it will help open some of those closed doors the next time we go "Knocking".
 5/23/07
-Disfellowshipped- When a person does something wrong, sometimes they are disfellowshipped to help them get their selves back on track. (Ex) you tell a child not to do something, cause if they do that they will be punished. If that child does it anyways, you need to follow threw with the punishment. It helps correct the child. Same thing with disfellowshipping. It�s helping them to get their lives in order. When you do and you want to be part of the organization again, you are then reinstated. Being disfellowshipped isn�t the worst thing that can happen or that you can do. It�s turning your back on Jehovah that�s the problem. Wants you do that, I�m sorry. Plus you are mostly disfellowshipped by your attitude on the matter. So, there�s many things that go into that.
 5/23/07
 M. C. BROWN
 GARY, INDIANA
 THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR HISTORICAL ACCURACY, YOUR RESPECTFUL DISCUSSION OF OUR BEIEFS AND THE EXCELLENT DOCUMENTARY WORK. WE AS JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ALL HAVE FAMILY THAT ARE NOT WITNESSES. HOWEVER, WITH MUTUAL RESPECT AND LOVE, WE CAN SHARE MANY NON-HOLIDAY, FAMILY ACTIVITIES. WE WANT THEM TO UNDERSTAND US AND NOT GO ON HEARSAY. THIS DOCUMENTARY WILL HELP US TO BE BETTER UNDERSTOOD. I COMMEND YOUR EFFORTS TO SHOW THAT WE HAVE FOUGHT FOR THE RELIGIOUS FREEDOM OF ALL PEOPLE IN THE COURTS. ALSO, WE FIGHT FOR SPIRITUAL INLIGHTENMENT OF ALL PEOPLE IN OUR DOOR TO DOOR MINISTRY.
 5/23/07
 Rayk
 Florida
 I felt something was missing in the oh so respectful tone of the film. Whatever values a 'religion' has there are some religions that are aggressive - such as the Witnesses and Scientology. I personally have seen homes broken by Witnesses coming to the door, converting one part of a family then insisting the children join also and if the other part of the family will not join then they insist the family break up. I think this is a menace. Whatever the history and beliefs. The Witnesses take over more of a person's life than the person spontaneously would prefer. This is cult like. I am afraid of them.
 5/23/07
 It's amazing the number of dissidents. But that is to be expected of anyone from any religion or society that is put out...I am a JW(21yrs, 40yrs old),have a brother who is disfellowshipped...due to breaking God's law set out in the Bible, not some doctrine of men. I love him still very much and hope he returns. I would expect that if I commit a sin of a great magnitude I too should be disfellowshipped if I'm not repentent and sorry for offending the God I serve.I would hope that my family would do the same to me...otherwise it would mean it's okay to keep doing the sin. How many of us who work FT do whatever we want@work?If we steal or lie or cheat or are late repeatedly @ work, don't we expect to get fired?? Really people need to grow up and accept discipline.
 5/23/07
 Miriana
 I am a young person and much apprciated, but i am a Jahovah's Witness. It is better because we praise a god. and i saw this and gave it to my teachers and is against my school rules but they never found out. It is great and i enjoy being one because when I pray someone can acctually hear me unlike others. I have been mad that people at my school think im weird but at least i get some friends and my parents try to be nice and get even with me. most parents hit and most parents teach little ones to stay still by reading the bible to them and they stay. I rather be nice then hit someone and get hit back.
 5/23/07
 former youth follower
 Milwaukee, WI
 This documentary did a nice job of showing a side of the Witnesses that, I think, many people do not see or know about. I grew up as a JW but left when i was about 16. It has been my experience that they are very giving people. They helped my family out many times when we were in desperate need. However, this generosity was limited. Those who didn't, or couldn't meet every expectation were looked down on as less than the rest of the congergarion, making it difficult to stay in the organization. Such was the case with my mother, who was shunned during her struggle with depression.
 5/23/07
 Ed Reasonover
 Ottawa, IL
 I viewed the DVD at home long before the PBS boradcast and shared it with many others, everyone truly enjoyed it. What was presented in the DVD shows both sides of how we as JW live as well as how others outside of the JW organization see us and feel about us. It was honest and factual yet informative to the extent that whoever does not understand JW will possibly want to listen next time we come KNOCKING! I was not raised as a JW but as a Methodist. My family did not take too kindly my change to becoming one of Jehovah's Witnesses. It took almost 5 years before the changes were recognized. We understand each other and my beliefs are understood better now.
 5/23/07
 KL
 I also enjoyed hearing the truth on matters concerning Jehovah's Witnesses aired on National TV. s for John who is obviously a disfellowshipped person (No longer one of Jehovahs Witness)or a dis-associated person,I am now in my mid to late 30's and also grew up as a witness.Your statements are totaly unfounded and untrue.You are bitter because you couldnt do it your way.Stop spreading false stories to justify your actions. You know what you need to do to make it right.Time is running out on you!
 5/23/07
 WHEN YOU ARE OBSESSED WITH THE FACT THAT THE LIVING GOD IN HEBREW TRANSLATES AS JEHOVAH IN THE OLD TESTAMENT YOU DENY THE FACT THAT THE LIVING GOD IS THE MEANS WITH WHICH THE FATHER ALMIGHTY HAS ALWAYS COMMUNICATED WITH HUMAN BEINGS. THE WORD FOR GOD IS NOT JEHOVAH. GOD SPOKE TO NOAH. THE LIVING GOD SPOKE TO NOAH. TWO SEPARATE SPIRITS. GOD SPOKE TO ABRAM, ABRAHAM, MOSES, THROUGH JEHOVAH, THE LIVING GOD, YHWH, I AM, THE ALMIGHTY GOD (THROUGH THE MOUTH OF THE LIVING GOD, JEHOVAH). WHAT DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND? THAT GOD APPEARS IN THE FORM OF THE LIVING GOD AND TELLS THE LIVING GOD TO SAY "I AM ALMIGHTY GOD"? IS THAT REALLY THAT HARD TO GRASP? ALMIGHTY GOD NEVER APPEARED IN HIS OWN FORM TO ANYONE ON EARTH IN THE OLD TESTAMENT OR THE NEW TESTAMENT!!! ALMIGHTY GOD MAKES COVENANTS WITH NOAH, ABRAHAM, MOSES!!! HE COMMUNICATES HIS COVENANTS THROUGH JEHOVAH, THE LIVING GOD, YHWH, I AM, THE LORD GOD!!! WHAT DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND???)
 5/23/07
 Ronnie
 Houston, Tx
 Its about Time. Someone Finally Put out a fair Documentary, one that tells you everything. I too Grew up in a witness family, although, I my not be a shining star among them or perfect in my ministry, it is faith strengthening to see that the deeds of witnesses do not go unnoticed.I have a colorful history with the witnesses, anything good you hear about them is most likely true. Why? Because they are not prone to lying, violence or anything else of the sort. If you hear anything bad about the witnesses, its probably just made up, propaganda, or just general hate from people whom are prejudice against the witnesses. They are pleasant people, everyone should befriend them. Again, Just about everything negative against witnesses is probably not true, i myself may not accept the religion but i am not about to let someone damage their sterling record.
 5/23/07
 You have to keep in mind that Jehovah's earthly organization is made up of imperfect people. Personality conflicts and misunderstandings are going to happen. The bottom line is what does God want you to do to serve him? Whether you call yourself a JW or not does not matter. Following God's laws, principles, and guidelines as set out in the Bible does. As far as a factual and functional knowledge of the Bible, JW's seem to be right on.
 5/23/07
 PA
 I caught the last half hour of this film and I must say, I enjoyed it very much. I am a disfellowshipped (JW) member of my congregation and have been for the past year. The reasons why are truely against Jehovahs beliefs and it was my decision NOT to seek help. The elders DID try to help me and graciously welcome me back but I was a fool not to. Seeing a film like this makes me proud of who I was brought up to be and love Jehovah that much more. In my heart I know clearly that I am never and was never 'shunned' and that it was clearly my choice. There is a scripture that states, God punishes whom he loves. Seeing things from a 'worldly' perspective and that of a JW, in your heart you will always know you found the truth, and that is in Jehovah.
 5/23/07
 R
 Pennsylvania
 THANK YOU Joel. The film was encouraging and helped solidify that serving Jehovah is the best way of living. There hasn't been any better way of living or hope for the future out there since learning about Jehovah and his purposes for the earth and mankind. Until then...I keep knocking.
 5/23/07
 Excellent presentation....I feel that JW are right on track putting Jehovah 1st with Jesus in his proper position as our savior and lord......but as God's Son, not God himself. If only the world would open their eyes to this truth.....Also, JW teach from the Bible that the problems in the world are the result of Satan....he has to be taken off the scene before the world can change, and only Jehovah God can do this.....not man. Man will never eliminate evil....only Jehovah God. Time will tell.
 5/23/07
 Bryan
 Odessa,TX
 I have just seen "Knocking", focused on Jehovah's Witnesses. I believe it is the best piece I've seen on the Witnesses, which was unbiased, candid and positive. Thank you for focusing on the truth of who Jehovah's Witnesses really are.
 5/23/07
 I realy liked the video. But when I went on the blog I was surprised at the comments some are making against them. why so bitter? Your actions only make me want to learn more about them. You would not be atacking them if you were not so scared and bitter, you would have moved on with your lives. I for my self am serching for the answers to many questions I have......and I for one will open my door to the next one knocking on my door. Please try to be nice If you think you have made the right desicion for you then you would not have the need or had beed tought better by your religion not to atack others with such hatred. So Sad! Any way the video showed me alot that I was not awre of about the Jehovahs witnesses. Good Job. I hope you come knocking soon.
 5/23/07
 MS
 Tx
 I noticed you insisting JW's are not Christians you are sadly mistaken. If you look up the meaning of Christian you will notice this is an individual who follows Christ example to the best of his or hers capabilities.. So it seems many of those comenting on this site are truly not being "true Christians" or having a Chrisrlike Attitude-Behavior if you need you can review his qulaities on compassion, love, forgiveness and understanding.
 5/23/07
 M&M
 El Paso,TX
 I remember being one of those rude people at the door. But i was a Devout Catholic attending a Private School for true Christians!! I was taught what was convenient for the priest to teach, rarely ever Bible based. If you had a question it was a mystery... But the realiity is we have all been lied to by our different faiths, pastors and so on. The point made by Witnesses is look into YOUR copy of the Bible!! I look forward to viewing an unbiased program giving attention to how we should appreciate the leagal battles fought for all peoples of this nation..Thanks
 5/23/07
 Andrew
 Dana Point, CA
 I want to say that whoever posted that parents beat their kids in the bathrooms for not paying attention (and that the elders support it) is both right and wrong. To prove this, let me use an illustration: in school, are kids punished for not paying attention and being disruptive? Of course. Same principle applies here: if kids are disruptive, they are taken outisde so that they don't disrupt the rest of the congregation; the elders support this for that reason. And belive me, parents only really give stern lectures and maybe a reprimanding smack at worst; what's wrong with that? How would you discipline a screaming toddler? PS I'm 13 and I believe Jehovah's Witnesses are the true religion: no other ones make any sense.
 5/23/07
 A M
 St. Joseph, MI
 Wonderfully truthful yet candid documentary,unlike most of the comments disgruntled ex-witnesses are making on this board. Jehovah's witnesses are peace loving people who don't "beat" their children at Kingdom halls and the elders look the other way. That is ridiculous at best. Thanks goodness even non-witness people can see beyond these lies and present a truthful depiction of this wonderful faith that follows closely in Jesus Christ's footsteps.
 5/23/07
 Mumsy
 WI
 After being a "devout" JW for over 4 decades, which included many, many hours of "knocking"...we finally had some sense knocked into our heads and saw the light about this destructive cult. The JW's will certainly disagree that they are a cult; but they are and they destroy families and lives. I only wish that there would be a documentary from the viewpoint of all of us (and there are thousands) who have been betrayed by the JW community and governing body for no reason except that we chose to leave. Don't believe a sugar-coated version of what the lives of JW's are all about. I am thankful every day that we escaped even though we suffer the consequences of being shunned by family and so-called "friends". Take a look at some of the X-JW forums and see for yourself, through personal experiences, what Jehovah's Witnesses really do to members. And we thought slavery was abolished!! AND DON'T DRINK THE KOOL-AID!!
 5/23/07
 Dave
 Boston, MA
 To answer the filmmaker's questions to this forum-- first, we are privileged to be living in a "civic society" that even allows us to have this public debate and make these choices for ourselves. Many do not have that choice. Faith is a deeply personal choice- but truly a choice. Everyone who IS a Jehovah's Witness makes that choice- knowing the consequences and sacrifice; everyone who leaves or is shunned, and decides not to return, makes that choice as well- knowing the consequences and sacrifice. In a country which prides itself on freedom of choice (with so many things), and given that we are all blessed with self-determination rather than instinct, it is remarkable that so make the CHOICE to spend time criticizing others' deeply personal choice of how they worship God. Especially when they are clearly bitter about the consequences and sacrifices they must endure due to their own choices.
 To the filmmaker's second question of peaceful co-existence among disagreement, it IS possible. Again, it's a choice. Because it's a personal choice, it reflects upon the individual rather than society as a whole. It shows what's really in that person's heart, how much respect they have (or don't have) for both their fellow man's right of self-determination and the state of their "civic society."
 5/23/07
 Kyria Abrahams
 New York, New York
 I suppose all documentaries are biased in one way or the other, but having been raised as a Jehovah's Witness, it is extremely disconcerting to read the same disinformation we were served as children (Myths & Realities) on PBS.org. Yes, the Jehovah's Witnesses had an impact on several laws throughout history, including the right to refuse blood transfusions. But keep in mind that when I was a child, my parents would have let me die in the hospital if I had needed a blood transfusion. I guess it all depends on what you find more worthy of being covered in a documentary: the historical and legal implications of Jehovah's Witnesses, or the very real deaths of very real children. I look forward to seeing this documentary but fear that I may need to be restrained, lest I lunge at my television with a brick.
 5/23/07
 I was pleasently surprised by the movie and I will recommend it to others! I do wish you had stated that our belief (yes I am one of those JWs) in the 144,000 ruling as kings and priests is found at Rev 14:1 and not just something made up. Having been raised a Catholic and went to a Cath school has given me insight into how other people view us and I did most of my research in the Cath Encyclopedia and prayed a lot before becoming one of those people at the brunt of many jokes. Most of my search was done to convince my husband he was wrong when he began to study with JWs and look where that got me! Most people are such cowards when it comes to the bible, they are scared to open it up and really read what it says because they don't want to know they may be doing something wrong.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_j.html







PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/23/07
 M.Cano
 San Antonio, TX
 I am happy that we were reported in an honest light. We are not a cult as many believe. As a youngster, I too was taken to the "bathroom" and spanked and disciplined for playing and not sitting in my seat or for making too much noise. But this was also after countless warnings. The Bible states Spare the rod spoil the children. Also, there have been many things brought to light these past years. Especially towards brothers and sisters with mental illness. The brothers are more understanding and loving and helpful. Probably because before, they did not understand. But my family and I really did enjoy the documentary.
 5/23/07
 Whitney
 I am suprised to read some of these comments. I have been Jehovah's Witness all my life and never have I witnessed abuse, or the fact of being forced to believe what others say. The human condition questions what we are told and without questioning something then where would we be. I have questioned everything I learned. I personally found the questions to my answers in my bible. No one in this world is perfect and neither are Jehovah's Witnesses. Like other religions people make mistakes. and sure some people took things too literally or just plinly misconstrued the point. And some people might be hypocrytes. But what we have to remember is that it is not people we serve it is God. If we live our lives angry at the world and talking down on others what makes us better than them? I am a proud Jehovah's Witness and I am one by choice. It was not forced. I will stand by my faith till my death and I have full hope that this is the TRUE religion. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. And yes we pass out the magazines but you are nto forced to accept. Not everyone accepts Christ. and we are not forced to accept yours. But know that if you do then you will find true joy and peace in a world of hate, crime, and pain. I truly enjoyed the film.
 5/23/07
 carolina wheate
 blakeslee, pennsylvania
 What a refreshing piece of film! To see such a personal and upclose window into the lives of 2 Jehovah Witness families was moving. I cried when I watched and listened to Joseph Kemplers expressions with his family while visiting the concentration camps from which he survived. I was moved with sympathy and compassion as I viewed a mother and wife fear for the outcome of her son's and husband's surgery. I never realized how important the legal actions taken by Jehovah Witnesses are to the rights of others not just here in the USA but throughout the world.I also have a family divided by beliefs or ways of life,but because I am a Jehovah's Witness,we too live in peace.
 5/23/07
 I was pleasently surprised by the movie and I will recommend it to others! I do wish you had stated that our belief (yes I am one of those JWs) in the 144,000 ruling as kings and priests is found at Rev 14:1 and not just something made up. Having been raised a Catholic and went to a Cath school has given me insight into how other people view us and I did most of my research in the Cath Encyclopedia and prayed a lot before becoming one of those people at the brunt of many jokes. Most of my search was done to convince my husband he was wrong when he began to study with JWs and look where that got me! Most people are such cowards when it comes to the bible, they are scared to open it up and really read what it says because they don't want to know they may be doing something wrong.
 5/23/07
 Mike
 Ohio
 I liked the fact that fundemental Bible beliefs as demonstrated by JW's can be persued without venomous intolerance, violence or political manuvering. Just as when Jesus was reviled, he did not go reviling in return; He continually preached that the kingdom of the heavens draws near. The apostle Paul made his defense before Caesar as JW's do before courts and officials worlwide. Imagine how much of the gosples, the acts of the apostles and letters to the congregations would be missing if the first century disciples of Christ did not go "knocking" too. I am proud to be part of a religion that puts Christianity into practice. As Jesus said, by their fruits you will recognize them. Thank you for making this documentary.
 5/23/07
 I am one of JW's and my children and I really enjoyed this program. There were some loose ends though. The grandmother used the word "cult". We are in fact not a cult we have be giventhe gift of free will by Jehovah Human run cults are not, if you leave they don't want you back. Not so with the loving christian congregation of Jehovahs witnesses. I erred as a youth and I was help get back on the right path with help from the elders and other friends in the congregation. I made the choice to change and was accepted with much love.
 5/23/07
 Amira
 Pittsburgh, PA
 I commend Mr. Engardio for this excellent honest and eye-opening depiction of Jehovah's Witnesses. I once attempted to shed light on these very issues in a much less publicized speech I prepared for a college Public Speaking course a few years ago. The other 8 or 9 members of my class had no idea that Jehovah's Witnesses fought so hard to secure their rights to free speech and by extension the rights of all Americans to such freedom. Nor did they realize the extent to which Jehovah's people were subjected to persecution in the concentration camps of Europe during the Nazi regime. I was also impressed by the film's demonstration that the efforts of Jehovah's Witnesses to abstain from blood has led to a cooperation from the medical community to become more adept at performing surgeries without the use of blood transfusions on all patients.
 I just hope that those non-Witnesses who watched tonight on PBS now realize that they have nothing to be afraid of when one of Jehovah's Witnesses comes knocking on their door. In fact, why not listen to what they have to say. All their teachings are completely bible-based and personal decisions on how to lead their individual lives are made using their bible-trained conscience.
 The films "Patient Needs and Rights: Medicine Meets the Challenge" and "Purple Triangles" made by the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society are also excellent films.
 5/23/07
 Much negative response has been given on this forum, and a lot of it is personal experiences, i.e. 'how one family member treated' another.
 please realize this, any JW who would read one of these experiences like the one i saw where 'a grandmother told a young child her parents didnt love her when they left the organization' any JW would agree that that person was wrong and out of line. please understand that.
 any one who didnt show love and discernment to their brother or sister wouldnt be in the right. the large majority of JW's as they should and any JW would be glad to talk to you.
 5/23/07
 Agustin
 Houston
 The good: they come to you, they have a true desire to share their beliefs, they use scripture and encourage that you read, they seem to be color blind.
 The not so good: they believe they alone have the correct interpretation of the bible
 I enjoy studying with jw's, but there is no room for independent thought
 5/23/07
 Agustin
 Houston
 The good: they come to you, they have a true desire to share their beliefs, they use scripture and encourage that you read, they seem to be color blind.The not so good: they believe they alone have the correct interpretation of the bible. I enjoy studying with jw's, but there is no room for independent though.
 5/23/07
 Angela
 It was nice to see a family with two conflicting religions coexists. However, it doesn't change that these examples are extremely rare in this religion. I was raised as a JW for 18 years. Although their conviction for thier faith is admirable, it is often out of control. Most Jw's are obsessed with wanting to be martyrs. Families are torn, and people suffer great depression due to these convictions. Your real story is with the victims of JW's. The abuse in this organization is even more disgusting than the catholic faith. I'm was a victim of incests which was covered up.
 5/23/07
 Dave
 Jehovah's Witnesess are not perfect and yes they do make mistakes. But they do addhere to bible principles the best they can. One thing you do have to admit though is that if All religions felt the way they do about War, well there wouldn't be any. And my what that extra money could do for the betterment of mankind!
 5/23/07
 David Ortega
 Houston, TX
 In Reply to John, nobody abuses no one for not being quiet. It sounds like you had problems of yourself. In addition, one does not serve or believe in a religion because of how other people act. One has to believe in what one believes in. We do not serve because others, but because we have faith in God's words.
 5/23/07
 Christina
 This was the first time I have seen a program on public television that did not make the Witnesses look like monsters, who abuse their children. I have several relatives that are Jehovah's Witnesses and we all get along great!
 5/23/07
 Being raised a Witness, but making it my own at 19, I feel that the film was positive; all of us are real people, with real problems in our lives. Both of the issues discussed in the film were issues faced by many people worldwide(including non-witnesses); I hope that it shows them that faith that is Bible-based gives strength, and also that Jehovah's Witnesses are much more a force for good than most realize. But at the same time we are all sinful, imperfect and make many mistakes(even against one another). This is what makes our faith even stronger, is that we keep going and dont give up.
 5/23/07
 Donald d. Frisbie
 J. w. hand pick the scriptures they want to hold to at the expense of others. for example Jesus is as much God as God the father period. jesus said "if you hath seen me thee hath seen the father." "i and my father are ONE." "before the world was, I AM." no blood transfusions? no pledge allegiance? no war. even God said to the isrealites to wipe out the canaanites, cuz God promised that land to the jews, etc. they just have enough truth to hold together a lot of lies and half truths. end of story!
 5/23/07
 Mary L. Olson
 Oklahoma City, OK
 Thank you so much for airing this basically accurate documentary about Jehovah's Witnesses. I've been associated with this since 1959 and thank Jehovah for directing me to his true organization & his true worship. It is the only one which holds out real hope for the future for our planet Earth & for those who look to Him for true peace and security. It's my prayer that other people who see your program will be moved to want to discuss the Bible with the Witnesses when they knock on their doors. And not be afraid to ask us why we believe as we do. Thank you again for airing "Knocking"!
 5/23/07
 Susanne
 Sarasota,Fl
 I have been a Jehovah's Witness for 17 years. I appreciated the thouroughness and accuracy of this program. Religious freedom is so important for everyone, no matter what religion you are in. If something you know for yourself is good won't you want to tell everyone? That's how I feel about it. Kudos to to everyone involved in this project.
 5/23/07
 Nicole
 Hey, I am also one of jehovahs witnesses and I think that this documentary is a very good thing for people that want to know more about our history. And I also think that it told the truth and that this will make others think again before they close the door because alot of people think that we dont beleive in God so I really loved this documentary!!!!! :)
 5/23/07
 RN
 Roanoke, Virginia
 I am a Hindu, a religion from India, so as you may have guessed I am an immigrant, but what strikes me most after seeing the documentary is that there is GOOD in all religions...it is up to us as humans to believe in that good and not to corrupt the basic doctrines of great religions....after looking at what is happening in Islam,..fundamentalism is there to a major or minor extent in all religions...what with the inquisitions in Europe and Hindu-Moslem riots in my own country...what "allows" us to judge other religions.. I have not practiced my own religion...but we fight over religion as school kids would fight over; say my subject English is a better subject than your math..forgetting that teaching English or Math is a way for the "teachers" to help us improve our lives...all religions ask us to follow a moral path..and yet there is so much pain and suffering that we inflict on each other...I really don't believe that our great prophets would approve of us fighting over "our" interpretations of their teachings...preachers/priests etc are also human and not above the follies that you or me are susceptible to and thus to blame them and tarnish a whole religions philosophy is extremely tragic and monumental waste..one wonders who is the real fundamentalist here...most likely all of us...
 5/23/07
 Amanda
 Sylvania, OH
 I thought it was great! At first, my dad didn't want to watch it because he thought it would be a show done by someone who had a grudge. But after seeing it, he said it was a fair representation of JW's. I personally think that the abuse of children going on in the organization is more noteworthy than the no blood issue, but that is important too.
 5/23/07
 Joseph M. Fenty
 Ann Arbor, MI
 While I am happy that Joseph Kempler reconciled with his family, and Seth Thomas survived the operation, I believe the film distorted and minimized the mental anguish that occurs within many JW families. For many ex-witnesses there is no happy ending. We reject superstition and false prophesies , and we pay the price of estrangement from family and friends. Witnesses are not tolerate of different points of view. You can not have peacefully co-existence with people who sincerely believe they have the only true religion.
 5/23/07
 Mancelona, Michigan
 After reading some of the posts here, I see that the majority of the contributors miss the whole point of being a Jehovah's Witness. It isn't about what you think, it's about what you believe. Do you believe there is a Supreme being, who created everything that lives on the earth? Wouldn't it be true then, that He has the right and the obligation to give us a set of laws that keep us on the straight and narrow? When all is said and done...it's between you and Jehovah. How you live your life, what you believe and how you apply it, is the key to Paradise.
 5/23/07
 Kids are never beaten in the restrooms,,, and teenagers are allowed to date,,,, you get shunned if you commit a major sin and refuse to apologize and forgive,,, if you vow to be part of the organization, than you must live by it. Every one has a decision, if you decide and vow and promise to live by their morals than why would you do the opposite?
 5/23/07
 KAYE
 I WAS RAISED A J.W. AND HAD BEEN DISFELLOWSHIPPED FOR 23 YEARS, MY PARENTS ARE J.W.'S. NO MAN CAN JUDGE US, AND CHRIST DIED FOR OUR SINS, SO JUST BECAUSE I WAS BAPTIZED AT A YOUNG AGE AND DID NOT KNOW WHAT I WAS DOING IS NOT A REASON FOR MAN TO NOT ASSOCIATE OR TALK TO YOU, NOT EVEN YOUR FAMILY. HOW CAN THEY LOVE A MAN ON THE STREET AND JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE TITLE DISFELLOWSHIPPED OVER YOUR HEAD, YOU CANT TALK TO THEM. SOMETHING IS DEFINITELY WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 5/23/07
 K.Ripple
 New York
 I really enjoyed your program. I think that it was very respectfull towards Jehovah's Witnesses and gave a good witness to our beliefs. Thank You for this fine program.
 5/23/07
 The show was very great. i am also one of jehovahs witnesses and as a young person it is very wonderful.
 5/23/07
 a.k.a Turtle
 I have not yet watched your film, merely perused your website. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. Throughout your discussion board, I have found those who previously Witnesses, but who are now abusing their former faith. I believe someone said we condoned abuse. We don�t but we do accept discipline. I should know, I�ve been a Witness all my life and have had my share of spankings in the bathroom, all of which I probably deserved. As for being shunned for handholding and looking for the bad, that too is untrue. Youths, who are still in the �bloom of youth�, are counseled about these kind of relationships and what they can lead to, which shows more love than most parents today do. If they choose to ignore this council, they must then disciplined. In some cases I could be wrong, but you must remember this point: Jehovah�s Witnesses are still people! They make mistakes and are capable of doing wrong. Chances are though, that any who have purposely wronged you, have been dealt with, and reproved severely. If there was such a big problem, and you truly loved Jehovah, you would have found a way to get through it, such as going to another congregation. I urge those who have left the truth, try again. The end is near. When was the last time you listened to one of Jehovah�s Witnesses? Also, we do not disallow �open gayness�, we do not allow homosexuality at all.
 5/23/07
 Frank Torres
 Norwalk California
 I will see the show tonight, I got Battized for 20 years, but in 1998 after I got divorced form my wife after 15 years of marriage(of corse under Biblical reasons) I felt betrayed from the elders of my Congregation and I stayed away for 4 years,I grew my hair and a beard I was very close to write to the Branch to tell them I did not wanted to be a witness any more, but them I met my present wife and I came back and Im very happy,and I came to a conclusion, we don't go to field service or to the meetings for memebers of the Congregation we go cause we want to Serve Jehovah not men Remenber we all imperfect and we make alot of mistakes, and remenber there is not alot of us that would not make it to the new system,can't find perfection in the Congregation's just go the the meetings and don't worry about the others that is their relantionship with Jehovah,There is nothing else in this system that can bring peace and Love.
 5/23/07
 Marie Jenkins
 Markham Illinois
 The report on Jehovah's Witnesses was so very well put together and so moving. It was accurate. I would like to purchase a copy since the story was very moving and it was a good lesson for our young ones who don't know about the holocoust and what Jews, JW's and so many other went through. Please let me know how I could purchase this cd. Thank You
 5/23/07
 R.V.
 PB.P., CA
 Wow! Amazing how many people are quick to bash on the J.W.'s because of their personal experiences "I was abused as a little boy, so therefore what they teach is wrong" or "When I was 18, I saw this or did that and they disfellowshipped me but did nothing to the elder's son". Grow up people! Everyone is accountable for their OWN ACTIONS... not what the Press reported about an elder touching a little boy. My family was heavily scrutinized by an elder. Many of my family members lost privileges. Am I going to cry? Did I become a J.W. for the privileges? No! because of my faith and what I believe in. People are imperfect and make mistakes. Aren't we taught to forgive? Isn't that what "Christians" are taught? I thought comments were supposed to be about the Documentary, not about what negative things you saw at the Kingdom Hall, or what unjustice you noticed. There are many of those sites where you can whine all you want about that. Not here.
 5/23/07
 Dale
 Phx,Az
 Ok... It is late Tuesday Nite and I just finished watching The Broadcast on PBS With the rest of the world. Choked up with tears, I must say You guys have done something very special. You were true to impartial journalism.Present the story and the reader will discern. Joel, Your association as well as your disassociation with witnesses made the film fair and non partial, Yet it was encouraging and empowering to anyone with conviction, to keep standing tall. I Had no idea we Witesses did all that for people of other religions, policies, and persuasions. Thanks for your observation and Expose. Ps: I smell golden globe, peabody, Edward R Morrow, oscar, And whatever else they hand out to you guys.
 5/23/07
 THANK YOU FOR THIS AMAZING DOCUMENTARY ON JEHOVAH WITINESSES. I HOPE IT WILL ANSWER MANY QUESTIONS OF THOSE SEEKING THE THRUTH ON WHO JEHOVAH WITNESSES REALLY ARE.
 Jehovah Witnesses Beliefs Based ON
 *preaching (Mathew 24:14)
 *Jehovah Witnesses name based on(Isaiah 43:10-12)
 *Paradise & Happiness on earth(psalms 37:9-12,29)
 *Resurrection (Acts 24:15)




Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_k.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/23/07
 M.Cano
 San Antonio, TX
 I am happy that we were reported in an honest light. We are not a cult as many believe. As a youngster, I too was taken to the "bathroom" and spanked and disciplined for playing and not sitting in my seat or for making too much noise. But this was also after countless warnings. The Bible states Spare the rod spoil the children. Also, there have been many things brought to light these past years. Especially towards brothers and sisters with mental illness. The brothers are more understanding and loving and helpful. Probably because before, they did not understand. But my family and I really did enjoy the documentary.
 5/23/07
 Whitney
 I am suprised to read some of these comments. I have been Jehovah's Witness all my life and never have I witnessed abuse, or the fact of being forced to believe what others say. The human condition questions what we are told and without questioning something then where would we be. I have questioned everything I learned. I personally found the questions to my answers in my bible. No one in this world is perfect and neither are Jehovah's Witnesses. Like other religions people make mistakes. and sure some people took things too literally or just plinly misconstrued the point. And some people might be hypocrytes. But what we have to remember is that it is not people we serve it is God. If we live our lives angry at the world and talking down on others what makes us better than them? I am a proud Jehovah's Witness and I am one by choice. It was not forced. I will stand by my faith till my death and I have full hope that this is the TRUE religion. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. And yes we pass out the magazines but you are nto forced to accept. Not everyone accepts Christ. and we are not forced to accept yours. But know that if you do then you will find true joy and peace in a world of hate, crime, and pain. I truly enjoyed the film.
 5/23/07
 carolina wheate
 blakeslee, pennsylvania
 What a refreshing piece of film! To see such a personal and upclose window into the lives of 2 Jehovah Witness families was moving. I cried when I watched and listened to Joseph Kemplers expressions with his family while visiting the concentration camps from which he survived. I was moved with sympathy and compassion as I viewed a mother and wife fear for the outcome of her son's and husband's surgery. I never realized how important the legal actions taken by Jehovah Witnesses are to the rights of others not just here in the USA but throughout the world.I also have a family divided by beliefs or ways of life,but because I am a Jehovah's Witness,we too live in peace.
 5/23/07
 I was pleasently surprised by the movie and I will recommend it to others! I do wish you had stated that our belief (yes I am one of those JWs) in the 144,000 ruling as kings and priests is found at Rev 14:1 and not just something made up. Having been raised a Catholic and went to a Cath school has given me insight into how other people view us and I did most of my research in the Cath Encyclopedia and prayed a lot before becoming one of those people at the brunt of many jokes. Most of my search was done to convince my husband he was wrong when he began to study with JWs and look where that got me! Most people are such cowards when it comes to the bible, they are scared to open it up and really read what it says because they don't want to know they may be doing something wrong.
 5/23/07
 Mike
 Ohio
 I liked the fact that fundemental Bible beliefs as demonstrated by JW's can be persued without venomous intolerance, violence or political manuvering. Just as when Jesus was reviled, he did not go reviling in return; He continually preached that the kingdom of the heavens draws near. The apostle Paul made his defense before Caesar as JW's do before courts and officials worlwide. Imagine how much of the gosples, the acts of the apostles and letters to the congregations would be missing if the first century disciples of Christ did not go "knocking" too. I am proud to be part of a religion that puts Christianity into practice. As Jesus said, by their fruits you will recognize them. Thank you for making this documentary.
 5/23/07
 I am one of JW's and my children and I really enjoyed this program. There were some loose ends though. The grandmother used the word "cult". We are in fact not a cult we have be giventhe gift of free will by Jehovah Human run cults are not, if you leave they don't want you back. Not so with the loving christian congregation of Jehovahs witnesses. I erred as a youth and I was help get back on the right path with help from the elders and other friends in the congregation. I made the choice to change and was accepted with much love.
 5/23/07
 Amira
 Pittsburgh, PA
 I commend Mr. Engardio for this excellent honest and eye-opening depiction of Jehovah's Witnesses. I once attempted to shed light on these very issues in a much less publicized speech I prepared for a college Public Speaking course a few years ago. The other 8 or 9 members of my class had no idea that Jehovah's Witnesses fought so hard to secure their rights to free speech and by extension the rights of all Americans to such freedom. Nor did they realize the extent to which Jehovah's people were subjected to persecution in the concentration camps of Europe during the Nazi regime. I was also impressed by the film's demonstration that the efforts of Jehovah's Witnesses to abstain from blood has led to a cooperation from the medical community to become more adept at performing surgeries without the use of blood transfusions on all patients.
 I just hope that those non-Witnesses who watched tonight on PBS now realize that they have nothing to be afraid of when one of Jehovah's Witnesses comes knocking on their door. In fact, why not listen to what they have to say. All their teachings are completely bible-based and personal decisions on how to lead their individual lives are made using their bible-trained conscience.
 The films "Patient Needs and Rights: Medicine Meets the Challenge" and "Purple Triangles" made by the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society are also excellent films.
 5/23/07
 Much negative response has been given on this forum, and a lot of it is personal experiences, i.e. 'how one family member treated' another.
 please realize this, any JW who would read one of these experiences like the one i saw where 'a grandmother told a young child her parents didnt love her when they left the organization' any JW would agree that that person was wrong and out of line. please understand that.
 any one who didnt show love and discernment to their brother or sister wouldnt be in the right. the large majority of JW's as they should and any JW would be glad to talk to you.
 5/23/07
 Agustin
 Houston
 The good: they come to you, they have a true desire to share their beliefs, they use scripture and encourage that you read, they seem to be color blind.
 The not so good: they believe they alone have the correct interpretation of the bible
 I enjoy studying with jw's, but there is no room for independent thought
 5/23/07
 Agustin
 Houston
 The good: they come to you, they have a true desire to share their beliefs, they use scripture and encourage that you read, they seem to be color blind.The not so good: they believe they alone have the correct interpretation of the bible. I enjoy studying with jw's, but there is no room for independent though.
 5/23/07
 Angela
 It was nice to see a family with two conflicting religions coexists. However, it doesn't change that these examples are extremely rare in this religion. I was raised as a JW for 18 years. Although their conviction for thier faith is admirable, it is often out of control. Most Jw's are obsessed with wanting to be martyrs. Families are torn, and people suffer great depression due to these convictions. Your real story is with the victims of JW's. The abuse in this organization is even more disgusting than the catholic faith. I'm was a victim of incests which was covered up.
 5/23/07
 Dave
 Jehovah's Witnesess are not perfect and yes they do make mistakes. But they do addhere to bible principles the best they can. One thing you do have to admit though is that if All religions felt the way they do about War, well there wouldn't be any. And my what that extra money could do for the betterment of mankind!
 5/23/07
 David Ortega
 Houston, TX
 In Reply to John, nobody abuses no one for not being quiet. It sounds like you had problems of yourself. In addition, one does not serve or believe in a religion because of how other people act. One has to believe in what one believes in. We do not serve because others, but because we have faith in God's words.
 5/23/07
 Christina
 This was the first time I have seen a program on public television that did not make the Witnesses look like monsters, who abuse their children. I have several relatives that are Jehovah's Witnesses and we all get along great!
 5/23/07
 Being raised a Witness, but making it my own at 19, I feel that the film was positive; all of us are real people, with real problems in our lives. Both of the issues discussed in the film were issues faced by many people worldwide(including non-witnesses); I hope that it shows them that faith that is Bible-based gives strength, and also that Jehovah's Witnesses are much more a force for good than most realize. But at the same time we are all sinful, imperfect and make many mistakes(even against one another). This is what makes our faith even stronger, is that we keep going and dont give up.
 5/23/07
 Donald d. Frisbie
 J. w. hand pick the scriptures they want to hold to at the expense of others. for example Jesus is as much God as God the father period. jesus said "if you hath seen me thee hath seen the father." "i and my father are ONE." "before the world was, I AM." no blood transfusions? no pledge allegiance? no war. even God said to the isrealites to wipe out the canaanites, cuz God promised that land to the jews, etc. they just have enough truth to hold together a lot of lies and half truths. end of story!
 5/23/07
 Mary L. Olson
 Oklahoma City, OK
 Thank you so much for airing this basically accurate documentary about Jehovah's Witnesses. I've been associated with this since 1959 and thank Jehovah for directing me to his true organization & his true worship. It is the only one which holds out real hope for the future for our planet Earth & for those who look to Him for true peace and security. It's my prayer that other people who see your program will be moved to want to discuss the Bible with the Witnesses when they knock on their doors. And not be afraid to ask us why we believe as we do. Thank you again for airing "Knocking"!
 5/23/07
 Susanne
 Sarasota,Fl
 I have been a Jehovah's Witness for 17 years. I appreciated the thouroughness and accuracy of this program. Religious freedom is so important for everyone, no matter what religion you are in. If something you know for yourself is good won't you want to tell everyone? That's how I feel about it. Kudos to to everyone involved in this project.
 5/23/07
 Nicole
 Hey, I am also one of jehovahs witnesses and I think that this documentary is a very good thing for people that want to know more about our history. And I also think that it told the truth and that this will make others think again before they close the door because alot of people think that we dont beleive in God so I really loved this documentary!!!!! :)
 5/23/07
 RN
 Roanoke, Virginia
 I am a Hindu, a religion from India, so as you may have guessed I am an immigrant, but what strikes me most after seeing the documentary is that there is GOOD in all religions...it is up to us as humans to believe in that good and not to corrupt the basic doctrines of great religions....after looking at what is happening in Islam,..fundamentalism is there to a major or minor extent in all religions...what with the inquisitions in Europe and Hindu-Moslem riots in my own country...what "allows" us to judge other religions.. I have not practiced my own religion...but we fight over religion as school kids would fight over; say my subject English is a better subject than your math..forgetting that teaching English or Math is a way for the "teachers" to help us improve our lives...all religions ask us to follow a moral path..and yet there is so much pain and suffering that we inflict on each other...I really don't believe that our great prophets would approve of us fighting over "our" interpretations of their teachings...preachers/priests etc are also human and not above the follies that you or me are susceptible to and thus to blame them and tarnish a whole religions philosophy is extremely tragic and monumental waste..one wonders who is the real fundamentalist here...most likely all of us...
 5/23/07
 Amanda
 Sylvania, OH
 I thought it was great! At first, my dad didn't want to watch it because he thought it would be a show done by someone who had a grudge. But after seeing it, he said it was a fair representation of JW's. I personally think that the abuse of children going on in the organization is more noteworthy than the no blood issue, but that is important too.
 5/23/07
 Joseph M. Fenty
 Ann Arbor, MI
 While I am happy that Joseph Kempler reconciled with his family, and Seth Thomas survived the operation, I believe the film distorted and minimized the mental anguish that occurs within many JW families. For many ex-witnesses there is no happy ending. We reject superstition and false prophesies , and we pay the price of estrangement from family and friends. Witnesses are not tolerate of different points of view. You can not have peacefully co-existence with people who sincerely believe they have the only true religion.
 5/23/07
 Mancelona, Michigan
 After reading some of the posts here, I see that the majority of the contributors miss the whole point of being a Jehovah's Witness. It isn't about what you think, it's about what you believe. Do you believe there is a Supreme being, who created everything that lives on the earth? Wouldn't it be true then, that He has the right and the obligation to give us a set of laws that keep us on the straight and narrow? When all is said and done...it's between you and Jehovah. How you live your life, what you believe and how you apply it, is the key to Paradise.
 5/23/07
 Kids are never beaten in the restrooms,,, and teenagers are allowed to date,,,, you get shunned if you commit a major sin and refuse to apologize and forgive,,, if you vow to be part of the organization, than you must live by it. Every one has a decision, if you decide and vow and promise to live by their morals than why would you do the opposite?
 5/23/07
 KAYE
 I WAS RAISED A J.W. AND HAD BEEN DISFELLOWSHIPPED FOR 23 YEARS, MY PARENTS ARE J.W.'S. NO MAN CAN JUDGE US, AND CHRIST DIED FOR OUR SINS, SO JUST BECAUSE I WAS BAPTIZED AT A YOUNG AGE AND DID NOT KNOW WHAT I WAS DOING IS NOT A REASON FOR MAN TO NOT ASSOCIATE OR TALK TO YOU, NOT EVEN YOUR FAMILY. HOW CAN THEY LOVE A MAN ON THE STREET AND JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE TITLE DISFELLOWSHIPPED OVER YOUR HEAD, YOU CANT TALK TO THEM. SOMETHING IS DEFINITELY WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 5/23/07
 K.Ripple
 New York
 I really enjoyed your program. I think that it was very respectfull towards Jehovah's Witnesses and gave a good witness to our beliefs. Thank You for this fine program.
 5/23/07
 The show was very great. i am also one of jehovahs witnesses and as a young person it is very wonderful.
 5/23/07
 a.k.a Turtle
 I have not yet watched your film, merely perused your website. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. Throughout your discussion board, I have found those who previously Witnesses, but who are now abusing their former faith. I believe someone said we condoned abuse. We don�t but we do accept discipline. I should know, I�ve been a Witness all my life and have had my share of spankings in the bathroom, all of which I probably deserved. As for being shunned for handholding and looking for the bad, that too is untrue. Youths, who are still in the �bloom of youth�, are counseled about these kind of relationships and what they can lead to, which shows more love than most parents today do. If they choose to ignore this council, they must then disciplined. In some cases I could be wrong, but you must remember this point: Jehovah�s Witnesses are still people! They make mistakes and are capable of doing wrong. Chances are though, that any who have purposely wronged you, have been dealt with, and reproved severely. If there was such a big problem, and you truly loved Jehovah, you would have found a way to get through it, such as going to another congregation. I urge those who have left the truth, try again. The end is near. When was the last time you listened to one of Jehovah�s Witnesses? Also, we do not disallow �open gayness�, we do not allow homosexuality at all.
 5/23/07
 Frank Torres
 Norwalk California
 I will see the show tonight, I got Battized for 20 years, but in 1998 after I got divorced form my wife after 15 years of marriage(of corse under Biblical reasons) I felt betrayed from the elders of my Congregation and I stayed away for 4 years,I grew my hair and a beard I was very close to write to the Branch to tell them I did not wanted to be a witness any more, but them I met my present wife and I came back and Im very happy,and I came to a conclusion, we don't go to field service or to the meetings for memebers of the Congregation we go cause we want to Serve Jehovah not men Remenber we all imperfect and we make alot of mistakes, and remenber there is not alot of us that would not make it to the new system,can't find perfection in the Congregation's just go the the meetings and don't worry about the others that is their relantionship with Jehovah,There is nothing else in this system that can bring peace and Love.
 5/23/07
 Marie Jenkins
 Markham Illinois
 The report on Jehovah's Witnesses was so very well put together and so moving. It was accurate. I would like to purchase a copy since the story was very moving and it was a good lesson for our young ones who don't know about the holocoust and what Jews, JW's and so many other went through. Please let me know how I could purchase this cd. Thank You
 5/23/07
 R.V.
 PB.P., CA
 Wow! Amazing how many people are quick to bash on the J.W.'s because of their personal experiences "I was abused as a little boy, so therefore what they teach is wrong" or "When I was 18, I saw this or did that and they disfellowshipped me but did nothing to the elder's son". Grow up people! Everyone is accountable for their OWN ACTIONS... not what the Press reported about an elder touching a little boy. My family was heavily scrutinized by an elder. Many of my family members lost privileges. Am I going to cry? Did I become a J.W. for the privileges? No! because of my faith and what I believe in. People are imperfect and make mistakes. Aren't we taught to forgive? Isn't that what "Christians" are taught? I thought comments were supposed to be about the Documentary, not about what negative things you saw at the Kingdom Hall, or what unjustice you noticed. There are many of those sites where you can whine all you want about that. Not here.
 5/23/07
 Dale
 Phx,Az
 Ok... It is late Tuesday Nite and I just finished watching The Broadcast on PBS With the rest of the world. Choked up with tears, I must say You guys have done something very special. You were true to impartial journalism.Present the story and the reader will discern. Joel, Your association as well as your disassociation with witnesses made the film fair and non partial, Yet it was encouraging and empowering to anyone with conviction, to keep standing tall. I Had no idea we Witesses did all that for people of other religions, policies, and persuasions. Thanks for your observation and Expose. Ps: I smell golden globe, peabody, Edward R Morrow, oscar, And whatever else they hand out to you guys.
 5/23/07
 THANK YOU FOR THIS AMAZING DOCUMENTARY ON JEHOVAH WITINESSES. I HOPE IT WILL ANSWER MANY QUESTIONS OF THOSE SEEKING THE THRUTH ON WHO JEHOVAH WITNESSES REALLY ARE.
 Jehovah Witnesses Beliefs Based ON
 *preaching (Mathew 24:14)
 *Jehovah Witnesses name based on(Isaiah 43:10-12)
 *Paradise & Happiness on earth(psalms 37:9-12,29)
 *Resurrection (Acts 24:15)




Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_k.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Allie Ward
 Baton Rouge, LA
 There is NO DECIENCY AND DIGNITY in the "jehovah cult." They have destroyed my family. They PRETEND to be family oriented, however, if you DO NOT join their sect, they will leave their married family, taking the children, lying to them as to why they can no longer see them. I KNOW THIS. I am PROOF ! Their children will NEVER have prefect attendance at school, their wives do not work unless it is within the realm of THEIR EXISTENCE, you cannot enter their "halls" without a "sponsor." NO OTHER CHURCH WOULD DO THIS ! They DO NOT want outsiders IN to reveal their TRUE practices. To become A CITIZEN and IN COURT,they raise their RIGHT HAND, PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO OUR FLAG, ONE NATION UNDER "GOD" (not jehovah). They "prey" on you ONLY when you are down emotionally and financially like they did in this area after Hurricane Katrina. I know ex-jehovah's who are under psychiatric care because of the emotional scars left by them. Their NEGATIVES are too GREAT. I feel sorry for those TRAPPED. They are DECEITFUL, LYING, INDIVIDUALS. They are WOLVES in sheeps clothing. If you who "think" you are being taught the TRUTH you MUST do further research. GOD BLESS YOU ALL...
 5/23/07
 Kevin A. Martinez
 Marrero, Louisiana
 My wife and I have been studying with the JW's for a while now and we have have many family members that have argued our decision. Studying the bible and learning what provisions Jehovah has for us has brought great relief to us. I went to my regular book study on 5/22/07 and our bible conductor announced that on PBS there was going to be a special on JW's entitled, 'Knocking'. My wife and I saw the entire program and enjoyed it so much. By being obedient we are sure to know that the true God Jehovah will bless our efforts. 'Knocking' was also a thunderous call from our God and may all those who saw the film be entrigued to share in the ministry and get to know a happy God, the creator of the universe. His word exerts power and is sharper than any two-edged sword. Joseph and Seth applied the counsel of Acts 5:29 which states,"We should obey God as ruler rather than men." They are sure to receive many rich blessings for their bravery. If obedient we too can have the same privilege.
 5/23/07
 James
 Virginia
 There are many misconceptions out there about us. Some people who have commented here really do not know us or our beliefs.
 Actually there have always been witnesses of Jehovah not just since the 1800's. Jesus, Paul, Jeramiah and other all "witnessed" about Jehovah.
 Not many credit us for saying well in advance that 1914 was and is a marked year.
 Our Bible translation was thoroughly researched using the orginial Hebrew\Greek and is explained too.
 5/23/07
 Paty
 SC
 Wow!!! It was an amazing documentary.
 I thank Jehovah for letting others see his real people. Despite what people say or think, the program showed our believes, how we've changed history & our love for people including our own family. The fact, that the person who did this is not a Jehovah's Witness makes a difference.
 Perhaps, those who watched the show will never become Witnesses, but I'm sure they know that they were wrong in their view towards us. That glorifies Jehovah's names more than anything else.
 Thanks one more time....
 5/23/07
 A. Moore
 I have noticed quite a few comments of people who wanted this documentary to focus more on what they view as negative info toward the JWs.To them I say that there are plenty of websites, blogs, readings etc. that do their best to do this. So, since I doubt you go to those forums and request that the more positive views be expressed. Why do it here? This false sense of "fairness" only proves that no matter what is written, if it's not negative you're not happy. Great show! I have it on my DVR until my DVD arrives.
 5/23/07
 Jenny
 I enjoyed "KNOCKING" very much. It's nice to watch an objectively, WELL-DOCUMENTED film about people we've always been curious about. Joel, you obviously did your homework for a long time. You were extremely courageous to choose such a subject, but somebody needed to do it. Thanks! It has brought up lots of controversy, as posted, but people choose what they want to believe -- no matter what the facts are. To follow a perfect man's footsteps is also a hard thing to do. You've revealed that there are imperfect people out there that are examining those steps and trying to walk in them. That takes alot of courage, too. Thanks again for showing us some of the effort that's involved. Some had rather do some "TALK" than to try the "WALK".
 5/23/07
 Michael Liuzza
 I am 14 years old and have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses from my birth. I would never change. I beleave this is the truth.
 5/23/07
 AMG
 I ALONG WITH MY FAMILY SAW YOUR DOCUMENATRY YESTERDAY EVENING AND I MUST SAY THAT I WAS PLEASANTLY SURPRISED.IT WAS A WELL BALANCED PRESENTATION OF OUR FAITH AND COMMUNITY. WHETHER INTENED OR NOT YOU HAVE GIVEN A GOOD WITNESS TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.YOU SHOWED THAT THIS ORGINZATION IS COMPRISED OF IMPERFECT BEINGS JUST TRYING TO DO THE RIGHT THINGS NOT MORE NOTHING LESS. TO THOSE WHO FEEL ANGER TOWARDS THIER BEING DISFELLOWSHIPED/SHUNNED LET'S MAKE ONE THING CLEAR ELDERS DO NOT DISFELLOWSHIP ANYONE, THE PERSON COMMITING THE SIN IS THE ONE WHO DOES IT TO THEMSELVES BY NOT ADMITTING THIER MISTAKE AND THRU ACTIONS SHOWING WHETHER THEY ARE TRULLY SORRY FOR THERE ERRORS. I SHOULD KNOW I WAS DISFELLOWSHIPPED FOR 14YRS AND MY FAMILY NEVER LOSS CONTACT WTH ME.WHEN MY SON WAS BORN MY MOTHER WAS IN THE ROOM TO WELCOME HIM.I CONTINUE TO STRUGGLE DAILY WITH DEPRESION AND OTHER AILMENTS AND MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS ARE AWARE OF THIS AND TREAT ME WITH LOVING KINDNESS WHeHER I PUT 1 HR OR 10 HRS OF SERVICE THE THING JEHOVA APPRECIATES IS THAT WE GIVE HIM OUR BEST IN EVERYTHING WE DO QUALITY NOT QUANTITY IS WHAT MATTERS TO HIM. ONCE AGAIN THANK YOU FOR YOUR EFFORT. AND THANK YOU TO OR BROTHERS FOR SHARING THEMSELVES WITH US AND THE WORLD
 5/23/07
 former
 Texas
 Wow, so many thoughts from so many people, I was a former J.W.What is wrong with them? Who do you see door to door like the bible say to do?Who upraises there kids in the stright path?I have never met a Witnees who is unhappy with there life.I have never meet a Wetnees dying of an STD. These people don't bother no one. Has any one ever wondered if there should be one true religion, what should it be? Should it be to meet our standards and benefits,and made up to please or daily life?Or should it be with faith and based on what God asked from Us.Times have changed becouse we have permitted it to,how many of us parents rise our kids to Gods standards, how many have read the bible to our kids? The bible and God do not exists now in days.Thats why when a group of people that are doing right in there believes, seems so wrong to us.What has life become?
 5/23/07
 G.K.
 Springfield, MO.
 For the last 30 plus years I've been deeply interested in whats correct dogma among the many different religions all claiming they know the true teachings of the Bible. I've collected over 80 different English Bible translations and the most indepth Greek and Hebrew inter-linear works to really know and study the Bible. I consider myself a scholar in Biblical research, having studied for years in many major Bible universities and theological libraries. So do the Jehovah's Witnesses have their major doctrines correct? They teach there is no hellfire torment for the wicked as well as no immortal soul. They teach Almighty God is only the Father and not the Trinity of three persons, each almighty and without beginning. Now I must be honest and admit that the JW's are teaching correctly here. A search of these subjects in libraries will reveal a bias by many churches to hid or change the actual Biblical information. The documentary film did well I think, but they are not a cult with non-biblical dogmas. I enjoy reading their literature and have used it for references many times.
 5/23/07
 BBB
 Los Angeles
 Convitions with an opposing set of beliefs. They are really great people. I am married to a member and I have attended the meetings and what I do not under stand is how a group of people can study the bible so much and have it interpreted so indifferant. They believe in what is made known to them and not what is read from the bible. Do they debate any thing studied? I do love my wife and her family and I have learned to tell them in a nice way as so not to upset them is "the bible does't say that,the Jehovah�s Witnesses say that". Getting back to the film, where there no other christian groups inprisoned in the camps and was the bloodless technic for an operaration developed for the Jehovah Witnesses beliefs? Was this a promotionl doctrine?
 5/23/07
 Maribel
 Miami, FL
 To my dear brothers and sisters: we are thankful for this honest documentary and proud of our beliefs. It is true that we do not like others to talk bad about our faith and association of brothers but, remember: Jesus did not lift a hand nor said a word when they were spitting on him. Like a recent Watchtower article said: Jehovah will take the stand. HE will judge. Let us PEACEFULLY continue doing the work we were told to do (Matt. 24:14) Or else, we would not be demonstrating with example what this documentary shows we are: seekers of peace.
 5/23/07
 RUDY
 As a Jehovah's Witness, I am very blessed to have as fellow worshippers true friends. Yes indeed, the Witnesses certainly stand out, Jesus Christ said we would, it's not a surprise.
 Although not political, the positive impact our Bible teaching has for families & the community. For example, no more alcohol & drug abuse, promiscuous conduct which leads to sexually transmitted diseases, some diseases due to blood transfusions, divorces, the emotional trauma for all, honest tax-payers, law abiding citizens, an honest days work, no gangs, no organized crime affiliation, basically a wholesome lifestle. ADD IT ALL UP !!! How much tax payer money goes to abuses ? BILLIONS !
 Jehovah's Witnesses, due to imperfections, have challenges in life like everyone does. The difference ? We leave our whole trust in our Almighty God Jehovah.
 Historically, despite well intentions, man cannot bring peace & a cure for mankind's woes, rich or poor. Due to imperfection & the influence of Satan & his demons, Jehovah God & His Kingdom under Christ is the only hope. That is our message we wish all mankind would grasp !!! For the time being, as a united brotherhood, we will love God & neighbor, & share this wonderful hope until Jehovah God says !
 5/23/07
 gretna, la.
 Film was shown in our area 5/22/07 for the first time. It was wonderful. I have always watchted Frontline, P.O.V.,Independent Lens, etc. All very informative and well done. This was no different. I am third generation Jehovah's Witness. Like the author, I was never a big fan of knocking on doors. I'm still not. But I do it anyway. I want to do the work Jesus did. It's nice when people listen (and some do) but it doesn't make or break our work. Sometimes it's fun. And I'm 53 yrs old.
 5/23/07
 Phoenix, AZ
 My Parents and me are the only JW in our extended family. I have a close relationship with some of my non-JW cousins, aunts and uncles. Not all agree with our beliefs and sometime try to argue about religion but that doesn't stop us from talking to them. We get together to eat and visit as long as its not for a holiday or birthday party.
 It hurts to hear all these negative comments from all these people that dont know anything about us and are not open to learning and respecting others point of views.
 To those who have been disfellowshiped because they felt other brothers were being a hypocrite, we are ALL imperfect, JW or non-JW. Sometimes there are brothers,sisters and elders in congregations that take Jehova's word to the extreme or misinterpret it. You should not let this discourage you. Jehova in his time will do what is just to keep his congregation pure, be it in this system or in armagedon. This and personal bible study helped me to keep my faith strong. I was in a congregation where some elders took Jehova's word a little to the extreme. I have since moved to another congregation and my faith is stronger than ever. Remember, Jehova wants ALL his children to live the life he intended in the beginning, eternal perfection in paradise.
 5/23/07
 to J. Blue from Chico, CA, great comment, i too forgot during my teens what i was thought as a child as a JW, and i lived the life the world wants you to live and i truthfully regret those wasted years, now i'm back being a witness, i'm baptized and can honestly say now i enjoy life.
 5/23/07
 Pennsylvania
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I am a young married woman. My Husband has just recently been disfellowshipped. I am not torn between the decision though, because I believe that it was the right choice for them to have made. The Elders do care, whether you want to believe it or not. Disfellowshipping is the result that Baptised JW's recieve if they are given cousel for their wrong, sinful action and are not genuinely repentant. If you are disfellowshipped, and just leave, then you have let satan overcome you. Jehovah made that happen because you would have been a bad influence to the congregation. We all know this. I still stand by my husband, and obey the rules. It is difficult right now, as I knew it would be, but He will come back. He loves the truth, and knows it is the truth. If the rest of you know it is the truth then remember, we do not do this for the people. We do it for JEHOVAH. There are corrupt congregations. But we must have faith that JEHOVAH will fix them. But leaving the congregation will got us NOWHERE. We trust our Faith. May Jehovah be with you all in your decisions. And children are not beaten, we have good children, the worlds children are terrors. Children killing parents. you do not hear of that in our christian congregation.
 5/23/07
 Jeremy
 Chicago, IL
 Thank you I enjoyed this film, it shows a side of everyday life that JW's face. Many think that we're fanatics that go from door to door in an effort to force people to our religion; but we're not. If you don't want us at your home just asked to be placed on the 'Do Not Call' list. If you're and yet don't come to the door, you're wasting our's and Jehovah's time. We may seem annoying but so were God's prophets; and even Jesus was 'annoying' to the Pharisees of his day. We bring a message of Hope and Judgment from God. You don't have to believe it or accept it, its your choice. But please continue to persecute us for our faith, for all TRUE followers of Jesus are supposed to be. I'll give you a prophecy that hasn't been fulfilled yet. The governments will turn on ALL religion. When that happens, remind yourself who told you that truth, and then maybe you'll wish you answered the door when we came KNOCKING.
 5/23/07
 Tempe, AZ
 I saw the documentary about Jehovah's Witnesses on PBS Tuesday night, and they missed several things. First, the Watchtower organization has had a history of false predictions about the end of the world. The most notable was in 1975 when the members were told (by the governing body in NY) to sell all of their property in preparation for it, and the end did not come. This should have been a sign for every JW to leave the organization. When someone makes a specific prediction for the Lord's return and it does not happen, that automatically indicates that the preson (or organization) is a false prophet. The Bible is very clear on this. For anyone who is impressed by JW's sincerety and dedication must realize one thing--sincerety is no substitute for the truth!!
 Here is a fact that the average JW on the street is likely not aware of. The Watchtower organization has, for years, taught that the United Nations was the beast of Revelation 17 (part of the "Harlot"). This fact appeared in various Watchtower articles through the years. However, from 1992 till 2001, the Watchtower organization was an NGO (non-governmental organization) member of the United Nations! This is pure hyprocrisy! It was on the UN website on its membership listing. When the news got around on the internet, they quickly bailed out! But it was too late! And this is the organization that goes around calling itself Christian?
 5/23/07
 jenny
 humble,texas
 Let me begin by saying i have been studing with my sister-in-law for several mounths now.I enjoy my bible studies very much.befor i began my studies i was so very depressed i was on the brink of suicide.Getting to know Jehovah and the bible has turned my life around.Now i know i have hope of the sesurrection and look forward to life in the paradise.
 I don't have support from my family especially my husband who refers to Jehovah Witnesses as a cult.How can anyone call Jehovahs people a cult?It is written the truth in the bible.
 All you have to do is open your bible and read befor passing judgement. Please draw closer to Jehovah and Jehovah will draw closer to you!
 5/23/07
 I think the film was tastefully done. It helps people to understand why we knock at their doors and keep coming back (unless they tell us not to of course). I work full time, as do most JW's, so I spend Saturdays or Sundays trying to reach people at their homes. Its a very gratifying work helping people to understand the bible and come into a relationship with God. I was raised Catholic and am the only one in my very large Italian family that is one of JW's. Still, I have a wonderful relationship with my brothers and sisters even though they have made different religious choices themselves. Jehovah's Witnesses don't judge people. We can offer insight into why the world is in the state it is in and offer hope for the future through the pages of the bible if people are interested. We also try to offer "pratical" assistance to our neighbors through a study of the bible. In the end, Jehovah God reads each individuals heart. I feel priviliged to be engaged in this worldwide work.
 5/23/07
 I never understood the reason for witnesses to not want blood if they needed it. After the AIDS epidemic and Hepatitis C and so many other diseases transmitted thru blood, I thought it was a smart move. After seeing the film and doing a little research, I found that the new techniques doctor's have pioneered as a direct result of JWs refusal to blood gave people who are NOT witnesses a medical choice that wasn't there for them before. I for my part wouldn't want someones nasty old blood put in my body. Who knows what other diseases they haven't discovered yet that is passed on thru blood. If you have a good surgeon, you shouldn't need someone elses blood put in you to survive. I also know a nurse who personally told me that you never hear of the bad reactions and even deaths of people and yes even children, who have died because they were given blood that was not compatible with their bodies. She is the head nurse at a university hospital. That was when I started thinking about how great it is that there are other options open to us now because JW's said no to blood.
 5/23/07
 tuff
 Baltimore, MD
 I read some of the blogs and was shock to read the bitterness others have toward Jehovah's Witnesses. Many who profess to be Chritians. Much of their criticism is based on miss information, personal opinions and hatred. What is a Christian? A foot step follower of Jesus Christ. That's what the Witnesses are 'True Christians'. They follow the teachings of Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ always gave credit, honor and respect to his father, Jehovah, the Creator. Therefore, Jesus' followers are to do the same. I just don't see what the problem is. Jehovah made it very clear that he will not share his worship with any other god or image. Jesus is Jehovah's son. The Son of God. There is no mention of 'three'. Is the holy spirit a person? Explain please by means of bible references, if you can. I just don't get the hostility and bitterness from so many so-called Christians.
 5/23/07
 Mc
 ML, WA
 I have noticed that many people think that the organization of Jehovah's Witness's FORCE their members to not take blood transfusions. I would just like to bring to light that that is not true. We as Jehovah's Witness's asure that that is the best decision one could take, because it is not just in our bible's but in everyone else's bible as well, for example look in the texts of (Acts 15:28,29)Especially verse 29 were it shows that we abstain from blood. Also the text of (Leviticus 17:10) shows how we should not eath ANY MANNER of blood. At the end it comes down to taking a decision based on you're conscious. At the end it comes down to the person him/her self taking the decision in accepting a blood transfusion or not. We do not FORCE people to be a JW, atleast we shouldn't cause Jehovah does not want to force anyone into doing something if it does not come from the heart of the person. So the next time a JW comes knocking at your door, PLEASE try to take time and ask ANY questions if you want to.
 5/23/07
 Catherine Seiber
 Tulsa,OK
 I would like to express deep appreciation to PBS for their broadcast and also the journalist who felt moved to document these life stories. I was moved by the journalists honesty and felt the program was historically accurate. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, but have not always been. It is love of God (Jehovah) and love of neighbor that compels us to continue to follow Jesus command to preach and teach and keep knocking. Matthew 22:37-40; Matthew 28:18-20. Thank you again.
 5/23/07
 I just want to thank this filmmaker for a fair and honest portrayal of Jehovah's Witnesses. Very often, the news media bends the reality of my religion but that did not happen in this documentary. I was very impressed and appreciative!
 5/23/07
 Chicago, IL
 My comments are regarding JW religion and personal freedom. To current JWs -- You cannot discount the comments of posters who were baptized JWs for many years and have now left. We know what are talking about. Most of us are very understanding of JW�s as individuals and as an organization. I am not an apostate � I simply left. I appreciate that for many of you this religion "saved" you or was the answer you had been searching for (It was for my parents). But, for those of us who are now shunned by our entire family just because we didn't want to be JW's anymore, that is truly unkind. I live my life by moral principles found in the Bible; however, I choose not to follow JW rules (all you current and former JW�s know what I mean by rules). I don�t begrudge a group their rules, but why can't I disagree and still get to have a relationship with my mother and sister? Why? Because at 16 I got baptized. It was the only life I knew since infancy. I was sheltered and was only told one side of the story.
 How is that a choice? And when I did finally grow-up and make a mature choice, I was shunned for it. I was forced to choose between my right to live my life according to my beliefs and a relationship with my entire family. How is that for freedom in America?
 5/23/07
 SC
 Texas
 I've been a Jehovah Witness for 20 years and watching that video last night made me appreciate the organization even more.After reading a few of the comments i cant help but feel sad for the ones who still dont get understand our beliefs.The ones who have only but negatives things to say obviously never really had Jehovah in their heart.The Elders are there to help us and the brothers and sisters are our support.Satan has blinded so many people and only Jehovah knows what is in our hearts.I may be young but i know im in the truth.And for the one who said God isnt Jehovah...read ur bible....
 5/23/07
 AM
 Michigan
 "John 13:35 "By THIS all will know that YOU are my disciples, if you have love among yourselves."
 JW's have a wordwide brotherhood something that no other religion has been able to attain or copy. Even during times of war JW's stand united to Christian neutrality as practiced by Jesus and the lst Century Christians. They would never go to war to kill any of their Christian brothers or sisters or anyone else for that matter.
 As an organzation no other religion has been able to have the peace and unity practiced by these people.
 No religion is more maligned than the witnesses and yet they are the ones that most closely follow the Christianity practiced by Jesus and his early disciples. "If they hated me they will hate you also." Jesus own words.All the things people on this board have said against the witnesses are the same things said about the early Christians,and just as those accusations were false (sect, cult, break up families, brainwashing etc.) the accusations against the witnesses are false also.
 What a wonderfully honest film.
 5/23/07
 Houston TX
 It seems to me that the JW's that are no longer associated or disfellowshipped criticize the Witnesses because of bad experiences they have had with imperfect human Beings and BLame Jehovah and his organization. Remember Jehovah has not done anything to you. The People in Jehovah's Organization are not perfect and do not claim to be. We all make mistakes and have different personalities and backgrouds. I believe this is the truth and will not allow any human (inside Jehovah's organization - because of imperfection or bad experiences - or outside of Jehovah's organization) make me stop serving Jehovah God the way he has set out in his Word. Like one of the Apostles said to Jesus "Where are we to go away to, because you have the sayings of Everlasting Life".
 5/23/07
 Just saw the documentary. Thought it was interesting and informative. Thanks for being willing to share your feelings and thoughts throughout it. Hope this gets more airtime as most of us don't know much about this religious group.
 5/23/07
 sarah
 I appreciate how they're are people out there curios about our beliefs. I strongly disagree with this documentary.Many of the things featured in this film were not true. Therefore its not fair for Jehovah's Witnesses to be judged for any reason,after watching this film. Some things said were facts,but not all was true. Next time get your facts straight. And in the future if anyone has any questions regarding Jehovah's Witnesses, We would gladly like to answer questions. Infact, you dont need to come to us. We'll be at your door one of these days..sooner than later.
 5/23/07
 Letty Y
 anaheim, ca
 I was reading what john said in his comment, no, we do not beat our children in the bathroom, he made it sound like we abuse them phisically, but is not that way, I am a witness and I have seen mothers spanking them like any mother would, and about the holding hands when going out with someone is allowed, I have a boyfriend and do hold hands with him and other witnesses know, and it is nothing to hide, but they do incourage us to be careful about fornication, just because we know is not right in Gods eyes and because we can suffer the consecuences such as unplanned pregnancies, wich happen very often, also for that reson they exist so many diseases like aids, gonorrea, and other std's. All they want for us is to be healthy so we can live longer. Theres a good reason for everything, but people refuse to follow Gods word and then they have to cry a river. Don't let this happen to you and don't let people fool you, find out for your self! Remember, Jehova God loves you, he wants the best for you.
 5/23/07
 G.P.
 Orland, CA
 My compliments to the journalists for creating an unbiased, realistic documentary. How refreshing in light of the many negative products the media has fed the public recently about Jehovah's Witnesses. It is my hope that more will choose to visit a Kingdom Hall, and evaluate the scriptural teachings, rather than focus on imperfections of people. Contrary to what many think, the Bible is not difficult to understand; when taken as a whole, the simple truths ring clear. The guidelines given in the Bible are a protection for us.
 5/23/07
 Rebekah
 This was one of the rare positive films I've ever watched regarding Jehovah's Witnesses. I was born into a Jehovah's Witness family. My parents have provided me with values that I will never be able to thank them enough for. Although I did not remain Jehovah's Witness, I will always admire and respect their loyalty to their faith. I grew up in a loving, God fearing home and am a better person for having been fortunate enough to have such a strong upbringing. Thank you for making this amazing film. I was very touched by the stories and could relate to many of the people who were interviewed. I love you mom and dad, thank you for staying strong in your beliefs!
 5/23/07
 Gregory Chalet
 Los Angeles, CA
 I would like to express my gratitude towards your team for this very good documentary, to the surgeon who operated on the father and son and to all persons interviewed, giving a true and honest witness.
 I have been a Jehovah's witness for 20 years and I too went to prison in France for 12 months because I refused to serve in the military. It takes a lot of faith, especially when you are 18 and have to face a General.
 And for those who are saying that the Jehovah's witnesses let their children die, this movie showed how much this father loved his son by giving his liver!
 5/23/07
 Rene
 True Civil & Human Rights are basic and historically sought after ideals by educated people worldwide. People with vision. MLK for instance.
 Remarkably, this film shows Jehovah's Witnesses have actually obtain a measure of both.
 Most people religious or not worldwide have built-in moral conflicts on how these can be achieved.
 For instance, a Christian or athiest, etc. may think freedom can only be acheived if he go to war and kill people with different political affiliations.
 The conflict is inherent. How can a Christian kill? Isn't against the prinicpals of the Bible?
 How can an athiest kill? Isn't against the basic moral fiber of conscience?
 Appearently you do not have to kill to make an impact afterall.
 The concept that Jehovah's Witnesses could be granted release from German WW2 Concentration camps for simply renouncing their faith in God is almost too hard to understand.
 Next time I think of human dignity, human rights and faith, I will think of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Bravo!
 5/23/07
 K D
 Florida
 The grandmother gave the impression that she was unwelcome to her Witness family members, almost as if she was denied contact with them. But clearly she was a welcomed family association - her son-in-law even thanking her for being there with them in the hospital. She said felt she couldn't fit into their niche. This is just the natural feeling when there are differing opinions, and differing opinions could encompass just about anything. If the grandmother loved chicken while everyone else in her family refused to ever eat it.. she wouldn't fit into this their niche either, but not fitting in, or having a differing opinion did not cause her to be left out of their lives, to be shunned or belittled. Also - although the man in this case who refused a transfusion was of age to make his own choice, sometimes Witness parents must make a choice for their under-aged child. Many people see a Witness parent's refusal of a blood transfusion for their minor child as a selfish and unloving decision/act. But the naturally deep love that Witness parents typically have for their children was wonderfully shown in that this man's father was willing to potentially give up his very life for his child's survival.. he was willing to give anything and everything.. except his integrity to his beliefs of right and wrong. This is the same strength of faith that enabled the Witnesses to refuse to sign their own release papers from the Nazi camps.. if to be released meant that they had to give up their integrity (or adherence)to what was right and wrong.
 5/23/07
 Joe Lombardo
 Dawsonville GA
 I have been a JW for 41 years and have spoken face to face - one on one with over 8000 people in my door to door ministry and this has resulted in personally knowing what spiritual offerings are available from religions throughout the world. I have thousands of personal friends among my faith that can report the same. Every JW receives extensive education on the bible. Thus when JWs make statements on faith or the truth or when they take a stand that puts them outside of mainstream thinking or politics you can be sure that its after having considered ALL of what is out there to be considered. We do not suffer the tyranny of ignorance so it shouldn't surprise you that JWs are so different.
 5/23/07
 Chicago, IL
 Congratulations of a well done video. Hopefully families of Jehovah's Witnesses and non-witnesses will be able to open up some dialog about our Grand Creator and his awesome love. Jehovah's Witnesses are not taught to hate anyone. God is love, therfore we try to imitate such love. Though we shun behavior that is not in harmony with what the Bible teachings that Jehovah God approves of. The reason we avoid contact with persons formerly Witnesses is because they aren't living to the highest moral standards set out in the bible. Many of the former witnesses have decided to PICK & CHOOSE what portions of the bible they feel suits their lifestyle...whether it is taking a stand against blood transfusions, or not celebrating holidays. But Jehovah has the right to decide what standards he wants his servants to live under, seeing how he created humans and gave his son's life so that we could have the slightest chance of being restored to a perfect human state oneday. It isn't up to us to see which portions of his standards feel right or are not "strict" as some people say, why should we want Jehovah to lower his standards so we(humans) can raise ours.
 5/23/07
 Andrew
 I am 54 years old and have been a baptized witness since 1987. I was born and raised a Roman Catholic. When I was young Mass was in Latin which did me and my two brothers and two sisters absolutely no good. We could always look forward to a good whipping from my dad for not sitting still and paying attention. Every Saturday morning we all had to attend Catechism classes for Catholic children who did not attend Catholic schools. This again was absolutely a waste of time as there was nothing learned, just three hours of trying to sitt still so the nuns would not spank us or rap our fingers with a wooden ruler. This happened for two weeks all day during the summer. We never learned nothing, all it was , was a babysitting session by the nuns and our beatings for not sitting still or talking, and they told our parents, so we were spanked again at home. Compare this with what Jehovah's witness's children learn at the kingdom hall from birth on and any correction by the parents to sit still so they can learn what about 100 people average want to learn without unruly children. I'll take the Kingdom Hall education anyday instead of the church mysteries.
 5/23/07
 Susie
 Sacramento, CA
 In response to John...I have been in the truth for 27 years. I recently got married and held hands with my husband the whole time we were dating and was never shunned or frowned upon. And if children are taken to the bathrooms and DISIPLINED it's because they need to learn to stay quiet. Those who chose not to disipline their children end up with unruly kids. 5/23/07
 I just finished watching the Knocking documentary. Although raised and baptized as a Jehovah's Witness, I am currently not practicing what is right. The film moved me to tears and I would like to say that I am SO PROUD to have ever been able to associate myself and my name with this wonderful, peaceful, beautiful group of God's people.
 5/23/07
 Jim P
 Thank You PBS for a fair,factual and positive look at us. The media does not always do this.
 One correction. The report stated that individuals who do not agree with our doctrine get disfellowshipped. Actually, it is an individual who breaks God's law and does not wish to change or stop their behavior or lifestyle . This is a big difference.
 While not perfect, I truly cannot find a more loving group of Christians. We will not kill another member in War or commit violence upon them.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_l.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Allie Ward
 Baton Rouge, LA
 There is NO DECIENCY AND DIGNITY in the "jehovah cult." They have destroyed my family. They PRETEND to be family oriented, however, if you DO NOT join their sect, they will leave their married family, taking the children, lying to them as to why they can no longer see them. I KNOW THIS. I am PROOF ! Their children will NEVER have prefect attendance at school, their wives do not work unless it is within the realm of THEIR EXISTENCE, you cannot enter their "halls" without a "sponsor." NO OTHER CHURCH WOULD DO THIS ! They DO NOT want outsiders IN to reveal their TRUE practices. To become A CITIZEN and IN COURT,they raise their RIGHT HAND, PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO OUR FLAG, ONE NATION UNDER "GOD" (not jehovah). They "prey" on you ONLY when you are down emotionally and financially like they did in this area after Hurricane Katrina. I know ex-jehovah's who are under psychiatric care because of the emotional scars left by them. Their NEGATIVES are too GREAT. I feel sorry for those TRAPPED. They are DECEITFUL, LYING, INDIVIDUALS. They are WOLVES in sheeps clothing. If you who "think" you are being taught the TRUTH you MUST do further research. GOD BLESS YOU ALL...
 5/23/07
 Kevin A. Martinez
 Marrero, Louisiana
 My wife and I have been studying with the JW's for a while now and we have have many family members that have argued our decision. Studying the bible and learning what provisions Jehovah has for us has brought great relief to us. I went to my regular book study on 5/22/07 and our bible conductor announced that on PBS there was going to be a special on JW's entitled, 'Knocking'. My wife and I saw the entire program and enjoyed it so much. By being obedient we are sure to know that the true God Jehovah will bless our efforts. 'Knocking' was also a thunderous call from our God and may all those who saw the film be entrigued to share in the ministry and get to know a happy God, the creator of the universe. His word exerts power and is sharper than any two-edged sword. Joseph and Seth applied the counsel of Acts 5:29 which states,"We should obey God as ruler rather than men." They are sure to receive many rich blessings for their bravery. If obedient we too can have the same privilege.
 5/23/07
 James
 Virginia
 There are many misconceptions out there about us. Some people who have commented here really do not know us or our beliefs.
 Actually there have always been witnesses of Jehovah not just since the 1800's. Jesus, Paul, Jeramiah and other all "witnessed" about Jehovah.
 Not many credit us for saying well in advance that 1914 was and is a marked year.
 Our Bible translation was thoroughly researched using the orginial Hebrew\Greek and is explained too.
 5/23/07
 Paty
 SC
 Wow!!! It was an amazing documentary.
 I thank Jehovah for letting others see his real people. Despite what people say or think, the program showed our believes, how we've changed history & our love for people including our own family. The fact, that the person who did this is not a Jehovah's Witness makes a difference.
 Perhaps, those who watched the show will never become Witnesses, but I'm sure they know that they were wrong in their view towards us. That glorifies Jehovah's names more than anything else.
 Thanks one more time....
 5/23/07
 A. Moore
 I have noticed quite a few comments of people who wanted this documentary to focus more on what they view as negative info toward the JWs.To them I say that there are plenty of websites, blogs, readings etc. that do their best to do this. So, since I doubt you go to those forums and request that the more positive views be expressed. Why do it here? This false sense of "fairness" only proves that no matter what is written, if it's not negative you're not happy. Great show! I have it on my DVR until my DVD arrives.
 5/23/07
 Jenny
 I enjoyed "KNOCKING" very much. It's nice to watch an objectively, WELL-DOCUMENTED film about people we've always been curious about. Joel, you obviously did your homework for a long time. You were extremely courageous to choose such a subject, but somebody needed to do it. Thanks! It has brought up lots of controversy, as posted, but people choose what they want to believe -- no matter what the facts are. To follow a perfect man's footsteps is also a hard thing to do. You've revealed that there are imperfect people out there that are examining those steps and trying to walk in them. That takes alot of courage, too. Thanks again for showing us some of the effort that's involved. Some had rather do some "TALK" than to try the "WALK".
 5/23/07
 Michael Liuzza
 I am 14 years old and have been one of Jehovah's Witnesses from my birth. I would never change. I beleave this is the truth.
 5/23/07
 AMG
 I ALONG WITH MY FAMILY SAW YOUR DOCUMENATRY YESTERDAY EVENING AND I MUST SAY THAT I WAS PLEASANTLY SURPRISED.IT WAS A WELL BALANCED PRESENTATION OF OUR FAITH AND COMMUNITY. WHETHER INTENED OR NOT YOU HAVE GIVEN A GOOD WITNESS TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.YOU SHOWED THAT THIS ORGINZATION IS COMPRISED OF IMPERFECT BEINGS JUST TRYING TO DO THE RIGHT THINGS NOT MORE NOTHING LESS. TO THOSE WHO FEEL ANGER TOWARDS THIER BEING DISFELLOWSHIPED/SHUNNED LET'S MAKE ONE THING CLEAR ELDERS DO NOT DISFELLOWSHIP ANYONE, THE PERSON COMMITING THE SIN IS THE ONE WHO DOES IT TO THEMSELVES BY NOT ADMITTING THIER MISTAKE AND THRU ACTIONS SHOWING WHETHER THEY ARE TRULLY SORRY FOR THERE ERRORS. I SHOULD KNOW I WAS DISFELLOWSHIPPED FOR 14YRS AND MY FAMILY NEVER LOSS CONTACT WTH ME.WHEN MY SON WAS BORN MY MOTHER WAS IN THE ROOM TO WELCOME HIM.I CONTINUE TO STRUGGLE DAILY WITH DEPRESION AND OTHER AILMENTS AND MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS ARE AWARE OF THIS AND TREAT ME WITH LOVING KINDNESS WHeHER I PUT 1 HR OR 10 HRS OF SERVICE THE THING JEHOVA APPRECIATES IS THAT WE GIVE HIM OUR BEST IN EVERYTHING WE DO QUALITY NOT QUANTITY IS WHAT MATTERS TO HIM. ONCE AGAIN THANK YOU FOR YOUR EFFORT. AND THANK YOU TO OR BROTHERS FOR SHARING THEMSELVES WITH US AND THE WORLD
 5/23/07
 former
 Texas
 Wow, so many thoughts from so many people, I was a former J.W.What is wrong with them? Who do you see door to door like the bible say to do?Who upraises there kids in the stright path?I have never met a Witnees who is unhappy with there life.I have never meet a Wetnees dying of an STD. These people don't bother no one. Has any one ever wondered if there should be one true religion, what should it be? Should it be to meet our standards and benefits,and made up to please or daily life?Or should it be with faith and based on what God asked from Us.Times have changed becouse we have permitted it to,how many of us parents rise our kids to Gods standards, how many have read the bible to our kids? The bible and God do not exists now in days.Thats why when a group of people that are doing right in there believes, seems so wrong to us.What has life become?
 5/23/07
 G.K.
 Springfield, MO.
 For the last 30 plus years I've been deeply interested in whats correct dogma among the many different religions all claiming they know the true teachings of the Bible. I've collected over 80 different English Bible translations and the most indepth Greek and Hebrew inter-linear works to really know and study the Bible. I consider myself a scholar in Biblical research, having studied for years in many major Bible universities and theological libraries. So do the Jehovah's Witnesses have their major doctrines correct? They teach there is no hellfire torment for the wicked as well as no immortal soul. They teach Almighty God is only the Father and not the Trinity of three persons, each almighty and without beginning. Now I must be honest and admit that the JW's are teaching correctly here. A search of these subjects in libraries will reveal a bias by many churches to hid or change the actual Biblical information. The documentary film did well I think, but they are not a cult with non-biblical dogmas. I enjoy reading their literature and have used it for references many times.
 5/23/07
 BBB
 Los Angeles
 Convitions with an opposing set of beliefs. They are really great people. I am married to a member and I have attended the meetings and what I do not under stand is how a group of people can study the bible so much and have it interpreted so indifferant. They believe in what is made known to them and not what is read from the bible. Do they debate any thing studied? I do love my wife and her family and I have learned to tell them in a nice way as so not to upset them is "the bible does't say that,the Jehovah�s Witnesses say that". Getting back to the film, where there no other christian groups inprisoned in the camps and was the bloodless technic for an operaration developed for the Jehovah Witnesses beliefs? Was this a promotionl doctrine?
 5/23/07
 Maribel
 Miami, FL
 To my dear brothers and sisters: we are thankful for this honest documentary and proud of our beliefs. It is true that we do not like others to talk bad about our faith and association of brothers but, remember: Jesus did not lift a hand nor said a word when they were spitting on him. Like a recent Watchtower article said: Jehovah will take the stand. HE will judge. Let us PEACEFULLY continue doing the work we were told to do (Matt. 24:14) Or else, we would not be demonstrating with example what this documentary shows we are: seekers of peace.
 5/23/07
 RUDY
 As a Jehovah's Witness, I am very blessed to have as fellow worshippers true friends. Yes indeed, the Witnesses certainly stand out, Jesus Christ said we would, it's not a surprise.
 Although not political, the positive impact our Bible teaching has for families & the community. For example, no more alcohol & drug abuse, promiscuous conduct which leads to sexually transmitted diseases, some diseases due to blood transfusions, divorces, the emotional trauma for all, honest tax-payers, law abiding citizens, an honest days work, no gangs, no organized crime affiliation, basically a wholesome lifestle. ADD IT ALL UP !!! How much tax payer money goes to abuses ? BILLIONS !
 Jehovah's Witnesses, due to imperfections, have challenges in life like everyone does. The difference ? We leave our whole trust in our Almighty God Jehovah.
 Historically, despite well intentions, man cannot bring peace & a cure for mankind's woes, rich or poor. Due to imperfection & the influence of Satan & his demons, Jehovah God & His Kingdom under Christ is the only hope. That is our message we wish all mankind would grasp !!! For the time being, as a united brotherhood, we will love God & neighbor, & share this wonderful hope until Jehovah God says !
 5/23/07
 gretna, la.
 Film was shown in our area 5/22/07 for the first time. It was wonderful. I have always watchted Frontline, P.O.V.,Independent Lens, etc. All very informative and well done. This was no different. I am third generation Jehovah's Witness. Like the author, I was never a big fan of knocking on doors. I'm still not. But I do it anyway. I want to do the work Jesus did. It's nice when people listen (and some do) but it doesn't make or break our work. Sometimes it's fun. And I'm 53 yrs old.
 5/23/07
 Phoenix, AZ
 My Parents and me are the only JW in our extended family. I have a close relationship with some of my non-JW cousins, aunts and uncles. Not all agree with our beliefs and sometime try to argue about religion but that doesn't stop us from talking to them. We get together to eat and visit as long as its not for a holiday or birthday party.
 It hurts to hear all these negative comments from all these people that dont know anything about us and are not open to learning and respecting others point of views.
 To those who have been disfellowshiped because they felt other brothers were being a hypocrite, we are ALL imperfect, JW or non-JW. Sometimes there are brothers,sisters and elders in congregations that take Jehova's word to the extreme or misinterpret it. You should not let this discourage you. Jehova in his time will do what is just to keep his congregation pure, be it in this system or in armagedon. This and personal bible study helped me to keep my faith strong. I was in a congregation where some elders took Jehova's word a little to the extreme. I have since moved to another congregation and my faith is stronger than ever. Remember, Jehova wants ALL his children to live the life he intended in the beginning, eternal perfection in paradise.
 5/23/07
 to J. Blue from Chico, CA, great comment, i too forgot during my teens what i was thought as a child as a JW, and i lived the life the world wants you to live and i truthfully regret those wasted years, now i'm back being a witness, i'm baptized and can honestly say now i enjoy life.
 5/23/07
 Pennsylvania
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I am a young married woman. My Husband has just recently been disfellowshipped. I am not torn between the decision though, because I believe that it was the right choice for them to have made. The Elders do care, whether you want to believe it or not. Disfellowshipping is the result that Baptised JW's recieve if they are given cousel for their wrong, sinful action and are not genuinely repentant. If you are disfellowshipped, and just leave, then you have let satan overcome you. Jehovah made that happen because you would have been a bad influence to the congregation. We all know this. I still stand by my husband, and obey the rules. It is difficult right now, as I knew it would be, but He will come back. He loves the truth, and knows it is the truth. If the rest of you know it is the truth then remember, we do not do this for the people. We do it for JEHOVAH. There are corrupt congregations. But we must have faith that JEHOVAH will fix them. But leaving the congregation will got us NOWHERE. We trust our Faith. May Jehovah be with you all in your decisions. And children are not beaten, we have good children, the worlds children are terrors. Children killing parents. you do not hear of that in our christian congregation.
 5/23/07
 Jeremy
 Chicago, IL
 Thank you I enjoyed this film, it shows a side of everyday life that JW's face. Many think that we're fanatics that go from door to door in an effort to force people to our religion; but we're not. If you don't want us at your home just asked to be placed on the 'Do Not Call' list. If you're and yet don't come to the door, you're wasting our's and Jehovah's time. We may seem annoying but so were God's prophets; and even Jesus was 'annoying' to the Pharisees of his day. We bring a message of Hope and Judgment from God. You don't have to believe it or accept it, its your choice. But please continue to persecute us for our faith, for all TRUE followers of Jesus are supposed to be. I'll give you a prophecy that hasn't been fulfilled yet. The governments will turn on ALL religion. When that happens, remind yourself who told you that truth, and then maybe you'll wish you answered the door when we came KNOCKING.
 5/23/07
 Tempe, AZ
 I saw the documentary about Jehovah's Witnesses on PBS Tuesday night, and they missed several things. First, the Watchtower organization has had a history of false predictions about the end of the world. The most notable was in 1975 when the members were told (by the governing body in NY) to sell all of their property in preparation for it, and the end did not come. This should have been a sign for every JW to leave the organization. When someone makes a specific prediction for the Lord's return and it does not happen, that automatically indicates that the preson (or organization) is a false prophet. The Bible is very clear on this. For anyone who is impressed by JW's sincerety and dedication must realize one thing--sincerety is no substitute for the truth!!
 Here is a fact that the average JW on the street is likely not aware of. The Watchtower organization has, for years, taught that the United Nations was the beast of Revelation 17 (part of the "Harlot"). This fact appeared in various Watchtower articles through the years. However, from 1992 till 2001, the Watchtower organization was an NGO (non-governmental organization) member of the United Nations! This is pure hyprocrisy! It was on the UN website on its membership listing. When the news got around on the internet, they quickly bailed out! But it was too late! And this is the organization that goes around calling itself Christian?
 5/23/07
 jenny
 humble,texas
 Let me begin by saying i have been studing with my sister-in-law for several mounths now.I enjoy my bible studies very much.befor i began my studies i was so very depressed i was on the brink of suicide.Getting to know Jehovah and the bible has turned my life around.Now i know i have hope of the sesurrection and look forward to life in the paradise.
 I don't have support from my family especially my husband who refers to Jehovah Witnesses as a cult.How can anyone call Jehovahs people a cult?It is written the truth in the bible.
 All you have to do is open your bible and read befor passing judgement. Please draw closer to Jehovah and Jehovah will draw closer to you!
 5/23/07
 I think the film was tastefully done. It helps people to understand why we knock at their doors and keep coming back (unless they tell us not to of course). I work full time, as do most JW's, so I spend Saturdays or Sundays trying to reach people at their homes. Its a very gratifying work helping people to understand the bible and come into a relationship with God. I was raised Catholic and am the only one in my very large Italian family that is one of JW's. Still, I have a wonderful relationship with my brothers and sisters even though they have made different religious choices themselves. Jehovah's Witnesses don't judge people. We can offer insight into why the world is in the state it is in and offer hope for the future through the pages of the bible if people are interested. We also try to offer "pratical" assistance to our neighbors through a study of the bible. In the end, Jehovah God reads each individuals heart. I feel priviliged to be engaged in this worldwide work.
 5/23/07
 I never understood the reason for witnesses to not want blood if they needed it. After the AIDS epidemic and Hepatitis C and so many other diseases transmitted thru blood, I thought it was a smart move. After seeing the film and doing a little research, I found that the new techniques doctor's have pioneered as a direct result of JWs refusal to blood gave people who are NOT witnesses a medical choice that wasn't there for them before. I for my part wouldn't want someones nasty old blood put in my body. Who knows what other diseases they haven't discovered yet that is passed on thru blood. If you have a good surgeon, you shouldn't need someone elses blood put in you to survive. I also know a nurse who personally told me that you never hear of the bad reactions and even deaths of people and yes even children, who have died because they were given blood that was not compatible with their bodies. She is the head nurse at a university hospital. That was when I started thinking about how great it is that there are other options open to us now because JW's said no to blood.
 5/23/07
 tuff
 Baltimore, MD
 I read some of the blogs and was shock to read the bitterness others have toward Jehovah's Witnesses. Many who profess to be Chritians. Much of their criticism is based on miss information, personal opinions and hatred. What is a Christian? A foot step follower of Jesus Christ. That's what the Witnesses are 'True Christians'. They follow the teachings of Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ always gave credit, honor and respect to his father, Jehovah, the Creator. Therefore, Jesus' followers are to do the same. I just don't see what the problem is. Jehovah made it very clear that he will not share his worship with any other god or image. Jesus is Jehovah's son. The Son of God. There is no mention of 'three'. Is the holy spirit a person? Explain please by means of bible references, if you can. I just don't get the hostility and bitterness from so many so-called Christians.
 5/23/07
 Mc
 ML, WA
 I have noticed that many people think that the organization of Jehovah's Witness's FORCE their members to not take blood transfusions. I would just like to bring to light that that is not true. We as Jehovah's Witness's asure that that is the best decision one could take, because it is not just in our bible's but in everyone else's bible as well, for example look in the texts of (Acts 15:28,29)Especially verse 29 were it shows that we abstain from blood. Also the text of (Leviticus 17:10) shows how we should not eath ANY MANNER of blood. At the end it comes down to taking a decision based on you're conscious. At the end it comes down to the person him/her self taking the decision in accepting a blood transfusion or not. We do not FORCE people to be a JW, atleast we shouldn't cause Jehovah does not want to force anyone into doing something if it does not come from the heart of the person. So the next time a JW comes knocking at your door, PLEASE try to take time and ask ANY questions if you want to.
 5/23/07
 Catherine Seiber
 Tulsa,OK
 I would like to express deep appreciation to PBS for their broadcast and also the journalist who felt moved to document these life stories. I was moved by the journalists honesty and felt the program was historically accurate. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses, but have not always been. It is love of God (Jehovah) and love of neighbor that compels us to continue to follow Jesus command to preach and teach and keep knocking. Matthew 22:37-40; Matthew 28:18-20. Thank you again.
 5/23/07
 I just want to thank this filmmaker for a fair and honest portrayal of Jehovah's Witnesses. Very often, the news media bends the reality of my religion but that did not happen in this documentary. I was very impressed and appreciative!
 5/23/07
 Chicago, IL
 My comments are regarding JW religion and personal freedom. To current JWs -- You cannot discount the comments of posters who were baptized JWs for many years and have now left. We know what are talking about. Most of us are very understanding of JW�s as individuals and as an organization. I am not an apostate � I simply left. I appreciate that for many of you this religion "saved" you or was the answer you had been searching for (It was for my parents). But, for those of us who are now shunned by our entire family just because we didn't want to be JW's anymore, that is truly unkind. I live my life by moral principles found in the Bible; however, I choose not to follow JW rules (all you current and former JW�s know what I mean by rules). I don�t begrudge a group their rules, but why can't I disagree and still get to have a relationship with my mother and sister? Why? Because at 16 I got baptized. It was the only life I knew since infancy. I was sheltered and was only told one side of the story.
 How is that a choice? And when I did finally grow-up and make a mature choice, I was shunned for it. I was forced to choose between my right to live my life according to my beliefs and a relationship with my entire family. How is that for freedom in America?
 5/23/07
 SC
 Texas
 I've been a Jehovah Witness for 20 years and watching that video last night made me appreciate the organization even more.After reading a few of the comments i cant help but feel sad for the ones who still dont get understand our beliefs.The ones who have only but negatives things to say obviously never really had Jehovah in their heart.The Elders are there to help us and the brothers and sisters are our support.Satan has blinded so many people and only Jehovah knows what is in our hearts.I may be young but i know im in the truth.And for the one who said God isnt Jehovah...read ur bible....
 5/23/07
 AM
 Michigan
 "John 13:35 "By THIS all will know that YOU are my disciples, if you have love among yourselves."
 JW's have a wordwide brotherhood something that no other religion has been able to attain or copy. Even during times of war JW's stand united to Christian neutrality as practiced by Jesus and the lst Century Christians. They would never go to war to kill any of their Christian brothers or sisters or anyone else for that matter.
 As an organzation no other religion has been able to have the peace and unity practiced by these people.
 No religion is more maligned than the witnesses and yet they are the ones that most closely follow the Christianity practiced by Jesus and his early disciples. "If they hated me they will hate you also." Jesus own words.All the things people on this board have said against the witnesses are the same things said about the early Christians,and just as those accusations were false (sect, cult, break up families, brainwashing etc.) the accusations against the witnesses are false also.
 What a wonderfully honest film.
 5/23/07
 Houston TX
 It seems to me that the JW's that are no longer associated or disfellowshipped criticize the Witnesses because of bad experiences they have had with imperfect human Beings and BLame Jehovah and his organization. Remember Jehovah has not done anything to you. The People in Jehovah's Organization are not perfect and do not claim to be. We all make mistakes and have different personalities and backgrouds. I believe this is the truth and will not allow any human (inside Jehovah's organization - because of imperfection or bad experiences - or outside of Jehovah's organization) make me stop serving Jehovah God the way he has set out in his Word. Like one of the Apostles said to Jesus "Where are we to go away to, because you have the sayings of Everlasting Life".
 5/23/07
 Just saw the documentary. Thought it was interesting and informative. Thanks for being willing to share your feelings and thoughts throughout it. Hope this gets more airtime as most of us don't know much about this religious group.
 5/23/07
 sarah
 I appreciate how they're are people out there curios about our beliefs. I strongly disagree with this documentary.Many of the things featured in this film were not true. Therefore its not fair for Jehovah's Witnesses to be judged for any reason,after watching this film. Some things said were facts,but not all was true. Next time get your facts straight. And in the future if anyone has any questions regarding Jehovah's Witnesses, We would gladly like to answer questions. Infact, you dont need to come to us. We'll be at your door one of these days..sooner than later.
 5/23/07
 Letty Y
 anaheim, ca
 I was reading what john said in his comment, no, we do not beat our children in the bathroom, he made it sound like we abuse them phisically, but is not that way, I am a witness and I have seen mothers spanking them like any mother would, and about the holding hands when going out with someone is allowed, I have a boyfriend and do hold hands with him and other witnesses know, and it is nothing to hide, but they do incourage us to be careful about fornication, just because we know is not right in Gods eyes and because we can suffer the consecuences such as unplanned pregnancies, wich happen very often, also for that reson they exist so many diseases like aids, gonorrea, and other std's. All they want for us is to be healthy so we can live longer. Theres a good reason for everything, but people refuse to follow Gods word and then they have to cry a river. Don't let this happen to you and don't let people fool you, find out for your self! Remember, Jehova God loves you, he wants the best for you.
 5/23/07
 G.P.
 Orland, CA
 My compliments to the journalists for creating an unbiased, realistic documentary. How refreshing in light of the many negative products the media has fed the public recently about Jehovah's Witnesses. It is my hope that more will choose to visit a Kingdom Hall, and evaluate the scriptural teachings, rather than focus on imperfections of people. Contrary to what many think, the Bible is not difficult to understand; when taken as a whole, the simple truths ring clear. The guidelines given in the Bible are a protection for us.
 5/23/07
 Rebekah
 This was one of the rare positive films I've ever watched regarding Jehovah's Witnesses. I was born into a Jehovah's Witness family. My parents have provided me with values that I will never be able to thank them enough for. Although I did not remain Jehovah's Witness, I will always admire and respect their loyalty to their faith. I grew up in a loving, God fearing home and am a better person for having been fortunate enough to have such a strong upbringing. Thank you for making this amazing film. I was very touched by the stories and could relate to many of the people who were interviewed. I love you mom and dad, thank you for staying strong in your beliefs!
 5/23/07
 Gregory Chalet
 Los Angeles, CA
 I would like to express my gratitude towards your team for this very good documentary, to the surgeon who operated on the father and son and to all persons interviewed, giving a true and honest witness.
 I have been a Jehovah's witness for 20 years and I too went to prison in France for 12 months because I refused to serve in the military. It takes a lot of faith, especially when you are 18 and have to face a General.
 And for those who are saying that the Jehovah's witnesses let their children die, this movie showed how much this father loved his son by giving his liver!
 5/23/07
 Rene
 True Civil & Human Rights are basic and historically sought after ideals by educated people worldwide. People with vision. MLK for instance.
 Remarkably, this film shows Jehovah's Witnesses have actually obtain a measure of both.
 Most people religious or not worldwide have built-in moral conflicts on how these can be achieved.
 For instance, a Christian or athiest, etc. may think freedom can only be acheived if he go to war and kill people with different political affiliations.
 The conflict is inherent. How can a Christian kill? Isn't against the prinicpals of the Bible?
 How can an athiest kill? Isn't against the basic moral fiber of conscience?
 Appearently you do not have to kill to make an impact afterall.
 The concept that Jehovah's Witnesses could be granted release from German WW2 Concentration camps for simply renouncing their faith in God is almost too hard to understand.
 Next time I think of human dignity, human rights and faith, I will think of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 Bravo!
 5/23/07
 K D
 Florida
 The grandmother gave the impression that she was unwelcome to her Witness family members, almost as if she was denied contact with them. But clearly she was a welcomed family association - her son-in-law even thanking her for being there with them in the hospital. She said felt she couldn't fit into their niche. This is just the natural feeling when there are differing opinions, and differing opinions could encompass just about anything. If the grandmother loved chicken while everyone else in her family refused to ever eat it.. she wouldn't fit into this their niche either, but not fitting in, or having a differing opinion did not cause her to be left out of their lives, to be shunned or belittled. Also - although the man in this case who refused a transfusion was of age to make his own choice, sometimes Witness parents must make a choice for their under-aged child. Many people see a Witness parent's refusal of a blood transfusion for their minor child as a selfish and unloving decision/act. But the naturally deep love that Witness parents typically have for their children was wonderfully shown in that this man's father was willing to potentially give up his very life for his child's survival.. he was willing to give anything and everything.. except his integrity to his beliefs of right and wrong. This is the same strength of faith that enabled the Witnesses to refuse to sign their own release papers from the Nazi camps.. if to be released meant that they had to give up their integrity (or adherence)to what was right and wrong.
 5/23/07
 Joe Lombardo
 Dawsonville GA
 I have been a JW for 41 years and have spoken face to face - one on one with over 8000 people in my door to door ministry and this has resulted in personally knowing what spiritual offerings are available from religions throughout the world. I have thousands of personal friends among my faith that can report the same. Every JW receives extensive education on the bible. Thus when JWs make statements on faith or the truth or when they take a stand that puts them outside of mainstream thinking or politics you can be sure that its after having considered ALL of what is out there to be considered. We do not suffer the tyranny of ignorance so it shouldn't surprise you that JWs are so different.
 5/23/07
 Chicago, IL
 Congratulations of a well done video. Hopefully families of Jehovah's Witnesses and non-witnesses will be able to open up some dialog about our Grand Creator and his awesome love. Jehovah's Witnesses are not taught to hate anyone. God is love, therfore we try to imitate such love. Though we shun behavior that is not in harmony with what the Bible teachings that Jehovah God approves of. The reason we avoid contact with persons formerly Witnesses is because they aren't living to the highest moral standards set out in the bible. Many of the former witnesses have decided to PICK & CHOOSE what portions of the bible they feel suits their lifestyle...whether it is taking a stand against blood transfusions, or not celebrating holidays. But Jehovah has the right to decide what standards he wants his servants to live under, seeing how he created humans and gave his son's life so that we could have the slightest chance of being restored to a perfect human state oneday. It isn't up to us to see which portions of his standards feel right or are not "strict" as some people say, why should we want Jehovah to lower his standards so we(humans) can raise ours.
 5/23/07
 Andrew
 I am 54 years old and have been a baptized witness since 1987. I was born and raised a Roman Catholic. When I was young Mass was in Latin which did me and my two brothers and two sisters absolutely no good. We could always look forward to a good whipping from my dad for not sitting still and paying attention. Every Saturday morning we all had to attend Catechism classes for Catholic children who did not attend Catholic schools. This again was absolutely a waste of time as there was nothing learned, just three hours of trying to sitt still so the nuns would not spank us or rap our fingers with a wooden ruler. This happened for two weeks all day during the summer. We never learned nothing, all it was , was a babysitting session by the nuns and our beatings for not sitting still or talking, and they told our parents, so we were spanked again at home. Compare this with what Jehovah's witness's children learn at the kingdom hall from birth on and any correction by the parents to sit still so they can learn what about 100 people average want to learn without unruly children. I'll take the Kingdom Hall education anyday instead of the church mysteries.
 5/23/07
 Susie
 Sacramento, CA
 In response to John...I have been in the truth for 27 years. I recently got married and held hands with my husband the whole time we were dating and was never shunned or frowned upon. And if children are taken to the bathrooms and DISIPLINED it's because they need to learn to stay quiet. Those who chose not to disipline their children end up with unruly kids. 5/23/07
 I just finished watching the Knocking documentary. Although raised and baptized as a Jehovah's Witness, I am currently not practicing what is right. The film moved me to tears and I would like to say that I am SO PROUD to have ever been able to associate myself and my name with this wonderful, peaceful, beautiful group of God's people.
 5/23/07
 Jim P
 Thank You PBS for a fair,factual and positive look at us. The media does not always do this.
 One correction. The report stated that individuals who do not agree with our doctrine get disfellowshipped. Actually, it is an individual who breaks God's law and does not wish to change or stop their behavior or lifestyle . This is a big difference.
 While not perfect, I truly cannot find a more loving group of Christians. We will not kill another member in War or commit violence upon them.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_l.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Rita and Wally Malins
 Really enjoyed your "presentation" introduction. My husband and I appreciated that I.L. & PBS respectfully showed this documentary. We appreciate that I.L. made it possible for many to view the documentary in their homes in a nonchallenging setting. My husband and I are long-time Jehovah's Witnesses (50 yrs and 58 years respectively) and have been active in our ministry in several states in the U.S.A. When I attended High School in Chicago, I earned many citizenship and athletic awards as well as being a co-editor of our award-winning high school yearbook. I mention this because during all that time I was one of Jehovah's Witnesses who did not salute the flag nor celebrate holidays.
 My teachers respected my stand and dedication to be a fine student, good citizen as well as living up to my faith as a Christian. At this time my mother was not one of Jehovah's Witnesses while my two older sisters (and their families) were very active Witnesses. Mom became a Witness many years later at age at age 63. Whether one listens or rejects our beliefs in an individual choice and we would not want to deny that to anyone. Thanks again
 5/24/07
 John
 Many thanks to Mr. Engardio, PBS, CPB, and this forum. Jehovah has NEVER failed me! He is neither a cultist, pedophile, wife or child beater, nor a hypocrite. To the poor souls who decry His witnesses I say, when all else fails, read His instructions to us!......thank God for His Word, the Bible. God has never failed to fulfill a promise to mankind. You can have total, complete confidence in Him. Satan is taunting Jehovah more than ever in this time of the end. The harvest is great and many grow weary due to Satan's attacks, but never forget the endurance of Jesus. He remained faithful even to death on a torture stake. He thus sanctified and continues to sanctify God's name even today.
 Noah preached to a dark and dying world each day for over 60 years. Not one person listened or turned around. Noah, like Christ, was accused of being a fool, a cultist, and a blasphemer. Both were beaten and spat upon, yet imagine the GULP in the throat of the Roman soldier who said, "Truly this WAS the Son of God", or the horror of those outside the Ark when the rains came. Keep on the watch!Continue to glorify Jehovah in your life and you will save some. This old system of things is in it final chapter, much like the "unsinkable" Titanic. Will you continue to decorate your room on the Titanic, or will you stay inside the figurative Ark ever holding dear Jehovah's promises, and working hard to encourage fellow sufferers and incite them to LOVE and Fine Works?
 5/24/07
 Jenny
 Humble, Texas
 I seen the program (knocking)and i enjoyed it very much.I have been studing with my sister-in-law who is a Jehovahs Witness and it has been fulfilling the spiritual need i was so thirsty for.people say they are cults but if they would open their bible they would know better than that.Jehovahs witnesses don't shun anyone, people shun them and Jehovah!!
 5/24/07
 Alex
 New York
 It�s an interesting documentary. I�m a former JW, left about 12 years ago shortly after the Watchtower society changed its doomsday predictions on the generation of 1914 (Mat 24:34). My parents converted when I was a small child. I was baptized at 15 years of age and worked for the religion as a 21 hour per week proselytizer (�Regular Pioneer�) for a number of years. The documentary is a disturbing expos� of how religious faith can blind people into taking unnecessary risks (refusal of transfusions) and endure avoidable deadly situations (their WWII experience in Germany). It�s a faith based on the belief and absolute confidence that the biblical interpretations of the Watchtower Society is the truth, this despite the metamorphosis of Watchtower teachings and predictions through the years. For the other side� of the JW story I highly recommend Crisis of Conscience by Raymond Franz. Franz was a member of the Governing Body of the Watchtower Society. This forbidden book by the Watchtower society is a true eye opener and a must read for any one interested in the JW.
 5/24/07
 For all on the "ANTI" side of the issue, may I pose a scenario. If for instance, let's suppose you are caucasion and would not seek the services of a doctor that was of a different race no matter how qualified, but were now facing a sure life ending situation and the only person that could "SAVE YOUR LIFE", would you have a change of heart? Belief in GOD and the Bible can change DEEPLY ENTRENCHED THINGS, ask a JW to show you in YOUR Bible. Be assured, almost 7 million people today can truly SEE the BEAUTY in being COLOR BLIND. The scenario is purely retorhical but JEHOVAH IS THE READER OF HEARTS HE already knows how you answered. Please if nothing else read Romans 14: 10-12 and take a little time to meditate on it.
 5/24/07
 Nicole
 Compton, CA
 Though I have been a Jehovah' s Witness for a short time I know this is the truth. Thank you for letting the public see us in a positive light, whereas the world shows us in a negative one, hopefully by watching this someone out there will talk to us when we come knocking at their door. Thanx!!!!!!!!
 5/24/07
 Like the Kempler family, I come from a Jewish background. My father's family escaped from Nazi Germany in the mid 1930s before the war.In my late teens I met a school friend who was a Witness and I got to study and understand Witness doctrine. I served 3.5 years of 6 year sentence for maintaining my neutrality and not going to the army in South Africa. Several years later I was disfellowshipped.
 No one is ever disfellowshipped for the sin that they committed - in my case, adultery. Jehovah will always forgive you if you are truly repentant and so will the congregation. People are disfellowshipped for willfully continuing in a course of action that is against Jehovah's standards. Thankfully, I have come to accept that I was the one who was in the wrong - not God. I bitterly regret the mistakes that I have made, especially that of turning my back on Jehovah when the going got really tough. In time, I hope the congregation will see fit to reinstate me. What I can say for sure, though, is that theprocess of being disfellowshipped and working toward reinstatement has taught me more about what it means to not just have faith, but to have a personal relationship with Jehovah. It's about a lot more than simply knowing the Bible and the doctrine. It's about coming to understand what and who God truly is.
 5/24/07
 I thoroughly enjoyed the documentary "Knocking". I was soo moved by the polish jewish brother who survived Auswitz that he continues to faithfuly and zeously preach about god's kingdom in his advanced age. I was so touched by this film, that on thursday I will return back to the meetings...Armagedon is around the corner!!
 5/24/07
 New York, NY
 KNOCKING portrayed the Witnesses as ordinary, sincere people dedicated to their faith and their families. The scenes in Europe were very touching as well as the extraordinary gift of love Seth Thomas received from his father. I was also impressed by their history in Germany and their unique role in protecting our rights as citizens. But I wish there had been an attempt to show a more balanced view of the organization (aside from Seth's grandmother, the only non-Witness interviewed). Why are 30,000 people kicked out every year? Why are women excluded from leadership positions? Why have the Witnesses concealed accusations of sexual abuse by church leaders and punished individuals who asked them for help?
 5/24/07
 David Silva
 Visalia, CA
 I just wan't to say thank you for such a non-predjiduce show on Jehovah Witnesses. They are so many misconseption's on our organization, and this program showed some that some of those ideas are wrong. I would like to add to some comment's posted by non-witnesses. We do not believe that only witnesses will survive Armagedon the bible clearly tells us that only Jehovah God will determine who will not survie his destruction and this includes Witnesses that are not living up to bible standards. Another thing is, we are christian's.
 5/24/07
 Moshe
 Indianapolis
 Knocking did not impress me. 99.9% of the world has rejected the WT message that in 1919 Jesus picked the Watchtower leaders to be the one true religion on earth and that the end was coming in 1914, 1925, WW2, 1975 and any day now. The Mormons, numbering over 10 million have had done a better job convincing the world that Joseph Smith was a prophet and that the American Indians are remnants of the lost tribes of Israel and the Book of Mormon is inspired. Only 99.8% of the world has rejected the Mormon gospel. I think that Jesus would reject the JW version of Christianity because it lacks any organized public charity, like a soup kitchen, orphanage or homeshelter. What would Jesus do with the Billion dollars of WT wealth? Do you think he might use it to help the poor? The Knocking movie was not untruthful, but it was not a scholarly work, either. 99.9% of the world has already judged the WT Society.
 5/24/07
 Corina
 Springfield, MA
 I truly loved this documentary, mainly because the directors used both witnesses and non-witnesses alike in this piece. It showed non-parciality and made me proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses, regardless or what other people want to think. I thank Jehovah everyday for allowing me to be a part of His people and allowing me to be able to spread the truth about Him and His written word. As a regualr pioneer (full time minister of the good news) I have 'knocked' on quite a few doors and have gotten different opinions from different people on our religion, but this movie brought out so many good points about us as an organization and as individuals. In conclusion, thank you.
 5/24/07
 Marieelena Mathena
 Steuben, Maine
 I want to thank the filmmakers and all involved in making and presenting this documentary. I would love to have the opportunity to see it. Jehovah�s Witnesses are not perfect. I am not perfect. I am one of Jehovah�s Witnesses and have been since 1975. I had lived a worldly immoral life. When I got baptized I cried to think Jehovah God could want me. I did not forgive myself for my past transgressions and felt how could he? It was years before I realized that Jehovah had forgiven me and I had to forgive myself and move on. I only knew that Jehovah counted me worthy and that helped me to build self-esteem and become the woman I am today. Jehovah is always waiting with his arms out to welcome new sheep and even ones who were disfellowshipped if they repent. The only unforgivable sin is apostasy. Pride is the only thing standing in the way of anyone who was disfellowshipped for not excepting counsel for his or her wrongdoing. Swallow your pride and return to Jehovah. Thank you again for the opportunity to tell people we are not a cult or fanatics. We love Jehovah and we do what we do for him. I had studied with the Mormon�s and the Seventh Day Adventist and raised a Catholic and I know the Truth and the Truth has set me free.
 5/24/07
 JERRI
 MEMPHIS,TN
 All the way up until I was 25 yrs. old I had been in and out of many religions trying to find answers tp many questions but no one had the answers. Even my own dad couldn't answer and he had his own church. One day I finally talked to JW'S after runing from that knock on the door for so many years. Beleive it or not they took me to the bible and answered every question I ever had. From studying God's word the bible I realized that being a JW'S was exactly what I wanted to do. Upon being a JW I had to make severe changes in my life so I had to put 1 Cor.6:9-11 into action. When you make positive changes in your life you eveentually associate with more positive ones(Birds of a feather flock together) I love being one of jw's even if I have to be expelled! It's the right way to live.
 5/24/07
 Buyck, Mn
 I really enjoyed the film. I have been baptized since 1993. My husband was baptized at a later date. I studied for many years off and on before I was baptized but I always believed that Jehovah's witnesses had the truth. None of my family are in the truth. But one of the things I find interesting is when I started to study and my family found out about it how different they expected you to act, so they know there should be a difference in your personality but they don't want to make that same change. I have watched the children grow up in a witness home and compared them with wordly children and I would rather carry on a conversation with the witness children any day. They have a lot more respect for the elderly and the world around them.
 5/24/07
 When i read what the person from Tempe, Az wrote,it didn't make sense. what you stated does NOT prove hypocricy. how do you know that the Governing Body or the decision making part of Jehovah's Witnesses "signed up" for the United Nations? or that someone else migh have did it. if anything like that would happen I WOULD know about it. do you have straight proof that you would bet your life on?
 5/24/07
 Ca
 I'am a new parent and my son is now going into what they call the terrible two's it's the hardest stage to keep a child Quiet and still for two hours anywhere specially at the kingdom hall, My way of training and disciplining is no spanking the reason is I don't want him growing up thinking hitting is o.k. , when he acts up and throws a tantrum I immediately have to take him to the bathroom so he's not distracting others, but I tell him that his behavior is not acceptable and that he needs to calm down, I remind him we are in Jehovah's house and that he needs to respect that. to my surprise he now hates going to the bathroom and prefers to sit with his books and sing along with us when we sing, Children are a gift from God and we need to treat them like so. ( Don't get the wrong idea about how witness parents handle their children ignore the negative comments in the forum.
 5/24/07
 WF
 Chicago, IL
 Indeed, Jehovah said at Haggai 2:7 that He will be the one to "rock the nations", and is a documentary like this not doing so? People all over the world tuned in to watch this program on May 22 and no doubt, were either enraged or endeared with the Witnesses than ever before. It is a known fact by now that whenever the Witnesses knock on doors in the neighborhood, the householder knows we are all carrying the same Kingdom message. It never ceases to center around the coming of God's perfect new world, and the crushing of this wicked system of things. This is evidence that we are UNITED IN WORSHIP, the way God intended it to be. I am proud to boldly stand firm as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I cannot fathom the joy we all will feel when God's name is declared throughout the earth so that EVERYONE WILL HAVE TO KNOW WHO JEHOVAH IS!(Ezekiel 11:12)
 5/24/07
 Lakewood Ca
 As one of Jehovah's witnesses I can say that we try to bring comfort and hope to those countless of people that are suffering in the world they are not alone, as you can see in the film we suffer aswell wether is from illnesses or any other form of pain. And having the bible answer to many of our questions like WHY me God? helps us to move on and be strong to face whatever we have to face, If Jehovah has helped us to endure, why wouldn't he help others who are suffering. That's the reason why we go to your doors, we are not trying to cause any harm,or force our beliefs on anyone all we are trying to do is to bring some peace, comfort and hope in to your homes in these last crititcal days. I 'am truly happy to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses and I thank my parent's for showing me the thruth.
 5/24/07
 "Knocking" aired 5/23/07 on the local PBS station. It was very interesting. I think your dedication to fairness should be applauded, especially since neither of you are JWs. There have been a lot of posts on the site from many unhappy people. I am, however, very happy to be a JW, not a simple minded fool happily doing what a man tells me to do. I read my Bible (and not just one translation...)and ask questions when I have them. The crux of the matter is that I love God and Christ and do the very best to follow the Bible's principles.Becoming one of JW's was my CHOICE. You learn the Bible's principles before you become a Witness. You make a dedication to do God's will and follow in Jesus' footsteps as closely as an imperfect human can. Thank you again for your fine film.
 5/24/07
 Frank Torres
 Norwalk California
 I saw the Documentory and It was very good, My wife and me we realy enjoy it,every body should see it, witnesses or not, every body should learn and understand what we believe, there is so much negative talk about us, if some of you had a bad experience Im very sorry,. you guys had to go thru, I raised my two kids as Witnesses I never force them to get battized I let them to choose, no body should force you of what to do, and since I became a witness I never saw any body abusing any children,and the thing about been disfellowship is a way Jehovah discipline us the same way we discipline our children and we do it cause we love them the same way Jehovah loves us as a good father, is up to us if we want to ask him for forgiveness and truly repented from our sins, we are never going be accepted from some of you guys but you guys should read the Bible and learn of how to live we jehovah's love. May Jehovah bless all my Brothers and Sisters around the world and keep the good work cause this system of things is goi ng to end very soon. hang on God Loves you.
 5/24/07
 Cathy Lisi
 New York, N.Y.
 I think what people fail to understand about religion in general is that there once was in the beginning a right and only way to worship God. That right and only way is still here because Jehovah does not change. There is a True religion and it is the religion of the bible. People are under the assumption that all religions are okay with God as long as you have something. Not true! If that were the case there would not be a bible and therefore we would not know about God. Since we do know about God what would be the only obvious place to find out what he expects from his followers? The bible is the obvious place and therefore those who follow the "formula" as I like to call Proverbs 3: 1-5 can gain God's favor. Following this format and way of thinking by sincerely wanting to know what God expects of his human creation can award you God's holy spirit to understand his word and thereby not interprete it on your own. It takes work to be granted everlasting life. But it is worth all the hard work in the world to be able to one day experience what it is like to truly be a healthy human being and not experience sickness or death anymore. To live securely and know our Creator as Adam and Eve were able to for a brief time. It is worth it, I have been a Witness for 17 years and I am so grateful to have Truth in my life and be able to answer questions such as "Why do we die", and Why does God permit suffering, etc. So please all you naysayers out there, have a bible study with one of my brothers or sisters and you will never regret it!!
 5/24/07
 Nancy
 I saw the documentary last night and it was very nice to see how it showed really how jehovahs organization works and what we believe. But one thing i'm very disgusted with is to read all those other coments of ex jws or just people that hate us for no valid reason just becuase they had problems in there lives or couldnt come threw with the vows they made to jehovah when they got baptized. This is for all you who bash jws first of all no member of the congergation is perfect and is going to make mistakes many of them, I myself had some bad experiences in the congergation with elders especially I was even married to a jw and got divorced " under biblical reasons" but becuase of my bad experince I have not stopped attending, I dont go to the kingdom hall to please the elders or who ever is there I do it for Jehovah. I know i have the truth and there is no two religions alike that teach the same things. All of you who bash jws are actually doing it towards Jehovah and he will seek vengence in armaghedon very soon and all of you will have to face him on that day you wont be able to hide from him. I would like to see your faces when finally the goverments go against babylon the great, you will be looking for us jws but it will be to late for you. so very sorry so sorry.
 5/24/07
 I really like what one person said: You choose to not take advice when you are disfellowshipped, which is very foolish. This makes others try to stay away from you because they do not want to have the bad association. So the Witnesses do not shun you and think that you are horrible, they want to help you because the Bible says that God punishes those whom He loves. So the people who are saying that the Witnesses look down on you and don't care about you anymore once you have left the organization are truly misled and have developed the wrong way of thinking. Otherwise, thank you for the uplifting film.
 5/24/07
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and proudly so. Some of the most kind people you'll ever want to meet. Do we believe we have the truth, of course, so do Catholics, Buddhists or they would not be Catholics or Buddhists. I think much of the negative talk on the boards are of x members who are upset at their course of action and due to the lack of humility decide to bash the religion as a whole. The majority of the time you see someone leave it is not that they become another religion - THE TRUTH IS THE TRUTH NO MATTER HOW YOU SLICE - we/they leave to feed their selfish desire and as long as there is time it is not too late to return. I have never seen a scripture in the bible that says to "beat kids" in fact, quit the opposite. There is so much I could say to defend Our Great God Jehovah, but he will do that on his own. What I do know is this documentary is fair and I enjoyed it. I have non witness families and get together often, have bbq's and we are fine....in fact their respect our beliefs and will even ask us to pray before a meal. Now there is such thing as bad associates, they exist within the congregation and outside, it's up to each individual and their bible trainined conscience to make that decision..... I pray though searching will find. "If God is for us who will be against us" again, thank you!
 5/24/07
 I am very pleased with the accurate portrayal of the witnesses in the film but am displeased by the thoughts of some that we are insensitive and that we hid abuse. These things simply are not true child abusers are punished like other erring ones yet unlike others they are no longer granted to serve in the position of oversight in the congregation because of this act God Jehovah does not allow wrongdoing to persist in his organization but he desires none to be destroyed but all to attain to repentance. That means turning around from their sinful course. We do not sweep wrongdoing under the rug but rather we punish for all who repentantly engage in such for those who God loves he disciplines.
 5/24/07
 Carlsbad, Ca
 When someone has been disfellowshiped by a congregation, as stated it normally follows repeated attempts to "readjust" that person's attitude towards the conduct which caused the problem in the first place. Quoting 1 Corinthians 13:11, the apostle Paul instructed the brothers in the congregation "to be readjusted,to be comforted,to think in agreement,to live peaceably..." Did JW's come up with this on their own? Isn't every Christian religion told to follow this council of readjustment and thinking in agreement to spiritual and moral standards in the congregation? Was Jesus tolerent of all the religions in Judea? No. He condemed the Jewish leaders of his own religion due to their rejection of bible standards. Jehovah himself repeated asked the nation of Isreal to repent from their willingness to accept and adopt the ways of other religions around them. Finally they were rejected by God himself, as stated clearly in the bible. Were Jews themselves tolerent of peaceful followers of Christ? Certainly not. However, what religion has consistantly taken a neutral stand in EVERY country, to the point of prision and torture, determined to live peacefully with people of various backrounds to this very day? Have all other "christian" religions done the same? History has made clear the answer is no. Does God condoned such a course? Check your bible. When one studies with a witness, they are consistently told NOT to just beleive what the conductor says, but reason on what the scriptures say. Also, it takes nearly two years to qualify for baptisim, then a series of bible questions are asked to ensure the person is knowledgeable and serious about their desire to become a Witness, no matter what their age. If they take lightly their dedication to God, what would Jesus feel towards them? Wouldn't he seperate that person from his followers. But wouldn't he also show mercy towards one who repented? How is that any different from what happens today when one shows the same attitude? Jehovah's people take the exact same approach to imoral conduct today. Did we come up with that on our own? How is "once saved, always saved" fit into the bible's instructions and standards? Answer that for yourself.
 5/24/07
 I watched the film last night and was excited to see a documentary that was closer to the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses. For all the negative comments from obvious haters of the witnesses, what I have read from you seems to be based on individual circumstances and the imperfections of individuals. This sounds just like what my father did way back in the 50's regarding the black race.He judged the entire race over individuals'experiences. I happened to grow up with a love for all races and years later found a love for the Bible. I have many translations of it and have found the message is the same. I raised my 5 children to love our great God, Jehovah, and this was always my own choice--not someone elses. I have my own free will, the intelligence to investigate as did the ancient Boreans, and the responsiblilty to find and apply the truth and, as the Bible says, work out my own salvation. I admire Chuck's responses because he has obviously spent his life 'choosing the real life'that our great God has implored us to do and educating himself deeply as to Bible truths.Regardless of what anyone believes, Jehovah is going to do what he is going to do and no one knows the exact day and hour, not even the son ( as the Bible says.) For the person or persons who "rant" about the trinity doctrine that even the early catholic church didn't believe, tell me how the son does not know what the father knows if he is the father. It would make no sense. And when the Bible says that God resurrected Jesus, that was 2 different people--one being resurrected and one resurrecting. And how would you exlain Jesus handing the kingdom back over to God if he was god--and who was Jesus praying to--himself? Why would he tell God that he would not try to usurp God's position? A reasonable, thinking person would have to look into this, in any Bible.
 5/24/07
 Mari Botello
 Fresno, California
 I am a 15 year old,happy, Jehova's Witness.I really enjoyed the film KNOCKING.Most of the things on there were true.But the fact that the filmmaker was not a JW,was odd to me. I have to say that some comments on here are very cruel a d mean!But i want to get into a comment that i saw that said that children ages 6-10 are ABUSED for not sitting and paying attention and that Elders just turn their checks and act like nothing is wrong,that comment is so WRONG!!!!As far as i can remember i never ever got hit for not paying attention or not sitting still.If the children are not behaving they will be taken to the restrooms or a special room for children and in there they let the child calm down but some parents do discipline NOT ABUSE their children so they wont be brats in the future,then they are taken back to the main seating area.And also,there was said that teenagers get removed from the Congregation(When we say "removed",we mean that they are excluded from everyboby else in the congregation.Nobody can talk to them or associate with them.This serves as a punishment for the ones who did not repent from their sins)because of just holding hands,that is also NOT true!!!!They have to do something severe, without repenting(as in fornication,or have premarital sexual relations or practice masturbation)to get removed for the congregation.
 5/24/07
 What if you willingly became a participating member of Weight Watchers? How do you think the group would, indeed, should react if you began to advocate that 3 Snicker bars a day will not hamper your weight loss? If you know your nutrition bible, go figure! How would you feel about people who would BLAME Weight Watchers for their strict, miserable diet keeping them from losing weight? What would you think of someone who said that Weight Watchers HATES fat people because THEY can't live up to the dietetic standards? Are they following the PEOPLE or the healthy PROGRAM? The organization of JWs is only there, not to be followed but to help and guide those of us (who want to)to follow Gods healthy PROGRAM of superior moral standards. If you are disfellowshipped or disgruntled, it is quite obvious what YOU were following! If you don't agree with or don't want to live up to what God requires, go join TOPS and leave the Weight Watchers alone!
 5/24/07
 Jennifer
 Garland, TX
 I realize that my dictionary is somewhat dated, (Webster's New World College Dictionary Fourth Edition copyright 2000,1999 by IDG Books Worldwide , Inc.) however it clearly defines the word Christain as -n. 1 a person professing belief in Jesus as the Christ, or in the religion based on the teachings of Jesus 2 a masculine name 3 (informal) a decent, respectable person -adj. 1 of Jesus Christ or his teachings 2 of or professing the religion based on these teachings 3 having the qualities demonstrated and taught by Jesus Christ, as love, kindness, humility, etc. 4 of or representing Christians or Christianity 5(Informal) humane, decent, etc. How then is it that so many view JW's as nonChristians? IMHO they follow Jesus example & teachings as humanly possible i.e.(Ten Commandments).A review of the Ten Commandments is in order...
 5/24/07
 David
 John on 5/22/07 writes about being beaten in the bathroom and a bunch of other negative stuff. Well, he must have been around some real bad apples,which one can find anywhere. I too was raised as one of JWs and have been a member of 11 congragations in 2 countries in my 45 years and have observed overwhelmingly people who are kind, decent, and unselfish, but I definitely know about a handful out of a thousand (maybe the same people John knows) who were the opposite, bad people, funny thing is, they eventually either change or leave. It was similar in Jesus's day, 1 out of 12 was rotten. Also some of the early Christians did not live up to the Word, and were doing terrible things. So John, relax, and try to look for the overall good, the Documentary does.The history of JWs in the Supreme Court and in the Holocaus is particularly praiseworthy, would not you agree?
 5/24/07
 Victor
 Torrance
 I am amazed at some of the remarks. I have been studying the Bible on my own for over 30 years, and then I met the Jehovah's Witnesses. I found them to be honest hard working individuals just like you and me. After studing the Bible on my own, and examining all other so called "Christian" religons, I find these are people are honestly desiring to grow closer to their God, Jehovah. So they study the Bible several times per week and try to live their life according to his guidelines as laid out in the Bible. Contrary to what one of the respondents left as a comment. There are no "bathroom beatings" or any type of physical or mental abuse. That is just silly. All are accepted, but if an individual openly decides to pursue a course of drug abuse, spousal abuse or any other type of immoral conduct, would you want them to live with your family. I didn't think so. So then they are seperated from the congregation, by the congreagation, for everyones safty and well being. After 30 years of searching for a closer relationship with God, Jehovah, and being 50 years of age, I myself proudly became one of Jehovah's Witnesses a little over a year ago. And for those who truly want to know God, I would recommend meeting a witness and decide for yourself.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_m.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Rita and Wally Malins
 Really enjoyed your "presentation" introduction. My husband and I appreciated that I.L. & PBS respectfully showed this documentary. We appreciate that I.L. made it possible for many to view the documentary in their homes in a nonchallenging setting. My husband and I are long-time Jehovah's Witnesses (50 yrs and 58 years respectively) and have been active in our ministry in several states in the U.S.A. When I attended High School in Chicago, I earned many citizenship and athletic awards as well as being a co-editor of our award-winning high school yearbook. I mention this because during all that time I was one of Jehovah's Witnesses who did not salute the flag nor celebrate holidays.
 My teachers respected my stand and dedication to be a fine student, good citizen as well as living up to my faith as a Christian. At this time my mother was not one of Jehovah's Witnesses while my two older sisters (and their families) were very active Witnesses. Mom became a Witness many years later at age at age 63. Whether one listens or rejects our beliefs in an individual choice and we would not want to deny that to anyone. Thanks again
 5/24/07
 John
 Many thanks to Mr. Engardio, PBS, CPB, and this forum. Jehovah has NEVER failed me! He is neither a cultist, pedophile, wife or child beater, nor a hypocrite. To the poor souls who decry His witnesses I say, when all else fails, read His instructions to us!......thank God for His Word, the Bible. God has never failed to fulfill a promise to mankind. You can have total, complete confidence in Him. Satan is taunting Jehovah more than ever in this time of the end. The harvest is great and many grow weary due to Satan's attacks, but never forget the endurance of Jesus. He remained faithful even to death on a torture stake. He thus sanctified and continues to sanctify God's name even today.
 Noah preached to a dark and dying world each day for over 60 years. Not one person listened or turned around. Noah, like Christ, was accused of being a fool, a cultist, and a blasphemer. Both were beaten and spat upon, yet imagine the GULP in the throat of the Roman soldier who said, "Truly this WAS the Son of God", or the horror of those outside the Ark when the rains came. Keep on the watch!Continue to glorify Jehovah in your life and you will save some. This old system of things is in it final chapter, much like the "unsinkable" Titanic. Will you continue to decorate your room on the Titanic, or will you stay inside the figurative Ark ever holding dear Jehovah's promises, and working hard to encourage fellow sufferers and incite them to LOVE and Fine Works?
 5/24/07
 Jenny
 Humble, Texas
 I seen the program (knocking)and i enjoyed it very much.I have been studing with my sister-in-law who is a Jehovahs Witness and it has been fulfilling the spiritual need i was so thirsty for.people say they are cults but if they would open their bible they would know better than that.Jehovahs witnesses don't shun anyone, people shun them and Jehovah!!
 5/24/07
 Alex
 New York
 It�s an interesting documentary. I�m a former JW, left about 12 years ago shortly after the Watchtower society changed its doomsday predictions on the generation of 1914 (Mat 24:34). My parents converted when I was a small child. I was baptized at 15 years of age and worked for the religion as a 21 hour per week proselytizer (�Regular Pioneer�) for a number of years. The documentary is a disturbing expos� of how religious faith can blind people into taking unnecessary risks (refusal of transfusions) and endure avoidable deadly situations (their WWII experience in Germany). It�s a faith based on the belief and absolute confidence that the biblical interpretations of the Watchtower Society is the truth, this despite the metamorphosis of Watchtower teachings and predictions through the years. For the other side� of the JW story I highly recommend Crisis of Conscience by Raymond Franz. Franz was a member of the Governing Body of the Watchtower Society. This forbidden book by the Watchtower society is a true eye opener and a must read for any one interested in the JW.
 5/24/07
 For all on the "ANTI" side of the issue, may I pose a scenario. If for instance, let's suppose you are caucasion and would not seek the services of a doctor that was of a different race no matter how qualified, but were now facing a sure life ending situation and the only person that could "SAVE YOUR LIFE", would you have a change of heart? Belief in GOD and the Bible can change DEEPLY ENTRENCHED THINGS, ask a JW to show you in YOUR Bible. Be assured, almost 7 million people today can truly SEE the BEAUTY in being COLOR BLIND. The scenario is purely retorhical but JEHOVAH IS THE READER OF HEARTS HE already knows how you answered. Please if nothing else read Romans 14: 10-12 and take a little time to meditate on it.
 5/24/07
 Nicole
 Compton, CA
 Though I have been a Jehovah' s Witness for a short time I know this is the truth. Thank you for letting the public see us in a positive light, whereas the world shows us in a negative one, hopefully by watching this someone out there will talk to us when we come knocking at their door. Thanx!!!!!!!!
 5/24/07
 Like the Kempler family, I come from a Jewish background. My father's family escaped from Nazi Germany in the mid 1930s before the war.In my late teens I met a school friend who was a Witness and I got to study and understand Witness doctrine. I served 3.5 years of 6 year sentence for maintaining my neutrality and not going to the army in South Africa. Several years later I was disfellowshipped.
 No one is ever disfellowshipped for the sin that they committed - in my case, adultery. Jehovah will always forgive you if you are truly repentant and so will the congregation. People are disfellowshipped for willfully continuing in a course of action that is against Jehovah's standards. Thankfully, I have come to accept that I was the one who was in the wrong - not God. I bitterly regret the mistakes that I have made, especially that of turning my back on Jehovah when the going got really tough. In time, I hope the congregation will see fit to reinstate me. What I can say for sure, though, is that theprocess of being disfellowshipped and working toward reinstatement has taught me more about what it means to not just have faith, but to have a personal relationship with Jehovah. It's about a lot more than simply knowing the Bible and the doctrine. It's about coming to understand what and who God truly is.
 5/24/07
 I thoroughly enjoyed the documentary "Knocking". I was soo moved by the polish jewish brother who survived Auswitz that he continues to faithfuly and zeously preach about god's kingdom in his advanced age. I was so touched by this film, that on thursday I will return back to the meetings...Armagedon is around the corner!!
 5/24/07
 New York, NY
 KNOCKING portrayed the Witnesses as ordinary, sincere people dedicated to their faith and their families. The scenes in Europe were very touching as well as the extraordinary gift of love Seth Thomas received from his father. I was also impressed by their history in Germany and their unique role in protecting our rights as citizens. But I wish there had been an attempt to show a more balanced view of the organization (aside from Seth's grandmother, the only non-Witness interviewed). Why are 30,000 people kicked out every year? Why are women excluded from leadership positions? Why have the Witnesses concealed accusations of sexual abuse by church leaders and punished individuals who asked them for help?
 5/24/07
 David Silva
 Visalia, CA
 I just wan't to say thank you for such a non-predjiduce show on Jehovah Witnesses. They are so many misconseption's on our organization, and this program showed some that some of those ideas are wrong. I would like to add to some comment's posted by non-witnesses. We do not believe that only witnesses will survive Armagedon the bible clearly tells us that only Jehovah God will determine who will not survie his destruction and this includes Witnesses that are not living up to bible standards. Another thing is, we are christian's.
 5/24/07
 Moshe
 Indianapolis
 Knocking did not impress me. 99.9% of the world has rejected the WT message that in 1919 Jesus picked the Watchtower leaders to be the one true religion on earth and that the end was coming in 1914, 1925, WW2, 1975 and any day now. The Mormons, numbering over 10 million have had done a better job convincing the world that Joseph Smith was a prophet and that the American Indians are remnants of the lost tribes of Israel and the Book of Mormon is inspired. Only 99.8% of the world has rejected the Mormon gospel. I think that Jesus would reject the JW version of Christianity because it lacks any organized public charity, like a soup kitchen, orphanage or homeshelter. What would Jesus do with the Billion dollars of WT wealth? Do you think he might use it to help the poor? The Knocking movie was not untruthful, but it was not a scholarly work, either. 99.9% of the world has already judged the WT Society.
 5/24/07
 Corina
 Springfield, MA
 I truly loved this documentary, mainly because the directors used both witnesses and non-witnesses alike in this piece. It showed non-parciality and made me proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses, regardless or what other people want to think. I thank Jehovah everyday for allowing me to be a part of His people and allowing me to be able to spread the truth about Him and His written word. As a regualr pioneer (full time minister of the good news) I have 'knocked' on quite a few doors and have gotten different opinions from different people on our religion, but this movie brought out so many good points about us as an organization and as individuals. In conclusion, thank you.
 5/24/07
 Marieelena Mathena
 Steuben, Maine
 I want to thank the filmmakers and all involved in making and presenting this documentary. I would love to have the opportunity to see it. Jehovah�s Witnesses are not perfect. I am not perfect. I am one of Jehovah�s Witnesses and have been since 1975. I had lived a worldly immoral life. When I got baptized I cried to think Jehovah God could want me. I did not forgive myself for my past transgressions and felt how could he? It was years before I realized that Jehovah had forgiven me and I had to forgive myself and move on. I only knew that Jehovah counted me worthy and that helped me to build self-esteem and become the woman I am today. Jehovah is always waiting with his arms out to welcome new sheep and even ones who were disfellowshipped if they repent. The only unforgivable sin is apostasy. Pride is the only thing standing in the way of anyone who was disfellowshipped for not excepting counsel for his or her wrongdoing. Swallow your pride and return to Jehovah. Thank you again for the opportunity to tell people we are not a cult or fanatics. We love Jehovah and we do what we do for him. I had studied with the Mormon�s and the Seventh Day Adventist and raised a Catholic and I know the Truth and the Truth has set me free.
 5/24/07
 JERRI
 MEMPHIS,TN
 All the way up until I was 25 yrs. old I had been in and out of many religions trying to find answers tp many questions but no one had the answers. Even my own dad couldn't answer and he had his own church. One day I finally talked to JW'S after runing from that knock on the door for so many years. Beleive it or not they took me to the bible and answered every question I ever had. From studying God's word the bible I realized that being a JW'S was exactly what I wanted to do. Upon being a JW I had to make severe changes in my life so I had to put 1 Cor.6:9-11 into action. When you make positive changes in your life you eveentually associate with more positive ones(Birds of a feather flock together) I love being one of jw's even if I have to be expelled! It's the right way to live.
 5/24/07
 Buyck, Mn
 I really enjoyed the film. I have been baptized since 1993. My husband was baptized at a later date. I studied for many years off and on before I was baptized but I always believed that Jehovah's witnesses had the truth. None of my family are in the truth. But one of the things I find interesting is when I started to study and my family found out about it how different they expected you to act, so they know there should be a difference in your personality but they don't want to make that same change. I have watched the children grow up in a witness home and compared them with wordly children and I would rather carry on a conversation with the witness children any day. They have a lot more respect for the elderly and the world around them.
 5/24/07
 When i read what the person from Tempe, Az wrote,it didn't make sense. what you stated does NOT prove hypocricy. how do you know that the Governing Body or the decision making part of Jehovah's Witnesses "signed up" for the United Nations? or that someone else migh have did it. if anything like that would happen I WOULD know about it. do you have straight proof that you would bet your life on?
 5/24/07
 Ca
 I'am a new parent and my son is now going into what they call the terrible two's it's the hardest stage to keep a child Quiet and still for two hours anywhere specially at the kingdom hall, My way of training and disciplining is no spanking the reason is I don't want him growing up thinking hitting is o.k. , when he acts up and throws a tantrum I immediately have to take him to the bathroom so he's not distracting others, but I tell him that his behavior is not acceptable and that he needs to calm down, I remind him we are in Jehovah's house and that he needs to respect that. to my surprise he now hates going to the bathroom and prefers to sit with his books and sing along with us when we sing, Children are a gift from God and we need to treat them like so. ( Don't get the wrong idea about how witness parents handle their children ignore the negative comments in the forum.
 5/24/07
 WF
 Chicago, IL
 Indeed, Jehovah said at Haggai 2:7 that He will be the one to "rock the nations", and is a documentary like this not doing so? People all over the world tuned in to watch this program on May 22 and no doubt, were either enraged or endeared with the Witnesses than ever before. It is a known fact by now that whenever the Witnesses knock on doors in the neighborhood, the householder knows we are all carrying the same Kingdom message. It never ceases to center around the coming of God's perfect new world, and the crushing of this wicked system of things. This is evidence that we are UNITED IN WORSHIP, the way God intended it to be. I am proud to boldly stand firm as one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I cannot fathom the joy we all will feel when God's name is declared throughout the earth so that EVERYONE WILL HAVE TO KNOW WHO JEHOVAH IS!(Ezekiel 11:12)
 5/24/07
 Lakewood Ca
 As one of Jehovah's witnesses I can say that we try to bring comfort and hope to those countless of people that are suffering in the world they are not alone, as you can see in the film we suffer aswell wether is from illnesses or any other form of pain. And having the bible answer to many of our questions like WHY me God? helps us to move on and be strong to face whatever we have to face, If Jehovah has helped us to endure, why wouldn't he help others who are suffering. That's the reason why we go to your doors, we are not trying to cause any harm,or force our beliefs on anyone all we are trying to do is to bring some peace, comfort and hope in to your homes in these last crititcal days. I 'am truly happy to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses and I thank my parent's for showing me the thruth.
 5/24/07
 "Knocking" aired 5/23/07 on the local PBS station. It was very interesting. I think your dedication to fairness should be applauded, especially since neither of you are JWs. There have been a lot of posts on the site from many unhappy people. I am, however, very happy to be a JW, not a simple minded fool happily doing what a man tells me to do. I read my Bible (and not just one translation...)and ask questions when I have them. The crux of the matter is that I love God and Christ and do the very best to follow the Bible's principles.Becoming one of JW's was my CHOICE. You learn the Bible's principles before you become a Witness. You make a dedication to do God's will and follow in Jesus' footsteps as closely as an imperfect human can. Thank you again for your fine film.
 5/24/07
 Frank Torres
 Norwalk California
 I saw the Documentory and It was very good, My wife and me we realy enjoy it,every body should see it, witnesses or not, every body should learn and understand what we believe, there is so much negative talk about us, if some of you had a bad experience Im very sorry,. you guys had to go thru, I raised my two kids as Witnesses I never force them to get battized I let them to choose, no body should force you of what to do, and since I became a witness I never saw any body abusing any children,and the thing about been disfellowship is a way Jehovah discipline us the same way we discipline our children and we do it cause we love them the same way Jehovah loves us as a good father, is up to us if we want to ask him for forgiveness and truly repented from our sins, we are never going be accepted from some of you guys but you guys should read the Bible and learn of how to live we jehovah's love. May Jehovah bless all my Brothers and Sisters around the world and keep the good work cause this system of things is goi ng to end very soon. hang on God Loves you.
 5/24/07
 Cathy Lisi
 New York, N.Y.
 I think what people fail to understand about religion in general is that there once was in the beginning a right and only way to worship God. That right and only way is still here because Jehovah does not change. There is a True religion and it is the religion of the bible. People are under the assumption that all religions are okay with God as long as you have something. Not true! If that were the case there would not be a bible and therefore we would not know about God. Since we do know about God what would be the only obvious place to find out what he expects from his followers? The bible is the obvious place and therefore those who follow the "formula" as I like to call Proverbs 3: 1-5 can gain God's favor. Following this format and way of thinking by sincerely wanting to know what God expects of his human creation can award you God's holy spirit to understand his word and thereby not interprete it on your own. It takes work to be granted everlasting life. But it is worth all the hard work in the world to be able to one day experience what it is like to truly be a healthy human being and not experience sickness or death anymore. To live securely and know our Creator as Adam and Eve were able to for a brief time. It is worth it, I have been a Witness for 17 years and I am so grateful to have Truth in my life and be able to answer questions such as "Why do we die", and Why does God permit suffering, etc. So please all you naysayers out there, have a bible study with one of my brothers or sisters and you will never regret it!!
 5/24/07
 Nancy
 I saw the documentary last night and it was very nice to see how it showed really how jehovahs organization works and what we believe. But one thing i'm very disgusted with is to read all those other coments of ex jws or just people that hate us for no valid reason just becuase they had problems in there lives or couldnt come threw with the vows they made to jehovah when they got baptized. This is for all you who bash jws first of all no member of the congergation is perfect and is going to make mistakes many of them, I myself had some bad experiences in the congergation with elders especially I was even married to a jw and got divorced " under biblical reasons" but becuase of my bad experince I have not stopped attending, I dont go to the kingdom hall to please the elders or who ever is there I do it for Jehovah. I know i have the truth and there is no two religions alike that teach the same things. All of you who bash jws are actually doing it towards Jehovah and he will seek vengence in armaghedon very soon and all of you will have to face him on that day you wont be able to hide from him. I would like to see your faces when finally the goverments go against babylon the great, you will be looking for us jws but it will be to late for you. so very sorry so sorry.
 5/24/07
 I really like what one person said: You choose to not take advice when you are disfellowshipped, which is very foolish. This makes others try to stay away from you because they do not want to have the bad association. So the Witnesses do not shun you and think that you are horrible, they want to help you because the Bible says that God punishes those whom He loves. So the people who are saying that the Witnesses look down on you and don't care about you anymore once you have left the organization are truly misled and have developed the wrong way of thinking. Otherwise, thank you for the uplifting film.
 5/24/07
 I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses and proudly so. Some of the most kind people you'll ever want to meet. Do we believe we have the truth, of course, so do Catholics, Buddhists or they would not be Catholics or Buddhists. I think much of the negative talk on the boards are of x members who are upset at their course of action and due to the lack of humility decide to bash the religion as a whole. The majority of the time you see someone leave it is not that they become another religion - THE TRUTH IS THE TRUTH NO MATTER HOW YOU SLICE - we/they leave to feed their selfish desire and as long as there is time it is not too late to return. I have never seen a scripture in the bible that says to "beat kids" in fact, quit the opposite. There is so much I could say to defend Our Great God Jehovah, but he will do that on his own. What I do know is this documentary is fair and I enjoyed it. I have non witness families and get together often, have bbq's and we are fine....in fact their respect our beliefs and will even ask us to pray before a meal. Now there is such thing as bad associates, they exist within the congregation and outside, it's up to each individual and their bible trainined conscience to make that decision..... I pray though searching will find. "If God is for us who will be against us" again, thank you!
 5/24/07
 I am very pleased with the accurate portrayal of the witnesses in the film but am displeased by the thoughts of some that we are insensitive and that we hid abuse. These things simply are not true child abusers are punished like other erring ones yet unlike others they are no longer granted to serve in the position of oversight in the congregation because of this act God Jehovah does not allow wrongdoing to persist in his organization but he desires none to be destroyed but all to attain to repentance. That means turning around from their sinful course. We do not sweep wrongdoing under the rug but rather we punish for all who repentantly engage in such for those who God loves he disciplines.
 5/24/07
 Carlsbad, Ca
 When someone has been disfellowshiped by a congregation, as stated it normally follows repeated attempts to "readjust" that person's attitude towards the conduct which caused the problem in the first place. Quoting 1 Corinthians 13:11, the apostle Paul instructed the brothers in the congregation "to be readjusted,to be comforted,to think in agreement,to live peaceably..." Did JW's come up with this on their own? Isn't every Christian religion told to follow this council of readjustment and thinking in agreement to spiritual and moral standards in the congregation? Was Jesus tolerent of all the religions in Judea? No. He condemed the Jewish leaders of his own religion due to their rejection of bible standards. Jehovah himself repeated asked the nation of Isreal to repent from their willingness to accept and adopt the ways of other religions around them. Finally they were rejected by God himself, as stated clearly in the bible. Were Jews themselves tolerent of peaceful followers of Christ? Certainly not. However, what religion has consistantly taken a neutral stand in EVERY country, to the point of prision and torture, determined to live peacefully with people of various backrounds to this very day? Have all other "christian" religions done the same? History has made clear the answer is no. Does God condoned such a course? Check your bible. When one studies with a witness, they are consistently told NOT to just beleive what the conductor says, but reason on what the scriptures say. Also, it takes nearly two years to qualify for baptisim, then a series of bible questions are asked to ensure the person is knowledgeable and serious about their desire to become a Witness, no matter what their age. If they take lightly their dedication to God, what would Jesus feel towards them? Wouldn't he seperate that person from his followers. But wouldn't he also show mercy towards one who repented? How is that any different from what happens today when one shows the same attitude? Jehovah's people take the exact same approach to imoral conduct today. Did we come up with that on our own? How is "once saved, always saved" fit into the bible's instructions and standards? Answer that for yourself.
 5/24/07
 I watched the film last night and was excited to see a documentary that was closer to the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses. For all the negative comments from obvious haters of the witnesses, what I have read from you seems to be based on individual circumstances and the imperfections of individuals. This sounds just like what my father did way back in the 50's regarding the black race.He judged the entire race over individuals'experiences. I happened to grow up with a love for all races and years later found a love for the Bible. I have many translations of it and have found the message is the same. I raised my 5 children to love our great God, Jehovah, and this was always my own choice--not someone elses. I have my own free will, the intelligence to investigate as did the ancient Boreans, and the responsiblilty to find and apply the truth and, as the Bible says, work out my own salvation. I admire Chuck's responses because he has obviously spent his life 'choosing the real life'that our great God has implored us to do and educating himself deeply as to Bible truths.Regardless of what anyone believes, Jehovah is going to do what he is going to do and no one knows the exact day and hour, not even the son ( as the Bible says.) For the person or persons who "rant" about the trinity doctrine that even the early catholic church didn't believe, tell me how the son does not know what the father knows if he is the father. It would make no sense. And when the Bible says that God resurrected Jesus, that was 2 different people--one being resurrected and one resurrecting. And how would you exlain Jesus handing the kingdom back over to God if he was god--and who was Jesus praying to--himself? Why would he tell God that he would not try to usurp God's position? A reasonable, thinking person would have to look into this, in any Bible.
 5/24/07
 Mari Botello
 Fresno, California
 I am a 15 year old,happy, Jehova's Witness.I really enjoyed the film KNOCKING.Most of the things on there were true.But the fact that the filmmaker was not a JW,was odd to me. I have to say that some comments on here are very cruel a d mean!But i want to get into a comment that i saw that said that children ages 6-10 are ABUSED for not sitting and paying attention and that Elders just turn their checks and act like nothing is wrong,that comment is so WRONG!!!!As far as i can remember i never ever got hit for not paying attention or not sitting still.If the children are not behaving they will be taken to the restrooms or a special room for children and in there they let the child calm down but some parents do discipline NOT ABUSE their children so they wont be brats in the future,then they are taken back to the main seating area.And also,there was said that teenagers get removed from the Congregation(When we say "removed",we mean that they are excluded from everyboby else in the congregation.Nobody can talk to them or associate with them.This serves as a punishment for the ones who did not repent from their sins)because of just holding hands,that is also NOT true!!!!They have to do something severe, without repenting(as in fornication,or have premarital sexual relations or practice masturbation)to get removed for the congregation.
 5/24/07
 What if you willingly became a participating member of Weight Watchers? How do you think the group would, indeed, should react if you began to advocate that 3 Snicker bars a day will not hamper your weight loss? If you know your nutrition bible, go figure! How would you feel about people who would BLAME Weight Watchers for their strict, miserable diet keeping them from losing weight? What would you think of someone who said that Weight Watchers HATES fat people because THEY can't live up to the dietetic standards? Are they following the PEOPLE or the healthy PROGRAM? The organization of JWs is only there, not to be followed but to help and guide those of us (who want to)to follow Gods healthy PROGRAM of superior moral standards. If you are disfellowshipped or disgruntled, it is quite obvious what YOU were following! If you don't agree with or don't want to live up to what God requires, go join TOPS and leave the Weight Watchers alone!
 5/24/07
 Jennifer
 Garland, TX
 I realize that my dictionary is somewhat dated, (Webster's New World College Dictionary Fourth Edition copyright 2000,1999 by IDG Books Worldwide , Inc.) however it clearly defines the word Christain as -n. 1 a person professing belief in Jesus as the Christ, or in the religion based on the teachings of Jesus 2 a masculine name 3 (informal) a decent, respectable person -adj. 1 of Jesus Christ or his teachings 2 of or professing the religion based on these teachings 3 having the qualities demonstrated and taught by Jesus Christ, as love, kindness, humility, etc. 4 of or representing Christians or Christianity 5(Informal) humane, decent, etc. How then is it that so many view JW's as nonChristians? IMHO they follow Jesus example & teachings as humanly possible i.e.(Ten Commandments).A review of the Ten Commandments is in order...
 5/24/07
 David
 John on 5/22/07 writes about being beaten in the bathroom and a bunch of other negative stuff. Well, he must have been around some real bad apples,which one can find anywhere. I too was raised as one of JWs and have been a member of 11 congragations in 2 countries in my 45 years and have observed overwhelmingly people who are kind, decent, and unselfish, but I definitely know about a handful out of a thousand (maybe the same people John knows) who were the opposite, bad people, funny thing is, they eventually either change or leave. It was similar in Jesus's day, 1 out of 12 was rotten. Also some of the early Christians did not live up to the Word, and were doing terrible things. So John, relax, and try to look for the overall good, the Documentary does.The history of JWs in the Supreme Court and in the Holocaus is particularly praiseworthy, would not you agree?
 5/24/07
 Victor
 Torrance
 I am amazed at some of the remarks. I have been studying the Bible on my own for over 30 years, and then I met the Jehovah's Witnesses. I found them to be honest hard working individuals just like you and me. After studing the Bible on my own, and examining all other so called "Christian" religons, I find these are people are honestly desiring to grow closer to their God, Jehovah. So they study the Bible several times per week and try to live their life according to his guidelines as laid out in the Bible. Contrary to what one of the respondents left as a comment. There are no "bathroom beatings" or any type of physical or mental abuse. That is just silly. All are accepted, but if an individual openly decides to pursue a course of drug abuse, spousal abuse or any other type of immoral conduct, would you want them to live with your family. I didn't think so. So then they are seperated from the congregation, by the congreagation, for everyones safty and well being. After 30 years of searching for a closer relationship with God, Jehovah, and being 50 years of age, I myself proudly became one of Jehovah's Witnesses a little over a year ago. And for those who truly want to know God, I would recommend meeting a witness and decide for yourself.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_m.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 NJ
 I was actually surprised that this was fair and balnced, most shows on this religion are bitter. i have been a witness for many years. i actually grew up as one. my parents were then disfellowshipped, one for adultry,and one for pysical abuse and drugs. because of them i was ripped from my home with my brother and placed in a foster home that was worse than my own.but i am still a witness after many hardships. i still talk to my mother as much as i could. i donot talk to my father because he is in jail and still hooked on drugs. this religion didnot tear us apart it was their stupidity and their selfishness.i still talk to my brother who comes to my house all the time and who is not a witness. also my husband isnot a witness but he believes i have the right to my religious freedom. so to anyone who thinks this religion tears families apart you are wrong. i love being a witness and i will be faithful until the day i die!
 5/24/07
 Johnnie
 PA
 Many Thanks to Mr. Engardio and Mr Shepard for grabbing the baton and running with it. Despite some disparaging comments and some obvious mis-information I truly applaud their effort. Many more Thanks to Jehovah's Witnesses for their commitment to securing our personal liberties in the US and abroad, so that all can worship, speak, and assemble without fear. We owe them big time. But most of all, Thanks to the one and only true God, Jehovah, our Creator. He has given us the power of free will, and created us Free Moral Agents...never forcing us to choose right or wrong, but allowing us to experience the consequences of every action or inaction. All praises to the Father of us all, our God, Jehovah!!!
 5/24/07
 Kay
 Houston, TX
 This documentary did a very good job in showing the accomplishments of Jehovah's Witnesses how we have expanded freedoms for all Americans by being loyal to our God Jehovah and making use of the laws of the land and doing so in a non violent manner. As a whole meaning most Jehovah's Witnesses practice what we preach, not perfectly because there is not one perfect person on this earth, however we try. Our loyality also includes sticking to our God and following his son Jesus example because we strongly believe that the way Jesus lived is the best way of life. We do recognize that there may be few that may called themselves Jehovah's Witnesses that lead what we call a double life and this includes hypocrisy. But most of us feel strongly that it is Jehovah God and not a man who we made a dedication to and never will we allow the unscripture behavior of anyone to stop us from serving Jehovah. He is not the blame for any wrong a person do. Last I really appreciate that the film makers bringing out that we do not impose our beliefs on anyone and we never resort to any violence but are a people who pursue peace. Thanks.
 5/24/07
 There are the ones that say tha JW let their children die by not taking blood transfutions, Wlell the bible states that you should avoid the blood, We as JW love are children as mush as you love your children.When they are sick we look for the best medical care there is, There are lots of treatments that haved been proven to save lives with out blood.I realize there are people that belive giving help buy donating blood and we respect that.But so far can you prove there is no risk of anyone getting more sick or diging with blood related treatments.If Jehova God made sure the bible say to avoid blood should we refuse to obey him.If you tell your children they can get injure, would you expect that the take care of them self and lisnen to you.
 5/24/07
 Richard Moment
 Sacramento, CA 95814
 What a tragedy. This propaganda piece glosses over and obfuscates the truth about a controlling, life diminishing, vindictive religion. Having been raised a JW, I've seen families and individual lives ruined. I've seen suicide and families torn asunder through the Watchtower's draconian manipulations. Maybe next time you can give a positive spin to Heaven's Gate, Jonestown, and the Branch Davidians. I'm sure their surviving members will applaud PBS -- just as the brainwashed JWs have done here.
 5/24/07
 John Solomon
 Chicago
 As one of Jehovah�s Witnesses my heart goes out to people in special circumstances. There is no level playing field in this world. So many of the people with negative comments about JW�s seem to fall into such a category. Re. chronically depressed and mentally ill: If only we could make them happy we would put a lot of drug companies out of business.Re. homosexuals: We found an ob nurse from a very large hosp. at her door and asked her what percentage of babies are born with noticeable genital differences (abnormalities) at that hosp. She replied �about 4%.� If that could be regarded as a cross section it would translate into approximately 240 million earth wide that have unique physical differences that range from slight to persons who are both male and female. People are treated with sensitivity and as individuals by Jehovah�s organization. Fornication isn�t tolerated by heterosexuals either. 1Cor.5:9; 6:9.Re. Jews: I love orthodox Jews. They would starve in the concentration camps ather than eat things condemned under the Mosaic Law, like shellfish. They�re fabulous students, worthy debaters, with an incredible spirit of fairness that allows them to disagree yet appreciate that Jehovah�s Witnesses know how to break eggs.
 Fundamentalists: No, we are not in the sense that the term has come to be used. No resorting to political demonstrations or violence. Dear Friends: Stay out of chat rooms and off the religious forums!!! Bad associations spoil..you know what.
 5/24/07
 Mel
 Texas
 This is to the comment posted under Houston, TX. I'm sorry you were treated badly for having Depression. I just wanted to say that that is not the norm. My husabnd of 8 years has been diagnosed as being bi-polar. He has suffered with it for years. Almost everyone in our congregation knows about it and has been very supportive, always trying to upbuild. He is currently getting treatment for it. I hope you are well and are getting the help you need. Sincerely, MeL
 5/24/07
 Angie
 OR
 I enjoyed the film. I saw it last night. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I was not one in my teens and early adulthood. but I was raised one. I had abuse from my step father as a child. This abuse was horrible to deal with. He was not one of JWs. My mother and grandmother were. As I look back on my life I am glad my grandmother and mother taught me the bible. (the way a true Jehovah Witnesses lives their life) My mother was disfellowedshiped from the religion when I was a teen. I did not understand why at the time. Now I know why she was kick out as you would say. I now understand why they disfellowship ones who do not live their life as the bible teaches. She has changed her life back in accordance with the bible and is accepted back in the religion. Everyone welcomed her back with open arms. The religion is not a cult. They just alow people to make there own decisions on where they stand Jehovah Gods or Satan's. Yes Satan. 1 John 5:19 this scripture states the whole world is lying in the power of the wicked one. Read it in your own copy of the bible. The film is a good one.
 5/24/07
 Jorge V
 I just want to say thank for talking about Jehovah in your film because that is the most important thing in our lives, that his name be praise. I also would understand the frustration of many when is talk about us in high standards but that's who we try to really be. By the way when we started studying the Bible we were thought that if you do something that is not in the standard not of man, but of Jehovah God's eyes he will deal with us according to our behavior, and if we repent he is so loving as to forgive us and allow us back into his Organization. We respect everybody's point of view even if it's trying to make us look like the worst people in the world, but you know something what really matters is what OUR GOD JEHOVAH THINK OF US... Thank you. Please let me know what can we do to see this presentation of the Knocking again in the New York Area...
 5/24/07
 Milton Brown
 Charleston, SC
 Great show! When I first saw the previews I thought "Oh, great! Here comes another hatchet job on Jehovah,s Witnesses. However, this documentary was well done, fair,unbiased and humanistic and factual. I loved it.
 5/24/07
 Styveston
 New York
 I really enjoyed this documentary and found it informative. At a time when religion has no effect on people and their lives I wish I had the kind of faith demonstrated by the elderly gentleman and the young man who were featured in the film. The next time one of the Jehovahs come to my door I am going to listen to ask them in. We need more people like this in this world.
 5/24/07
 Jerry
 Miami, Flordia
 I was able to view the film last night and believe that it was a well covered subject. I, a 22 year old male Jehovah's Witness and only member in my family to be a witness, I could say with pride that, I'm proud to follow Jehovah's ways. Learning about the truth has blessed me in several ways and the most recent; it gave me the opportunity to meet my beautiful fianc�, also a witness. It bothers me to see some accusations of wrong doing within the congregations by people who weren't able to stay faithful to Jehovah.
 5/24/07
 N H
 Houston, Tx
 I enjoyed the film and applaud its makers. Joel's mother is to be commended for her hard work in raising a son alone ( I can identify). It is unsettling to read the comments of uninformed individuals,whose first response is to spew their OPINIONS instead of taking the steps to educate themselves first.Most offensive is the comments that as an organization we condone and sweep under the rug acts of abuse against ones mate or children.I personally know of cases where this is not the case. Our love separates us in this ungodly society and it is preserved first and foremost in our households.
 5/24/07
 Bill Bowen
 I was a JW for 43 years, served as an elder for many years. I am shunned by my family for encouraging members to report child molesters. I committed no sin but simply told the truth. The bias in this film is unprecedented for not presenting both sides of the issue. Parts of the film that presented the reality were left on the editing room floor. Joel you know what I am talking about. It is a sad day when PBS can be manipulated to sell a religion.
 5/24/07
 Dana
 Springfield, MO
 Best documentary on Jehovah's Witnesses I've seen thus far. Really enjoyed it. Had no idea so many freedoms that benefit all persons regardless of religious preference have been tried and won by JW's.
 5/24/07
 Bronx NY
 What I find amazing is how people get all bent out of shape about JW's. If I go to work and someone says they are a Catholic or Pentecostal people will just shrug and not think twice. Someone might may a comment about the abuse of priests or some kind of joke. Yet when someone says they are a JW the climate changes. Emotions and uncomfortableness start to stir. Attacks about their beliefs that the person heard from someone else that hates them. This is no different then PREJUDICE. Attacking a whole people because of their skin or beliefs. Obviously it is an emotional response then a mature disagreement. Here we are in the 21st Century and it is sad to see the possibility that people can still emotionaly allow another holocaust or still have a prejudice amongst a group of people.
 5/24/07
 Tom
 New Mexico
 The film seemed to lack clarification. Not all Witnesses will accept organ transplants. It is a conscience matter. When they become witnesses they do not shun family members. Rather they become close to other witnesses, and some family members seem to view this as a rejection of family. Especially when they stop celibrating the holidays with the family. They still love their families and will endevor to get together with them at other times. The creator has a right to be worshiped the way he views as proper, which is set forth in the Bible. This is what they attempt to teach to others.
 5/24/07
 I am really looking forward to viewing this documentary. I really hope my PBS station will show it in my area. I appreciate how you are standing up to the basic truths about the witnesses and not letting the sea of negativity deter your attempt to air the truth. I'm sure negative critisism will continue until the end of this system of things.
 5/24/07
 Joshua
 Austin, Texas
 I viewed the film because I love someone that was brought up a Witness and I am not one. The sad thing is that our relationship has to be hidden because she can not tell her parents about me or she will loose all contact with them. So she lives a double life and lives in turmoil because she can't be with me, the love of her life. I have kids of my own and I could not imagine EVER abandoning them for following their heart. This is very hard for both of us and I don't think we will be able to be together for years and years and it just isn't fair. I also have a problem with the fact that there is no room for individuality in the organization. God gives all of us special gifts and we are supposed to find them, how can we find them if we are not able to be different than others, play sports, go to college, etc.? I do like some of the beliefs of the organization and understand the "brotherhood," but there is a lot that I do not agree with, especially the shunning. I just keep praying that God will guide us and l ead us to what is supposed to be.
 5/24/07
 Wailuku, Hi
 I found the film inspiering.I was impressed with the stength of the family in regards to not taking blood. The father was so loving, his first concern after giving up most of his liver to his son was "how is my son?" the Jewish father/grandfather was outstanding in his Faith, and honest in regard to his damage, and how it was hard to be close to his family. But corageous in going forward, and bonding with his family, and reliving his horrific memeories.Fine examples of love and faith. Thank you!
 5/24/07
 Thanks to these filmmakers who have succeeded where so many have failed. Rather than half-truths and insinuations they presented a factual account of JW's as "people". Just imperfect people trying to live in harmony with the Bible and God's standards rather than man's. I appreciated their acknowlegement that many of our freedoms today have been cemented by JW's in their pursuit of religious freedom. This in spite of the fact that many, while loudly proclaiming their love of this country due to the freedoms, would have happily deprived us of ours. That lack of tolerance continues to be displayed not only toward JW's but to anyone not agreed with and the divisions in this country, and indeed the world, continue to grow. I'm sorry there have been so many 'sour grapes' by those who have chosen to be ex-witnesses but it's to be expected by any ex-anything. Human nature makes one want to blame someone, anyone, everyone except ourselves for our own actions. Not to say there has not been the occasional mistake made and someone was unjustly treated. I've been a Witness for 56 years and I've run into a few imperfect Witnesses (and a few have run into imperfect me) but remember, there are ALWAYS two sides to every story. A judge doesn't just hear the plaintiff's case.
 5/24/07
 Jerome Potts
 Austin, Texas
 Great I.L. episode, bravo, and thanks.Regarding the J.W.'s themselves, even though i don't agree with all their tenets, i am impressed by, and in agreement with, some others of those. But i already felt that way before seeing the show. But the show taught me even more, much more. Thanks again. As concerns the invitation for me to say something on whether people of different faiths can coexist peacefully, i can't really say, but i sure hope so, and that's partly why i watch PBS, to obtain wisdom. And i think i do. W/out PBS, life in this country would be a serious drag.
 5/24/07
 Lompoc, CA
 Thank you for the film, it was balanced and well put together. I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses, 34 years ago. My family were not JW's. There were some tensions, hurt feelings, etc. But over time they realized that this faith was what I wanted and it was a positive thing. I believe I am who I am because of my faith and reliance on the Scriptures. For those individuals who are no longer Witnesses or who had bad experiences (from their perspective), I say: each of us make our own choices and we will all be individually judged by Christ and God. Best wishes to all.
 5/24/07
 Claremont, CA
V I really enjoyed the presentation of JW's. It was based on balanced, historical fact. Whether or not some people agree with its presentation, I felt it was done in good taste, with an understanding of what JWs have done for people of all races, nationalities and religions. Great job! In July, I will celebrate my 37th anniversary as a witness. We are not a "cult," and we truly do care about the people we speak to--yours, and our lives are at stake! Whether or not you agree with Bible teachings, take a few minutes to listen to its message-it may very well save your life and your family's lives. Our great Creator, Jehovah, has allowed us this time to give a warning--please take the time to listen to it. Our time in this system is ever more limited each day, therefore, please don't waste another minute and learn about the love our Creator has for each of us, despite our faults. He has the biggest heart ande embraces all who love him. It is an invitation He, and we, lovingly invite you to embrace.
 5/24/07
 Sophia Garrett
 I really enjoyed "Knocking", it was very enjoyable to see the life that I live everyday. I was raised as a Jehovah's Witness and have been dedicated for 17 years now. What I find that seems to baffle those on the outside looking in is how do we live this way, there is only one way we do this- our wonderful friendship with our precious God Jehovah. And until anyone comes into such a precious friendship, they will never understand us completely- they will continue to always look at us as "Jehovah's Witnesses-the religion", but as for me, I am a fellow worker and servant of Jehovah, witnessing HIS purposes for the earth, as it unfolds for the world to see.
 5/24/07
 Houston, TX
 To Chicago, IL 5/23 - Thank you for your post. You hit the nail on the head. Those of us who made the choice to leave and are still living an upright life and honoring Jehovah's ways should not be judged by other JW. They are NOT Jehovah Himself and do not have the right to judge us. Even if we STILL have love for our former brothers, their harsh words show they do not have love for us. I can count on one hand the number of posts that are kind towards those who had to leave with a heavy heart. The Bible states that a person can reach Jehovah through JESUS ONLY-not through an organization of imperfect beings...whether it be JW or other religions. So I do not need IMPERFECT people to judge me for NOT BEING PERFECT or to reach Jehovah when I need Him. Even now, I still feel His presence and blessings. I remain faithful to JEHOVAH because he has never betrayed me. To SC in Texas, when did Jehovah give you the ability to read other people's heart? If I were in need - would you help me knowing I left the organization but still have a good heart? Probably not. Even to this day, I would bend over backwards to help a JW regardless of my personal choices. I cannot read a person's heart, I just see a child of Jehovah who needs help.
 5/24/07
 Clarence Mennis
 MN
 I am thankful that people will see that Jehovah's Witnesses do what the best helth care. We may not want to use blood and that turns one's off, but we do all we can. My dear wife passed away a few mouths ago, but all the help she got at USC for her liver and other problems, the team at USC help with everything to the max. Next time a Jehovah's Witnesses calls on your door, ask him about Jehovah or how we look at blood or other things, they will tell you just how it is. Thanks
 5/24/07
 Los Angeles
 First of all I want to thank PBS and Independent Lens for taking the time to do such an extraordinary presentation with such accuracy. that only reinforces my respect for anintellectually stimulating channel. Secondly I'm studying with the Witnesses and I feel greatful that such organization exists. Jehovah's Witnesses faith is unwavering and forever tested. I wouldl like to be a witness on day. Jehovah only wants what's best for us and wants us to live forever in a beautiful peaceful paradice on earth, what does this (global warming-war loving-world) offer us?
 5/24/07
 Cristina
 Houston,TX
 I AM CURRENTLY STUDYING WITH JW'S AND HAVE NEVER LOVED AND APPRECIATED GOD AS MUCH AS I DO NOW. I LEARNED MORE ABOUT THE BIBLE IN A FEW MONTHS THAN I EVER DID IN MY WHOLE LIFE AT THE CHURCH. WHEN PEOPLE ARE RAISED TO BELIEVE WHATEVER THE "PRIEST OR PREACHER" SAYS AT CHURCH WITH OUT SCRIPTURAL REASONINGS, I UNDERSTAND WHY THERE IS SO MUCH IGNORANCE TO WHAT THE BIBLE REALLY TEACHES.THERE IS SO MUCH NEGATIVITY AND OPPOSITION TOWARDS JW'S B/C THEY REALLY USE THE BIBLE AND PEOPLE DONT WANT TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS AND WANT TO 'WORSHIP AND BELIEVE' THE WAY THEY WANT TO AND NOT ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE. THIS DOCUMENTARY IS A GREAT TESTIMONY OF WHO JW'S REALLY ARE. THANK YOU FOR SUCH A GREAT AND INFORMATIVE FILM.
 5/24/07
 en Martin
 My wife and I were raised as Witnesses and are very happy as such. We watched the show last night on DVR and were riveted, and we are buying the DVD. Watching the interaction between the Witness and non witness families was difficult, as my wifes parents left the truth a few years ago and decided to write a letter instead of just being inactive... Needless to say we have been unable to speak to them or see them since. While this has been extremely difficult for my wife and her sister, it is a protection to us, and somoething she has been able to deal with thru the help of her brothers and sisters at the hall. Thanks to the director and to PBS for airing a fair and balanced documentary.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_n.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 NJ
 I was actually surprised that this was fair and balnced, most shows on this religion are bitter. i have been a witness for many years. i actually grew up as one. my parents were then disfellowshipped, one for adultry,and one for pysical abuse and drugs. because of them i was ripped from my home with my brother and placed in a foster home that was worse than my own.but i am still a witness after many hardships. i still talk to my mother as much as i could. i donot talk to my father because he is in jail and still hooked on drugs. this religion didnot tear us apart it was their stupidity and their selfishness.i still talk to my brother who comes to my house all the time and who is not a witness. also my husband isnot a witness but he believes i have the right to my religious freedom. so to anyone who thinks this religion tears families apart you are wrong. i love being a witness and i will be faithful until the day i die!
 5/24/07
 Johnnie
 PA
 Many Thanks to Mr. Engardio and Mr Shepard for grabbing the baton and running with it. Despite some disparaging comments and some obvious mis-information I truly applaud their effort. Many more Thanks to Jehovah's Witnesses for their commitment to securing our personal liberties in the US and abroad, so that all can worship, speak, and assemble without fear. We owe them big time. But most of all, Thanks to the one and only true God, Jehovah, our Creator. He has given us the power of free will, and created us Free Moral Agents...never forcing us to choose right or wrong, but allowing us to experience the consequences of every action or inaction. All praises to the Father of us all, our God, Jehovah!!!
 5/24/07
 Kay
 Houston, TX
 This documentary did a very good job in showing the accomplishments of Jehovah's Witnesses how we have expanded freedoms for all Americans by being loyal to our God Jehovah and making use of the laws of the land and doing so in a non violent manner. As a whole meaning most Jehovah's Witnesses practice what we preach, not perfectly because there is not one perfect person on this earth, however we try. Our loyality also includes sticking to our God and following his son Jesus example because we strongly believe that the way Jesus lived is the best way of life. We do recognize that there may be few that may called themselves Jehovah's Witnesses that lead what we call a double life and this includes hypocrisy. But most of us feel strongly that it is Jehovah God and not a man who we made a dedication to and never will we allow the unscripture behavior of anyone to stop us from serving Jehovah. He is not the blame for any wrong a person do. Last I really appreciate that the film makers bringing out that we do not impose our beliefs on anyone and we never resort to any violence but are a people who pursue peace. Thanks.
 5/24/07
 There are the ones that say tha JW let their children die by not taking blood transfutions, Wlell the bible states that you should avoid the blood, We as JW love are children as mush as you love your children.When they are sick we look for the best medical care there is, There are lots of treatments that haved been proven to save lives with out blood.I realize there are people that belive giving help buy donating blood and we respect that.But so far can you prove there is no risk of anyone getting more sick or diging with blood related treatments.If Jehova God made sure the bible say to avoid blood should we refuse to obey him.If you tell your children they can get injure, would you expect that the take care of them self and lisnen to you.
 5/24/07
 Richard Moment
 Sacramento, CA 95814
 What a tragedy. This propaganda piece glosses over and obfuscates the truth about a controlling, life diminishing, vindictive religion. Having been raised a JW, I've seen families and individual lives ruined. I've seen suicide and families torn asunder through the Watchtower's draconian manipulations. Maybe next time you can give a positive spin to Heaven's Gate, Jonestown, and the Branch Davidians. I'm sure their surviving members will applaud PBS -- just as the brainwashed JWs have done here.
 5/24/07
 John Solomon
 Chicago
 As one of Jehovah�s Witnesses my heart goes out to people in special circumstances. There is no level playing field in this world. So many of the people with negative comments about JW�s seem to fall into such a category. Re. chronically depressed and mentally ill: If only we could make them happy we would put a lot of drug companies out of business.Re. homosexuals: We found an ob nurse from a very large hosp. at her door and asked her what percentage of babies are born with noticeable genital differences (abnormalities) at that hosp. She replied �about 4%.� If that could be regarded as a cross section it would translate into approximately 240 million earth wide that have unique physical differences that range from slight to persons who are both male and female. People are treated with sensitivity and as individuals by Jehovah�s organization. Fornication isn�t tolerated by heterosexuals either. 1Cor.5:9; 6:9.Re. Jews: I love orthodox Jews. They would starve in the concentration camps ather than eat things condemned under the Mosaic Law, like shellfish. They�re fabulous students, worthy debaters, with an incredible spirit of fairness that allows them to disagree yet appreciate that Jehovah�s Witnesses know how to break eggs.
 Fundamentalists: No, we are not in the sense that the term has come to be used. No resorting to political demonstrations or violence. Dear Friends: Stay out of chat rooms and off the religious forums!!! Bad associations spoil..you know what.
 5/24/07
 Mel
 Texas
 This is to the comment posted under Houston, TX. I'm sorry you were treated badly for having Depression. I just wanted to say that that is not the norm. My husabnd of 8 years has been diagnosed as being bi-polar. He has suffered with it for years. Almost everyone in our congregation knows about it and has been very supportive, always trying to upbuild. He is currently getting treatment for it. I hope you are well and are getting the help you need. Sincerely, MeL
 5/24/07
 Angie
 OR
 I enjoyed the film. I saw it last night. I am one of Jehovah's Witnesses. I was not one in my teens and early adulthood. but I was raised one. I had abuse from my step father as a child. This abuse was horrible to deal with. He was not one of JWs. My mother and grandmother were. As I look back on my life I am glad my grandmother and mother taught me the bible. (the way a true Jehovah Witnesses lives their life) My mother was disfellowedshiped from the religion when I was a teen. I did not understand why at the time. Now I know why she was kick out as you would say. I now understand why they disfellowship ones who do not live their life as the bible teaches. She has changed her life back in accordance with the bible and is accepted back in the religion. Everyone welcomed her back with open arms. The religion is not a cult. They just alow people to make there own decisions on where they stand Jehovah Gods or Satan's. Yes Satan. 1 John 5:19 this scripture states the whole world is lying in the power of the wicked one. Read it in your own copy of the bible. The film is a good one.
 5/24/07
 Jorge V
 I just want to say thank for talking about Jehovah in your film because that is the most important thing in our lives, that his name be praise. I also would understand the frustration of many when is talk about us in high standards but that's who we try to really be. By the way when we started studying the Bible we were thought that if you do something that is not in the standard not of man, but of Jehovah God's eyes he will deal with us according to our behavior, and if we repent he is so loving as to forgive us and allow us back into his Organization. We respect everybody's point of view even if it's trying to make us look like the worst people in the world, but you know something what really matters is what OUR GOD JEHOVAH THINK OF US... Thank you. Please let me know what can we do to see this presentation of the Knocking again in the New York Area...
 5/24/07
 Milton Brown
 Charleston, SC
 Great show! When I first saw the previews I thought "Oh, great! Here comes another hatchet job on Jehovah,s Witnesses. However, this documentary was well done, fair,unbiased and humanistic and factual. I loved it.
 5/24/07
 Styveston
 New York
 I really enjoyed this documentary and found it informative. At a time when religion has no effect on people and their lives I wish I had the kind of faith demonstrated by the elderly gentleman and the young man who were featured in the film. The next time one of the Jehovahs come to my door I am going to listen to ask them in. We need more people like this in this world.
 5/24/07
 Jerry
 Miami, Flordia
 I was able to view the film last night and believe that it was a well covered subject. I, a 22 year old male Jehovah's Witness and only member in my family to be a witness, I could say with pride that, I'm proud to follow Jehovah's ways. Learning about the truth has blessed me in several ways and the most recent; it gave me the opportunity to meet my beautiful fianc�, also a witness. It bothers me to see some accusations of wrong doing within the congregations by people who weren't able to stay faithful to Jehovah.
 5/24/07
 N H
 Houston, Tx
 I enjoyed the film and applaud its makers. Joel's mother is to be commended for her hard work in raising a son alone ( I can identify). It is unsettling to read the comments of uninformed individuals,whose first response is to spew their OPINIONS instead of taking the steps to educate themselves first.Most offensive is the comments that as an organization we condone and sweep under the rug acts of abuse against ones mate or children.I personally know of cases where this is not the case. Our love separates us in this ungodly society and it is preserved first and foremost in our households.
 5/24/07
 Bill Bowen
 I was a JW for 43 years, served as an elder for many years. I am shunned by my family for encouraging members to report child molesters. I committed no sin but simply told the truth. The bias in this film is unprecedented for not presenting both sides of the issue. Parts of the film that presented the reality were left on the editing room floor. Joel you know what I am talking about. It is a sad day when PBS can be manipulated to sell a religion.
 5/24/07
 Dana
 Springfield, MO
 Best documentary on Jehovah's Witnesses I've seen thus far. Really enjoyed it. Had no idea so many freedoms that benefit all persons regardless of religious preference have been tried and won by JW's.
 5/24/07
 Bronx NY
 What I find amazing is how people get all bent out of shape about JW's. If I go to work and someone says they are a Catholic or Pentecostal people will just shrug and not think twice. Someone might may a comment about the abuse of priests or some kind of joke. Yet when someone says they are a JW the climate changes. Emotions and uncomfortableness start to stir. Attacks about their beliefs that the person heard from someone else that hates them. This is no different then PREJUDICE. Attacking a whole people because of their skin or beliefs. Obviously it is an emotional response then a mature disagreement. Here we are in the 21st Century and it is sad to see the possibility that people can still emotionaly allow another holocaust or still have a prejudice amongst a group of people.
 5/24/07
 Tom
 New Mexico
 The film seemed to lack clarification. Not all Witnesses will accept organ transplants. It is a conscience matter. When they become witnesses they do not shun family members. Rather they become close to other witnesses, and some family members seem to view this as a rejection of family. Especially when they stop celibrating the holidays with the family. They still love their families and will endevor to get together with them at other times. The creator has a right to be worshiped the way he views as proper, which is set forth in the Bible. This is what they attempt to teach to others.
 5/24/07
 I am really looking forward to viewing this documentary. I really hope my PBS station will show it in my area. I appreciate how you are standing up to the basic truths about the witnesses and not letting the sea of negativity deter your attempt to air the truth. I'm sure negative critisism will continue until the end of this system of things.
 5/24/07
 Joshua
 Austin, Texas
 I viewed the film because I love someone that was brought up a Witness and I am not one. The sad thing is that our relationship has to be hidden because she can not tell her parents about me or she will loose all contact with them. So she lives a double life and lives in turmoil because she can't be with me, the love of her life. I have kids of my own and I could not imagine EVER abandoning them for following their heart. This is very hard for both of us and I don't think we will be able to be together for years and years and it just isn't fair. I also have a problem with the fact that there is no room for individuality in the organization. God gives all of us special gifts and we are supposed to find them, how can we find them if we are not able to be different than others, play sports, go to college, etc.? I do like some of the beliefs of the organization and understand the "brotherhood," but there is a lot that I do not agree with, especially the shunning. I just keep praying that God will guide us and l ead us to what is supposed to be.
 5/24/07
 Wailuku, Hi
 I found the film inspiering.I was impressed with the stength of the family in regards to not taking blood. The father was so loving, his first concern after giving up most of his liver to his son was "how is my son?" the Jewish father/grandfather was outstanding in his Faith, and honest in regard to his damage, and how it was hard to be close to his family. But corageous in going forward, and bonding with his family, and reliving his horrific memeories.Fine examples of love and faith. Thank you!
 5/24/07
 Thanks to these filmmakers who have succeeded where so many have failed. Rather than half-truths and insinuations they presented a factual account of JW's as "people". Just imperfect people trying to live in harmony with the Bible and God's standards rather than man's. I appreciated their acknowlegement that many of our freedoms today have been cemented by JW's in their pursuit of religious freedom. This in spite of the fact that many, while loudly proclaiming their love of this country due to the freedoms, would have happily deprived us of ours. That lack of tolerance continues to be displayed not only toward JW's but to anyone not agreed with and the divisions in this country, and indeed the world, continue to grow. I'm sorry there have been so many 'sour grapes' by those who have chosen to be ex-witnesses but it's to be expected by any ex-anything. Human nature makes one want to blame someone, anyone, everyone except ourselves for our own actions. Not to say there has not been the occasional mistake made and someone was unjustly treated. I've been a Witness for 56 years and I've run into a few imperfect Witnesses (and a few have run into imperfect me) but remember, there are ALWAYS two sides to every story. A judge doesn't just hear the plaintiff's case.
 5/24/07
 Jerome Potts
 Austin, Texas
 Great I.L. episode, bravo, and thanks.Regarding the J.W.'s themselves, even though i don't agree with all their tenets, i am impressed by, and in agreement with, some others of those. But i already felt that way before seeing the show. But the show taught me even more, much more. Thanks again. As concerns the invitation for me to say something on whether people of different faiths can coexist peacefully, i can't really say, but i sure hope so, and that's partly why i watch PBS, to obtain wisdom. And i think i do. W/out PBS, life in this country would be a serious drag.
 5/24/07
 Lompoc, CA
 Thank you for the film, it was balanced and well put together. I became one of Jehovah's Witnesses, 34 years ago. My family were not JW's. There were some tensions, hurt feelings, etc. But over time they realized that this faith was what I wanted and it was a positive thing. I believe I am who I am because of my faith and reliance on the Scriptures. For those individuals who are no longer Witnesses or who had bad experiences (from their perspective), I say: each of us make our own choices and we will all be individually judged by Christ and God. Best wishes to all.
 5/24/07
 Claremont, CA
V I really enjoyed the presentation of JW's. It was based on balanced, historical fact. Whether or not some people agree with its presentation, I felt it was done in good taste, with an understanding of what JWs have done for people of all races, nationalities and religions. Great job! In July, I will celebrate my 37th anniversary as a witness. We are not a "cult," and we truly do care about the people we speak to--yours, and our lives are at stake! Whether or not you agree with Bible teachings, take a few minutes to listen to its message-it may very well save your life and your family's lives. Our great Creator, Jehovah, has allowed us this time to give a warning--please take the time to listen to it. Our time in this system is ever more limited each day, therefore, please don't waste another minute and learn about the love our Creator has for each of us, despite our faults. He has the biggest heart ande embraces all who love him. It is an invitation He, and we, lovingly invite you to embrace.
 5/24/07
 Sophia Garrett
 I really enjoyed "Knocking", it was very enjoyable to see the life that I live everyday. I was raised as a Jehovah's Witness and have been dedicated for 17 years now. What I find that seems to baffle those on the outside looking in is how do we live this way, there is only one way we do this- our wonderful friendship with our precious God Jehovah. And until anyone comes into such a precious friendship, they will never understand us completely- they will continue to always look at us as "Jehovah's Witnesses-the religion", but as for me, I am a fellow worker and servant of Jehovah, witnessing HIS purposes for the earth, as it unfolds for the world to see.
 5/24/07
 Houston, TX
 To Chicago, IL 5/23 - Thank you for your post. You hit the nail on the head. Those of us who made the choice to leave and are still living an upright life and honoring Jehovah's ways should not be judged by other JW. They are NOT Jehovah Himself and do not have the right to judge us. Even if we STILL have love for our former brothers, their harsh words show they do not have love for us. I can count on one hand the number of posts that are kind towards those who had to leave with a heavy heart. The Bible states that a person can reach Jehovah through JESUS ONLY-not through an organization of imperfect beings...whether it be JW or other religions. So I do not need IMPERFECT people to judge me for NOT BEING PERFECT or to reach Jehovah when I need Him. Even now, I still feel His presence and blessings. I remain faithful to JEHOVAH because he has never betrayed me. To SC in Texas, when did Jehovah give you the ability to read other people's heart? If I were in need - would you help me knowing I left the organization but still have a good heart? Probably not. Even to this day, I would bend over backwards to help a JW regardless of my personal choices. I cannot read a person's heart, I just see a child of Jehovah who needs help.
 5/24/07
 Clarence Mennis
 MN
 I am thankful that people will see that Jehovah's Witnesses do what the best helth care. We may not want to use blood and that turns one's off, but we do all we can. My dear wife passed away a few mouths ago, but all the help she got at USC for her liver and other problems, the team at USC help with everything to the max. Next time a Jehovah's Witnesses calls on your door, ask him about Jehovah or how we look at blood or other things, they will tell you just how it is. Thanks
 5/24/07
 Los Angeles
 First of all I want to thank PBS and Independent Lens for taking the time to do such an extraordinary presentation with such accuracy. that only reinforces my respect for anintellectually stimulating channel. Secondly I'm studying with the Witnesses and I feel greatful that such organization exists. Jehovah's Witnesses faith is unwavering and forever tested. I wouldl like to be a witness on day. Jehovah only wants what's best for us and wants us to live forever in a beautiful peaceful paradice on earth, what does this (global warming-war loving-world) offer us?
 5/24/07
 Cristina
 Houston,TX
 I AM CURRENTLY STUDYING WITH JW'S AND HAVE NEVER LOVED AND APPRECIATED GOD AS MUCH AS I DO NOW. I LEARNED MORE ABOUT THE BIBLE IN A FEW MONTHS THAN I EVER DID IN MY WHOLE LIFE AT THE CHURCH. WHEN PEOPLE ARE RAISED TO BELIEVE WHATEVER THE "PRIEST OR PREACHER" SAYS AT CHURCH WITH OUT SCRIPTURAL REASONINGS, I UNDERSTAND WHY THERE IS SO MUCH IGNORANCE TO WHAT THE BIBLE REALLY TEACHES.THERE IS SO MUCH NEGATIVITY AND OPPOSITION TOWARDS JW'S B/C THEY REALLY USE THE BIBLE AND PEOPLE DONT WANT TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS AND WANT TO 'WORSHIP AND BELIEVE' THE WAY THEY WANT TO AND NOT ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE. THIS DOCUMENTARY IS A GREAT TESTIMONY OF WHO JW'S REALLY ARE. THANK YOU FOR SUCH A GREAT AND INFORMATIVE FILM.
 5/24/07
 en Martin
 My wife and I were raised as Witnesses and are very happy as such. We watched the show last night on DVR and were riveted, and we are buying the DVD. Watching the interaction between the Witness and non witness families was difficult, as my wifes parents left the truth a few years ago and decided to write a letter instead of just being inactive... Needless to say we have been unable to speak to them or see them since. While this has been extremely difficult for my wife and her sister, it is a protection to us, and somoething she has been able to deal with thru the help of her brothers and sisters at the hall. Thanks to the director and to PBS for airing a fair and balanced documentary.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_n.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Zulema
 TX
 Thank you so much for airing the documentary "Knocking," if not very often we - Jehovah's Witnesses are able to hear nor see, positive things going out about our Faith! and when such a thing as "Knocking," does happen it truly makes the heart jump for joy! also, Thanks to the Show's Host - Mr. Howard for his canned remarks on the NPR Show: "Tell Me More." Thank you for sharing the Good News something the world needs to hear now-a-days. Again, Thank you.
 5/24/07
 El Paso, TX
 I watched the film knocking yesterday and liked it very much. If possible I would like to know how we can get a hold of the producers or people in the film. I would love to learn more about their lives.
 5/24/07
 M Gilbert
 Please tell the producers of Knocking thanks for a great film. They need to do another on Witnesses to describe more of the info on the website. 60 Minutes and Dateline were so filled with bias and out right disrespect. CNN often show their prejudice against Jehovah's Witnesses. Of course pleasing God is our only concern. We have faith in his great love and justice. To live in peace and good health, on clean earth and being guaranteed happiness by our Creator is worth all effort. Thank you.
 5/24/07
 Angie Mott
 Ontario OR
 I just want to let you know I really enjoyed the Independent Lens Knocking last night. It was put together nicely. I just wanted the person or persons who make it did a great job. I like how they showed a little of the opposing side. I hope you show it again that way more that way more of my family sees it. Great Job done!
 5/24/07
 Dave Hall Enterprises
 Yucca Valley, California
 Immensely enjoyed KNOCKING as televised last evening. Program was well developed, and showed the true beliefs of Jehovahs Witnesses as a pattern of Bible teachings. Often time Jehovahs Witnesses are often misunderstood, because of the Blood Issue and the Flag Salute Issue.Jehovahs Witnesses respect the flag of any country and would not do any act of disrespect to it as it is a symbol of freedom. A salute, whether to a flag or to a person, is an act of worship that Jehovahs witnesses give only to their Creator. The Bible and the old testament and the new testament forbid the misuse of blood, being sacred in the eyes of our creator. Thanks to the Jehovahs Witnesses in setting up bloodless surgery that all religions can benefit from The concentration camp portrayal showed what the Jews and the Jehovahs Witnesses experience when dictator type people are in power. Dave Hall Yucca Valley, California.
 5/24/07
 Guy Richards
 Athol, Ma
 I enjoyed watching your program "Knocking" about Jehovah's Witnesses. The stories of the elderly Jewish member who was in the Nazi concentration camps and the young man who needed a liver transplant were very moving. There is no question about the sincerity and zeal of the majority of the Watchtower members.However, there are aspects of the organization that you failed to report. For example, nothing was mentioned about the effort of the leadership of the Watchtower to appease Hitler in 1933. Both the letter sent to Hitler and the distribution of the tract "Declaration of Facts" in that year was a shameful attempt to save the Watchtower property in Magdeburg, Germany at the expense of condemning the Jews as well as the United States and Britain.
 Likewise, the program failed to note that if the young man who needed a liver transplant had faced his problem a few years previously, he probably would have died since the Watchtower deemed that all organ transplants were a form of "cannibalism" and proscribed the procedure. I hope that someday the full story about the Watchtower's vacillation on the use of blood over the years and its current sexual abuse scandal will also be aired so that public will have a balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower Society.
 5/24/07
 Antonio Molina
 Miami Florida
 My name is Antonio Molina , i'm one of the Jehovah's witnesses.I'd like to take this opportunity to thanks for this material seen last night, and i wanted to let you know about the situation with my job, where i've been suffering discrimination for been a Jehovah's witness because they have been giving to me a very hard time with the schedules of the meetings that we have every week. There are more religious persons at this company and they have received a different treatment.I've been really dicrimination.
 5/24/07
 George Gibson
 Alpharetta Georgia
 I am one of Jehovah's Witness and I have seen many programs that has put us in a bad light. Your program was very objective and gave the facts as they truly are. I am thankful to all those involved in making this production and would recommend it to fellow Witnesses. Thank you once again and all those at Independent Lens.
 5/24/07
 Gloryah Kastor
 Colorado Springs, CO
 I enjoyed your program on Jehovahs Witnesses. They are doing exactly what any bible says to do and that is to preach this good news of the kingdom. They are following what Jehovahs son, Jesus did when he was on earth. Please take any literature from them and if you have the opportunity, accept a free home bible study and learn how Jehovah our grand creator loves us and will keep his word. Thank You for a wonderful program,
 5/24/07
 You folks did an exceptional job on us .very enjoyable i being a jehovah witness for 30 years have not regret it .thank u for what u did .i hope some day everyone there will come to know jehovah as me and my family have. thank u once again nice work
 5/24/07
 Rod Bender
 Portland, OR
 For the virtually the first time ever, we finally have a balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses, made by journalists who have done a superb job of presenting both sides of the story from a personal perspective. Many ex-JWs and others who are opposed to JWs will protest this film, since this film does not spout their misconceptions and slander. They have their websites to do that if they want. But now we finally see the private lives of the Witnesses shown to the world as I, and millions of others, have known it. I know this film is true because it shows a slice of my own life and beliefs. To Mr. Engardio, I offer you the most sincere thanks of all of Jehovah's Witnesses who are happy to see the truth about us finally revealed.
 5/24/07
 Whitney
 Wisconsin
 I'm 15 and I've been a Witness all my life. I love being part of this organization. For me being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is my life I can't imagine being myself if I wasn't one. This film was very accurate and well done, especially since a lot of people put us in such a bad light. We aren't perfect, but we aren't what people have been saying earlier either. I have had my share of spankings in my time, but that is NOT abuse and it made me an obediant and better child. btw, thx for making such an accurate movie!!!!!
 5/24/07
 North Miami
 I would like to express my thanks to the producers of the film knocking. It was extremely well made. I loved how it started witht he father and son and ended with the father and son. I also found the pledge of alligence issue that all of us Jehovah Witness face since childhood a very well written and investigated piece. It explained how it has nothing to do with our feeling for the place we were born but for the alligence to an idol made of clothe a Flag. Our alligence is only to Jehovah God not to any idol made by man. Thanks again for bringing up that issue up so others will understand it. BRAVO to a very neutral (we like neutral) film!
 5/24/07
 Pammy Angel
 Benzonia,Michigan
 "Knocking" was tastefully done. I hope that many people who watched it can learn about our ministry, our lives and our beliefs and be more accepting about what we belief. I am hoping that once the world has seen it.I been a bapzied witness since 2003, I learned the truth about 7 yrs ago, and I am happy to say that I am relieved that my future is to live in a cleansed earth. Yet of course it important to understand that we are to live only for Jehovah. This documentary is clean, simple and emotional.
 5/24/07
 Justin, McLaughlin
 Harrison, Arkansas
 This program was an acurate portrayal of Jehovahs witnesses. I dissasociated my self about a year ago from the wittneses, which I know now was a mistake. It is so nice to know that the world will be a peacefull place to live for Jehavahs people in the near future. Psalms:37:9,10,11,29
 5/24/07
 Ivette
 Miami
 If you look back in history to true christians they where thrown to the lions because they wouldn't follow the Romans in their killings and traditions. Roman traditions went against their christian believes. That is what a Jehovah Witness is a true Christians you can also see it by their preaching. How many other religions are out there preaching like Jesus taught us and his apostles? How many religions are truly neutral when it comes to war? Just something to think about.
 5/24/07
 Moe
 Brooklyn, NY
 I didn't get the opportunity to see the documentary intitled "Knocking" aired recently on Channel 13 PBS in NY. Will the program be airing again in the near future. I am highly interested in seeing it. There have been so many responses to it. I read Director/Producer Tom Shepard comments on AOL blog and his comments increased my interest and desire to see the program,
 Http://movies.aol.com/truestories/blog/category/knocking/
 I hope that the program will be played again. Thanks.

 5/24/07
 Florida
 People are going to have negative things to say about any religion, race, culture, school etc. We just hope that people look past a few disgruntled people to see the truth of the matter. I am very glad that this documentary focused on a few key things that people are misinformed about. People who might have been to afraid to ask, or too afraid to open their doors, can now see that Jehovah's Witnesses aren't mind washing cult following freaks. We are people just like you who read the Bible and believe in the prophecies, values, and principles found within. In the matter of having family members who do not share our faith, most of us do as much as we can to maintain a family arrangement. While Jehovah's Witnesses don't celebrate holidays because of the pagan backgrounds, they still attend other family functions, they still call each other, write letters, and live together in peace. Jehovah's Witnesses are never told to leave their husbands/family just because they are not of the same faith. In the end the only thing that makes us different from other people is the moral stands that we take. And while we respect our governments and local authorities, in the end our faith is in Jehovah's Kingdom.
 5/24/07
 BK. G.
 VA
 Jehovah is God's name, god is a title, Jehovah gives us free will. No one is forced to serve him. Jehovah is holy therefore his people must be holy.To be holy means to be clean in all ways. we do not follow a man, Jesus Christ is over the congegation. Jesus was rejected so we expect people to reject us.However we still have to preach the truth. We have a worldwide brotherhood of Faithful witnesses who are willing to serve Jehovah. Our love for Jehovah, Jesus and people compels us to continue to the end.May Jehovah's name forever be praised and honored among his people now and forever. Rev. 21 3-5 Psalms 37:9-11, 29
 5/24/07
 San Antonio
 This film tells the whole truth of jehovahs witnesses...they are the only true cristians...that live there life as one of them...all other religions are hipocrites...going to mass on sunday.....and then go back to live an inmoral life....i just hope everyone would be jehovahs witnesses. the world would be in peace. 5/24/07
 Barbara L.
 Pompano Beach, Florida
 I enjoyed watching the documentary. I felt it presented a fair, balanced view of my religion which is often misrepresented in the media, particularly by former members.I am proud to be one of Jehovah's Christian Witnesses and am glad I am raising my two children in the faith.
 5/24/07
 TX
 All you JW haters who have been Disfellowshiped are only hurting yourself and Jehovah. (PSALM 119:165- There is peace for those who love God and there is no Stumbling block.) You alone are living with your choices. There are imperfect humans in every religion. This film explained how JWs have been fighting for civil rights that has opened a gateway for all humans everywhere. I was very excited to see this film and thought it was fair, and hope it gives people who have never taken the time to speak w JWs a better understanding of Us :)
 5/24/07
 Houston, TX
 To the JW who are blasting the people who made the decision to leave, have any of you ever bothered to ASK them why they left instead of automatically assuming they did something wrong? Why don't you ask the elders why they were against me seeking mental health services when I was diagnosed with SEVERE clinical depression? I have a legitimate illness that is causes by a biological defect in my brain - I was not being punished by Jehovah for being a bad person as one sister said to me. I spent years of my life VERY dedicated to Jehovah and his organization. Ask the brothers and sisters WHY they turned their backs on me when I needed help! It is this hypocritical and JUDGMENTAL attitude that made me leave. As stated in another post - you are looked down upon if you are not able to help (as what happened to me when I became ill) or if you have a mental illness. JW need to address these problems instead of acting like they not exist.
 5/24/07
 John Bergman
 Madison, In.
 This is probably one of the best documentaries I have ever seen about the Witnesses. It was fair, balanced, honest, and direct. As a journalist, it was understandable that Mr. Engardio would put in, as part of the doc, people who disagree with our beliefs, and it shows both sides of the issue. It does put us into a new , positive light that we are not cultist, freaky people who hide in barracks or houses and shun everybody. If we were, we wouldn't be involved in the door to door preaching activity that we are known for. The part of the documentary where it tells that what the Witnesses fought for through the Supremem Court did and still has a rippling effect on many American lives so that we live as a free people as well as a free individual.
 5/24/07
 Justin Kurtz
 Danielsville, GA
 Thank you to PBS and to Independent Films for broadcasting this excellent documentary. From the message board it is clear that you have challenged us to broaden our perspective and question the way we look at life and the issues we all face. Well done.
 5/24/07
 Stuff
 Baltimore, MD
 I read some of the blogs and was shock to read the bitterness others have toward Jehovah's Witnesses. Many who profess to be Chritians. Much of their criticism is based on miss information, personal opinions and hatred. What is a Christian? A foot step follower of Jesus Christ. That's what the Witnesses are 'True Christians'. They follow the teachings of Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ always gave credit, honor and respect to his father, Jehovah, the Creator. Therefore, Jesus' followers are to do the same. I just don't see what the problem is. Jehovah made it very clear that he will not share his worship with any other god or image. Jesus is Jehovah's son. The Son of God. There is no mention of 'three'. Is the holy spirit a person? Explain please by means of bible references, if you can. I just don't get the hostility and bitterness from so many so-called Christians.
 5/24/07
 Sandmadd
 L.A., CA
 Maybe, one day someone will make a documentary from the other side; people who are annoyed by the Jehovah Witnesses knocking on their door. This documentary will turn the tables on the Witnesses, having people of other faiths going to the homes of Witnesses, knocking on their doors to interrupt their sleep, their lovemaking, their meditation, their conversations, movie-watching, etc. Then have the intruders impose their religious beliefs on the Witnesses and tell them to read another "holy" text-not the Bible.
 5/24/07
 Linda
 PA
 I am a JW since 1973. I have been disfellowshiped twice and have a son who is mentally retarded. I feel I was given fine councel from the elders which helped me to recover from my errors. My only regret is that I did not obey Jehovah in the first place. As for my son, he is treated like anyone else and is shown much love from the congregation, which dispells the myth that the mentally challenged are treated like lepers. JW's are truly a brotherhood.
 5/24/07
 Funny thing about growing up as one of Jehovah's Witnesses with relatives who are not Witnesses; they only seemed to want to "get together" for holidays or birthdays. It was like "we are having fun, we dare you to comprimise that religion and join us". Even as a child, I always felt that we didn't "shun" them, they were "shunning" US. Even as a child, I never really missed anything. My kids didn't either.
 5/24/07
 Phyllis Harmon
 Houston,Texas
 I think the documentary was wonderful. It really showed that Jehovah Witnesses are not just people who just walk around and just knock on your door for nothing. There is a message that is being given that is from the Bible and if we all look around us we can see that it is being fulfilled. This world is getting worse everyday, with sickness and death.How wonderful it would be to live in a world where this will no longer be.The film was wonderful to watch.Thanks.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_o.html







PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/24/07
 Zulema
 TX
 Thank you so much for airing the documentary "Knocking," if not very often we - Jehovah's Witnesses are able to hear nor see, positive things going out about our Faith! and when such a thing as "Knocking," does happen it truly makes the heart jump for joy! also, Thanks to the Show's Host - Mr. Howard for his canned remarks on the NPR Show: "Tell Me More." Thank you for sharing the Good News something the world needs to hear now-a-days. Again, Thank you.
 5/24/07
 El Paso, TX
 I watched the film knocking yesterday and liked it very much. If possible I would like to know how we can get a hold of the producers or people in the film. I would love to learn more about their lives.
 5/24/07
 M Gilbert
 Please tell the producers of Knocking thanks for a great film. They need to do another on Witnesses to describe more of the info on the website. 60 Minutes and Dateline were so filled with bias and out right disrespect. CNN often show their prejudice against Jehovah's Witnesses. Of course pleasing God is our only concern. We have faith in his great love and justice. To live in peace and good health, on clean earth and being guaranteed happiness by our Creator is worth all effort. Thank you.
 5/24/07
 Angie Mott
 Ontario OR
 I just want to let you know I really enjoyed the Independent Lens Knocking last night. It was put together nicely. I just wanted the person or persons who make it did a great job. I like how they showed a little of the opposing side. I hope you show it again that way more that way more of my family sees it. Great Job done!
 5/24/07
 Dave Hall Enterprises
 Yucca Valley, California
 Immensely enjoyed KNOCKING as televised last evening. Program was well developed, and showed the true beliefs of Jehovahs Witnesses as a pattern of Bible teachings. Often time Jehovahs Witnesses are often misunderstood, because of the Blood Issue and the Flag Salute Issue.Jehovahs Witnesses respect the flag of any country and would not do any act of disrespect to it as it is a symbol of freedom. A salute, whether to a flag or to a person, is an act of worship that Jehovahs witnesses give only to their Creator. The Bible and the old testament and the new testament forbid the misuse of blood, being sacred in the eyes of our creator. Thanks to the Jehovahs Witnesses in setting up bloodless surgery that all religions can benefit from The concentration camp portrayal showed what the Jews and the Jehovahs Witnesses experience when dictator type people are in power. Dave Hall Yucca Valley, California.
 5/24/07
 Guy Richards
 Athol, Ma
 I enjoyed watching your program "Knocking" about Jehovah's Witnesses. The stories of the elderly Jewish member who was in the Nazi concentration camps and the young man who needed a liver transplant were very moving. There is no question about the sincerity and zeal of the majority of the Watchtower members.However, there are aspects of the organization that you failed to report. For example, nothing was mentioned about the effort of the leadership of the Watchtower to appease Hitler in 1933. Both the letter sent to Hitler and the distribution of the tract "Declaration of Facts" in that year was a shameful attempt to save the Watchtower property in Magdeburg, Germany at the expense of condemning the Jews as well as the United States and Britain.
 Likewise, the program failed to note that if the young man who needed a liver transplant had faced his problem a few years previously, he probably would have died since the Watchtower deemed that all organ transplants were a form of "cannibalism" and proscribed the procedure. I hope that someday the full story about the Watchtower's vacillation on the use of blood over the years and its current sexual abuse scandal will also be aired so that public will have a balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower Society.
 5/24/07
 Antonio Molina
 Miami Florida
 My name is Antonio Molina , i'm one of the Jehovah's witnesses.I'd like to take this opportunity to thanks for this material seen last night, and i wanted to let you know about the situation with my job, where i've been suffering discrimination for been a Jehovah's witness because they have been giving to me a very hard time with the schedules of the meetings that we have every week. There are more religious persons at this company and they have received a different treatment.I've been really dicrimination.
 5/24/07
 George Gibson
 Alpharetta Georgia
 I am one of Jehovah's Witness and I have seen many programs that has put us in a bad light. Your program was very objective and gave the facts as they truly are. I am thankful to all those involved in making this production and would recommend it to fellow Witnesses. Thank you once again and all those at Independent Lens.
 5/24/07
 Gloryah Kastor
 Colorado Springs, CO
 I enjoyed your program on Jehovahs Witnesses. They are doing exactly what any bible says to do and that is to preach this good news of the kingdom. They are following what Jehovahs son, Jesus did when he was on earth. Please take any literature from them and if you have the opportunity, accept a free home bible study and learn how Jehovah our grand creator loves us and will keep his word. Thank You for a wonderful program,
 5/24/07
 You folks did an exceptional job on us .very enjoyable i being a jehovah witness for 30 years have not regret it .thank u for what u did .i hope some day everyone there will come to know jehovah as me and my family have. thank u once again nice work
 5/24/07
 Rod Bender
 Portland, OR
 For the virtually the first time ever, we finally have a balanced view of Jehovah's Witnesses, made by journalists who have done a superb job of presenting both sides of the story from a personal perspective. Many ex-JWs and others who are opposed to JWs will protest this film, since this film does not spout their misconceptions and slander. They have their websites to do that if they want. But now we finally see the private lives of the Witnesses shown to the world as I, and millions of others, have known it. I know this film is true because it shows a slice of my own life and beliefs. To Mr. Engardio, I offer you the most sincere thanks of all of Jehovah's Witnesses who are happy to see the truth about us finally revealed.
 5/24/07
 Whitney
 Wisconsin
 I'm 15 and I've been a Witness all my life. I love being part of this organization. For me being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is my life I can't imagine being myself if I wasn't one. This film was very accurate and well done, especially since a lot of people put us in such a bad light. We aren't perfect, but we aren't what people have been saying earlier either. I have had my share of spankings in my time, but that is NOT abuse and it made me an obediant and better child. btw, thx for making such an accurate movie!!!!!
 5/24/07
 North Miami
 I would like to express my thanks to the producers of the film knocking. It was extremely well made. I loved how it started witht he father and son and ended with the father and son. I also found the pledge of alligence issue that all of us Jehovah Witness face since childhood a very well written and investigated piece. It explained how it has nothing to do with our feeling for the place we were born but for the alligence to an idol made of clothe a Flag. Our alligence is only to Jehovah God not to any idol made by man. Thanks again for bringing up that issue up so others will understand it. BRAVO to a very neutral (we like neutral) film!
 5/24/07
 Pammy Angel
 Benzonia,Michigan
 "Knocking" was tastefully done. I hope that many people who watched it can learn about our ministry, our lives and our beliefs and be more accepting about what we belief. I am hoping that once the world has seen it.I been a bapzied witness since 2003, I learned the truth about 7 yrs ago, and I am happy to say that I am relieved that my future is to live in a cleansed earth. Yet of course it important to understand that we are to live only for Jehovah. This documentary is clean, simple and emotional.
 5/24/07
 Justin, McLaughlin
 Harrison, Arkansas
 This program was an acurate portrayal of Jehovahs witnesses. I dissasociated my self about a year ago from the wittneses, which I know now was a mistake. It is so nice to know that the world will be a peacefull place to live for Jehavahs people in the near future. Psalms:37:9,10,11,29
 5/24/07
 Ivette
 Miami
 If you look back in history to true christians they where thrown to the lions because they wouldn't follow the Romans in their killings and traditions. Roman traditions went against their christian believes. That is what a Jehovah Witness is a true Christians you can also see it by their preaching. How many other religions are out there preaching like Jesus taught us and his apostles? How many religions are truly neutral when it comes to war? Just something to think about.
 5/24/07
 Moe
 Brooklyn, NY
 I didn't get the opportunity to see the documentary intitled "Knocking" aired recently on Channel 13 PBS in NY. Will the program be airing again in the near future. I am highly interested in seeing it. There have been so many responses to it. I read Director/Producer Tom Shepard comments on AOL blog and his comments increased my interest and desire to see the program,
 Http://movies.aol.com/truestories/blog/category/knocking/
 I hope that the program will be played again. Thanks.

 5/24/07
 Florida
 People are going to have negative things to say about any religion, race, culture, school etc. We just hope that people look past a few disgruntled people to see the truth of the matter. I am very glad that this documentary focused on a few key things that people are misinformed about. People who might have been to afraid to ask, or too afraid to open their doors, can now see that Jehovah's Witnesses aren't mind washing cult following freaks. We are people just like you who read the Bible and believe in the prophecies, values, and principles found within. In the matter of having family members who do not share our faith, most of us do as much as we can to maintain a family arrangement. While Jehovah's Witnesses don't celebrate holidays because of the pagan backgrounds, they still attend other family functions, they still call each other, write letters, and live together in peace. Jehovah's Witnesses are never told to leave their husbands/family just because they are not of the same faith. In the end the only thing that makes us different from other people is the moral stands that we take. And while we respect our governments and local authorities, in the end our faith is in Jehovah's Kingdom.
 5/24/07
 BK. G.
 VA
 Jehovah is God's name, god is a title, Jehovah gives us free will. No one is forced to serve him. Jehovah is holy therefore his people must be holy.To be holy means to be clean in all ways. we do not follow a man, Jesus Christ is over the congegation. Jesus was rejected so we expect people to reject us.However we still have to preach the truth. We have a worldwide brotherhood of Faithful witnesses who are willing to serve Jehovah. Our love for Jehovah, Jesus and people compels us to continue to the end.May Jehovah's name forever be praised and honored among his people now and forever. Rev. 21 3-5 Psalms 37:9-11, 29
 5/24/07
 San Antonio
 This film tells the whole truth of jehovahs witnesses...they are the only true cristians...that live there life as one of them...all other religions are hipocrites...going to mass on sunday.....and then go back to live an inmoral life....i just hope everyone would be jehovahs witnesses. the world would be in peace. 5/24/07
 Barbara L.
 Pompano Beach, Florida
 I enjoyed watching the documentary. I felt it presented a fair, balanced view of my religion which is often misrepresented in the media, particularly by former members.I am proud to be one of Jehovah's Christian Witnesses and am glad I am raising my two children in the faith.
 5/24/07
 TX
 All you JW haters who have been Disfellowshiped are only hurting yourself and Jehovah. (PSALM 119:165- There is peace for those who love God and there is no Stumbling block.) You alone are living with your choices. There are imperfect humans in every religion. This film explained how JWs have been fighting for civil rights that has opened a gateway for all humans everywhere. I was very excited to see this film and thought it was fair, and hope it gives people who have never taken the time to speak w JWs a better understanding of Us :)
 5/24/07
 Houston, TX
 To the JW who are blasting the people who made the decision to leave, have any of you ever bothered to ASK them why they left instead of automatically assuming they did something wrong? Why don't you ask the elders why they were against me seeking mental health services when I was diagnosed with SEVERE clinical depression? I have a legitimate illness that is causes by a biological defect in my brain - I was not being punished by Jehovah for being a bad person as one sister said to me. I spent years of my life VERY dedicated to Jehovah and his organization. Ask the brothers and sisters WHY they turned their backs on me when I needed help! It is this hypocritical and JUDGMENTAL attitude that made me leave. As stated in another post - you are looked down upon if you are not able to help (as what happened to me when I became ill) or if you have a mental illness. JW need to address these problems instead of acting like they not exist.
 5/24/07
 John Bergman
 Madison, In.
 This is probably one of the best documentaries I have ever seen about the Witnesses. It was fair, balanced, honest, and direct. As a journalist, it was understandable that Mr. Engardio would put in, as part of the doc, people who disagree with our beliefs, and it shows both sides of the issue. It does put us into a new , positive light that we are not cultist, freaky people who hide in barracks or houses and shun everybody. If we were, we wouldn't be involved in the door to door preaching activity that we are known for. The part of the documentary where it tells that what the Witnesses fought for through the Supremem Court did and still has a rippling effect on many American lives so that we live as a free people as well as a free individual.
 5/24/07
 Justin Kurtz
 Danielsville, GA
 Thank you to PBS and to Independent Films for broadcasting this excellent documentary. From the message board it is clear that you have challenged us to broaden our perspective and question the way we look at life and the issues we all face. Well done.
 5/24/07
 Stuff
 Baltimore, MD
 I read some of the blogs and was shock to read the bitterness others have toward Jehovah's Witnesses. Many who profess to be Chritians. Much of their criticism is based on miss information, personal opinions and hatred. What is a Christian? A foot step follower of Jesus Christ. That's what the Witnesses are 'True Christians'. They follow the teachings of Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ always gave credit, honor and respect to his father, Jehovah, the Creator. Therefore, Jesus' followers are to do the same. I just don't see what the problem is. Jehovah made it very clear that he will not share his worship with any other god or image. Jesus is Jehovah's son. The Son of God. There is no mention of 'three'. Is the holy spirit a person? Explain please by means of bible references, if you can. I just don't get the hostility and bitterness from so many so-called Christians.
 5/24/07
 Sandmadd
 L.A., CA
 Maybe, one day someone will make a documentary from the other side; people who are annoyed by the Jehovah Witnesses knocking on their door. This documentary will turn the tables on the Witnesses, having people of other faiths going to the homes of Witnesses, knocking on their doors to interrupt their sleep, their lovemaking, their meditation, their conversations, movie-watching, etc. Then have the intruders impose their religious beliefs on the Witnesses and tell them to read another "holy" text-not the Bible.
 5/24/07
 Linda
 PA
 I am a JW since 1973. I have been disfellowshiped twice and have a son who is mentally retarded. I feel I was given fine councel from the elders which helped me to recover from my errors. My only regret is that I did not obey Jehovah in the first place. As for my son, he is treated like anyone else and is shown much love from the congregation, which dispells the myth that the mentally challenged are treated like lepers. JW's are truly a brotherhood.
 5/24/07
 Funny thing about growing up as one of Jehovah's Witnesses with relatives who are not Witnesses; they only seemed to want to "get together" for holidays or birthdays. It was like "we are having fun, we dare you to comprimise that religion and join us". Even as a child, I always felt that we didn't "shun" them, they were "shunning" US. Even as a child, I never really missed anything. My kids didn't either.
 5/24/07
 Phyllis Harmon
 Houston,Texas
 I think the documentary was wonderful. It really showed that Jehovah Witnesses are not just people who just walk around and just knock on your door for nothing. There is a message that is being given that is from the Bible and if we all look around us we can see that it is being fulfilled. This world is getting worse everyday, with sickness and death.How wonderful it would be to live in a world where this will no longer be.The film was wonderful to watch.Thanks.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                


http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_o.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/25/07
 Dallas, TX
 Your Film was magnificent, you did an outstanding job. I truly believe that if the entire world had the mindset of a true JW, he world would be a much better place to live. Until that time we can only hope and pray for a better tomorrow. Thanks for doing great Job!
 5/25/07
 "Personally, I don�t agree with the Jehovah�s Witness stand on various issues. So after listening to their message, I don�t join. No one has to be a Jehovah�s Witness, just as no one has to be Catholic or Mormon or Baptist. But we all have to be given the freedom to live our lives as we see fit�as long as we respect each other�s right to live differently and do no harm. Jehovah�s Witnesses offer a good example of how fundamentalist religion can remain true to itself while peacefully co-existing with a progressive society. It is how America is supposed to work. "
 Ah, but they don't give that freedom do they Joel? The quote above is from your website, but JW's do not allow people who once were in their religion (I was raised and baptized at age 14), to choose to leave. Sure I had a choice to not get baptized, but I was FOURTEEN, what did I know. When I did leave, because I am gay and they won't let me stay, I was shunned. You are gay, and the only difference between me and you is that you didn't get baptized at age 14. I can't choose to not be a JW without losing my family. That is not freedom, that is control and cultish behavior.
 5/25/07
 SB
 Florida
 Although I try to respect all those who are doing some form of good, I no longer turn my spirituality over to a formed man made group. No religion on the face of this earth replaces Jesus Christ, who came in the flesh, sent by his Father. We are to be Christians, Christ like. God did not pick one group who could only understand his bible. He sent his Son to die and to redeem,.... for all those who put their faith in him, individually, not as a formed group. Jesus Christ is the Leader of faith walking believers, and spoke the complete truth, long before the mid 1800's religious movements of that time, with many failed documents. Facts are facts and they should be presented fully, your life depends on it!!!!!!
 5/25/07
 Shoshanah Simon
 Sunny Isles, Florida
 My father was a presiding elder for many years. Though I've forgiven him, I'm left with many scars of abuse, like being told at 16 that I had a "poisonous root" and he used a belt BUCKLE to "beat it out of me".). There was sexual abuse in every family (all Witnesses) on my father's side. No one was disfellowshipped for these atrocities. I was disfellowshipped later for fornication.
 Out of nine children, two are still in the "truth", one of which has attempted suicide twice. When I called to offer support, he shunned me because I�m disfellowshipped. His attempting to take his own life goes against most faiths, not just his own. He hasn't been disfellowshipped, which is hypocritical and utter lunacy.
 All is not lost. For when my father had his heart attack weeks ago and was unconscious, he told many of this revelation: He was standing in the corner watching the doctor and nurse try to revive him. He mentioned seeing two tunnels; one tunnel was bright with others who've passed reaching out to him; the other tunnel was dark and frightening. His first wife was there in between and told him that he had to choose the light or the darkness. Before he died, he regretted to admit that the "truth" had duped him and torn his family apart. He asked us for forgiveness and not to make the mistake he made. WAKE UP people before your sanity and souls are compromised.
 5/25/07
 EC
 Tennessee
 I have seen the documentary on TV and I watched the DVD Home Edition several times with my friends. From the very beginning I was very impressed by the documentary. The DVD has as an added bonus. You can listen to interviews with the directors of the film and seven different experts, who are not Jehovah Witnesses.
 I applaud the makers of this documentary and I am not surprised that it won four awards. I wished that PBS would have aired the �Home Edition� version or at least parts of these interviews.
 People with the goal to be objective can really appreciate the different viewpoints presented. I agree with Anderson Cooper (CNN) who said: "Riveting and illuminating. Knocking takes us inside the world of Jehovah�s Witnesses in a way that is utterly surprising and moving."
 5/25/07
 Raymond Chu
 Its always a joy to watch ANY independent lens shows! If not for this show, i would have never realize when JW went through during the second world war in Germany, their contribution to our freedom of speach, ect. I am angry at the fact that in my 35 + years in this country, all i have heard about JW is cutting remarks and butt of jokes! How can a faith that believes in nothing but loving your fellow human being be so misunderstood.......i will definately read the next pamphlet instead of putting it in the trash! Keep up the good work Independent Lens.......
 5/25/07
 SMILES
 CHICAGO, IL
 Many thanks to the producer and editor of this article. Finally someone showed the world the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses. This is the first time I've known for an article to be produced that has true facts about this religion. I really enjoyed watching and listening to the article, it could not been done any more percise than that. I Look forward to watching and listening to more of your articles. This is a job well done.
 5/25/07
 Pam
 Thousand Oaks
 Thank you Joel, PBS and Independent Lens for taking on such a controversial and unpopular subject. I hope that this film has a positive influence on peoples willingness to discuss the Bible peacefully without fear and anger. Watching this film made me so proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/25/07
 JW's are trying their best to imitate a PERFECT person, Jesus Christ, and follow the PERFECT instruction of our God. But we are all, by nature, IMPERFECT. So we cannot do this flawlessly. Therefore, at times, there are bound to be injustices, AS IN ANY OTHER RELIGION. Nobody living on earth is perfect. All we can do is try. That's all that anyone, JW or not, can do.
 In response to whoever has said that there is "no room for independent thought," well, that's just not true. We are encouraged in the Bible to "make the truth your own." That requires study and PLENTY of thought to prove to yourself what is an isn't true. But we are not going to stand by and watch someone who claims to be a member doing wrong things that are cleary out of line with Bible teachings. That reflects badly on the whole organization. We don't want people representing our name who are what you call "independantly thinking" and deciding to smoke, have premarital sex, abuse drugs, etc. and still call themselves a JW. If you get baptized, you are expected to do what's right. If you want to do something other than that, then DON'T GET BAPTIZED. Simple as that. It's not an unreasonable request for someone who is a MEMBER of an organization to follow the teachings of that organization.
 5/25/07
 Shelby Sanchez
 San Jose California
 Thank you for bring out this documentary. i think this will help alot of people, understand our beliefs and why we are always at there door step knocking.and as a Jehovah Wittness i think this film will have a great influence on peoples opionion on us.once again thank you.
 5/25/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 To look for absolute truths in the Bible is to miss the point of what it means to be a truly spiritual person and informs a lack of spiritual maturity. The true test of ones spirituality is how we treat one another - the kindness, love and benevolence we display to our fellowman. This should transcend any faith that we belong to. However people tend to wear their religions around their necks like a badge of honor defending their beliefs as a matter of who has the correct scriptural interpretations. In this sense Jehovah's Witnesses are no different from other dogmatic religions. The witnesses have projected the violence of our times onto the divine. They preach and look forward to a time when God will unleash vengeful wrath upon humanity who have not become Jehovah�s witnesses. For them to claim otherwise by saying that God only destroys the wicked would be to also admit that God would spare individuals in this world who lead a clean Christian life and are kind and benevolent to other - regardless of any particular religious affiliation. As a former witness I always wondered how the witnesses could reconcile in themselves the prospect of losing close family members who were not witnesses to a horrific Armageddon. Something to think about.
 5/25/07
 Joe Lombardo
 To Bill Bowen:
 We encourage everyone to report child molesters and if they willingly do not report them then they themselves are disfellowshipped. And further in every congregation the presiding overseer is aware of any known child molesters and subsequently that offender is reported privately to any future congregations they may go to.
 Neither you nor any other person can rid the world of this kind of sin or produce a community were it never arises.
 5/25/07
 Houston, Texas
 Wonderful job and fair assessment of our Organized Religion! God is a God of Order not disorder. If people where thrown out of a satanic cult they would have something to complain about. How they were not treated fairly!! The truth is, many of us don�t like the truth or want to receive discipline for not following guidelines. I appreciate attempt to present facts along with our scriptural reasoning and let others decide. There are many, many people of other religions who do respect our stand even if they don�t agree with our doctrine.
 What is great is that others at my job who are not Jehovah�s Witnesses watched the presentation and said they gained a great deal of appreciation for our organization and wanted to thank PBS for this airing. They are not ready to convert but they where very pleased with the show.
 To those who have mental illnesses please remember it can be hard to detect and diagnose who is spiritually or mentally sick. Just look at how many times doctors misdiagnose this problems and people are let out to commingle with others and often end up hurting people.
 If there is mercy needed on your part the true Judge Jehovah will help you in due time meanwhile we imperfect men will just do the best we can to protect others. May you have peace and if you are truly ill the New World will cure it. Again thanks for a fair presentation.
 5/25/07
 LDR
 Miami Fl
 it's much better on the big screen! great untold story. 5/25/07
 I would like to thank the producers of the piece on "knocking" and the positive light that it shedded on Jehovah's Witnesses, because we are often cast in such a negative light. The film was very moving, me and my family thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it. Those brothers and sisters in those concentration camps are faith strengthening to witnesses all over the world. Those words in Matthew 10:16-23 ring true to witness worldwide. For information about the 1933 convention in Germany and the publication "Declaration of Facts" visit. http://www.watchtower.org/library/g/1998/7/8/article_01.htm
 5/25/07
 EC
 Tennessee
 This is for Joshua from Austin, Texas who posted on 5/24/07
 A Jehovah Witness does not get "shunned" for being in love with a non Jehovah Witness. We discourage marriage outside our faith, because it makes it harder. Most unbelieving mates can not be as supportive as a believing mate. A male servant of Jehovah has many responsibilities in his family to strengthen his loved ones to fight temptations. This can�t be done as good by someone who doesn�t live by the same high standards.
 If your girlfriend is a baptized Witness, she might get �shunned� for lying by living a double life and for committing adultery if you have a sexual relationship. Only those get "shunned" who show no repentance.
 There is a lot of room for individuality among Jehovah�s Witnesses. We just get warnings so that we don�t loose balance.
 Someone who lives a double live is not a reliable source for finding the truth.
 5/25/07
 Carl Brandstrom
 Ronkonkoma, NY
 I found the presentation very balanced and accurate. I appreciate the efforts JWs have made in behalf of all who love freedom. Ironically, as was pointed out in the documentary, one who becomes a JW gives up some of those very freedoms. You simply cannot openly disagree with their policies and doctrines w/o serious consequences, the most extreme of which is expulsion and shunning. You are then quite literally treated as someone dead, even by family. People act this way because they are INDOCTRINATED with the belief that only THEY have the "truth" and anyone leaving or even disagreeing with the group has turned away from God. This causes me to agree with Seth's Grandma about the group being a cult.
 5/25/07
 Marcia
 Boise, Idaho
 Thank you for a most informative look at Jehovah's Witnesses in a public presentation, as your "Knocking" documentary portrayed. I especially appreciated the reference to the many Supreme Court cases that have established certain freedoms that have benefited many people, not just Jehovah's Witnesses only. The respect that they show the Bible as being inspired by God and very relevant for our modern times should be noted and imitated.
 5/25/07
 Ron Owens
 Bridgeport Mi
 I was a Jehovah's Witness for many years. I was even a Regular Pioneer(that is a lot of Knocking). Until my eyes were open to see what a Cult it really is. The "organization" has control over their lives. They also take the place of Christ and destroy many families. Learn more at http://www.freeminds.org
 5/25/07
 Maluenda
 St Louis Missouri
 This "documentary" is a sham. It does not portray JWs as they truly are. There are many decent people who do belong tothis cult, however, if the general public was informed of both sides of the coins they would have a completely different picture. The pedophilia problem in this cult is horrendous and will be comparable to the Catholic Church scandal. The social isolation experienced by it's members leads to mental health issues. All this can be substantiated by their own literature and the fact that they need to practice Theocratic Warfare or lying. So beware who is "knocking" at your door. It may well be a pedophile. There can not be open dialogue and discussion between JWs and society, or their family members when their own literature teaches to hate nonbelievers and nt to associate with them. I would be happy to provide anyone with a list of their publications that state just that. Hate your unbelieving parents, children, family, or anyone not believing in Jehovah. How cvan they deny it when they published it? How can people accept their faith as legitimate when it preaches hatred? I was raised a JW, married to a JW, and my father is still an elder. I can tell you from personal experience what is the truth.
 5/25/07
 Long Beach, CA
 You guys did a fantastic job with this film, in telling the truth about JW's in the different facets of life (with non-believing relatives, door to door work, etc.). Some are writing to share their bad experiences with JW's, and we saw that coming. In every organization there are always those who are unhappy and rather do things THERE WAY. It's not about what JW's tell people they have to do, it's about what GOD TELLS us to do. I was disfellowshipped because I practiced sin and was not repented. But, with time I realized it was my mistake and I needed Jehovah in my life, and thankfully I was reinstated as a witness. People need to know, this organization is made up of imperfect human beings, but backed by GOD, JEHOVAH himself and that is all that matters. If people make mistakes, that is something HE will deal with. Finally, remember, even some of his angels went astray. I really hope the general public that watched this will TRY to understand JW's better, just like we have TRIED to understand and respect everybody else for who they are.
 5/25/07
 bonnie
 merritt islnd,fl.
 please dear brothers and sisters let's remember satan has many ways of entering our heads this is one because of all the bad comments that have nothing to do with the film.it was a good film.thank you

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_p.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19




 
Read the AOL True Stories KNOCKING blog for more from the filmmakers and film subjects.
Visit the blog »
  


 This comment area is closed to new submissions. Visit ITVS.org to continue the conversation about this film.
 5/25/07
 Dallas, TX
 Your Film was magnificent, you did an outstanding job. I truly believe that if the entire world had the mindset of a true JW, he world would be a much better place to live. Until that time we can only hope and pray for a better tomorrow. Thanks for doing great Job!
 5/25/07
 "Personally, I don�t agree with the Jehovah�s Witness stand on various issues. So after listening to their message, I don�t join. No one has to be a Jehovah�s Witness, just as no one has to be Catholic or Mormon or Baptist. But we all have to be given the freedom to live our lives as we see fit�as long as we respect each other�s right to live differently and do no harm. Jehovah�s Witnesses offer a good example of how fundamentalist religion can remain true to itself while peacefully co-existing with a progressive society. It is how America is supposed to work. "
 Ah, but they don't give that freedom do they Joel? The quote above is from your website, but JW's do not allow people who once were in their religion (I was raised and baptized at age 14), to choose to leave. Sure I had a choice to not get baptized, but I was FOURTEEN, what did I know. When I did leave, because I am gay and they won't let me stay, I was shunned. You are gay, and the only difference between me and you is that you didn't get baptized at age 14. I can't choose to not be a JW without losing my family. That is not freedom, that is control and cultish behavior.
 5/25/07
 SB
 Florida
 Although I try to respect all those who are doing some form of good, I no longer turn my spirituality over to a formed man made group. No religion on the face of this earth replaces Jesus Christ, who came in the flesh, sent by his Father. We are to be Christians, Christ like. God did not pick one group who could only understand his bible. He sent his Son to die and to redeem,.... for all those who put their faith in him, individually, not as a formed group. Jesus Christ is the Leader of faith walking believers, and spoke the complete truth, long before the mid 1800's religious movements of that time, with many failed documents. Facts are facts and they should be presented fully, your life depends on it!!!!!!
 5/25/07
 Shoshanah Simon
 Sunny Isles, Florida
 My father was a presiding elder for many years. Though I've forgiven him, I'm left with many scars of abuse, like being told at 16 that I had a "poisonous root" and he used a belt BUCKLE to "beat it out of me".). There was sexual abuse in every family (all Witnesses) on my father's side. No one was disfellowshipped for these atrocities. I was disfellowshipped later for fornication.
 Out of nine children, two are still in the "truth", one of which has attempted suicide twice. When I called to offer support, he shunned me because I�m disfellowshipped. His attempting to take his own life goes against most faiths, not just his own. He hasn't been disfellowshipped, which is hypocritical and utter lunacy.
 All is not lost. For when my father had his heart attack weeks ago and was unconscious, he told many of this revelation: He was standing in the corner watching the doctor and nurse try to revive him. He mentioned seeing two tunnels; one tunnel was bright with others who've passed reaching out to him; the other tunnel was dark and frightening. His first wife was there in between and told him that he had to choose the light or the darkness. Before he died, he regretted to admit that the "truth" had duped him and torn his family apart. He asked us for forgiveness and not to make the mistake he made. WAKE UP people before your sanity and souls are compromised.
 5/25/07
 EC
 Tennessee
 I have seen the documentary on TV and I watched the DVD Home Edition several times with my friends. From the very beginning I was very impressed by the documentary. The DVD has as an added bonus. You can listen to interviews with the directors of the film and seven different experts, who are not Jehovah Witnesses.
 I applaud the makers of this documentary and I am not surprised that it won four awards. I wished that PBS would have aired the �Home Edition� version or at least parts of these interviews.
 People with the goal to be objective can really appreciate the different viewpoints presented. I agree with Anderson Cooper (CNN) who said: "Riveting and illuminating. Knocking takes us inside the world of Jehovah�s Witnesses in a way that is utterly surprising and moving."
 5/25/07
 Raymond Chu
 Its always a joy to watch ANY independent lens shows! If not for this show, i would have never realize when JW went through during the second world war in Germany, their contribution to our freedom of speach, ect. I am angry at the fact that in my 35 + years in this country, all i have heard about JW is cutting remarks and butt of jokes! How can a faith that believes in nothing but loving your fellow human being be so misunderstood.......i will definately read the next pamphlet instead of putting it in the trash! Keep up the good work Independent Lens.......
 5/25/07
 SMILES
 CHICAGO, IL
 Many thanks to the producer and editor of this article. Finally someone showed the world the truth about Jehovah's Witnesses. This is the first time I've known for an article to be produced that has true facts about this religion. I really enjoyed watching and listening to the article, it could not been done any more percise than that. I Look forward to watching and listening to more of your articles. This is a job well done.
 5/25/07
 Pam
 Thousand Oaks
 Thank you Joel, PBS and Independent Lens for taking on such a controversial and unpopular subject. I hope that this film has a positive influence on peoples willingness to discuss the Bible peacefully without fear and anger. Watching this film made me so proud to be one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
 5/25/07
 JW's are trying their best to imitate a PERFECT person, Jesus Christ, and follow the PERFECT instruction of our God. But we are all, by nature, IMPERFECT. So we cannot do this flawlessly. Therefore, at times, there are bound to be injustices, AS IN ANY OTHER RELIGION. Nobody living on earth is perfect. All we can do is try. That's all that anyone, JW or not, can do.
 In response to whoever has said that there is "no room for independent thought," well, that's just not true. We are encouraged in the Bible to "make the truth your own." That requires study and PLENTY of thought to prove to yourself what is an isn't true. But we are not going to stand by and watch someone who claims to be a member doing wrong things that are cleary out of line with Bible teachings. That reflects badly on the whole organization. We don't want people representing our name who are what you call "independantly thinking" and deciding to smoke, have premarital sex, abuse drugs, etc. and still call themselves a JW. If you get baptized, you are expected to do what's right. If you want to do something other than that, then DON'T GET BAPTIZED. Simple as that. It's not an unreasonable request for someone who is a MEMBER of an organization to follow the teachings of that organization.
 5/25/07
 Shelby Sanchez
 San Jose California
 Thank you for bring out this documentary. i think this will help alot of people, understand our beliefs and why we are always at there door step knocking.and as a Jehovah Wittness i think this film will have a great influence on peoples opionion on us.once again thank you.
 5/25/07
 RJ
 New Jersey
 To look for absolute truths in the Bible is to miss the point of what it means to be a truly spiritual person and informs a lack of spiritual maturity. The true test of ones spirituality is how we treat one another - the kindness, love and benevolence we display to our fellowman. This should transcend any faith that we belong to. However people tend to wear their religions around their necks like a badge of honor defending their beliefs as a matter of who has the correct scriptural interpretations. In this sense Jehovah's Witnesses are no different from other dogmatic religions. The witnesses have projected the violence of our times onto the divine. They preach and look forward to a time when God will unleash vengeful wrath upon humanity who have not become Jehovah�s witnesses. For them to claim otherwise by saying that God only destroys the wicked would be to also admit that God would spare individuals in this world who lead a clean Christian life and are kind and benevolent to other - regardless of any particular religious affiliation. As a former witness I always wondered how the witnesses could reconcile in themselves the prospect of losing close family members who were not witnesses to a horrific Armageddon. Something to think about.
 5/25/07
 Joe Lombardo
 To Bill Bowen:
 We encourage everyone to report child molesters and if they willingly do not report them then they themselves are disfellowshipped. And further in every congregation the presiding overseer is aware of any known child molesters and subsequently that offender is reported privately to any future congregations they may go to.
 Neither you nor any other person can rid the world of this kind of sin or produce a community were it never arises.
 5/25/07
 Houston, Texas
 Wonderful job and fair assessment of our Organized Religion! God is a God of Order not disorder. If people where thrown out of a satanic cult they would have something to complain about. How they were not treated fairly!! The truth is, many of us don�t like the truth or want to receive discipline for not following guidelines. I appreciate attempt to present facts along with our scriptural reasoning and let others decide. There are many, many people of other religions who do respect our stand even if they don�t agree with our doctrine.
 What is great is that others at my job who are not Jehovah�s Witnesses watched the presentation and said they gained a great deal of appreciation for our organization and wanted to thank PBS for this airing. They are not ready to convert but they where very pleased with the show.
 To those who have mental illnesses please remember it can be hard to detect and diagnose who is spiritually or mentally sick. Just look at how many times doctors misdiagnose this problems and people are let out to commingle with others and often end up hurting people.
 If there is mercy needed on your part the true Judge Jehovah will help you in due time meanwhile we imperfect men will just do the best we can to protect others. May you have peace and if you are truly ill the New World will cure it. Again thanks for a fair presentation.
 5/25/07
 LDR
 Miami Fl
 it's much better on the big screen! great untold story. 5/25/07
 I would like to thank the producers of the piece on "knocking" and the positive light that it shedded on Jehovah's Witnesses, because we are often cast in such a negative light. The film was very moving, me and my family thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it. Those brothers and sisters in those concentration camps are faith strengthening to witnesses all over the world. Those words in Matthew 10:16-23 ring true to witness worldwide. For information about the 1933 convention in Germany and the publication "Declaration of Facts" visit. http://www.watchtower.org/library/g/1998/7/8/article_01.htm
 5/25/07
 EC
 Tennessee
 This is for Joshua from Austin, Texas who posted on 5/24/07
 A Jehovah Witness does not get "shunned" for being in love with a non Jehovah Witness. We discourage marriage outside our faith, because it makes it harder. Most unbelieving mates can not be as supportive as a believing mate. A male servant of Jehovah has many responsibilities in his family to strengthen his loved ones to fight temptations. This can�t be done as good by someone who doesn�t live by the same high standards.
 If your girlfriend is a baptized Witness, she might get �shunned� for lying by living a double life and for committing adultery if you have a sexual relationship. Only those get "shunned" who show no repentance.
 There is a lot of room for individuality among Jehovah�s Witnesses. We just get warnings so that we don�t loose balance.
 Someone who lives a double live is not a reliable source for finding the truth.
 5/25/07
 Carl Brandstrom
 Ronkonkoma, NY
 I found the presentation very balanced and accurate. I appreciate the efforts JWs have made in behalf of all who love freedom. Ironically, as was pointed out in the documentary, one who becomes a JW gives up some of those very freedoms. You simply cannot openly disagree with their policies and doctrines w/o serious consequences, the most extreme of which is expulsion and shunning. You are then quite literally treated as someone dead, even by family. People act this way because they are INDOCTRINATED with the belief that only THEY have the "truth" and anyone leaving or even disagreeing with the group has turned away from God. This causes me to agree with Seth's Grandma about the group being a cult.
 5/25/07
 Marcia
 Boise, Idaho
 Thank you for a most informative look at Jehovah's Witnesses in a public presentation, as your "Knocking" documentary portrayed. I especially appreciated the reference to the many Supreme Court cases that have established certain freedoms that have benefited many people, not just Jehovah's Witnesses only. The respect that they show the Bible as being inspired by God and very relevant for our modern times should be noted and imitated.
 5/25/07
 Ron Owens
 Bridgeport Mi
 I was a Jehovah's Witness for many years. I was even a Regular Pioneer(that is a lot of Knocking). Until my eyes were open to see what a Cult it really is. The "organization" has control over their lives. They also take the place of Christ and destroy many families. Learn more at http://www.freeminds.org
 5/25/07
 Maluenda
 St Louis Missouri
 This "documentary" is a sham. It does not portray JWs as they truly are. There are many decent people who do belong tothis cult, however, if the general public was informed of both sides of the coins they would have a completely different picture. The pedophilia problem in this cult is horrendous and will be comparable to the Catholic Church scandal. The social isolation experienced by it's members leads to mental health issues. All this can be substantiated by their own literature and the fact that they need to practice Theocratic Warfare or lying. So beware who is "knocking" at your door. It may well be a pedophile. There can not be open dialogue and discussion between JWs and society, or their family members when their own literature teaches to hate nonbelievers and nt to associate with them. I would be happy to provide anyone with a list of their publications that state just that. Hate your unbelieving parents, children, family, or anyone not believing in Jehovah. How cvan they deny it when they published it? How can people accept their faith as legitimate when it preaches hatred? I was raised a JW, married to a JW, and my father is still an elder. I can tell you from personal experience what is the truth.
 5/25/07
 Long Beach, CA
 You guys did a fantastic job with this film, in telling the truth about JW's in the different facets of life (with non-believing relatives, door to door work, etc.). Some are writing to share their bad experiences with JW's, and we saw that coming. In every organization there are always those who are unhappy and rather do things THERE WAY. It's not about what JW's tell people they have to do, it's about what GOD TELLS us to do. I was disfellowshipped because I practiced sin and was not repented. But, with time I realized it was my mistake and I needed Jehovah in my life, and thankfully I was reinstated as a witness. People need to know, this organization is made up of imperfect human beings, but backed by GOD, JEHOVAH himself and that is all that matters. If people make mistakes, that is something HE will deal with. Finally, remember, even some of his angels went astray. I really hope the general public that watched this will TRY to understand JW's better, just like we have TRIED to understand and respect everybody else for who they are.
 5/25/07
 bonnie
 merritt islnd,fl.
 please dear brothers and sisters let's remember satan has many ways of entering our heads this is one because of all the bad comments that have nothing to do with the film.it was a good film.thank you

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19

Read more >>

Tell a Friend top
  



Home | The Film | Myths & Realities | Jehovah's Witnesses | Filmmaker Bios
Filmmaker Q&A | Learn More | Get Involved | Talkback | Site Credits
 


Independent Lens:
 Home
 Explore Films
 TV Schedule
 Watch Video
 Local Screenings
 Classroom
 Blog
 About
 Credits
 Contact
 Newsletter
 Pressroom
 
Posted 4/18/07  © 2015 Independent Television Service (ITVS). All rights reserved.  |  PBS Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
                

http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/knocking/talkback_p.html






PBS

WKAR-TV


 

PBS.org




Video

Programs

TV Schedules

Shop

Donate
 .                  
 Mondays 10/9 Central Independent Lens 



..
EXPLORE FILMS

TV SCHEDULE

WATCH VIDEO

LOCAL SCREENINGS

CLASSROOM

BLOG

ABOUT
.
KNOCKING

preview
schedule
  
Talkback
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19